How the Blue Wave Hit Utility Commissions
Once overlooked, utility regulator elections drew millions in outside spending and increased attention from consumer and environmental groups nationwide.
A data center opponent holds a sign at a protest on Oct. 12, 2026, in Mason, Mich. (AP Photo/Paul Sancya)
This article originally appeared on Inside Climate News, a nonprofit, nonpartisan news organization that covers climate, energy and the environment. Sign up for their newsletter here.
Data centers and increased energy costs brought attention to typically low-profile utility commission races in states across the country during this year’s midterms.
Nine states, all historically Republican, held elections for their utility regulators this year. Democrats won five of the 15 contested seats, flipping four Republican-held seats and retaining one, while Republicans won 10 seats, including one flipped from a Democrat in Louisiana.
Every state has a commission responsible for regulating its utilities, with authority over decisions that affect how electricity is generated, delivered and priced. Most are called public service commissions (PSCs) or public utility commissions (PUCs), and their structures vary. Some have three members, others five or seven. In most states commissioners are appointed, while in 10 states they are elected in partisan races.
The biggest shifts occurred in Georgia and Arizona.
In this election cycle, the biggest shifts occurred in Georgia and Arizona, where Democrats made historic gains. In Georgia, they won control of the PSC for the first time in 30 years, while in Arizona, they ended Republicans’ 5-0 hold on their commission. Both states have seen a surge in data center development, bringing new scrutiny to electricity costs and how to meet growing energy demand.
In Georgia, Democrats Shelia Edwards won her first PSC election while Peter Hubbard was reelected to his first full term, an early endorsement of the job he did his rookie year as commissioner. Joined by Commissioner Alicia Johnson, who won a seat last year, Democrats now hold a 3-2 majority on a commission that was entirely Republican just two years ago.
In Arizona, Clara Pratte and Jonathon Hill won the first Democratic seats on the commission since 2020.
Pratte also became the first Indigenous woman elected to statewide office in Arizona, bringing a unique perspective and set of goals to the utility regulator.
“We’re the sunniest state in the union; we could be generating a lot of our own solar rather than relying on fossil fuels,” Pratte said. “We need to be collaborative, and reach across the aisle to help Arizonans.”
Pratte noted that in addition to fossil fuel reliance, energy costs and transparency among utilities were key issues in the state. She also hopes to make meetings more accessible for the Navajo Nation.
Of the nine states that held elections this year, Georgia and Arizona have experienced the most data center development. All four of the elected Democrats in those states promised increased scrutiny for data centers, ensuring they pay their fair share of energy costs and preventing unchecked expansion.
“I think data centers definitely played a role in Democrats’ success in Arizona and Georgia,” said Jared Heern, a political scientist at Connecticut College who studies utility commission politics across the country.
In Arizona, concerns about data centers’ water use likely played a particularly large role, according to Heern. Hill, a scientist, campaigned on protecting natural resources, including water, an increasingly prominent issue amid concerns over the Colorado River’s declining supply.
“Incumbents who got booted out in those states can be directly tied to data center development,” Heern said. Utility commissioners have the ability to shape how data centers are powered and who pays for the infrastructure needed to serve them.
“Incumbents who got booted out in those states can be directly tied to data center development.”
Hill and Pratte finished ahead of incumbent Kevin Thompson in the statewide, at-large election for two commission seats. Thompson owns a consulting firm and acknowledged having a data center client.
Outside spending across the two states topped $7 million. In Arizona, Democrats received the most support, largely from a PAC called Arizonans for Affordable Energy. In Georgia, Republicans received the most outside support, much of it from a group called Powering Georgia’s Future, which supports “pro-growth” policies and a stronger industrial base. Spending in Georgia reached a record high for its PSC election.
Activists and energy watchdogs also played a big role in the elections, helping raise awareness of the little-known regulatory bodies. Grassroots groups like Georgians for Affordable Energy ran social media campaigns and distributed flyers, while national groups like the Sierra Club endorsed the Democratic candidates in Georgia and Arizona and educated members on the stakes of utility commission elections.
“The increased awareness of these bodies over the past few years has translated into frustration and anger as the public sees they are not doing their job,” said David Rogers, deputy director of the Beyond Coal Campaign at the Sierra Club. ”I think that’s what really showed up at the polls.”
While Democrats’ biggest victories came in Georgia and Arizona, they also picked up a seat in Nebraska. Former state Sen. Wendy DeBoer won Nebraska’s 2nd District seat, which includes Omaha, by more than 30 percentage points, breaking Republicans’ single-party hold on the state’s PSC. DeBoer campaigned on modernizing the state’s infrastructure.
But despite Democratic gains in those red states, Republicans held on to control of eight of the nine commissions that held elections. They also flipped a historically Democratic seat in Louisiana.
The funding gap between Republicans and Democrats in Louisiana’s two PSC races was substantial and likely played a significant role in the outcome, according to Heern. Republican candidates raised a combined $1.26 million, compared with less than $40,000 for the two Democratic candidates, according to campaign finance filings from late September.
Louisiana is one of six states that allow regulated utilities to contribute directly to candidates for utility commission seats. Both Democratic candidates refused utility contributions, while Republican Stephanie Hilferty accepted substantial donations from companies and executives connected to utilities she will now regulate. Republican John Atkins, who won the other seat, also pledged not to accept contributions from regulated utilities.
Hilferty did not respond to requests for comment.
In the other five states that held elections — South Dakota, North Dakota, Oklahoma, Alabama and Montana — Democrats failed to pick up a single seat in the deep-red states. But that does not mean voters weren’t interested in energy affordability.
In Alabama, voters clearly sought change amid high electricity prices, even though Democrats didn’t gain any seats on the Public Service Commission. The two incumbent Republican commissioners on the ballot this year lost in their party’s primary, and the commission will undergo even more dramatic changes thanks to sweeping utility legislation passed in April.
“People are struggling to meet their basic needs, including electricity.”
The Alabama PSC will expand from three members to seven, including the first two Black commissioners in state history, appointed by outgoing Gov. Kay Ivey.
Gov.-elect Tommy Tuberville will also select Alabama’s first secretary of energy, a new Cabinet-level position that will oversee the commission, set its agenda and give the governor a much larger and more direct role in regulating utilities.
For states that do not elect utility commissioners, the midterms still mattered. Governors or state legislatures appoint commissioners in those states. Democrats flipped governorships and legislatures across the country, giving them more influence over appointments in states like Texas, where the governor appoints all five members of the Public Utility Commission.
“That’s obviously a much slower process, decided when seats open up,” Heern said. ”But even though the public didn’t get to directly vote on commissioners, seeing how their midterm votes will translate into new commissions is important to watch.”
In Georgia, a new majority will allow Democratic commissioners to leave an immediate mark, pursuing campaign promises, improving transparency, scrutinizing data center deals and limiting rate increases as much as possible. But even in states where they made partial gains, their performance was not insignificant, according to Heern and consumer and environmental advocacy groups.
In Arizona and Nebraska, breaking up unanimous Republican majorities will give Democrats a greater voice in commission decisions and more opportunity to challenge existing policies.
“Regardless of who won and where, one thing is abundantly clear: People are struggling to meet their basic needs, including electricity,” said Rogers. ”The candidates who won promised to address these issues and we expect them to keep their word.”
Dennis Pillion contributed to this article.
Rooted in Truth.Independent by Design.
Your support helps ensure that rigorous reporting, thoughtful analysis, and investigative journalism remain accessible to everyone.
Support our independent journalism.
You need to be a supporter to comment.
There are currently no responses to this article.
Be the first to respond.