Dispatches From Cairo: Manipulating the Mob
Editor’s note: We asked Lauren Unger-Geoffroy, an Arabic-speaking American who lives in Cairo, to share her perspective of life in Egypt after the revolution. In this entry, she writes about the raid on the Israeli Embassy and the forces vying to steer Egypt’s huge youth movement.
Wisdom stands at the turn in the road and calls upon us publicly, but we consider it false and despise its adherents.
— Khalil Gibran
Sunday was 9/11, the world played harmony to America’s strange, huge memorial to the end of the era of security, and still no clarity.
Anyone who didn’t already see that Egypt’s massive youth movement was being played, as young and clueless as it is courageous and strong and nationalistic — and as easily provoked as a crowd of edgy football fans — has seen it now. On Friday its unfortunately predictable pent-up mob energy followed the obvious path to the most visible enemy, and acted out without purpose in storming the Israeli Embassy, damaging the image of the movement’s success in the eyes of the world.
The Friday sermon at the mosque on my corner, broadcast through loudspeakers, was fiery and impassioned, calling for the courage to continue the revolution, to not be weak and to not let the corrupt and the evildoers regain power. To not let the military keep the power. To never submit again to tyranny! That Israel must repent for its brutality. That we must stay pure and devoted to our country and follow the Quran, and that faith in Allah and the example of the Prophet will guide and protect us.
This was before the protest at the Israeli Embassy went from the symbolic and acceptable breaking down of a newly built wall at the site to the purposeless and unacceptable mob-frenzy fiasco of attacking and violating the embassy itself.
Who were these protesters following? Did this coalesce without instigation? The majority of people feel uneasy, suspecting that they were manipulated.
Saturday continued in the logical progression of such things as, dazed and bruised as the adrenalin rush subsided, but still sullenly self-righteous, the crowds turned their focus upon blaming someone for their misguided action and sudden apparent loss of advantage. Unsure and hesitant spying accusations were muttered all over the street and the social and local media.
Today [Sunday] as heads begin to clear of the residual primal hormones and mouths sensed the acrid aftertaste of tear gas residue, many realized the big fail that they had mindlessly accomplished. Some became lucid enough to try to piece together this failure.
On the tail of Israel’s crossing the border and killing innocent Egyptian officers, while bombing civilians in Gaza, and then refusing to apologize to Turkey for killing nine of its civilian activists, Israel’s image as aggressor, menace and enemy has become a beacon of cohesion for a simmering Egyptian agitation.
While the USA is absorbed in the 10 anniversary of 9/11, still overwhelmed by emotion and unconcerned with examination of that historical event’s murky details, Syria is blocking humanitarian aid and communication, Turkey is coming here to Egypt to make a bid for alliance, and Saudi Arabia is offering billions in financial support with unclear conditions. At the same time, Egypt’s revolution is facing its demons, having engaged in several skirmishes with the police and supporters of the old party outside deposed President Hosni Mubarak’s trial for killing protesters. Later there was violence at a football stadium, followed by the attack on the Israeli Embassy. But who was leading this crowd?
Who benefits from this degradation of the revolution?
Now Egypt’s Supreme Council of the Armed Forces (SCAF) can claim justification in making a tougher stance on protests. Israel and critics of Egypt see justification in their negative viewpoint, and Egypt loses dignity and face.
The football mentality is the people at their least common denominator, as is tribal-type loyalty and the rallying point of Palestine and “martyrs” and a few other instant-reaction buttons, to which the youthful and inexperienced “revolutionaries” have no resistance. Without strong leadership it is easy for anyone with a strong agenda to take over the minds of the uncalculating and excitable masses, and thus the streets of Egypt.
Though there was a new trend of freedom in media expression, the official pressure to not criticize the military has come to a head in the raid on the Egyptian Al-Jazeera television network, concurrent with the Egyptian and Israeli governments’ attempts to re-establish their awkward peace after Friday night’s attack on the Israeli Embassy.
Egypt’s minister of media, Osama Heikal, had warned that the government would take action against stations that “endanger the stability and security” of the nation, and some fear this could be the beginning of the end of the freedoms of expression gained since the overthrow of Mubarak in February.
Ahmed Zein, Al-Jazeera manager, said officers in plain clothes entered without showing a warrant or identifying themselves, confiscated equipment and arrested an engineer operating it. “If broadcasting the truth is considered endangering stability,” he said, “then it is an honor for any media outlet to be endangering stability.”
Journalists and news organizations are required to have their information vetted by the military before publication; some journalists and bloggers have been summoned for questioning about their writing or broadcasts.
Fortunately things appear calmer now. The Mubarak trial has been postponed until the emergency has passed. But maybe the government will undo that decision, as it did the visa limitation, which was decided and then undecided in two days. Is trial postponement a component in still another agenda? Oh, there are so many agendas on all sides.Of course this means spies, agents for those seeking to manipulate — the old thug regime cabal, the SCAF mandarinate, Israel, the U.S., Saudi Arabia, the Bilderberg Group. Some people ask where was the army until the embassy attack was well under way — at which point the army rushed in and the casualties began. Of course there were no police here earlier; surely they weren’t in the crowd as thug/agitators as usual?
Now I suppose that you think of these unruly Egyptians as out-of-control car-burning, rioting criminals … and the foreign press has delighted in crying out that criminality is on the rise in Egypt. Yes, a car was stolen, a girl was groped, some small crimes happened. … Just remember this: With the exceptional reappearance in the past month of a few timid traffic-control white-jackets, there have been no police here for seven months. No police. Can you imagine the USA for one week with no police? There would be nothing left. There would be slaughter and destruction. Egyptians are truly good and faithful people who value morality and virtue and obedience to their God. They believe in right and wrong.
But they are easily misled.
So we were a little terrified to see a number of foreign journalists indiscriminately accused and pushed around on Saturday, cameras broken, crowds yelling, those mob-dumbed faces yelling “Israeli spy” once again, at people like my blond Dutch journalist friend. I dared not leave my flat with a notebook or a camera, but that has subsided, and some of those awakening out of the pack-consciousness back into their own discerning awareness are ashamed and regretful. My neighbors, who were ill at ease this morning, were laughing and bickering about normal things after the evening prayer.
It seems unlikely that none of the numerous forces waiting to turn Egypt’s movement to their advantage would have been involved in getting Egypt’s revolution to behave against its own interests, to keep it weak and malleable to their sophisticated agendas.
But what are these other agendas? How many? Which are in whose interest? And which will dominate? Is this a shared intention to keep the rubble dust and smoke in the air, obscuring the nature of the endgame?
Insha allah, in the coming days there will be a new page and the people will regain some effectiveness and insight. I hope it will be led by the people who understand the big picture and how to make it all work to achieve a new and better Egypt. As we hope and pray that the coming changes in the world will bring a better life for all.
May we have the strength and enough time to learn strategy and focus and put them to use while the ball is still in play.Wait, before you go…
If you're reading this, you probably already know that non-profit, independent journalism is under threat worldwide. Independent news sites are overshadowed by larger heavily funded mainstream media that inundate us with hype and noise that barely scratch the surface. We believe that our readers deserve to know the full story. Truthdig writers bravely dig beneath the headlines to give you thought-provoking, investigative reporting and analysis that tells you what’s really happening and who’s rolling up their sleeves to do something about it.
Like you, we believe a well-informed public that doesn’t have blind faith in the status quo can help change the world. Your contribution of as little as $5 monthly or $35 annually will make you a groundbreaking member and lays the foundation of our work.Support Truthdig