No, Protests Against Police Brutality Are Not Increasing Crime
In a recent piece for The Nation, Alex S. Vitale -- a professor of sociology at Brooklyn College -- disproves claims that the Black Lives Matter movement has caused an uptick in crime.
Shutterstock
Shutterstock
In a recent piece for The Nation, Alex S. Vitale — a professor of sociology at Brooklyn College — disproves claims that the Black Lives Matter movement has caused an uptick in crime.
He writes:
Much has been made in recent months of a series of isolated crime increases in a handful of US cities. Breathless accounts of a new crime wave have appeared in both liberal and conservative media. Right-wing pundits and some police leaders have claimed that there is a “Ferguson effect”—a significant crime increase due to the “Black Lives Matter” protests against police violence. This is both junk science and political opportunism.
The New York Times recently reported that a couple dozen US cities have experienced increases in murders, and a few others some increase in other violent crimes. While any uptick in serious crime should be of concern, short-term changes in a few crime categories is thin evidence of a sustained national trend. In fact, in most parts of the country, crime in general, and murder rates in particular, continue to go down. While New York City, one site of ongoing protest, had a spike in homicides in the early part of the year, the city just completed the “safest summer in 25 years” according to Commissioner Bill Bratton. In addition, a new report by the Sentencing Project shows that in St. Louis, the uptick in homicides actually was well underway before the death of Michael Brown.
Even in cities that have experienced some increase in homicides, there has been no increase in other crimes. Why would a reduction in policing (as claimed by proponents of the “Ferguson effect”) result in more homicides but fewer robberies, burglaries, and auto thefts? The fact is that while homicide numbers are considered very accurate, they are such rare occurrences that it is very dangerous to draw any conclusions about broader crime trends from limited periods of time. Six months of homicide data is not enough to predict what year-end numbers will look like, and it’s bad journalism and worse science to do so.
Read more.
—Posted by Natasha Hakimi Zapata
Your support is crucial...As we navigate an uncertain 2025, with a new administration questioning press freedoms, the risks are clear: our ability to report freely is under threat.
Your tax-deductible donation enables us to dig deeper, delivering fearless investigative reporting and analysis that exposes the reality beneath the headlines — without compromise.
Now is the time to take action. Stand with our courageous journalists. Donate today to protect a free press, uphold democracy and uncover the stories that need to be told.
Race
In the wake of George Floyd’s murder in 2020, a flurry of funding went to Black nonprofits. That funding is now being pulled back amidst a right-wing backlash.
TD Interview
The Black Lives Matter co-founder has joined the ticket in Cornel West’s campaign of “truth, justice and love.”
Women
It takes effort to track the impacts of mass mobilizations like #MeToo, Occupy or Black Lives Matter, but understanding social change is impossible without such work.
TD Column
A right-wing parents' group is attacking decades of progress in L.A.'s deeply unequal public education system.
TD Original
It started as a hashtag after the acquittal of George Zimmerman—what has the movement accomplished since then?
TD Interview
While racial equity progress is slow, Melina Abdullah sees enough hope to continue.
You need to be a supporter to comment.
There are currently no responses to this article.
Be the first to respond.