Justice Kagan Discusses Public Trust of the Supreme Court
The Supreme Court is in the midst of a crisis of legitimacy.
Associate Justice of the Supreme Court Elena Kagan delivers remarks shortly before administering the oath of office to Secretary of Defense Ash Carter during a ceremonial swearing in held in the Pentagon Auditorium, March 6, 2015. Photo by Glenn Fawcett / Public Domain
This is Part of the "The Supreme Court’s War on the Future" Dig series
The Supreme Court is in the midst of a crisis of legitimacy. As a result of its rapid shift to the right, especially with its 5-4 decision in June in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization that overturned Roe v. Wade and revoked the constitutional right to abortion, the court’s public approval ratings have plummeted. It suggests that increasing numbers of Americans are losing faith in the highest judicial body in the land.
Justice Elena Kagan addressed the legitimacy crisis in a talk before the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals’ Judicial Conference on July 24, 2022, in Montana.
You can hear Kagan’s complete speech recorded on CSPAN here or on YouTube here:
Pay close attention to these comments:
WAIT BEFORE YOU GO...If over time the court loses all connection with the public and with public sentiment, that is a dangerous thing for a democracy,” Kagan said. “I think people are rightly suspicious if one justice leaves the court or dies and another justice takes his or her place and all of a sudden, the law changes [and] it’s like: What’s going on here? That doesn’t seem like law…The way the court retains its legitimacy and fosters public confidence is by acting like a court.
This year, the ground feels uncertain — facts are buried and those in power are working to keep them hidden. Now more than ever, independent journalism must go beneath the surface.
At Truthdig, we don’t just report what's happening — we investigate how and why. We follow the threads others leave behind and uncover the forces shaping our future.
Your tax-deductible donation fuels journalism that asks harder questions and digs where others won’t.
Don’t settle for surface-level coverage.
Unearth what matters. Help dig deeper.
Donate now.
John Robert is the newest swing vote, but he's still a conservative. And if Trump is reelected, the GOP will likely get a sixth justice.
After the Supreme Court's potentially devastating decision in Rucho v. Common Cause, it's up to we the people to reclaim our democracy.
The highest court in the land puts a halt to the Trump administration’s plans to add a citizenship question to the 2020 census---for now.
A pair of new cases, decided on the final day before summer recess, will likely determine the country's electoral map for years to come.
The language of an immigration law is ruled “unconstitutionally vague” by a Supreme Court majority that included Justice Neil Gorsuch.
You need to be a supporter to comment.
There are currently no responses to this article.
Be the first to respond.