$#!* That: High Court Tosses FCC Indecency Rules but Skirts Free Speech Issue
The Supreme Court threw out the FCC's heavy-handed sanctions on Fox and ABC but stayed mum on whether the commission's prudish and outdated indecency policy violates free speech laws.
In a unanimous decision, the Supreme Court on Thursday tossed out indecency sanctions imposed by the Federal Communications Commission on the Fox and ABC television networks.
In the court’s opinion, written by Justice Anthony Kennedy, “the FCC failed to give Fox or ABC fair notice prior to the broadcasts in question that fleeting expletives and momentary nudity could be found actionably indecent.” The commission’s standards are “vague,” he added.
Although the court’s ruling establishes guidelines that the government must follow in regulating broadcast content, it dodges the question of whether the regulations are unconstitutional under the First Amendment.
The FCC’s prohibitions on naughty words and private parts have undergone little change since they first took shape in 1978 when the court decided FCC v. Pacifica. The FCC remains “free to modify its current indecency policy,” Kennedy said.
–Posted by Sara Beladi
Your support is crucial...The Wall Street Journal:
The decision, which focused on process rather than substance, offered little clarity to broadcasters after nearly a decade of legal battles over expletives uttered on live television and brief displays of bare breasts and buttocks. The high court declined to say whether government punishments in such cases violate the First Amendment’s free-speech protections.
The justices’ punt leaves the Federal Communications Commission to grapple with more than a million indecency complaints that have piled up at the agency since the litigation began. The FCC also must decide whether to stick with a tough standard for policing the airwaves set during the George W. Bush administration.
As we navigate an uncertain 2025, with a new administration questioning press freedoms, the risks are clear: our ability to report freely is under threat.
Your tax-deductible donation enables us to dig deeper, delivering fearless investigative reporting and analysis that exposes the reality behind the headlines — without compromise.
Now is the time to take action. Stand with our courageous journalists. Donate today to protect a free press, uphold democracy and uncover the stories that need to be told.
You need to be a supporter to comment.
There are currently no responses to this article.
Be the first to respond.