Subscribe
TD originals

U.S. Domestic Surveillance Papers Raise Rights Concerns

Associated Press

New documents obtained by Human Rights Watch reveal a Department of Defense policy that seems to allow monitoring of U.S. citizens and green card holders deemed by the executive branch to be “homegrown violent extremists”—even when they have “no specific connection to foreign terrorist(s).”

The organization says that the documents, obtained by a Freedom of Information Act request, raise concerns about the government’s ability to gather data on citizens without obtaining a warrant. The group is especially concerned that “people who are exercising their legitimate, free-expression rights will be targeted for monitoring in a discriminatory or arbitrary manner”:

The new materials … are training modules that primarily concern Executive Order 12333. That order broadly governs the US intelligence agencies’ activities, and includes provisions allowing the agencies to collect information on US persons—meaning US citizens and lawful permanent residents, as well as some corporations and associations—in a manner the government  has never fully explained to the public. The training slides largely summarize Defense Department procedures concerning EO 12333 that were released in 2016, updating a 1982 version. Using plain language to demystify the procedures’ phrasing, the slides offer hints about Defense Department intelligence practices that require further inquiry and exposure.

“These documents point to just how thoroughly the public has been kept in the dark about warrantless surveillance under Executive Order 12333,” said Sarah St.Vincent, US surveillance and national security researcher at Human Rights Watch. “Their explanations of the order suggest that the government may be carrying out monitoring that poses serious problems for human rights, and Congress should seek more information about what the intelligence agencies are doing in this respect.”

In an interview with Aaron Maté of The Real News, St.Vincent said that the documents are especially disconcerting because they lack qualifiers to determine who might fall under the umbrella of “homegrown violent extremists.”

“I wouldn’t want to speculate, but I think that it’s potentially significant that the training slides refer to the San Bernardino and Orlando shooters, which suggests to me a potential focus on Muslims,” she said. “But I think what we should all really focus on is this idea that … homegrown violent extremists, when you don’t have a definition, or you don’t have criteria, I think there’s a real danger that that could be applied to a really wide spectrum of people who are potentially just expressing their political opinions or their religious views, and for whom there is no, as we say in the criminal justice field, ‘probable cause’ to believe they’re going to commit a crime or engage in an act of violence. I think that when the focus is on this so-called ‘extremism,’ that is to say, apparently, the beliefs, that you risk having people get caught in a dragnet who really don’t belong there.”

That the vague policy could be applied disproportionately to Muslims is especially alarming after President Trump’s inflammatory remarks on Twitter following Tuesday’s shootings in New York City, in which eight people died:

The vagueness of the classification “homegrown violent extremist” is also of concern in light of Trump’s varying responses to acts of violence. CNN notes his very different reactions after the Oct. 1 mass shooting by a white man in Las Vegas and Tuesday’s New York City attack by a man allegedly inspired by Islamic State. In the wake of the Las Vegas incident, Trump refused to discuss gun control when pressed by reporters. But he was quick to urge more “extreme vetting” by Homeland Security just four hours after the Manhattan attack.

Read the Human Rights Watch documents here.

Emily Wells
​Emily Wells is an Ear to the Ground blogger at Truthdig. As a journalist, she began as a crime reporter at the Pulitzer-winning daily newspaper, The Press-Enterprise...
Emily Wells
In this article:

Now you can personalize your Truthdig experience. To bookmark your favorite articles, please create a user profile.

Personalize your Truthdig experience. Choose authors to follow, bookmark your favorite articles and more.
Your Truthdig, your way. Access your favorite authors, articles and more.
or
or

A password will be e-mailed to you.

Statements and opinions expressed in articles and comments are those of the authors, not Truthdig. Truthdig takes no responsibility for such statements or opinions.