Judge Rules for Web Freedom
Yet another court has ruled against the 1994 Child Online Protection Act, a major victory for civil rights advocates. The law has been a mess from the start. With the stated goal of protecting kids from pornography, it would punish offending websites with $50,000 fines and jail time for exposing children to "harmful" material, whether intentionally or not. Innocent sites like Salon and BoingBoing could've been targeted under the legislation.Yet another court has ruled against the 1994 Child Online Protection Act, a major victory for civil rights advocates. The law has been a mess from the start. With the stated goal of protecting kids from pornography, it would punish offending websites with $50,000 fines and jail time for exposing children to “harmful” material, whether intentionally or not. Innocent sites like Salon and BoingBoing could’ve been targeted under the legislation.
Rooted in Truth.BBC:
Judge Reed said that while he sympathised with the need to protect minors, the 1998 Child Online Protection Act was problematic.
“I may not turn a blind eye to the law… to protect this nation’s youth by upholding a flawed statute, especially when a more effective and less restrictive alternative is readily available,” he wrote.
The act was challenged by civil liberties groups and sexual health and other websites, including the online magazine salon.com, which claimed it was too restrictive and unconstitutional.
Independent by Design.
Your support helps ensure that rigorous reporting, thoughtful analysis, and investigative journalism remain accessible to everyone.
Support independent journalism.
Editorial Cartoons
Health & Wellness
Despite a growing public health crisis, physicians cite many reasons for not talking about firearm safety with patients.
Social Justice
As many as 70,000 child care centers are projected to close in the next several months as pandemic-era federal funding ends, pushing an industry already in crisis to a breaking point.
Health & Wellness
Many store shelves remain bare as the private and government response struggles to produce results.
World
Aid workers blame a climate change-induced drought that’s turned the Horn of Africa into a parched, barren wasteland.
State official says information being mined at schools includes locations, websites visited, videos watched, passwords and contact lists.
You need to be a supporter to comment.
There are currently no responses to this article.
Be the first to respond.