‘Foreclosure King’ Steven Mnuchin Is Put on Defensive at Senate Hearing
"Mnuchin didn't mention the name of a single victim in his remarks," journalist David Dayen reports. "He gave dubious statistics that fall apart upon scrutiny."By Deirdre Fulton / Common Dreams
At Thursday’s hearing before the Senate Finance Committee, U.S. Treasury secretary nominee Steven Mnuchin was forced to defend his offshore holdings and his record at the bank dubbed a “foreclosure machine.”
Mnuchin faced occasionally tough questioning from Democrats on the Finance Committee, including Sens. Ron Wyden (Ore.), Bob Casey (Pa.), Sherrod Brown (Ohio), and Claire McCaskill (Mo.), who drilled into his time running OneWest Bank, his offshore business ventures, and the conflicts of interest posed by President-elect Donald Trump’s foreign debts.
Watch Wyden take on the tax havens:
Offshore Entities in Tax Havens 101 with Mr. #Mnuchin, #ForeclosureKing pic.twitter.com/rbTMzYtdGf
— Senate Finance Cmte (@SenateFinance) January 19, 2017
Sen. Bob Menendez (D-N.J.) also delved into the matter:
Steve #Mnuchin said his reason for creating offshore entities for his clients was complicated. Let me make it simple: it was to avoid taxes. pic.twitter.com/UT2y0ubdIQ
— Senator Bob Menendez (@SenatorMenendez) January 19, 2017
Meanwhile, McCaskill reminded Mnuchin that as head of the Treasury Department he would oversee the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS)—”which investigates foreign investments into U.S. businesses for possible national security conflicts,” as Business Insider explains—and in turn be tasked with evaluating the debt from President-elect Donald Trump’s businesses held by foreign entities:
Steve Mnuchin can’t tell Sen. Claire McCaskill how much of Trump’s debt is held by foreign entities. #draintheswamp pic.twitter.com/Efj1pkLVIV
— Keith Boykin (@keithboykin) January 19, 2017
And both Brown and Casey dug into Mnuchin’s record with OneWest, which foreclosed on tens of thousands of families after Mnuchin and his investors bought it.
I asked Mr. #Mnuchin if he knew how many people he foreclosed on, he didn’t. #MnunchinHearing
— Senator Bob Casey (@SenBobCasey) January 19, 2017
If a nominee doesn’t know the # of people they have foreclosed on then they’ve foreclosed on too many families #Mnuchin
— Senator Bob Casey (@SenBobCasey) January 19, 2017
#Mnuchin failed to answer ?s abt fortune he made kicking seniors, servicemembers & working people out of their homes https://t.co/k0pI1bYpG7
— Sherrod Brown (@SenSherrodBrown) January 19, 2017
Democrats not on the committee, including Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) weighed in as well.
Steve Mnuchin told @SenStabenow & @SenatorMenendez he didn’t disclose $100M because “the amount of paperwork” was tough. Boo hoo.
— Elizabeth Warren (@SenWarren) January 19, 2017
.@SenOrrinHatch said Mnuchin’s bank’s disgraceful actions are “essentially unrelated” to his qualifications. Tell that to his victims.
— Elizabeth Warren (@SenWarren) January 19, 2017
But journalist and author David Dayen, writing Thursday afternoon at The Nation, said Democrats missed their opportunity to truly “expose Mnuchin as a predator.”
“Democratic committee members pummeled him over the tax haven,” Dayen wrote, referring to newly uncovered revelations that Mnuchin was director of investment funds incorporated in offshore havens like the Cayman Islands and Anguilla. But, Dayen continued, that line of questioning “got bogged down into an arcane discussion of hedge fund rules and tax law, when there were literally thousands of human stories, of people who lost everything they had at the hands of Steve Mnuchin’s bank, waiting to be discussed.”
One particularly impactful exchange was between Mnuchin and a Republican senator, Dean Heller of Nevada. Mnuchin opponents have targeted Heller’s district with ads in recent weeks, recognizing him as a possible swing vote on this confirmation. Dayen reports:
Mnuchin didn’t mention the name of a single victim in his remarks. He gave dubious statistics that fall apart upon scrutiny. And this tripped up Mnuchin with an important Senator, Republican Dean Heller of Nevada, one of the worst states for foreclosures. Heller asked how many Nevada loans were in OneWest’s servicing portfolio. Mnuchin didn’t know. He asked how many foreclosures and loan modifications OneWest committed in Nevada. Mnuchin didn’t know. Heller apparently asked this of Mnuchin and his staff seven different times for weeks, and got no answer. Heller asked why Mnuchin and his investors bought OneWest. Mnuchin said it would have been more lucrative to invest in Bank of America. (Not true; the investors doubled their money when OneWest was sold) Heller keyed in on the FDIC Loss-Share Agreement with OneWest, where the agency committed to backstop losses by the bank. Mnuchin couldn’t give a figure on how much money FDIC paid OneWest. The number is $1.2 billion. “You’re saying $1.2 billion isn’t an incentive to foreclose?” Heller asked. Mnuchin said no, but combined with the normal incentives among servicers to foreclose, this backstop was critical for OneWest.
Heller’s tough questioning suggests that he might not be inclined to support Mnuchin. And one senator in the committee could bottle up the nomination. That’s worth watching.
Watch here:
Your support is crucial…#NV was hit hard by the housing crisis. I need answers from Treasury Nom. Mnuchin on these critical Qs: https://t.co/kPy0oGT9cJ
— Dean Heller (@SenDeanHeller) January 19, 2017
With an uncertain future and a new administration casting doubt on press freedoms, the danger is clear: The truth is at risk.
Now is the time to give. Your tax-deductible support allows us to dig deeper, delivering fearless investigative reporting and analysis that exposes what’s really happening — without compromise.
During this holiday season, stand with our courageous journalists. Donate today to protect a free press, uphold democracy and ensure the stories that matter are told.
You need to be a supporter to comment.
There are currently no responses to this article.
Be the first to respond.