May 22, 2015
Why Republicans Protect the ‘Honor’ of Offensive Team Names
Posted on Jan 14, 2014
By Jeremiah Goulka
Roadblock 3: Never Been a Loser
How can a Republican keep a straight face and write that “[n]obody names their football team the Losers” when talking about Native American-based team names? Even with our crummy educations on the subject, there’s no way anyone can claim that Indians have come through the past centuries as history’s winners. But Republicans remain blind because they are almost all white, and white people—or at least non-immigrant white men—have never been a losing tribe in this country.
Sure, plenty of whites may feel victimized one way or another when life doesn’t go their way, and it’s not only Republicans who attribute it to race. Some feel excluded from the white establishment, but that’s a class issue. Some believe that their failure to snag a job or a spot in college is due to affirmative action, but that’s because they believe they are being denied something that is already rightly theirs—an entitlement, if you will. But this is nothing like being in a losing tribe.
Whites don’t get pulled over by the police for driving in black neighborhoods, and where they do get pulled over, they seldom get dragged out of the car and shoved against the hood. Whites don’t get their resumes chucked in the trash because of unfamiliar, group-pride-oriented names. White men as a group have not had to fight for their basic rights in this country for generations. (Universal white manhood suffrage dates to the 1820s.)
Square, Site wide
This has massive ripple effects for Republican politics and policy. Never having been a victim of history, Republicans have no intuitive understanding of victimhood or institutional racism or glass ceilings or other common experiences for people of color (and women).
If more Republicans had an intuitive feel for the experience of American life as a minority (or a woman), they’d probably spend way less time making fun of “the politics of victimization” or promoting their version of “melting pot” America—a country where, no matter your color, you are supposed to dress, act, and aspire to be white. And the GOP might actually stand a chance of figuring out how to attract more than a token number of non-white voters nationally.
White Skin in the Game
So why don’t Republicans just cave on this one and stop looking like jerks? Even conservative columnist Charles Krauthammer recognizes that the name “Redskins” is defunct. What do they have to lose?
To recognize that names matter, however, means recognizing that human experience matters—not just the experiences of approved people, but of all people. Republican ideology is based on protecting its in-group, fighting off solidarity with out-groups, and claiming that success and failure in American life is a moral story of meritocracy alone—to the extent, of course, that government regulations don’t get in the way.
As much as Republicans may formulaically say that they care about everyone, the party is scared to death of empathy. It could lead Republicans to get past their false moral narrative and see the many ways that their policies harm minorities, women, and the poor. Empathy could even lead Republicans into embarrassing historical terrain where they might learn that, through germs and violence, whites killed off millions of Indians, and that “Manifest Destiny” is just a marketing catchphrase hiding the fact that the United States broke off from one empire and immediately started its own on this continent. And once they recognize that, they might even start noticing our empire abroad or getting serious about equality at home. Next thing you know, they might start pushing to increase taxes on the rich and funding for Food Stamps or Head Start or Medicaid… Republican Armageddon.
Jeremiah Goulka, a TomDispatch regular and former RAND Corporation analyst, writes about American politics and culture, focusing on security, race, and the Republican Party. You can follow him on Twitter @jeremiahgoulka or contact him through his website jeremiahgoulka.com.
Follow TomDispatch on Twitter and join us on Facebook or Tumblr. Check out the newest Dispatch Book, Ann Jones’s They Were Soldiers: How the Wounded Return From America’s Wars—The Untold Story.
Copyright 2014 Jeremiah Goulka
New and Improved Comments