|
|
May 24, 2013
|
|
Suleiman’s TravelsPosted on Sep 27, 2011
By Susan Zakin (Page 3) My husband is embarrassed and I feel badly for him, but I also feel the same way I have felt ever since I returned from Africa. I feel safe. I am glad my husband is here, and I am impatient for the day when we can bring his sons to live in a place where they can grow up without worrying about malaria or periodic political upheaval. Unlike so many of my liberal friends, I don’t discount the vehemence of anti-American feeling or the fragility of civil society. Certainly I worry that “the system” has the latitude to lock people away in places like Guantanamo Bay whether they are guilty or not, and I am disgusted that the American people have been drugged by a steady diet of celebrity journalism. But as I remind my husband, during World War II, the U.S. herded Japanese-Americans into internment camps with no evidence they had any involvement with the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor. The immigration guy isn’t responsible for American foreign policy. Inside the borders of our country, he was nice and respectful, which is more than you can say for government officials in Kenya. And in the end, we made it onto the plane. But there was a weird coda: My best friend, who is renting us her mother’s apartment in San Francisco, told us that two FBI officers had showed up at her door the previous morning. Sensing that they weren’t on high alert, she joked around, telling them I was probably more of a troublemaker than my husband, an easygoing guy whose only political activism was agitating for payment for his fellow players on a soccer team nearly 20 years ago. “I think they were just doing, what’s the word, due diligence,” she said. Advertisement “The system works,” I say. “What do you think?” He points out that the security agents should have questioned him after he went through the TSA checkpoint, which would have saved him the embarrassment of being pulled off the plane. “It could work better,” he says. Yeah, I think. And it could work a whole lot worse.
1
2
3
Previous item: Troy Davis and the Machinery of Death Next item: Why You Should Eat Yak Instead of Beef New and Improved CommentsIf you have trouble leaving a comment, review this help page. Still having problems? Let us know. If you find yourself moderated, take a moment to review our comment policy. |
By oakland steve, September 29, 2011 at 11:19 am Link to this comment
This is the worst written item that I’ve encountered in TruthDig. It has the feel of a rambling disgorgement on a right wing radio talk show, with the author breathlessly trying to impress the listeners while making her points before the host cuts her off.
One pearl of wisdom that stuck with me was her statement that “Unlike so many of my liberal friends, I don’t discount the vehemence of anti-American feeling or the fragility of civil society.” I am duly impressed that she has any friends, and that she manages to keep some. I never knew that it is common among “liberals” to discount the vehemence of anti-American feelings in the muslim world. Learning is fun.
In three pages, the author convinced me that I never want to meet her or read anything else she ever writes.
She should have gotten a personal rejection letter from TruthDig.
Report thisBy Mike, September 29, 2011 at 6:47 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
Craig, it wasn’t Jefferson who made the quote. Here it is:
“Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.” - Benjamin Franklin, Historical Review of Pennsylvania, 1759
Report thisBy Allan, September 28, 2011 at 7:53 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
The shocking thing about this piece is how completely the author seems to
Report thishave accepted, and even taken advantage of, some of the most unacceptable
and racist parts of the experience her husband was forced to endure. The fact
that two men were called off the plane after it had boarded is perhaps as
uncontroversial as she presents, only a cause of slight embarrassment - but it
appears just as likely that their detaining was an afterthought, based on no
evidence and no threat but simply the sound of the passenger’s names.
Maybe this is enough justification to the author, who used the fact of her own
Judaism to try to expedite their experience with the authorities (I suppose that
in order to subvert this entire ordeal that behavior is perhaps acceptable, but
the action isn’t even really addressed here, as if it is perfectly justifiable, almost
common sense).
I’m guessing that the internment camp example is meant to remove some of
the dissonance the author must feel between her uncritical approach and the
reality of executive power abuse in the US, because the example is such a
reach. Japanese internment camps were reprehensible, of course. But they
were actually a less potentially subversive practice than today’s brand of abuse
to the long-term safety of citizens’ basic freedoms. The context of “war” in
each case is drastically different. The War on Terror, like other concept wars, is
a war against an ill-defined group, with ill-defined goals and whose practice
could go on indefinitely without any tangible results except for an ever-
increasing pricetag, an increasingly hegemonic expansion of executive power,
and a vague feeling of “security” that I actually think is probably more like a
consistently present feeling of “fear”. Perhaps the sense of fear, both of the
enemy and of one’s own authorities, is a consistent between the two wars. The
difference here is how deeply the war is woven into non-wartime civilian
society. In other words, our military and security apparatuses are at war, but
we are not.
And as racist as the practice of profiling is, my fear is that the exercise of
executive power, within this peaceful civilian mileu, will actually become more generalizable in a way embodied by
Giorgio Agamben’s writing on “Homo Sacer”. In other words, creating within
each person the potential to be singled out by the state for punishment, despite
his or her record of transgressions, in the service of “stability”. It certainly
seems that this is the direction that the war is going in, both domestically and
overseas.
By Craig, September 28, 2011 at 2:39 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
I believe it was Thomas Jefferson who said something
Report thislike “Any society willing to sacrifice liberty for
security deserves neither and shall lose both.”
By Mohamed MALLECK, September 28, 2011 at 1:27 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
It is hot very flattering that Susan Zakin’s husband’s “only political activism was agitating for payment for his fellow players on a soccer team nearly 20 years”. I am not myself from Lamu Island but from another island, Mauritius, located some distance further from the Kenyan coast. Even then, I am painfully aware of the Somali people’s rage at the time of the “Black Hawk Down” incident, and the horrendous fact, some months before that incident two Dutch soldiers on a UN peacekeeping force had held a teenage Somali boy on a beachside-barbecue-type bonfire, roasting him alive. The picture of their barbaric act had made first-page news in many print media and even on some TV channels. That was around 1991/92. Readers can read about the “Black Hawk Down” incident on the Wikipedia website. By the way, not only is Somalia far more strategically located than Afghanistan as far as the parameters of the Project for the New American Century (check that one also on Wikipedia)are concerned, with bases throughout the country expected to help keep under surveillance the oil assets of Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Iraq, Iran and the ‘security’ (from Arab oppressors, right?)of Israel, should the military bases located on Saudi soil itself be forced to leave the country, but also Somalia has non-negligible volumes of oil assets of its own. About famine, it has been more than 40 years since Amatya Sen convincingly documented, in his Ph.D. thesis that, historically, it has been conflicts that cause famine, not shortage of food.
Report thisBy ugarit, September 28, 2011 at 12:06 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
A fairly pretentious piece of little substance or contribution.
Report thisBy jojojo, September 28, 2011 at 7:41 am Link to this comment
Refreshing, pragmatic, real-life look at a volatile issue.
Report thisBy The Farside, September 28, 2011 at 7:22 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
Zakin is “impatient for the day when we can bring his sons to live in a place where they can grow up without worrying about malaria or periodic political upheaval.” Blah blah! The article is trite vacuous fluff. Style over substance journalism. I live in Africa. Give me Malaria and periodic political upheaval any day, to the constant political oppression of the USA and it’s far
Report thismore deadly parasitic diseases of rampant consumerism and voracious globalization.
By thecrow, September 28, 2011 at 4:26 am Link to this comment
http://michaelfury.wordpress.com/2011/06/02/maximum-visibility/
Report thisBy DarthMiffy, September 28, 2011 at 4:25 am Link to this comment
This is what it is coming to? I’m ashamed.
Report thisBy Lisa, September 28, 2011 at 1:15 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
Hear, hear. Borderline moronic. “.. but because exact dates and times aren’t as important in Africa as they are here, except among the highly educated.” Africa the present continent or Africa of “Tarzan the Ape Man” the 1934 movie?
Report thisBy maruata, September 27, 2011 at 7:01 pm Link to this comment
One can’t help but gag at the bitter aftertaste of national pride here… we’re left
with “it could be worse” as if to say “at least we’re doing our best” against the
terrorist enemy.
Basically this could be a Bush Administration piece on the war on terror and why
america should fight the endless war.
A far better solution than getting it right at US airports would be to stop pissing
off the rest of the planet with self-righteous foreign policies.
“I feel safe” ... in America God Bless Us…
The norwegian is indeed way more evolved!
Report thisBy kerryrose, September 27, 2011 at 5:34 pm Link to this comment
What self-satisfied garbage.
Report this