Winner 2013 Webby Awards for Best Political Website
Top Banner, Site wide
Apr 19, 2014

 Choose a size
Text Size

Top Leaderboard, Site wide

Drought Adds to Syria’s Misery




The Divide


Truthdig Bazaar
If I Were Another: Poems

If I Were Another: Poems

By Mahmoud Darwish
$20.44

Black Tuesday

Black Tuesday

by Nomi Prins

more items

 
Report

A Memory of Howard

Email this item Email    Print this item Print    Share this item... Share

Posted on Jan 27, 2010
AP / Dima Gavrysh

By Daniel Ellsberg

(Page 2)

Then a line of employees emerged from the building, wearing coats and ties or dresses. Their arms were raised and they were holding cards in their raised hands. As they circled past us, they held out the cards so we could see what they were: ID cards, showing they were federal employees. They were making the peace sign with their other hands, they were circling around the building to show solidarity with what we were doing. Their spokesman said over a bullhorn, “We want this war to be over, too! Thank you for what you are doing! Keep it up.” Photographers, including police, were scrambling to take pictures of them, and some of them held up their ID cards so they would get in the picture. It was the high point of the day.

A little while after the employees had gone back inside the building, there was a sudden shift in the mood of the police. An order had been passed. The bloc of police in the center of the square got into tight formation and lowered their plastic helmets. The police standing right in front of us, over us, straightened up, adjusted their uniforms and lowered their masks. Apparently the time had come to start arrests. The supporters who didn’t want to be arrested fell back.

But there was no arrest warning. There was a whistle, and the line of police began inching forward, black batons raised upright. They were going to walk through us or over us, push us back. The man in front of us, who had been talking to Howard about his lecture a little earlier, muttered to us under his breath, “Leave! Now! Quick, get up.” He was warning, not menacing us.

Howard and I looked at each other. We’d come expecting to get arrested. It didn’t seem right to just get up and move because someone told us to, without arresting us. We stayed where we were. No one else left either. Boots were touching our shoes. The voice over our heads whispered intensely, “Move! Please. For God’s sake, move!” Knees in uniform pressed our knees. I saw a club coming down. I put my hands over my head, fists clenched, and a four-foot baton hit my wrist, hard. Another one hit my shoulder.

Advertisement

Square, Site wide
I rolled over, keeping my arms over my head, got up and moved back a few yards. Howard was being hauled off by several policemen. One had Howard’s arms pinned behind him, another had jerked his head back by the hair. Someone had ripped his shirt in two, there was blood on his bare chest. A moment before he had been sitting next to me, and I waited for someone to do the same to me, but no one did. I didn’t see anyone else getting arrested. But no one was sitting anymore, the line had been broken, disintegrated. Those who had been sitting hadn’t moved very far, they were standing like me a few yards back, looking around, holding themselves where they’d been clubbed. The police had stopped moving. They stood in a line, helmets still down, slapping their batons against their hands. Their adrenaline was still up, but they were standing in place.

Blood was running down my hand, covering the back of my hand. I was wearing a heavy watch, and it had taken the force of the blow. The baton had smashed the crystal and driven pieces of glass into my wrist. Blood was dripping off my fingers. Someone gave me a handkerchief to wrap around my wrist and told me to raise my arm. The handkerchief got soaked quickly and blood was running down my arm while I looked for a first-aid station that was supposed to be at the back of the crowd, in a corner of the square. I finally found it, and someone picked the glass out of my arm and put a thick bandage around it.

I went back to the protest. My shoulder was aching. The police were standing where they had stopped, and the blockade had reformed, people were sitting 10 yards back from where they had been before. There seemed to be more people sitting, not fewer. Many of the supporters had joined in. But it was quiet. No one was speaking loudly, no laughing. People were waiting for the police to move forward again. They weren’t expecting any longer to get arrested.

Only three or four people had been picked out of the line to be arrested before. The police had made a decision (it turned out) to arrest only the “leaders,” not to give us the publicity of arrests and trials. Howard hadn’t been an organizer of this action, he was just participating like the rest of us, but from the way they treated him when they pulled him out of the line, his comments directly to the police in the rally the day before must have rubbed someone the wrong way.


New and Improved Comments

If you have trouble leaving a comment, review this help page. Still having problems? Let us know. If you find yourself moderated, take a moment to review our comment policy.

By Caring H. Beings, February 9, 2010 at 7:48 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

We all love you Howard Zinn.  You live in our hearts and minds, ever strengthening and encouraging us, giving us hope in this seemingly hopeless time of unthinkable violence and greed.  I can still hear your voice, from times I’ve heard you speaking.  Thank you for all the love and courage you expressed in your life, in so many ways.
This is the first comment I ever made on the internet.

Report this

By doublestandards/glasshouses, January 30, 2010 at 1:48 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

Three hour talk with Howard Zinn from 2002 at:
http://www.booktv.org

Report this

By Henry Pelifian, January 30, 2010 at 9:39 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

Howard Zinn was the kind of scrupulously honest thinker and historian the country needs more of as we stumble along putting our great forward in one quagmire after another using the national credit card by elected officials who despite all the rhetoric are as much collectors of welfare money as the most needy in our country requiring financial assistance and namely they are not better than the poor, they just have more public money to utilize.

Mr. Zinn and I exchanged emails and he was always very considerate and he was kind enough to take a look at my play Thoreau which I sent him less than two weeks ago.

His contributions to the country have been immense.

Report this

By Magda, January 29, 2010 at 8:02 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

Don’t mourn. Organise! He had a great and long life. A man and life to celebrate. Be inspired by his example and go out and live and love and connect with others and ORGANISE together!

Report this

By YMR, January 29, 2010 at 4:47 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

and regarding “Columbus Day” humbug:

It had been a distinct honor to have my UH sociology students read aloud in class, relay fashion, Zinn’s chapter about Columbus over the course my 16 years teaching.

Some students cried, and all were utterly shocked.

Many, many thanks Howard Zinn.

ymr

Report this

By NYCartist, January 29, 2010 at 2:36 pm Link to this comment

What wonderful comments.  I only will add that my favorite book is “You Can’t Be Neutral on a Moving Train”, Zinn’s autobio.  It’s a masterpiece of social activism, starting with the intro.  And the photo in the book’s front is one of Howard and Roslyn Zinn, his wife who died in May, 2008, taken by Daniel Ellsberg, long ago.  H. Zinn would write that you never know what action you take, even small, might have an effect on someone, to do something for peace and justice.  There’s a great line in the article/obit on Howard Zinn (the one on Roslyn Zinn was so good, I saved it), by James Carroll.  After saying how Howard Zinn loved people, Carroll said, “How much we all loved him back.”.  Indeed.  He saw each one of us as people to make change happen.

Report this

By NYCartist, January 29, 2010 at 2:26 pm Link to this comment

To Mike 789: there’s a Yiddish word for what you just said, mensch, a real human being.  You captured Howard Zinn, the person, perfectly.

Report this

By Norman Birnbaum, January 29, 2010 at 7:41 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

Howard was a man of inner steadfastness—for an earlier generation one of those inner directed Americans dewcribed in David Rieman’s The Lonely Crowd as representative of an earlier and certainly not worse nation. I recall his reflecting on his wartime experiences as a member of a bomber crew in the USAF: only later, he said, did he come to question the morality of bombing cities. I also remember the vulgarity of the spiritually impoverished John Silber, who as President of Boston University kept Howard’s salary low as a punitive gesture. John interpreted academic freedom to mean the freedom of university administrators to set limits on what was taught and said. So Howard’s salary as time went on was relative to that of others, smaller and smaller—-but the sales of his books and the impact of his ideas and person were undiminished.even larger. Howard wasted no time or energy on his would be adversary, rendering his antagonism even more contemptible.

Report this
Mike789's avatar

By Mike789, January 29, 2010 at 7:06 am Link to this comment

A genuine “human being”. In the truest extistential interpretation in the modern era, sustaining a mental toughness based on Truth and Justice, is not an easy task. Prof. Zinn taught responsibility for one’s actions, without the convenience of subterfuge. He lived that ethic and for that honestly, for me, he will always be a symbol of what nobility ought to be founded upon.

Report this

By craigkelly, January 28, 2010 at 10:49 pm Link to this comment

By cmarcusparr, January 28 at 1:56 pm #
I never met Howard Zinn but he was a part of my life. I became a public school teacher late in my life and was fortunate to teach in a small school, that gave me freedom to teach.  I used Zinn’s A Peoples’ History in my Contemporary World Problems class..

I am proud that a number of the students purchased copies of this book for their personal libraries and shared it with friends. 

So,cmarcusparr, share his works with your grandkids and hope for the future.

Report this

By FreeWill, January 28, 2010 at 9:54 pm Link to this comment

Voice of the people, for the people and with the people.  Stood tall, committed to airing truth in history as apposed to politically correct interpretations of history.
An inspiration to all who are oppressed. Reminding us that real change never comes from the so called leaders at the top, but is created by the people at the bottom.
The people have lost a very great man.  It’s very sad, but for the many lives he has changed for the better and people he has inspired; which is just about the most
any one could hope to accomplish.

Report this
Ouroborus's avatar

By Ouroborus, January 28, 2010 at 6:52 pm Link to this comment

Amy Goodman, Naomi Klein, Noam Chomsky and Alice Walker
on Howard Zinn;

http://www.democracynow.org/

Report this

By doublestandards/glasshouses, January 28, 2010 at 6:20 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

In his last published piece of writing which he did
for this weeks issue of The Nation, on Obama’s first
year, Zinn said that he wasn’t disappointed in Obama
because he never expected much to begin with.  He
said he thought Obama would be a mediocre president
and that a mediocre president is a dangerous
president.  For that reason he said the left has to
keep pressure on him.

Zinn is a good antidote to the sense of hopelessness
that seems to afflict everybody these days.  In his
later years he was very clear about his belief that
there is no such thing as a just war - that war can
never be justified.  We need to keep telling our so
called leaders that.

Report this
Samson's avatar

By Samson, January 28, 2010 at 5:35 pm Link to this comment

By the way, you know what’s odd about this.  For all the praise lavished on him now that he’s gone, I don’t ever remember Truthdig publishing any of Zinn’s writings on this site.  I guess he was just a little too far left for this site that so loves WaPo Democrat propaganda writers instead.

Report this
Samson's avatar

By Samson, January 28, 2010 at 5:34 pm Link to this comment

Howard Zinn is a hero to me.

Years ago, I subscribed to some magazine, I forget which one.  I didn’t even know the subscription came with a book, until ‘The Howard Zinn Reader’ arrived in my mailbox.

What an amazing book.  I was in the midst of my 20 year stint in Atlanta then, and the history that book helped to teach me about the civil rights movement in that town was alone well worth the subscription to whatever magazine that was.

Thank you very much Profesor Zinn!!!!!!!!!!!

Report this

By john, January 28, 2010 at 3:22 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

Lectures on civil disobedience can be good.  There will be a lot of it if the fines and prison terms pass for the health care bill.

Report this

By Tom Degan, January 28, 2010 at 1:37 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

There will never again be anyone like him - or will there? We can always hope, can’t we?

http://www.tomdegan.blogspot.com

Tom Degan

Report this

By radson, January 28, 2010 at 12:36 pm Link to this comment

Thank you Professor Zinn for all your efforts and wisdom ,may your spirit emanate from the heavens ,to help guide us all .Your conclusion in stating that Wars through all the tumultuous reasons for being waged
have not changed the Fundamental erroneous enterprise is correct. The famous Quote “You can’t stand still on a moving train ” is so true and I wonder how long we will Stand Still?

Report this

By marlene share, January 28, 2010 at 12:31 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

In addition to being saddened by the loss of this giant, I feel a personal loss since in 1 short week, on A Nation Magazine Cruise, his warmth and friendliness gave me a much needed shot of adrenaline at a tough time in my life.  My favorite gift to any young people - I believe I’ve purchases 100 or more - has been “Voices of a People’s History”.  The world will miss Howard, but we’ll have his wisdom, courage and leadership forever.

Report this
Night-Gaunt's avatar

By Night-Gaunt, January 28, 2010 at 10:42 am Link to this comment

We have lost the man but not his legacy. That will still stand as will all the people who have been touched by him and have yet to be touched. May your ideas inspire many generations, especially this one. So long but not good by.

Report this

By 7man, January 28, 2010 at 10:26 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

Howard Zinn gave a lecture at my high school, some forty years ago, on the nature of radicalism. Mr. Zinn explained that “radical meant ‘root’- a radical seeks the root of an issue, nothing more, nothing less”. In a world of spin,distortion, and plain old B.S., Howard Zinn’s words still speak with clarity- not to be ashamed to seek out the truth. A radical concept.

Report this

By cmarcusparr, January 28, 2010 at 9:56 am Link to this comment

We’ve lost a true American hero. My tribute to Howard Zinn will be to purchase his books for my grandchildren to read when they enter the public school system. They’re three- and two-years-old. My hope is, through the despair of these times, a new generation of Americans will wake up and take to the streets and wrench our democracy back from the corporations, Supreme Court, and a Congress run by venal self-interest. But, I have to admit, it seems a blighted hope lately.

Report this

By Bubba, January 28, 2010 at 8:25 am Link to this comment

Thank you for leading your life as you did. Godspeed.

Report this

By Lyn LeJeune, January 28, 2010 at 7:21 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

He was the kindest man I ever knew.  He took time for anyone who needed him and gave his honest and true self. He was much loved; he changed many of us for the better; he will be missed and remembered as a friend to democracy, goodness, and peace.
Lyn LeJeune

Report this

By idarad, January 28, 2010 at 5:56 am Link to this comment

Howard -  truly a man of peace, you weren’t an American you were a moral compass for the world.  For you, no person’s achievements were too small, and no leader above reproach when criticism due, for in your eyes all are equal. 
Amazing life - amazing human!  I will miss you greatly!

Report this
photoshock's avatar

By photoshock, January 28, 2010 at 5:46 am Link to this comment

To one and all, My heartfelt condolences on the untimely death of a GREAT American and Patriot. This is a blow to all who knew him, and to those of us who only knew his words.
I am deeply saddened at this great loss! An American Patriot who had given his life for the cause of the people, peace and progress. We, the ones left behind cannot begin to estimate the gravity of the loss of Howard Zinn.
A voice of compassion and true patriotism has been silenced. I am at a standstill as to how to continue, but continue I will to defend the cause of peace and justice in the Americas and around the world. I will not be silenced by any act of Congress that goes against the Bill of Rights, as does HR 1955.
The struggle must continue, we must use all means at our disposal, except violence, to continue the struggle of peace and justice. For the memory of Howard Zinn, I pledge my life, my body, my very being
to continue this struggle.
Nothing more be said, only more be done to fight the powers that be. WE ARE ONE! WE ARE INVINCIBLE! WE ARE THE PEOPLE! WE cannot be denied, we cannot lose, we will win. Always in the end the people win.

Report this

By ardee, January 28, 2010 at 5:41 am Link to this comment

That Americans like Howard Zinn exist, Daniel Ellsburg too, gives the lie to hopelessness and despair. This nation can and will be saved, exactly because of people like these.

Report this
Ouroborus's avatar

By Ouroborus, January 28, 2010 at 4:55 am Link to this comment

I envy that you actually got to know him; alas, I only
knew him through his writings. But that alone was
awesome.
Here’s what I wrote on my blog for Howard;
This is truly a huge loss for America and the world.
Historian, activist, and author; Howard Zinn is the
person who woke me up to the real history of the U.S.
and thus, the world. Thanks to him I’ll never be fooled
again.
RIP Howard; you’ll be missed; you were truly one of a
kind. Thanks.

Report this

By bmeisen, January 28, 2010 at 1:32 am Link to this comment

Thanks for this rememberance. Howard Zinn was a great American, a true patriot and generous defender of a work in progress - the Constitution. 3 books are at the center of my identity as an American: An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the US by Beard, The Tragedy of American Diplomacy by Williams, and A People’s History of the US by Zinn.

Report this

By Ruth, January 28, 2010 at 12:57 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

Howard Zinn was one of the greatest minds of all time.  He made such a great difference in the world by presenting history as those who lived it saw it.

I remember that he endorsed Dennis Kucinich for President, showing that he understood that America needed a President they could trust.  He also spoke highly of Cyhthia McKinnney and her courage to stand up against the First Gulf War in “A People’s History…”

I hope that schools will continue to encourage students to read his books as there are no substitutes for “A People’s History…” and “Voices of a People’s History…”

I also recall that Howard Zinn was a very nice man who was easy to speak with. He was always trying to help others and was a genuine hero.

There are no words that can adequately describe how tragic a loss this is.

Report this
Newsletter

sign up to get updates


 
 
Right 1, Site wide - BlogAds Premium
 
Right 2, Site wide - Blogads
 
Join the Liberal Blog Advertising Network
 
 
 
Right Skyscraper, Site Wide
 
Join the Liberal Blog Advertising Network
 

A Progressive Journal of News and Opinion   Publisher, Zuade Kaufman   Editor, Robert Scheer
© 2014 Truthdig, LLC. All rights reserved.