Top Leaderboard, Site wide
Truthdig: Drilling Beneath the Headlines
May 27, 2017 Disclaimer: Please read.

Statements and opinions expressed in articles are those of the authors, not Truthdig. Truthdig takes no responsibility for such statements or opinions.

Rising Star

Truthdig Bazaar more items

Email this item Print this item

Africa’s Good Friend

Posted on Feb 27, 2009
Bush and Tantoh
AP photo / J. Scott Applewhite

After speaking on his efforts to fight HIV/AIDS, President Bush hoists 4-year-old Baron Mosima Loyiso Tantoh, son of HIV-positive Manyongo Mosima “Kuene” Tantoh of South Africa, who met with Bush at the White House in 2007.

By Gbemisola Olujobi

(Page 2)

In Uganda, where Coutinho works, 110,000 people are under treatment, and 2 million have HIV tests each year, a huge difference from the 10,000 treated and 400,000 tested annually before PEPFAR. According to Coutinho, “The money comes mostly from PEPFAR, and also from a United Nations fund to which the United States contributes.”

Indeed, Bush was honored on the 20th anniversary of World AIDS Day with the International Medal of Peace, given by the Saddleback Church’s Rev. Rick Warren on behalf of the Global Peace Coalition during the Saddleback Civil Forum on Global Health.

At the 2008 Bishop John T. Walker Memorial Dinner, Africare, the oldest and largest black-run African aid organization, awarded the group’s Distinguished Humanitarian Service Award to Bush for the work done for Africa by his administration and family, and described that work as “a labor of love.”

Barack Obama acknowledged Bush’s AIDS relief efforts in taped remarks to the Saddleback Civil Forum on Global Health. “I salute President Bush for his leadership in crafting a plan for AIDS relief in Africa and backing it up with funding dedicated to saving lives and preventing the spread of the disease,” said Obama, who went on to promise to continue working “to address the crisis around the world.”


Square, Site wide
Deddeh Zaizay, a Liberian woman, was abandoned by her husband because she was illiterate. Left alone to struggle to bring up the three children of the marriage, she soon picked up the pieces of her life. But before she could put the humiliation of her abandonment behind her, she had to do one thing—learn to read and write. She started learning to read under a program supported by the Africa Education Initiative, AEI, another of Bush’s “Africa programs.”

When AEI was launched in 2002, Bush committed to provide $600 million over eight years to increase access to quality basic education in 39 sub-Saharan countries through scholarships, textbooks and teacher training programs. Thanks to AEI, Deddeh has put her pain behind her. She now plans to go to college.

So far, the Africa Education Initiative has trained 700,000 teachers, distributed more than 10 million textbooks and provided hundreds of thousands of scholarships to help girls go to school. By 2010, AEI will have distributed over 15 million textbooks, trained nearly 1 million teachers and provided 550,000 scholarships for girls. The United States Agency for International Development (USAID) estimates that, overall, 80 million African children will have benefited from AEI by 2010.

African girls like Esther Gohole are beginning to dream. Says Esther, “My favorite subject is math. I want to be a pilot when I grow up.” Hawa Hussein says, “My favorite subject is biology. … I would like to be a medical doctor.” Phales Malisope wants to be a scientist.

Dr. Sarah Wright, chief education officer of USAID in Kenya, supports the dreams of these Kenyan girls. She says: “Education is a key element in long-term sustainable development. If children are educated, particularly the girl child, she is more likely to send her children to school, they are more likely to be healthy, they are more likely to be more productive citizens as a result of the influence of their educated mother.”

Rougiatou Diallo, a mother of two in the Guédiawaye district near Dakar, Senegal, is a beneficiary of the President’s Malaria Initiative (PMI), a $1.2 billion, five-year plan to reduce deaths caused by malaria by 50 percent in 15 African countries. The program was launched in June 2005 by President Bush. Diallo received an anti-malaria bed net when she took her children to participate in a combined micronutrient and bed net campaign in May 2007. She was so pleased with the free net that “came from the Americans” that her family bought a second net at a nearby health center to help protect her and her six children from malaria. In seven months of using the nets, she said, no one in her family came down with the mosquito-borne disease.

In addition to providing bed nets, the malaria initiative supports indoor spraying of insecticide as well as drugs and medicine to treat the disease. Manufacture of mosquito nets, treated with a special insecticide, can also provide employment for local people.

According to the United Nations, malaria is the main cause of death for children in Africa, killing a child every 30 seconds. The World Health Organization also argues that one in five childhood deaths in Africa is due to the effects of the disease. Pregnant women and small children are advised to sleep under mosquito barriers treated with insecticide, but many African mothers, such as Rakiatou Touré of Kabara, Mali, cannot afford a net, which cost $10. The PMI has stepped in. Touré got a net through PMI. “Without this program I would never have been able to afford a net. Now I sleep well, and my kids aren’t bothered by mosquito bites,” she says. It is estimated that the PMI has already reached 25 million people in sub-Saharan Africa alone.

New and Improved Comments

If you have trouble leaving a comment, review this help page. Still having problems? Let us know. If you find yourself moderated, take a moment to review our comment policy.

Join the conversation

Load Comments

By Franc, March 4, 2009 at 12:38 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

Unfortunately, PEPFAR’s flawed prevention policies including directives for abstinence and be-faithful programs, and fails to integrate HIV prevention services into family planning services. In their version of this legislation, H.R. 5501, the House of Representatives also includes ideological constraints on the provision of care. Specifically, the House requires family planning clinics to abide by the global gag rule and not provide or refer for abortions to be eligible for HIV funding.

Although initially PEPFAR may have helped thousands, I believe that giving vital aid should never be conditional on poor people accepting ideology.

It’s a form of bribery and blackmail!

Report this

By Santayana, March 4, 2009 at 8:16 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

We should also remember that Bono and Bobby Shriver created Project (RED) to provide anti-retroviral drugs for Africa, and did so with no silence clauses, gag orders, or strings attached. As for Bush doing something worthwhile, let’s credit the man. Now he spends one less day face down on Satan’s griddle. And Hitler loved puppies. What’s the point?

Report this

By msgmi, March 3, 2009 at 8:56 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

Bono lobbied his heart out and for once Bush delivered.

Report this

By mg, March 2, 2009 at 10:37 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

Thanks to Mr. Wexler, and Louise, for the counterpunch. It seems nothing the man did was for good. Too much in the way. He was the best worst President we ever had!

Report this

By Reubenesque, March 2, 2009 at 9:09 am Link to this comment

AMEN, W.W.W.!  This photo of ‘Wrongworst’ can’t be pushed down the ‘Reports’ stack soon enough!

Report this
William W. Wexler's avatar

By William W. Wexler, March 2, 2009 at 8:34 am Link to this comment

Sorry, but calling Bush Africa’s good friend over his role in AIDS prevention is naive and inaccurate.  Depending on the motivation, it could just be called an outright lie.

The truth about Bush and AIDS relief is that his interest is in Big Pharma, not ending the devastation of the disease.  Under the Bush AIDS relief plan, it was illegal to sell the cheaper generic drugs, so only the high profit drugs were available.  So although AIDS medications reached around 2 million people, the 25 million who got none could have if it wouldn’t have been for Bush’s restriction on generics.

Further, aid was contingent on “economic austerity” measures from these poor governments, which complied in part by cutting health services to the people who needed them most.

According to a joint report issued by 39 NGOs, Bush’s Africa AIDS relief plan allows 5 people to become infected for every 2 it helps, based on its ideological (religious) approach.  Among recommendations in a letter written to Senators Reid, Lugar, and Biden are:

1) Remove all requirements and language governing distribution of funds for prevention of sexual transmission. The original PEPFAR legislation contained an earmark requiring that 33 percent of all funding for prevention activities be allocated to abstinence-only-until-marriage programs despite any evidence supporting this practice.

2) Remove the refusal clause (the so-called “conscience clause.”) The Global AIDS Act of 2003 includes a refusal clause or so-called “conscience clause” allowing organizations to receive scarce public funding to carry out prevention programs that are based on their own philosophy, even if it is in conflict with evidence-based interventions.

3) Remove the “prostitution pledge.” Though to date both the House and Senate have been disinclined to address it, imperatives of both public health and human rights compel us to remind you of the enormous negative impact of the anti-prostitution pledge. Current law requires groups fighting HIV/AIDS overseas to pledge their opposition to prostitution and sex trafficking before receiving U.S. money.

4) Include explicit language strengthening the linkages between reproductive health services and HIV prevention.

These are highlights from the letter, which was signed by 39 NGOs.  You can get the list here:

I am not sure what the motivation was for writing this article.  If it was legacy-building for Bush, forget it.  Bush was the worst president in America’s history and his approach to every single problem was to evaluate it for its political ideology first and business impact second.  His disregard for US and international law is famous, and he should and probably will be prosecuted for war crimes including an illegal invasion and occupation of a sovereign state, torture, and a raft of other charges including illegal wiretapping, disregard of Article VI paragraph 2 (Supremacy Clause),  and outing a CIA operative for political purposes.

No, it’s not “cool” to bash Bush.  But it’s ignorant and dishonest to apologize for him.  After the outright atrocious, dangerous, and lawless government we’ve suffered for the last 8 years, I’m not going to stand by and let his legacy be whitewashed by half-truths about a feel-good AIDS relief package, either.  This approach was ineffective, dishonest, and ideological and it ended up costing people’s lives… just like everything else Bush did.


Report this

By SteveL, March 1, 2009 at 4:34 pm Link to this comment

Guess we needed to see Bush’s smiling face once again.

Report this

By Gambetti, March 1, 2009 at 1:59 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

Wow all I can read from these comments are words of pure IGNORANCE. So none of you were there when he rescued us from Silicon Valley crash? or maybe you were not there when he gave us tax cuts so we could use that money on the economy? Or what about the relief he gave in tax cuts on investing in stocks that helped us keep afloat for as long as we did. He had this planned for awhile. He also previously gave aid for the fight again Malaria in Africa and cut the spread by 65%. I see hating Bush is cool but if you are American he was still your president. He also had the highest approval rating of any president in history. So instead of making him the scapegoat for owning up to what he did and remaining steadfast instead of wavering to your flimsy do’s and don’ts, you should maybe look at yourself in shame. Know your facts, not what other people state as facts…. nubs

Report this

By Ibett, March 1, 2009 at 11:33 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

Most of the monies do not get to the needed source, there are strings attached to receive aid:  NO CONDOMS, ABSTENENCE ONLY, LISTEN TO CHRISTIAN RHETORIC, this is a farce just like georgey dumbo stupid.  The only prize george bush deserves is life in prison for war crimes and demolishing our country and constitution, it is shameful.


Report this

By Louise, March 1, 2009 at 11:08 am Link to this comment

This comes on the heels of a week-long bash Bush conference. Or at the very least, a “we don’t know that man” celebration. How sad when the very people who so hysterically supported Bush are now hysterically trying to distance themselves from Bush. He must be feeling a twinge of abandonment. And seeing the hopelessness of looking to his base to help him, he turns instead to the rest of us. Could the reality that those loyal supporters are all completely nuts be lost on him? Could it be that Bush is not near so stupid as we all thought he was? That in fact he simply worked hard to portray himself as, dumb enough to deserve the position of leading the even dumber?

Look who his former base elevates to a mock position of authority. Newt Gingrich! Sarah Palin! Joe the plumber! Rush Limbaugh! They are so fractured and befuddled, they even celebrate Ron Paul as one of their own! And the fact that Ron Paul accepted that elevation, showed up and spoke to CPAC’s collection of burned out light bulbs is telling. Can we suppose Bush was expecting an invitation to speak? Or should we suppose one was extended and he refused.

Recognition comes late to Bush. Maybe that should be the title of his memoir.

Gbemisola Olujobi, is a recipient of the first IWMF fellowship for international women journalists. This article reports a reality in Africa we hear about, but pay little attention to. Reporting a portion of that reality is responsible journalism. That the man featured in the positive happens to be Bush is simply just what it is. PEPFAR has had positive effect on the lives of many in Africa, suffering from AIDS. So maybe this story isn’t about Bush, so much as it’s about a journalist who reminds us not everything Bush did was followed by disaster.

Or, maybe Bush really is as dumb as a board and like so many morons, accidentally does something good once in a while. I doubt Bush focused on PEPFAR any more than he focused on anything else. But it might help his staff find something to focus on.

But even PEPFAR has it’s critics. As Joshua Kurlantzick points out in the September/October 2008 Issue of Mother Jones,

“Foreign assistance to African nations hard-hit by AIDS could have been the administration’s greatest success. Then ideology interfered.”

” - while PEPFAR has done wonders for aids treatment, it has missed the boat on prevention by insisting on moralistic rather than epidemiological strategies - until recently, one-third of its prevention funding, totaling hundreds of millions of dollars, was squandered on premarital abstinence programs that research shows don’t work. - PEPFAR has revolutionized aids treatment in Africa. When it comes to prevention, however, the White House has ensured that the aids program is governed by a counterproductive moral standard.

To run his aids initiative, Bush chose former Eli Lilly CEO Randall Tobias, who was indifferent to his own staff’s on-the-ground experience. Tobias’ reign ended with his resignation in April 2007. Turned out the man who’d been promoting abstinence around the globe was a client of the infamous DC Madam.”

In general, at least two-thirds of all foreign aid funds never leaves the United States, according to a Congressional Research Service report in 2006, The money buys U.S. products, pays U.S salaries, overhead, benefits packages, travel, American-made vehicles, office expenses, computers and other equipment. USAID awards 87 percent of its consultant dollars to U.S. based firms. In addition 30% of PEPFAR funds have been given to ideologically driven groups who inhibit prevention and treatment with an abstinence only and NO sex education policy.

During the campaign, Obama released a plan to combat global HIV and AIDS pledging that “best practice, not ideology” would drive US funding for HIV/AIDS programs. Perhaps that plan will include reducing waste in money’s held here and actually deliver more money there.

Report this

By Inherit The Wind, March 1, 2009 at 5:53 am Link to this comment

I guess the only thing I can say is that this is the broken clock syndrome: Even a broken clock is right twice a day.

Amidst all of the havoc and despair that George W. Bush wrought during his catastrophic 8 years there are few items and actions for which he cannot be condemned (amidst the cornucopia of ones for which he MUST be condemned).  This is one of them. Could it have been done better? Of course.  But at least he did it.

He also set aside the Mariana Trench as a protected area so it isn’t contaminated. That’s good—small, but good.

He also did his best to evade and avoid the Hard Right’s push for draconian immigration laws and enforcement against Mexico and illegal immigrants (primarily Mexicans and Latin Americans).  As an offshoot of that in a rare moment of political insight, he warned that the GOP was seriously alienating a critical support base: The largest minority in America, Hispanics.

Of course, even birdbrains like James Buchanan, Franklin Pierce and Warren G. Harding had minor things they did well, amidst the disasters they otherwise foisted upon the US.

Report this

By Chris, February 28, 2009 at 10:43 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

If somebody does something good, I will focus on that. There are many people who would owe their lives to his program.

Might your own take on it be different if you were one of those people?

And this is coming from someone who regretted the day Bush was selected (obviously not elected) to be President. I don’t think any of us had a clue as to how horrible his Presidency would really be…

Hundreds of thousands of Iraqi’s dead…perhaps a million or more. Countless injured for life. Somewhere near 4500 dead American soldiers. Many thousands “wounded”...meaning paralyzed, blinded for life, brain damaged, psychologically damaged…

It’s horrible. The man who was really elected the first time out, Al Gore, would never have done any of that. And, I don’t see why he wouldn’t have given Africa the same assistance with AIDS that George W. Bush gave them.

But still, help arrived to a hurting Africa. Many people are alive today that may not have been. If George W. Bush is responsible for it, he should be credited with it.

Report this

By Less Laugh, February 28, 2009 at 6:31 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

I say, we give Bush the “Ignoble Peace Prize.”

Report this

By Ching-Ching, February 28, 2009 at 3:28 pm Link to this comment

At last, somethong good that Bush did.

Report this

By Fadel Abdallah, February 28, 2009 at 1:37 pm Link to this comment

Strange! Very strange indeed that Bush is viewed by some Africans as a friend of Africa when he could not be a friend of at least half of the his own American people and most of the world at large!

I would suggest that the writer of this piece lead a campaign among his African brothers and sisters to appoint Bush as a king-for-life over all the continent so per chance they would really experience Bush’s benevolence at a larger scale!

Report this
lOst_sOuls_rembrd's avatar

By lOst_sOuls_rembrd, February 28, 2009 at 1:20 pm Link to this comment

Is this the beginning of Bush trying to change how history will judge him?  He is a shameful human being and I will NEVER forget his part in the destruction of this country, our freedom and the many lost lives of our fellow citizens as well as human beings all over the world.

I promise to never forget and I will never stop doing my part to help others to remember.

God have mercy on us all…all over the world.

Report this

By GB, February 28, 2009 at 9:46 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

At first this looks good for bush but we know with everything he did in his disasterous 8 years was to line the pockets of his business friends in oil and pharmaceuticals. He stripped the family planning parts out leaving millions more in Africa vulnerable to STDs including HIV. Where was he during Katrina? We know that answer. I would love to be able to hail his acheivements but it seems his best photo ops were anywhere but where they should have been.

Report this
Right Top, Site wide - Care2
Right Skyscraper, Site Wide
Right Internal Skyscraper, Site wide