|
|
May 23, 2013
|
|
Whistling Dixie—AgainPosted on Feb 18, 2011Does Haley Barbour really have a warped and offensive view of America’s racial history? Or is he just playing a dangerous game? Perhaps both. The Mississippi governor, considered a potential Republican candidate for president in 2012, keeps displaying what appears to be an astonishing level of ignorance about our nearly 400-year struggle with issues of race. At this point, it’s more than a pattern. It’s either a pathology or a plan. The latest outrage—and I don’t use that word lightly—came Tuesday, when Barbour was asked to comment on a proposal for a state license plate honoring one of the most notorious figures of the Civil War era, Confederate Gen. Nathan Bedford Forrest. I question whether any Confederate officer is worthy of such recognition, given that they were all committing treason. But even for the Sons of Confederate Veterans—the group proposing the license plate—Forrest should be an embarrassment. For those who do not see the Civil War through a revisionist gauze of gallantry and Spanish moss, Forrest is an abomination. In 1864, his troops mowed down scores of black Union soldiers who were trying to surrender, in what became known as the Fort Pillow Massacre. After the war, Forrest became one of the founding fathers of the terrorist Ku Klux Klan—and was the group’s first national leader, or “grand wizard.” Advertisement But of course, Barbour denounces people all the time. Just last weekend, at the annual Conservative Political Action Conference in Washington, he denounced President Obama and the Democratic Party. Denouncing is part of any politician’s job, and Barbour does it with brio and elan. Why would he refuse to say what he thinks about honoring a founder of the KKK? This odd reticence follows three recent episodes in which Barbour was all too glib. Last April, he was asked to comment on Virginia Gov. Bob McDonnell’s “Confederate History Month” proclamation that neglected to mention slavery. McDonnell quickly apologized and corrected what he described as a serious error. Barbour, however, maintained that the controversy “doesn’t amount to diddly” and that there was no need “to explain to people that slavery is a bad thing.” In September, Barbour claimed that “my generation” in the South went to “integrated schools” and that he “went to integrated college—never thought twice about it.” Barbour actually went to all-white Mississippi schools. His college, the University of Mississippi, was integrated in 1962 when federal marshals escorted James Meredith onto campus while white students rioted in protest. When Barbour arrived a few years later, the few black students at Ole Miss were harassed and shunned. In December, Barbour praised the White Citizens Council in his hometown of Yazoo City for its role in the fight over desegregation. In fact, the Citizens Councils throughout the South were implacable in their defense of segregation. They just favored nonviolent tactics—such as having “uppity” blacks fired from their jobs—instead of burning crosses. Barbour quickly retracted his praise of the Citizens Councils. But here we are again, just a couple of months later, trying to bridge the distance between Barbour’s version of history and what actually happened. If this is the way Barbour thinks, the prospect that he might run for president should be alarming. I have to acknowledge the possibility, however, that in this instance he’s just being insincere and clever. Nothing about the way Barbour has acted in his long public life suggests that he really admires the first grand wizard of the KKK. But by dodging the question, he avoids alienating voters who might think that Forrest was a prince of a guy. In other words: “It’s not my job to tell the American people what to think.” Hold it, that quote isn’t from Barbour, it’s from House Speaker John Boehner. That’s what he said Sunday on “Meet the Press,” when asked why he doesn’t forthrightly tell the “birthers” who doubt President Obama’s citizenship that they’re wrong. Like other prominent Republicans, Boehner was encouraging the wing nuts with careful equivocation and strategic silence. “I’ll take him at his word,” Boehner said, when asked whether he believes Obama is a Christian. I suppose, then, that I’ll have to take Barbour at his word that he’s not a racist. Is that how you play this game? Eugene Robinson’s e-mail address is eugenerobinson(at)washpost.com. New and Improved CommentsIf you have trouble leaving a comment, review this help page. Still having problems? Let us know. If you find yourself moderated, take a moment to review our comment policy. |
By Chris Herz, February 22, 2011 at 5:04 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
If there is some future for civilization, and if there are historians working in that day, the object of their greatest wonder and scholarly researches will be the suicide of the Great Republic.
Report thisI suggest they look at the people who support the likes of Haley Barbour, an ugly and corrupt K Street creep who knows full well how to exploit the crudest racism and superstition.
Of course, these historians will be likewise astonished at the weakness and venality of the mock opposition to these perverts . . .
By ocjim, February 21, 2011 at 11:10 pm Link to this comment
Haley Barbour’s been a jerk his whole life.
Report thisBy aacme88, February 20, 2011 at 9:21 pm Link to this comment
Barbour knows exactly who he’s playing to. We live in a right-wing media induced era of one-upmanship (or one-downmanship) in stupidity and craziness, a race to the bottom in rhetoric designed to be completely devoid of intelligence, integrity or sensitivity.
Report thisThis is what we crave in our leaders, because it’s what we are programmed to crave by an oligarchy who know that a leaderless population are easy to dominate and strip of its assets.
Any leader emerging to prominence who does not fit that description is first vilified, then co-opted.
Having all the money in the world makes it easy to get things done, but also makes all the money in the world seem like not enough.
By mack894, February 19, 2011 at 3:24 pm Link to this comment
Haley Barbour will never be president. Making statements like he has
guarantees they’ll define his campaign; he’ll be turned into a freak show.
Barbour hopes that if he can revise the history of the south, people won’t hold
it against him, especially Mississippi. If he wants to debate it, there are plenty
of historians who would be glad to share their research with him.
Even the Clintons indulged in racial innuendos until they got caught. Hillary
Clinton’s “as far as I know,” is the same thing as “well, that’s what he’s said.”
Scare people, make them doubt Obama’s heritage, his religion, his loyalties.
As a firm progressive, I am no longer an Obama enthusiast. He knows
Report thisprogressives have abandoned him, but thinks that if he centers enough, he’ll
get get independents and enough progressives who just couldn’t tolerate
another Bush. Perhaps. But people have been pretty battered these past few
years; I don’t think they’ll tolerate much more.
By Aarky, February 18, 2011 at 10:58 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
Big B- I’m still laughing and it’s all so sadly true. I will never forget travelling with a bunch of Yankee soldiers through Alabama in late 1964 and how the owner of a gas station almost grovelled as he apologized for having us use the colored rest room because the for “whites only” was being repaired. It’s all about God Guns, and Gays along with a good dose of racism. The kicker is that many of those people who vote Republican are dirt poor, with no insurance, and will suffer in silence and die early quite like those cursed Democrats. Barbour is catering to that crowd, but I still judge a man on how fat he is and won’t trust a fat politician. General Nathan Bedford Forest was probably the best tactician the South had during the war. He enlisted as a private and rose to the rank of General. After the war he let the KKK use his name and then told them to disband, they refused and he quite the outfit. I’ll have to do more research on the Ft Pillow incident, but the South will keep their heros no matter how bad they might be.
Report thisBy berniem, February 18, 2011 at 6:28 pm Link to this comment
At age 63 and having met numerous people in and from different parts of this nation I regret to have to say that with few exceptions white, “conservative”, evangelical protestants are for the most part white supremacists and intolerant of any group or culture unlike their own. Of course, as in all things, some are more virulent or demonstrative in their prejudices than others but if one scratches the surface, a true red, white, and blue bigot will appear! This tendency supercedes political party or geographic region although the tendency is ridiculously pervasive in what continues to exist as the confederacy!
Report thisBy wonkronk, February 18, 2011 at 6:16 pm Link to this comment
As a politician, Governor Haley Barbour might want to pander to the many Neo-Confederates and white separatists who comprise a sizeable constituency, especially among Republicans, in his state, but this does not mean he isn’t a racist himself. We cannot reasonably expect any present Republican politician to be so bold as to denounce a white supremacist war criminal,as white supremacist war criminals are the models of highest aspiration among white Southerners. The kind of leadership needed to guide Neo-Confederates away from hate and ignorance does not exist among Republicans.
Report thisBy gerard, February 18, 2011 at 5:43 pm Link to this comment
When the upper class holds all the resources and money, and the middle class has to work to earn money to eat and pay the bills issued by the opper class, there has to be an under class to take care of the middle class kids while their parents work.
Report thisIn the case of the post-war South, this was the situation. Result? Many white middle class kids grew up to school age loving the black underclass men and particularly women who took care of them kindly and lovingly, and the little black kids they played with while their parents worked.
Those little white kids grew up with conflicted but unacknowledged feelings: They observed from daily experience that the people they loved who took care of them, they felt closer to than their parents, but their parents didn’t love these black “servants”—didn’t treat them equally, didn’t cross “the color line”, Furthermore, if asked, the white adults refused to admit any line existed. The truth was largely unspoken.
These kids, now grown up, are the majority of the Southern adult population. Their heads are full of un-asked and un-answered questions. Emotional confusion reigns unacknowledged and misunderstood.
The North makes enough mistakes to entitle it to be blamed.
Psychiatrists for Social Responsibility have their work cut out for them—after they get through with
closing Guantanamo, reforming the prison system, and
keeping an eye on Bradley Manning’s solitary confinement. Correct me if I’m wrong.
By Big B, February 18, 2011 at 4:05 pm Link to this comment
As someone who has traveled through the south extensively in the past 30 years, I can tell everyone that there is no reason to re-right the history books of Dixie, for they never changed. For many honkeys in the deep south and southwest, The civil war was a draw, the voting rights act was just northern agression, and the KKK is a social club like the masons or kiwanis. Barry being elected prez was for them the biggest “I told you so” coming true. One of those “uppity northern blacks” gettin’ all high and mighty with that college learnin’ and thinkin’ their better than us.
With that said, Haley stands a good chance in this repug field, because as far as dixie is concerned, there are only 2 republican candidates, Barbour and the pin-head Huckabee. Just remember, no other current repug will play in the south. Palin, let’s face it, in the south if its gots boobs, it aint gots brains (besides, ain’t no woman gonna tell me what to do) Pawlenty? carpetbagger. And poor Mitt Romney. They wouldn’t vote for him even if he wasn’t a member of that devil worshipping religion. Folks, it’s these sort of delicate sensabilities and grasp of social issues that gave us eight years of W.
Jebus! I am glad I am only 47! I may just live long enough to see the begining of the new dark ages.
Report thisBy Azcat85, February 18, 2011 at 3:38 pm Link to this comment
The enter South fought for secession, yet only 22% of the whites in the south
Report thisowned slaves. To label all of the south as slave owners is just as dishonest as
disregarding the free blacks that owned slaves and the white slaves that also
existed. Slavery was and always will be a fact in our history. Haley did not
indicate that it did not exist and probably should have limited his recollections to
his own history.
By who'syourdebs, February 18, 2011 at 2:33 pm Link to this comment
It absolutely is a game, Eugene. A cynical interchangeability of truth and falsehood. An imperialist end that always justifies the means. The Republicans are channeling Goebbels when the hammer the media with outrageous assertions and conspicuous lies, news cycle upon news cycle. People hear it so often, it becomes truth for too many. These modern conservatives believe deeply in the stupidity of Americans. They are betting the bank on this. It is likewise clear why they subvert education at every turn. It’s their modus operandi, after all. Some decades ago, in the sixties, too many blue-collar types and minorities got to go to college. Look what trouble that caused. Clinton! Planned Parenthood! Can’t let that happen again. The neo-con dream to take over the world. Mercy. People like Barbour don’t need political office-they need therapy.
Report thisBy Rodney, February 18, 2011 at 2:18 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
Haley Barbour is just another Republican who is
Report thisafraid to denounce the bigotry and hatred of the
racists that voted for him. He is actually one of
them. They have been trying to rewrite or soften the
history of slavery,the rape of black women and of
course lynching. Not to mention discrimination and
civil rights violations. They are trying to make
hero’s of people who committed war crimes and crimes
against humanity. These same people today talk of
states rights and taking their country. Haley Barbour
Sarah Palin and the racist wing of the Republican
will never win the Presidency.
By Leefeller, February 18, 2011 at 1:31 pm Link to this comment
Well the unhidden bigotry is not an exposure just a given coming from Mississippi! (actually spelled it without looking it up)
Now if I had only know before hand Obama was going to shuck what he touted during the campaign, though I knew he was a war hawk, one action before he became president which seemed a clear indicator should have been his dumping of Reverend Right plus the way he did it should have been a clear indicator of Obamas moldy irk. Now indicator of this Moron from Mississippi is clearly a given!
I can see it now, the transition from the birther, half black president who is clearly a Muslim to a racist KKK supporter, (Evangelical?) .....Nice! What ever happened to Palin, I prefer witch craft, I love the choices!
Though I prefer being sold down the river by someone who I know is going to do it, Obama has turned out a disappointment, maybe I will vote for the Mississippi moron, at least I know where I will be going before hand.
Report this