|
|
May 23, 2013
|
|
Unhinged on the RightPosted on Jun 29, 2010By Ruth Marcus The campaign video is such a transparent ploy, the temptation is to ignore it. After all, tea party candidate Rick Barber is a long shot in his July runoff race for the Republican nomination for an Alabama congressional seat. But then you hit replay, and see again the iconic images you think you must have imagined. They last a fraction of a second, but they are so imprinted on the modern brain that is all it takes to recognize the photographs. Arbeit Macht Frei, spelled out in cold metal on the concentration camp gates. And the skeletal survivors, packed naked in bunks four tiers high. And now these images appear in a campaign video in which Barber inveighs against the evils of taxation and has an imaginary conversation with Abe Lincoln. “Hey Abe, if someone’s forced to work for months to pay taxes so a total stranger can get a free meal, medical procedure, or a bailout, what’s that called? What’s it called when one man is forced to work for another?” Extreme close-up of Lincoln impersonator, who solemnly intones: “Slavery.” Images flash by: African slaves. North Korean prisoners. Concentration camps. “We shed a lot of blood to stop that in the past, didn’t we?” asks Barber, a Marine Corps veteran. “Now look at us. We are all becoming slaves to our government.” Advertisement Another is: unhinged. The taxes over which Barber is ready to revolt are the product of a democratic system, approved by a majority of elected lawmakers—the system that could produce a Congressman Barber if he somehow wins the runoff against Montgomery Councilwoman Martha Roby to face incumbent, first-term Democrat Bobby Bright, who won in 2008 by just 1,766 votes. Another, and the reason it is worth paying attention to Barber, is: emblematic. Emblematic of the dangerous take-back-our-country rhetoric that is spread on the conservative airwaves and fueling the tea partyers. Barber may be on the outer edges of this movement but he is not alone there, and he is a predictable outgrowth of it. If you haven’t spent any time listening to conservative talk radio, you will probably be surprised by the white-hot vehemence of the commentary. The concern and disagreement—over health care legislation, over bank bailouts, over debt—are understandable; the slippery-slope fears of descent into socialism/totalitarianism are incomprehensible. Last I looked, our checks and balances seemed pretty firmly anchored. Yet it does not take much to imagine the leap from bellicose talk to action for those who sincerely believe that the country they love is being wrested from them. They are delusional but passionate, and they are whipped daily by the Limbaughs and Hannitys and Becks into a frenzy of fear. Sarah Palin accuses the media of overreacting to her “don’t retreat—reload” approach. But it is hardly surprising when Sharron Angle, the Nevada Republican nominee for Senate, then warns that “If this Congress keeps going the way it is, people are really looking toward those Second Amendment remedies.” Or when Ohio Republican John Boehner, the House minority leader, accuses Democrats of “snuffing out the America that I grew up in,” and warns, “There’s a political rebellion brewing, and I don’t think we’ve seen anything like it since 1776.” When I spoke by phone with Barber, he was affably extreme, calling “most of our major departments”—he mentioned Education and Energy—unconstitutional and suggesting that Social Security is as well because it is not among Congress’ enumerated powers. “I don’t believe that it’s the government’s job to provide retirement for the nation,” he said. As to the video, Barber was unapologetic. “We can’t be so naive to think that just because we live in America that can’t happen to us,” he said. “We are being fed a socialist agenda spoon by spoon and we don’t see it coming. In Germany, when Hitler was first elected under the Socialist Party, no one would have thought in a million years it would have gone where it did.” I would not have thought in a million years that this kind of thinking would be inside the conservative mainstream. If it is not, it is time for rational conservatives to speak up. Ruth Marcus’ e-mail address is marcusr(at symbol)washpost.com. © 2010, Washington Post Writers Group
New and Improved CommentsIf you have trouble leaving a comment, review this help page. Still having problems? Let us know. If you find yourself moderated, take a moment to review our comment policy. |
By dihey, July 3, 2010 at 7:50 pm Link to this comment
From one who lost relatives murdered in concentration camps I thank you Ms. Marcus from the bottom of my heart for what you wrote. Now I urge you to join me in condemning with equal strength as I have done the vile use of Nazi/Hitler/Himmler/etc. similes by persons who posture as “progressives”, “left wingers”, or “liberals” as I have done and will continue to do on this website.
Report thisIn fact, I wonder why you have not already attacked these pseudo “progressives”, “left wingers”, and “liberals”.
By berniem, July 3, 2010 at 2:27 pm Link to this comment
Alas! Just another reminder of the mindless and mean-spiritedness that oozes from the spleen of the creatures that inhabit the confederacy and their fellow travellers of the cancervative persuasion. The fact that trash like this gets publicity at all speaks to the extent to which this nation is rotting internally!
Report thisBy Sandra, July 1, 2010 at 11:45 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
Wow! Some great, intelligent posts here today! My sincere wish for America is that
Report thissomehow they would become educated about what terms like Socialism and
Nazism truly mean before they start throwing them around like Barber and Beck do
so dishonestly. The truth shall set you free!
By MRawlings, June 30, 2010 at 6:46 pm Link to this comment
Black is white; up is down; war is peace; Homeland Security; War on Terror, Clear Skies Initiative, Healthy Forests, compassionate conservative…
Perception is reality and ours has been intensively stage-managed for a long time. When the truth gets in the way of profits, we know which one wins.
There are a few other inconvenient truths we really haven’t been paying attention to, in part because they have been actively hidden from us. You’ve probably heard of some of them. The fact that all of this is coming to a head in the near future is no accident- just the inevitable natural consequences of human behavior. Check out, “Crash Course,” and Chis Martenson on Youtube.
Report thisBy Tobysgirl, June 30, 2010 at 3:32 pm Link to this comment
Americans wouldn’t recognize a great leader if they tripped over him rushing into Walmart on Black Friday. Great leaders speak truth, and nothing is greater anathema to Americans across the political spectrum from conservative to liberal. I purposely distinguish liberals from leftists. If you voted for Obama, ignoring his cronies, you are a liberal.
Report thisBy gerard, June 30, 2010 at 3:00 pm Link to this comment
diamond: A really good comment, along with a number of other good comments.
Ruth Marcus said at the end: “it is time for rational conservatives to speak up.” Will they? Doubtful. Why?
Report thisMy take is, the entire country has switched toward the right due to a decade or more of studious official governmental ignoring of facts. such as:
War is counterproductive and a very limited, inadequate substitute for peaceful industries.
Natioinal egotism is silly.
A handful of “terrorists” from the Middle East cannot seriously effect the U.S. unless U.S. citizens shrivel up in fear and start reacting by sponsoring war, which leads to repression of civil rights and a vast accumulations of wealth in the hands of a few powerful corporations in charge of energy and weapons technologies.
The majority of U.S. citizens have come to doubt these facts, which have long been granted without dispute by liberals generally.
Unfortunately, due to fears spread widely throughout our population, plus the recent crisis of capitalists’ mismanagement of the economy, liberals too are stymied by doubts and trapped by their own reactionary tendencies. Rather than propose any radical, creative, untested response they content themselves with criticizing Obama and each other.
Obama is the primary victim of this tendency to react only, not to invent, not to experiment, not to organize for change. A strong avant guarde would make a move for change possible.
Let’s face it: In general the American people were traumatized by McCarthyism and its long follow-on of suspicion and misunderstanding. Public education through schools and media has been woefully resistant to facts for fifty years or more.
One should not be surprised by the overall conservative/reactionary tendencies we see now in the face of threat and political disillusion.
The truth is that a great leader is needed—but a great leader is all too often extremely dangerous.
I fervently hope that the people will organize themselves reasonably and take leadership intelligently, but I doubt that they will.
By diamond, June 30, 2010 at 1:25 pm Link to this comment
The problem is they’re not unhinged: they know exactly what they’re doing. They pretend to be anti-fascist but they are fascist through and through. I suppose a lot of people in Germany thought Hitler was really a socialist (Nazi was an abbreviation of National Socialist Party)but he never was and others certainly thought he was ‘unhinged’ and that his little party of backroom brawlers would never get anywhere. I have read parts of ‘Mein Kampf’ and what Hitler stressed in that book was that it was futile to appeal to the intellect of the working class, what he calls ‘the masses’. You had to appeal to their emotions and give them a myth to believe in. The tea party myth is that they are the political heirs to the forebears who threw the tea in Boston Harbour- dressed as Indians so the Indians would get the blame if it all went pear shaped. The Tea Partiers claim to have something in common with Tom Paine: they have absolutely nothing in common with Tom Paine. With Thomas Jefferson? Well, he was a slave owner who slept with a 13 year old black girl, kept her as a concubine and fathered eight children with her and never freed even his own mixed race children until he was on his death bed. With him, they have a lot in common -racism and hypocrisy for a start. But the section of the voters they’re pitching to will only hear the words, ‘Thomas Jefferson’, ‘Tea Party’, ‘socialism’, ‘democracy’ and many of them don’t have the faintest idea who Thomas Jefferson really was or how he really lived his life. They don’t have any real understanding of what socialism actually is either or what it aims to do, mostly for them.
A lot of people thought Hitler was a joke and in fact the Nazi party had very little support, around 2% of the vote but in politics deals can always be done, even deals with the devil. Such a deal with the establishment far right of German politics saw Mr. 2% installed as Chancellor. The idiots who put him there, thought they could control him but the German officer corps, fascists to a man, rallied to his cause, Hitler then suspended the constitution, after the Nazis lost ground in a by-election, and the rest is history. After that he never had to face the voters again and cheated the hangman by swallowing cynanide. Something similar to the Nazis rise and suspension of the constitution could happen if enough of these fascists get into the halls of political power in America. Voters should realize you can’t be a little bit pregnant, or a little bit fascist. These people are unofficially linked to the same far right that has taken over the Republican Party but they are strictly the Dick Cheney model: Dick’s motto was and is that once you get power all bets are off. They are indistinguishable from the Nazis in all but name so they need to show the concentration camps to pretend they are opposed to such things. They aren’t.
Report thisBy Steve in TX, June 30, 2010 at 12:45 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
The Nazi’s where “socialist” in name only. Their ideology was pure right-wing authoritarianism, masked in conservative populism. And, like the Nazi’s, the current right-wing (Republican/Libertarian/Tea Party/JBS/Heritage Foundation/et al) has employed a massive propaganda machine, possibly greater than Goebbel’s, that spews out disinformation, fear, and hatred at an alarming rate. Today’s right-wing is also authoritarian, a precursor to totalitarianism, which is the real threat. Hitler used the intolerance of Jews, gays, and others to mount an insurrection; and the right is using Mexicans, gays, drugs, and abortion.
One of the key messages the right is adept at spewing is aligning themselves with American heroes, and using fallacious arguments to connect opposing idealogies with Hitler. Which, in addition to having good marketing face-value, it also serves to intercept any opposing claims to the contrary.
The weakness of the opposition now, as it was in Germany, is that we are comparatively disorganized. We need to move past our disagreements, and work together to oppose this insurrection. We need to pull the various minorities, workers/unions, civil rights, and other liberal-minded groups together, and combine our efforts. I don’t see our president (no offense) doing that, so it has to be a grass-roots movement. In fact, I believe it’s necessary, because we need to work to abolish the political parties, because they provide fertile ground for the plutocrats to take hold.
Report thisBy WriterOnTheStorm, June 30, 2010 at 10:18 am Link to this comment
When you know you can’t win the argument with reason, you’d best go with
emotion. That’s been the conservative’s approach since Reagan (at least), and it
works like gangbusters. (They keep the actual gangbusters on the payroll, just
in case.)
Some favorite rhetorical tactics from the right:
1. The enemy is at the gates.
We are the best. Why else would all those heathens want us dead? And since
we’re the best, we must have the best heathen deterrence technology, no matter
what it costs. And anyway, what’s wrong with making a little profit in the name
of homeland security? Just lately, this one has taken the form of:
1b. The enemy walks among us.
Old fashioned sci-fi paranoia straight from Invasion of the Bodysnatchers. You
must never sleep (i.e. think) because if you do, the pod people will come and
turn you into a plant (i.e. socialist).
2. Nostalgia for imaginary by-gone eras as code for cultural/racial supremacy.
Everything was so much better before we let those (other) huddled masses in,
with their chutneys and their pickled fish and their chipotle—oh wait a minute,
I like chipotle.
3. Exceptionalism masquerading as patriotism.
Anyone who thinks we’re not the fastest, strongest, brightest, richest, coolest
and overall ‘bestest’ can just go line up over there with those huddled masses
until we figure how to get rid of you in way that doesn’t make us look bad.
4. Bootstrapper Mythology as official stroker of the national ego.
Yes, go-getters (and you ARE all go-getters, right?), all the plums in this nation
of plenty are yours for the taking. So no whining, let’s just get it done!
Remember, fortune favors the brave, therefor the poor are a pack of sniveling
cowards.
5. Reductio Ad Hitlerum (yawn, even they don’t really believe this one).
It seems everybody and their brother knew Hitler was star material way before he
made it big. Maybe it’s time the crystal ball factory stopped making that model
with the hindsight feature. It just begs this kind of abuse.
6. Your favorite conservative rhetorical tactic here.
Report thisBy Paul_GA, June 30, 2010 at 8:40 am Link to this comment
Elroy, thay’s what needs cutting worse than anything—the military. But I fear it won’t be cut until this country finally collapses economically and the money spigots are shut off for everybody.
Report thisBy Elroy, June 30, 2010 at 8:02 am Link to this comment
Would Barber like to cut military spending as he would
Social Security? How about shutting down the VA - our most
Socialist of services? Should the rich continue to have
tax shelters and loopholes? Should the government get
Medicare off the people’s collective back?
He’s bobbing and weaving, but there are still some punches
Report thishe might not be able to duck.
By robertaustin, June 30, 2010 at 7:27 am Link to this comment
“In Germany, when Hitler was first elected under the Socialist Party, no one would have thought in a million years it would have gone where it did.”
For so many, Hitler is the gift that just keeps on giving. Barber is either a fool or just plain ignorant to equate Hitler’s National Socialist (Nazi) party with socialism. He is fixated on a word and ignores the context. Is Barber unaware that Hitler abhorred socialism’s sympathy for the working class? Hitler despised Communism, liberalism, and democracy. Hitler’s thinking was more in line with Barber’s Tea Party than it would be with any kind of European-style social democracy that Barber fears could take hold in the USA.
Report thisBy Paul_GA, June 30, 2010 at 6:51 am Link to this comment
That’s American big-party politics for you—and shows why this country needs a multitude of parties, not one Statist-War party masquerading as two.
Report thisBy Danny, June 30, 2010 at 5:18 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
Right on, Ms. Marcus. What you wrote needs to be said. Unhinged lunatics are trying to take over our democracy, and they need to be shamed. And we would like to hear criticism of those extreme views from the Eisenhower republicans, if there are any left.
Report this