|
|
June 18, 2013
|
|
The GOP Is Holding the Economy Hostage, and It’s Time to Call Its BluffPosted on Jan 6, 2011By Joe Conason In their ideological zeal, the new Republicans on Capitol Hill seem eager to gamble everything—the financial reputation of the United States, the international status of the dollar, even the chance of a worldwide depression—on a showdown over the national debt ceiling. What has been mostly a routine if unpleasant debate in years past, with each party blaming the other for the nation’s rising indebtedness, is rapidly becoming a mortal threat to economic recovery. The congressional Republican leaders, like their counterparts on the Democratic side and in the White House, all understand that the debt limit must be increased—just as they understood the imperative of the bank bailouts two years ago. But that won’t stop them from indulging in reckless rhetoric—or from seeking to take advantage of the situation in ways that could result in dangerous consequences, as they vow to hold the debt ceiling hostage to enormous budget cuts. These veteran leaders appear to have learned nothing since the debacle of 1995, when then-Speaker Newt Gingrich told the bond industry that he would allow the country to default on its debt unless President Clinton agreed to his plans to slash Medicare and other federal programs. “I don’t care what the price is,” he declared. That was a very different time—and the price of default would be far higher today, in a world where nations and states on the verge of insolvency continuously threaten to scuttle global recovery. Back in the ’90s, the Clinton administration was able to outwit Gingrich both politically and fiscally, using tactics that preserved the full faith and credit of the Treasury without capitulating to Republican demands. Clinton forced the Republicans to fulfill their bluff. Now the numbers are bigger, the space to maneuver is smaller, the potential downside is incalculable—and the nihilistic ignorance of the tea party faction is the dominant attitude within the GOP. Advertisement What the Republicans have hinted they must have in order to release the debt hostage is a package of budget cuts amounting to at least $100 billion this year—or a rollback of spending on discretionary programs (excepting veterans, defense and homeland security) to 2008 levels—and perhaps a deal to destroy Social Security and Medicare, as well. They have carefully refused to offer specific cuts that might anger their own constituencies. No doubt the Obama White House, which too often prefers “bipartisanship” to principled confrontation, will be tempted to make such a deal. The problem is that cutting the budget so drastically will undo the stimulative effects of the December tax-and-spending agreement—and plunge the economy back into recession. The president loses either way. Perhaps the time has come for the Democrats to adopt a different strategy. Let the Republicans govern, or misgovern. Don’t rescue them from their own recklessness. Don’t vote to raise the debt ceiling unless and until the Republican leadership supports the bill—and if they refuse, let them take the responsibility for the consequences. Let’s see how long they can listen to the screaming of their major contributors on Wall Street as the world economy shudders. Make the hostage-takers surrender this time. Joe Conason writes for the New York Observer. © 2011 Creators.com New and Improved CommentsIf you have trouble leaving a comment, review this help page. Still having problems? Let us know. If you find yourself moderated, take a moment to review our comment policy. |
By Not One More!, January 9, 2011 at 8:36 pm Link to this comment
Joe Conason writes: “The congressional Republican leaders, like their counterparts on the Democratic side and in the White House, all understand that the debt limit must be increased—just as they understood the imperative of the bank bailouts two years ago.”
What, am I missing something? Is was imperative to give the trillion dollar bailout to wall street, the very entity that created the crisis at the expense of the general public?
Am I missing something? Was the author being sarcastic in saying that?
Oh wait, maybe lifting the debt is just as against the public interest like the bailout. Maybe this is just another transfer of money to the corporate elite.
Thank you for illuminating it in a succinct way. I now understand that we are in bizarro world where everything is opposite.
Support republican policy,
vote for a democrat
http://www.NotOneMore.US - Take the Pledge for Peace
Report thisBy G.Anderson, January 9, 2011 at 4:11 pm Link to this comment
When this country becomes a vast Wasteland from shore, to shore, you can bet that the vast Mordor on the Potomac will still be disembling. Sadly, that day is not far away.
When that day comes the Democrats and the Rebublicans, will still be fighting over power, still pointing fingers at each other. Still telling us all to hope for happiness.
Yet, they expect people to hope in lies. Believe in their deceptions, believe in the unreal.
They have no intention of changing anything, never did.
Their only intention is to remain in power, no matter what it takes, no matter how many light plane crashes or traffic accidents, they have to arrange.
Report thisBy the worm, January 9, 2011 at 3:41 pm Link to this comment
The author says that it is time to call the Republicans’ bluff.
But, we cannot ‘call the Republicans’ bluff’, because we have a Republican
President.
Obama has been:
1. Shifting private debt to the public sector (thereby freeing corporations, esp
the financial industry, but also financial arms of GM, GE, etc, and saddling the
middle class with the obligation to ‘pay it off’).
2. Watching private sector profits reach un-precedented levels (while
investment goes abroad, hiring moves abroad, and manufacturing continues to
disappear and un-employment continues).
3. Raising the defense budget 6% (so, when “cuts” come, the defense industries
will be safely sandbagged).
4. Allowing the financial industry to ‘borrow’ from the ‘public sector’ (i.e. me
and you) at 1% and buy bonds that pay 3% interest (Banks take your $1 and
make $2 off each one they ‘borrowed’ from you. But, here’s the real deal: You
gave them the $1 they ‘borrowed’, and you pay them the $2 interest they
‘earned’ on the bonds. All the money they ‘invest’ came from you – a ‘loan’ –
and all the money they make comes from you – you have to cover the interest
on the bonds).
5. Allowing the financial industry to ‘borrow’ from the ‘public sector’ (i.e. me
and you again) at 1%, to loan to me and you at 4%, 12%, 18% or more
mortgages, credit cards and other lines of credit (pocketing 3%, 11% and 17% on
your and my money – first given to them by us, then ‘paid back with interest’ by
us).
6. Giving private sector insurers a windfall: mandated customers, with a
taxpayer-paid overhead rate of 20% for ‘mandated customers’ (20% of our
premium spent on administration, CEO salaries, bonuses, sitting on Boards to
set rates and decide who’s covered, lobbying for the insurers’ benefit,
advertising and propagandizing to redefine more and more as ‘health care
service’ while delivering fewer and fewer services—- essentially, giving our tax
money to insurers to do with it what they will). *The American people wanted a
government administered plan like Medicare - for everyone. (72% - CBS/New
York Times poll June 2009)
7. Expanding the war in Afghanistan. (64% of the American people opposed
expanding the war in Afghanistan and wanted to disentangle from Bush-era
‘War on Terror’ and ‘preventive war’ policies. Still, over 60% of Americans
oppose the war.?
8. Keeping the six too-big-to-fail banks – now bigger than ever; kept deposits
at risk by maintaining huge grey areas between commercial and investment
banking; didn’t ‘punish’ the financial industry - now even more profitable, with
bonuses among the biggest ever.
9. Supporting ‘The Compromise’ – giving billionaires $10 for each $1 to an un-
or under-employed person or family.
It is foolish or the very least delusional to pretend we can ‘call the bluff’ of the
Republicans, when we continue to have a President whose policies are
fundamentally those of a corporate apologist - subsidizing failed ‘capitalist’
institutions with public tax money.
We must find a third Party, leave the pseudo-Democratic party or resign
Report thisourselves to the corporate agenda. I suspect the later will be the case:
Democracy crushed by Corporate Subsidized ‘Capitalism’ (i.e. rule of the
wealthy under a ruse of democracy).
By the worm, January 9, 2011 at 3:41 pm Link to this comment
The author says that it is time to call the Republicans’ bluff.
But, we cannot ‘call the Republicans’ bluff’, because we have a Republican
President.
Obama has been:
1. Shifting private debt to the public sector (thereby freeing corporations, esp
the financial industry, but also financial arms of GM, GE, etc, and saddling the
middle class with the obligation to ‘pay it off’).
2. Watching private sector profits reach un-precedented levels (while
investment goes abroad, hiring moves abroad, and manufacturing continues to
disappear and un-employment continues).
3. Raising the defense budget 6% (so, when “cuts” come, the defense industries
will be safely sandbagged).
4. Allowing the financial industry to ‘borrow’ from the ‘public sector’ (i.e. me
and you) at 1% and buy bonds that pay 3% interest (Banks take your $1 and
make $2 off each one they ‘borrowed’ from you. But, here’s the real deal: You
gave them the $1 they ‘borrowed’, and you pay them the $2 interest they
‘earned’ on the bonds. All the money they ‘invest’ came from you – a ‘loan’ –
and all the money they make comes from you – you have to cover the interest
on the bonds).
5. Allowing the financial industry to ‘borrow’ from the ‘public sector’ (i.e. me
and you again) at 1%, to loan to me and you at 4%, 12%, 18% or more
mortgages, credit cards and other lines of credit (pocketing 3%, 11% and 17% on
your and my money – first given to them by us, then ‘paid back with interest’ by
us).
6. Giving private sector insurers a windfall: mandated customers, with a
taxpayer-paid overhead rate of 20% for ‘mandated customers’ (20% of our
premium spent on administration, CEO salaries, bonuses, sitting on Boards to
set rates and decide who’s covered, lobbying for the insurers’ benefit,
advertising and propagandizing to redefine more and more as ‘health care
service’ while delivering fewer and fewer services—- essentially, giving our tax
money to insurers to do with it what they will). *The American people wanted a
government administered plan like Medicare - for everyone. (72% - CBS/New
York Times poll June 2009)
7. Expanding the war in Afghanistan. (64% of the American people opposed
expanding the war in Afghanistan and wanted to disentangle from Bush-era
‘War on Terror’ and ‘preventive war’ policies. Still, over 60% of Americans
oppose the war.?
8. Keeping the six too-big-to-fail banks – now bigger than ever; kept deposits
at risk by maintaining huge grey areas between commercial and investment
banking; didn’t ‘punish’ the financial industry - now even more profitable, with
bonuses among the biggest ever.
9. Supporting ‘The Compromise’ – giving billionaires $10 for each $1 to an un-
or under-employed person or family.
It is foolish or the very least delusional to pretend we can ‘call the bluff’ of the
Republicans, when we continue to have a President whose policies are
fundamentally those of a corporate apologist - subsidizing failed ‘capitalist’
institutions with public tax money.
We must find a third Party, leave the pseudo-Democratic party or resign
Report thisourselves to the corporate agenda. I suspect the later will be the case:
Democracy crushed by Corporate Subsidized ‘Capitalism’ (i.e. rule of the
wealthy under a ruse of democracy).
By GW=MCHammered, January 9, 2011 at 2:41 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
The American Dream
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZPWH5TlbloU
Report thisBy CaptRon, January 8, 2011 at 6:51 pm Link to this comment
My opinion is, so as not to get deleted:
Report thisRepublicans spend because their heredity is unlimited funds available, spoiled elites maybe. Don’t have to know where it comes from, just spend. To make sure they keep the cash cow, they must blame others for overspending on useless(?) policies that don’t benefit the masses. The masses are the Republicans because we are vastly becoming enthralled by the “golden idols” that wealth provides. Everybody wants to be rich don’t they? For the power it brings? The main problem of a civil conflict between red/blue states as stated would be no boundaries defined as who is who and it seems to be the exact goal of the Bin Laden types who attacked the WTC. It’s been downhill ever since with more infighting than ever before. The people who had the money before can pick up and run, say to Asia, and start again or continue on. Might the answer be to legislate the money and power from their hands and put control back with our country and our say so?
By Inherit The Wind, January 8, 2011 at 5:02 pm Link to this comment
And now a Democratic Congresswoman has been shot in the head at point-blank range. She’s been threatened before and had her office vandalized. She was, as noted, one of the congresswoman who Sarah Palin put a gun site one in an ad.
While the Judge Roll is a Republican, he made a VERY unpopular ruling, I believe allowing a discrimination suit to go forward, that got him threatened by radical reactionaries.
Report thisBy ocjim, January 8, 2011 at 2:38 pm Link to this comment
Call on the bluff of the miscreants, a word that must stand for Republicans in the new dictionary.
Report thisBy firefly, January 8, 2011 at 1:12 pm Link to this comment
ItW
Exactly. The GOP sends the country into debt and up
until recently, Democratic Governments have taken the
country out of debt. The Republicans love to shout
about the deficit, but recent history shows that it
is the Republicans that create deficits by spending
insane amounts on an excessively bloated military
industrial complex while cutting taxes for
millionaires at the same time.
China isn’t going to finance US wars forever, so
Republicans will either have to stop bombing other
countries or raise taxes to finance it.
Alternatively, they can convince their supporters
that they have a genuine need to trash other nations
and then hand the mess back to the Democrats to clean
up like they always do. Meanwhile ordinary Americans
just get poorer, worse services and infrastructure.
The advantage this time, is that the mess the
Report thisRepublicans created is simply too big for the
Democrats to clean up this time, so the Republicans
are going to have to actually help this time. But I’m
not holding my breath…..
By Eric L. Prentis, January 8, 2011 at 12:11 pm Link to this comment
Republicans are the biggest spenders of all, they will not do anything to upset their gravy train.
Report thisBy Inherit The Wind, January 8, 2011 at 9:21 am Link to this comment
All these changes have occurred under Democrats.
********************
Wow! As if the Reagan/Bush I years from 1981-1993, and Bush II years from 2001-2009 never happened! As if Reagan didn’t start killing unions, and shipping manufacturing jobs off-shore, and as if Dubya didn’t get us in a 1.3 trillion dollar war that was totally unnecessary just to prove his manhood—and sank our economy doing so.
None of that happened…it was all democrats.
In what universe?
Report thisBy glider, January 8, 2011 at 2:14 am Link to this comment
Firefly,
Report thisAll these changes have occurred under Democrats. If you split the country into a Democrat side nothing will change expect they won’t be able to blame Republicans for their sellout legislation. The root problem of government funded by Corporations will not allow it.
By Inherit The Wind, January 8, 2011 at 2:11 am Link to this comment
Firefly’s right.
The red states are like vampires draining the lifeblood out of the blue states.
As a Garden Stater, the US Govt spends 65 cents of every IRS dollar we send them in NJ.
But in Mitch McConnell’s and Rand Paul’s Kentucky, the US Govt spends $1.51 for every IRS dollar they send them!
So if we separated the Red and Blue states into two nations, the Reds would be bankrupt in 2 years and in that time the Blues would be solvent—even California, which only gets 78 cents back for every IRS dollar. The Reds will only last that long because Florida loses 3 cents and Texas lose 6 cents. Besides, even without separation, Rick Scott is going to sink Florida in 2 years all by himself. DO NOT move to Florida if you have children—he’s about to move the Sunshine State all the way to the bottom of the educational rankings…but a lot of private “school” owners are gonna get rich!
Report thisBy firefly, January 8, 2011 at 1:17 am Link to this comment
Or divide the country into two parts. The Republican
part and the Democrat part and see which governs more
wisely! The Republican side of the country will begin
to look like a third world country with corrupt and
unaccountable leadership, squalor on the streets,
religious extremism, high crime rates which low paid
police turning a blind eye in exchange for bakshish.
The Democrats will finally have a state funded
healthcare system, better schools and education in
general, better infrastructure, but not so many
billionaires.
The Republicans who are sick and can’t afford private
Report thisinsurance for medicine, will move to the Democrats
side in order to see a doctor, and then start to try
to cut back government….
By ray, January 7, 2011 at 9:59 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
By godistwaddle, January 7 at 8:45 pm Link to this comment
I’m only 67, but the only good Democrats and
Republicans I’ve ever seen were dead.
The GOP may start popping off like fly’s if the people get pissed enough?
Report thisBy glider, January 7, 2011 at 9:07 pm Link to this comment
Look, so far we got a massive transfer of wealth to Bankers, an institutionalized transfer of tax and citizen money to the “Health” Insurance Industry, Tax Cuts for the Rich, and More War for the MIC. Now we are just getting a little media prep work for the next “bipartisan” con game of putting those pesky worker “entitlements” such as a decent education and their already paid for social security, on the chopping block. Don’t worry, I am quite sure the Democrats will assuring explain that while they could not get what they truly wanted in a perfect world they did cut the best deal they could.
Report thisBy tammysue990, January 7, 2011 at 6:23 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
I think they should say flat out NO to raising the debt ceiling. Yes it will cause all hell to break lose but we can not keep running up debt with no way to pay. They need to cut all spending to just the bare bones and start living within our means.
I can’t spend money I don’t have and neither should they.
If they quit giving money to other countries (Haiti, Pakistan) to name a couple and bring our troops home and reduce pay to congress from Obama down the line and cut their Insurances and retirement we should be able to save some money to pay down debt pretty darn fast.
Report thisBy ElkoJohn, January 7, 2011 at 5:07 pm Link to this comment
The Republicans and Democrats like to run up the national debt with their wars
of foreign occupation.
The Republicans and Democrats like to run up the national debt with their
corporate welfare for the big money corporations and the banksters on Wall
Street.
Of course, only the Democrats want to run up the national debt by throwing
bones to the voters like extending unemployment benefits and passing junk legislation (Obamacare)—and hopefully (although not for certain) defending Social Security & Medicare from destruction by the Republicans.
So the big gamble is, how long can our broken political system play it’s games
until the expanding federal deficit brings everything down like a super-nova?
Yes the government keeps telling us that deficits don’t matter,
Report thisbut can we, the people, really trust our government to be truthful
competent & knowledgable,
if they couldn’t even see the see, much less avoid, the tech, housing
and financial bubbles?
if they couldn’t even see, much less avoid the mistakes of Iraq & Afghanistan?
By godistwaddle, January 7, 2011 at 3:45 pm Link to this comment
I’m only 67, but the only good Democrats and
Report thisRepublicans I’ve ever seen were dead.
By gerard, January 7, 2011 at 3:26 pm Link to this comment
“The president loses either way.” BINGO! What else would be the primary purpose of the Republicans?
Deal or No Deal? Again Obama and the Dems have an opportunity to stand up and fight, morally speaking. Don’t drink the Kool-Aid!
Report thisBy Inherit The Wind, January 7, 2011 at 12:22 pm Link to this comment
After years of Dems rolling over whenever the GOP draws a line in the sand, why would they expect anything different?
The one who controls the relationship is the one who has less to lose. But who has less to lose? If the Dems say “No!” and don’t compromise then either the GOP must back down or….they sink the economy and it will be blatantly obvious even to the dumbest dummy and blindest blinder-bound, that they did it. It’s far harder on the nation, but breaking the current GOP is needed to save the US. We NEED to true parties who can oppose each other, but this GOP is not into that. They are into dictatorship and, it’s not worth saving the economy by giving it to them.
Report thisBy RayLan, January 7, 2011 at 9:14 am Link to this comment
There is no bipartisan solution - the Reps don’t budge and fillibuster with impunity - there’s only slavish compliance to the corporate funders - which is both parties’ bluff.
Report thisThe lie is that the problem is government and the deficit. The truth is that it is the Wall Street capitalist run- away money market malfeasance - not to mention the stupid immoral defense spending.
Watch what gets cut - the weakest citizens will be gouged - that means Medicare, Social Security, Education and all the social programs that level the unequal playing field - that is the socialist programs.
By samg, January 7, 2011 at 8:28 am Link to this comment
I’d love to see the Dems call the Republicans’ bluff.
Report thisI can’t believe the business community, which, let’s face it, owns the Republican party, would permit the credit of the U.S., including the zillions it borrows on a daily basis in bonds, to dry up, and the US debt it already owns to take a deep drop in value. I’d like to read more comments on this article from knowledgeable people.
By TAO Walker, January 7, 2011 at 4:47 am Link to this comment
Such all-grown-up seriousness from Joe Conason….who has to be as terrified as those he takes-to-task here of the inevitable day when even the rubes realize how completely they’ve been had. The damned “money” is all make-believe! The books’ve been cooked-to-death.
How do you “call” a “bluff” when the stuff your playing with is nothing but a figment of the fevered collective imagination anyhow? As David Sirota ‘next-door’ might say: Things just keep getting curiouser and curiouser.
Having already been divinely HAD, now e-e-everybody must get royally fucked!
HokaHey!
Report thisBy CaptRon, January 7, 2011 at 3:01 am Link to this comment
Do you remember the “clique” people in school(unless you were one)who all dressed, acted, and talked alike so as to not be deemed “out”? School is increasingly becoming the world with the same results, no substance, phony, clueless people with a license to condescend people. Some never grow up, constantly living their past through the present. Until, until they are confronted with religion so to speak. Confronted with truth and forced to deal with their lack of character, kind of like those that Michael Moore confronts in his documentaries. First thought is that the German people have to be forgiven for Hitler’s prominence because we are proving how easy it can be to “create” a monster through apathy and the juvenile thought process. The results of letting the few dictate their idiocy through the weak so as to pass the blame when the turn comes, and this seems the current path. Lastly, the cure is easier than it seems and can be quicker than one might think. We can’t let those with the money, which is power, have the podium regardless of political party since they have no allegiance anyway except to their wealth. It is embedded deeply in our system it seems and has taken a long time to be deemed the norm, but it can be undone quickly or at least quicker than it took to be the controlling influence. It really is quite simple as long as one doesn’t think it impossible. The key is to care, really care, and treat it like a diet. The first small steps will yield small results but make it easier to take a larger path because more will participate. Why? When one has to face truth in the face when they have no backbone, they wilt to the pressure and cease to follow through confusion. Those that control will hide because they can afford to and because they need to with no one to blame as the followers dwindle. How? Make truth and compassion one’s foundation for starters, and one won’t be afraid to look anyone in the eye because they walk the walk and there will be more like them on the same path. Everyone will be leaders. The goal has to be to take away control of our economy and put it back in a Democracy controlled by us.
Report this