|
|
May 26, 2013
|
|
The Good Ol’ Days Before AnesthesiaPosted on Apr 29, 2010If you haven’t heard the name Sue Lowden, brace yourself. She is a Republican who might well become a U.S. senator from Nevada, and judging by her idea for containing health care costs—critics call it “chickens for checkups”—she threatens to make Sarah Palin sound like some kind of pointy-headed policy wonk. Yes, I said chickens. There is a larger point to be made about the kind of thinking, or non-thinking, that Lowden exemplifies. But first, it’s my duty to recap her perilous foray into health care policy, which sounds like a good premise for a Monty Python sketch. Lowden, a wealthy gambling executive, leads the Republican field in the primary campaign for the right to challenge the Democratic incumbent, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid. She a former Nevada state senator, a former head of the state GOP, a former television anchorwoman and a former Miss New Jersey. Polls show her leading Reid by at least 10 points. Three weeks ago, at a candidate forum, Lowden criticized the new health care reform law and laid out her preferred alternatives. She asserted that “bartering is really good” and that people should “go ahead and barter with your doctor.” Advertisement Last week, in a television interview, Lowden insisted that no, she hadn’t misspoken, she meant actual bartering. “Let’s change the system and talk about what the possibilities are,” she said. “I’m telling you that this works. You know, before we all started having health care, in the olden days, our grandparents, they would bring a chicken to the doctor. They would say I’ll paint your house…. I’m not backing down from that system.” Reid’s campaign promptly e-mailed the YouTube video of Lowden’s statement to reporters, under the subject line: “Seriously ... Has Sue Lowden Lost Her Mind?” Democrats have been having great fun with the “chickens for checkups” idea ever since—how many chickens for a colonoscopy, what procedures might a goat pay for, that sort of thing. Lowden’s campaign even passed along a testimonial from a doctor who claimed he had “bartered with patients—for alfalfa hay, a bathtub, yardwork and horseshoeing in exchange for my care.” But on Tuesday, Lowden finally gave up and retreated to the taken-out-of-context defense, which is where politicians go when they realize they said something stupid. Bartering was “never a policy proposal,” the campaign said. End of story, Lowden hopes. Except for the larger point I promised. Lowden’s gaffe was part of a disturbing current in American politics these days: Nostalgia for a golden age that never was. Her words conjured the image of a kindly old man named Doc who made the rounds of frontier homesteads, presumably in his horse and buggy, and fixed everybody up, good as new—“Just pay me when you can, Sue.” But the truth is that in those days, doctors routinely watched people die from diseases that are easily cured today; simple infections and even childbirth carried grave risks. The care that Doc could give wasn’t worth much more than a chicken. Today’s reality is that Nevada is a highly urbanized state—almost three-fourths of its residents live in and around Las Vegas—where the collapse of housing prices, the epidemic of foreclosures and the lack of access to health care are as acute as anywhere in the nation. No wonder some people might find a sepia-toned fantasy more attractive. This same false-memory syndrome infects the tea party movement, which harks back to some imagined time when the United States was a sylvan utopia where everyone walked around peacefully carrying guns and quoting Thomas Jefferson. But this was a big, messy, complicated country even when Jefferson was president, with sharp conflicts over slavery, economic policy and the rights of the individual versus the welfare of all. To mention just a few. Oh, and doctors really preferred to be paid in money. Not livestock. Eugene Robinson’s e-mail address is eugenerobinson(at)washpost.com. Previous item: Past Statements Tell Present Truth About Immigration Law’s Goals Next item: The Supreme Court’s Cross to Bear New and Improved CommentsIf you have trouble leaving a comment, review this help page. Still having problems? Let us know. If you find yourself moderated, take a moment to review our comment policy. |
By Linda C, May 3, 2010 at 6:14 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
People paid in chickens during the depression. No one had money. This also meant that if you saw the doctor on Friday and paid him a chicken your family probably wouldn’t eat on Sunday.
Report thisMy father would tell me the story of Dr. Cambell who was paid in chickens during the depression. His wife was never happy about it.
By Wichitan, May 2, 2010 at 4:11 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
Even though I disagree with the “chickens for check-ups”, I think we all should give her the bird!
Report thisBy Mike, May 2, 2010 at 1:47 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
Another millionaire trying to get in office so they can tell everyone else they can just do without.
Report thisBy race_to_the_bottom, May 2, 2010 at 7:23 am Link to this comment
If your doctor is Jewish, does the chicken have to be kosher?
Report thisBy tedmurphy41, May 1, 2010 at 4:19 am Link to this comment
I am normally against putting people to death, whatever the crime, however, in the case of Sue Lowden, I believe it would, in truth, be a kindness.
Report thisBy Inherit The Wind, May 1, 2010 at 12:09 am Link to this comment
I’ll bet she was a M*A*S*H fan, where the Korean doctor tells Hawkeye that when his client can’t pay, he will take a chicken.
It’s scary when an old comedy show gag is proposed as serious policy by a Republican dim-wit!
Report thisBy Mundt, April 30, 2010 at 5:23 pm Link to this comment
Sue Lowden is pretty & popular. So is Sarah Palin. Real men love ‘em both.
Report thisBy gerard, April 30, 2010 at 10:23 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
My grandfather is said to have died from an emergency appendectomy performed on the kitchen table by the local doctor with a pair of sewing shears. He didn’t charge anything—or so I am told. Whether my grandmother paid him to leave is just one more question.
Report thisBy queensbee, April 30, 2010 at 9:03 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
what about Frozen chickens??? not that i am defending this nonsense, but it might address the problem of livestock in the city. of course that could open up a whole raft of possibilities.
Report thisobviously, this woman has been smokin’ something.
By Sick, April 30, 2010 at 8:30 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
Yeah right! Really? You live in Phoenix and you can walk into a specialist office and trade a good house cleaning or a bail of hay for a laporoscopy, or an MRI? So rediculous! The thing is, most people who are sick, DONT HAVE the ability to labor or have already lost most of their assets due to their health. What about them? What are we supposed to do, die because we aren’t rich? This countries lack of compassion for more than a third of it’s citizens is wholey UNchristian, as most claim to be, and barbaric!
Report thisBy Paul_GA, April 30, 2010 at 7:04 am Link to this comment
Lots of people on both the Left and the Right dream of a lost “Golden Age” and try to imagine all sorts of ways to bring it back—while doing as little damage to the System as possible. For example, the tea-partiers long for a smaller government while insisting that this country should remain warlike and continue fighting the “global war on terror” regardless of the political, economic and social consequences to this land and its people. But “War is the health of the State”, as Randolph Bourne said in his unfinished 1918 essay; and to quote James Madison, “Of all the enemies of public liberty, war is perhaps the most to be dreaded, because it comprises and develops the germ of every other.” And the tea-partiers’ beloved Thomas Jefferson said, “War is an instrument entirely inefficient toward redressing wrong; and multiplies, instead of indemnifying losses.”
This stupidly rigid insistence on maintaining the war-making power of the American State, regardless, is the primary reason why I could never become a tea-partier. Rather, I subscribe to Murray Rothbard’s belief: “I am getting more and more convinced that the war-peace question is the key to the whole libertarian business.”
Report thisBy purplewolf, April 30, 2010 at 6:10 am Link to this comment
Ahah! A former Ms. Beauty Queen brainless blonde airhead. That explains it all.
First of all most people live in cities and there are laws against owning livestock in cities. The health problems alone with bringing livestock to a doctors office would make more government agencies to oversee that all livestock were healthy and its shots etc were current-yep no bigger government here with the Repukelicans “smaller government” intrusion. The show us your paperwork crowd will love this.Will the doctors office provide you with those little bags to clean up after your doctors payment has an accident on the floor, or will the receptionist do it?
Owning livestock is not cheap and if you have to barter, usually that means you have no money.
I have bartered at events I have taken part of and it was mutual. Bartering is great in some cases, but it does not pay the utilities, your employees,etc..
What is it about the repug party that they are so out of touch with reality? There should be mandatory intelligence test for people to run for political office, if you cannot pass on at least a 90%+, you are not qualified to run for office. That requirement would eliminate the majority of those who are unfit for political office. Even the lowly paid fast food employee has more tests to pass to even be considered a suitable employee that what we have representing Americans.
I am ashamed at the laughing stock these elected officials have made of We the People to the rest of the world. How embarrassing.
BTW, Hey doc, don’t have any chickens, but how about the service of my stud buffalo?
Report thisBy C.Curtis.Dillon, April 30, 2010 at 2:30 am Link to this comment
Even in the good, old days, doctors preferred cash to anything else. Chickens (and most other barnyard animals) are dirty ... can you imagine bringing a cage full of birds into the examining room? I rode in a sleeper car last month from Lvov, Ukraine to Simferopol with a family and their bag full of pigeons! Not the most comfortable journey I’ve had.
I understand and have sometimes bartered services ... I took a nice MacBook for services rendered on a software project just last year ... but money is still my preferred currency. You can’t buy much with a dead chicken.
This is just a method of deflecting the whole issue of greed and stupidity which saturates our society these days. Everywhere you look someone is demanding more money for their services. No banker is worth billions of dollars! No doctor, even the most brilliant surgeon is worth millions. No movie star is worth $20 million/picture. Greed has distorted our values and created this rush for the cash. We will never solve these difficult problems while self-interest and greed are the most important factors.
One last point ... the best doctor I ever had was the family physician of my childhood. His skills weren’t all that fantastic and his alcoholism sometimes got in the way but he made house calls ... even at 3 am. And, if my dad didn’t have the money, the bill was either forgiven or deferred until there was some to pay. Doc was a family friend who dispensed the most important medicine possible ... compassion!
Report thisBy birdieman073, April 29, 2010 at 10:21 pm Link to this comment
say what you will, I like to trade tangible objects or
Report thisservices rather than money. as do some of my
neighbors. and I live in a metro-mecca, Phoenix! put
that in your pipe and smoke it