LOGO: Truthdig: Drilling Beneath the Headlines. A Progressive Journal of News and Opinion. Editor, Robert Scheer. Publisher, Zuade Kaufman. Winner 2013 Webby Awards for Best Political Website
May 23, 2013

 Choose a size
Text Size

Trending:     chris hedges     economy     elizabeth warren     politics     robert scheer
Most Read

A Call to Action

Bizarre, Apparently Jihadist Slaying in London (Video)

Hell on Earth for Greeks

Oklahoma Needs Help, Not Ideology

Revenge of the Bear: Russia Strikes Back in Syria

Most Comments
Most Emailed

Reports

Ear to the Ground

A/V Booth

Arts & Culture
 * NEW! * A Call to Action
Act of Congress
Daily Rituals

Digs

Truthdig Bazaar
Desert Reckoning

Desert Reckoning

By Deanne Stillman
$24.99

more items

 
Reports

Penance Demands Action

Email this item Email    Print this item Print    Share this item... Share

Posted on Apr 1, 2010

By Eugene Robinson

At its holiest time of the year, the Roman Catholic Church is being forced to confront not only the central mystery of the faith—life after death—but also a more worldly riddle: What did the Holy Father know, and when did he know it?

Questions about whether Pope Benedict XVI was personally involved, as he rose through the church hierarchy, in sweeping incidents of sexual abuse by parish priests under the rug have put the Vatican on the defensive. A top legal official of the Holy See even felt obliged to argue, in an interview with the Rome newspaper Corriere della Sera, that the Vatican is not legally responsible for any failure by individual bishops to properly handle reports of abuse—and that, in any event, Benedict is a head of state and thus beyond the jurisdiction of any foreign court.

A spokesman said that Benedict sees the sex scandal as a “test for him and the church” and is spending Holy Week in “humility and penitence.” Another official, Cardinal William Levada, took a much more aggressive approach, releasing a lengthy statement attacking newspaper stories that have sought to investigate Benedict’s role. Levada, who is prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith—essentially the Vatican’s chief enforcer on matters of faith, a post Benedict held for more than 20 years before becoming pope—singled out the New York Times’ reporting as “deficient by any reasonable standards of fairness.”

The most explosive allegation is that Benedict, in his old job, did not take action to defrock a Wisconsin priest, Lawrence Murphy, who had molested as many as 200 boys at a school for deaf children. Benedict’s office halted a church trial of Murphy when it was learned that he was terminally ill; the priest was investigated by civil authorities as well but never faced charges. He died in 1998.

The particulars of this case, and another one from when Benedict was archbishop of Munich, do raise real questions about the pope’s handling of abuse allegations. It was all-too-common practice for priests found to have raped or abused young boys to be quietly reassigned, and ultimately that is what happened in these instances.

Advertisement

The larger problem for the church this Easter season is not just that the man considered the Vicar of Christ is personally being scrutinized but that the sex abuse scandal has become a major issue outside of the United States. For years, those so inclined could put the whole thing down as an overreaction by litigious Americans. Now the scandal has spread throughout Europe. German bishops are operating a hot line for abuse victims, Danish and Swiss bishops have launched investigations of old claims, and an Austrian cardinal has held a service for victims in which he admitted the church’s guilt. Last month, Benedict sharply rebuked Irish bishops for errors of judgment in handling allegations of rape.

Even more disturbing, the scandal has spread to the heart of today’s church—Latin America. In Brazil, where more Roman Catholics live than in any other country, a television network aired a video that purported to show a priest in the northeast state of Alagoas having sex with an altar boy. That priest and two others have been suspended by the church and are under investigation by police.

Here lies the real crisis for the church. The United States, with its ethic of individualism and its legions of trial lawyers, can be thought of as a special case. European societies are aging, and the continent’s majestic churches are often practically empty at Mass. It is countries such as Brazil and Mexico, with their growing population and burgeoning economic development, that represent the future for the Vatican. But there is intense competition throughout the developing world from evangelical Protestant denominations, and any suggestion of scandal and corruption can only damage the Catholic Church’s prospects.

Easter is a time for Benedict, as the spiritual leader of a billion people, to meditate and reflect. Then he must act. It is time for the pope to be comprehensively honest and open about the tragic failure of the church to prevent or punish horrific sexual abuse—including his own errors—and he must credibly assure the faithful that such crimes will never be allowed to happen again. Even more urgently, molesters still serving as priests must be defrocked and reported to civilian authorities.

Penance, as Benedict well knows, is a sacrament. It is not optional.

Eugene Robinson’s e-mail address is eugenerobinson(at)washpost.com.
   
© 2010, Washington Post Writers Group


New and Improved Comments

If you have trouble leaving a comment, review this help page. Still having problems? Let us know. If you find yourself moderated, take a moment to review our comment policy.

By melpol, April 6, 2010 at 10:35 am Link to this comment

The cries of sodomized altar boys have echoed all through the universe. Even the Lord up high has heard its sounds. Those that have preferred a altar boys anus to the teachings of the Bible must be punished.

Report this

By ender, April 6, 2010 at 10:00 am Link to this comment

The Catholic church is first and foremost a large corporation, probably the largest.  Not only have they covered up sexual abuse of children by priest, but when the lawsuits start they transfer parish property to bankrupt the parish being sued which blocks not just punishment for the organization guilty of condoning pedophilia, but treatment for the victims.  They are despicable in every way.  I hope this opens they eyes of catholics worldwide that the pope is the titular head of a vile corporation that operates on a power and profit motive and not the benefit of it’s followers.

Report this

By helloanyonethere, April 5, 2010 at 9:43 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

I feel fortunate that what is happening to the Roman Catholic church is going on in my lifetime.  This has been centuries coming.  Although many Christian denominations, including Roman Catholicism, do not believe in the concept ‘karma’ as far as the cliche “What goes around, comes around” is concerned; this is great news for me to hear!  I am in a frenzy of sheer excitement that the Roman Catholic church is finally experiencing what it so rightfully deserves.

Yet, I would hope that most Roman Catholics throughout the world do not feel too concerned.  The Vatican will work it out as they always do - painful as it may be for me to say this.

Report this

By stcfarms, April 4, 2010 at 10:26 am Link to this comment

The catholic church has been butt fucking the world for two millennia, it is
time that they got a dose of their own medicine. They have stolen three entire
continents and murdered the inhabitants and yet no one complained until they
are caught screwing a few little catholic kids. The catholic church is not a
religion, it is a disease.

Report this

By gerard, April 2, 2010 at 8:21 pm Link to this comment

Taikan puts the universal escape hatch into words:

“However, I see no reason why that should be a matter of concern to anyone (such as myself) who is not a member of the Roman Catholic church.”

Extended to its logical conclusion, it would read:

“However I see no reason why the widespread abuse of the world’s children should be a matter of concern to anyone (such as myself) who is not a member of the human race.”  Over the fence and out!  Don’t worry.  Be happy.

Report this

By Mel Landers, April 2, 2010 at 6:59 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

It is time that Roman Catholics demand accountability for the destructive institutional doctrines under which they live.  Mr. Ratzinger recently said that they no longer hold to the doctrine of “Limbo.” He made no mention of the fact that the institution used this doctrine to demand the unbiblical baptism of infants for centuries, or the fact that the church tortured and burned countless individuals who rightly decried this practice as evil. He should have at least apologized for the murder of all those who were killed before the theologians had changed their minds.

Now, he wishes for the “faithful” to accept no more than an apology for the widespread rape of children that is the result of the demand that priests remain in the unnatural state celibacy. The abuse begins in the seminary, is then perpetrated by the seminary victims on children around the world. The reason it has not surfaced in Latin America is that the priests have done such a good job of making the victims feel that the guilt is there own. The code of silence in Latin America is five centuries old.


The Congregations themselves, not the priests who run them, must decide to whom they will remain faithful. Did they also take a vow of obedience to the Bishop of Rome? They must be faithful to the children, by vowing, and remaining, obedient and faithful to their creator alone. They must demand an end to non biblical doctrines.

Report this

By taikan, April 2, 2010 at 5:27 pm Link to this comment

The Roman Catholic church is a large organization that, like many other large organizations, has both members and employees.  When the actions of the organization’s employees, up to and including the highest executive, damage the organization as a whole, or damage its reputation, the members are justified in expressing their concern about that damage. 

To the extent that the conduct of the Pope and the various bishops, cardinals, etc. who were aware of sexual crimes committed by Catholic priests and who withheld from the authorities whatever information they had constituted a prosecutable crime, their conduct is a matter to be dealt with by the legal authorities.  However, to the extent that it is not actually criminal in nature, then it is a matter to be dealt with internally by the organization and its members. 

As Robinson points out, the actions the church takes, or fails to take, in response to this situation may cause even further damage to the church.  How its members respond is up to them.  However, I see no reason why that should be a matter of concern to anyone (such as myself) who is not a member of the Roman Catholic church.

Report this

By berniem, April 2, 2010 at 5:16 pm Link to this comment

Cmon! If the mafia or any other group engaged in pedophilia and used fear and intimidation to cover it up the world would SCREAM for justice and the organization’s outlawing! The only reason this cult doesn’t burn witches anymore is because they know that criminal sanctions will apply EVEN TO THEM! This gang of wierdos perpetually garbed for halloween has been allowed to get away with murder(halocaust anyone),slavery, and terroristic intimidation for almost two millenia! I’m sorry if many benighted, superstitious, and gullible people around the world are offended, but I think its way past time to start using your brains for more than figuring out the next best way to screw your neighbor and start applying reason to all the blatant contradictions and lies oozing from this bunch of parasites! Hey people! Its time to EVOLVE!

Report this

By omygodnotagain, April 2, 2010 at 4:47 pm Link to this comment

Big B
There is no connection between the mega churches of the various Protestant denominations and the Catholic Church, further your statement they have been molesting children before the founding of America is based on what. I am asking a very important question, a thorough study was done of Public Schools where most children go to school and they found rates of molestation 100% higher and there is virtually no media on this.
I ask why? If they cared about kids Public schools would be part of this debate and they are not.
So, the conclusion is that digging up this dirt from decades ago is a way to discredit, why because they opposed the War in Iraq and they want to silence them before they bomb Iran.

Report this

By samosamo, April 2, 2010 at 4:30 pm Link to this comment

I find it hard to imagine any organized religion NOT being a
commercial business and some of their best works are
separating people from their money, making people think of
themselves as sinners of little worth and especially when the
people hear ‘FROG!’ they jump.

And it doesn’t take much more of the imagination to see how
corporations have learned these methods and put them to use
for their benefit.

Report this

By the worm, April 2, 2010 at 2:26 pm Link to this comment

Is the Pope an ‘administrator’?, a ‘spiritual leader’?, ‘god’s representative on
earth’?

Which ever (or even all of the above), the behavior is reprehensible.

This is surely one more indication that, like all institutions, the Catholic
Church’s first and foremost concern is with itself.

and

that like all men, the Pope’s first inclination is to live in denial.

As Mr Rogers once said “Discovering Truth Will Make You Free’. Try it,
Christian.

(Maybe he’s not “Pope Fraudulent the Fourth”; Maybe he’s just another in a long
line of Popes “Fraudulent the Perpetual”.)

Report this

By Big B, April 2, 2010 at 2:19 pm Link to this comment

omygodnotagain, the catholics have been molesting children for generations, long before even the founding of america.  Of course any molestation is awful, but your childish argument that just because there is pedophilia in the public schools that it somehow lessens the fact that the church has been advocating it for centuries is asinine. Are you so blinded by your god that you are willing to overlook the transgressions of his followers? But I guess that’s how religion has always worked, eh? Suffer the little children that come unto me should not be a mantra.

the biggest supporters of the independent neoconservative mega churches that dot the american landscape are corporate america. Don’t you religious wackos get it, corporations love employees that have the same blind devotion for the company as they do for their church, Obey, never question. It is how corporations took over this nation, they did it from the boardroom and broadcast it through the pulpit.

And the right wing wackos continue to buy this bullshit. God wants all of us to be rich, so just bend over, and keep this between us, or you will burn in hell.

Report this

By omygodnotagain, April 2, 2010 at 1:41 pm Link to this comment

Big B, a fine bigoted post, never said it was Ok, just asked why after 156 page report by the US Dept of Education stating the problem was 100 times worse in public schools, where most children go to school, why there has been virtually no media.
My contention is that there is no corporate link with religion, and in fact they and th financial and intellectual elites want to bust them, so thy have no opposition. One hs only to consider the following cases some of many and ask why no outrage about public schools
http://archive.newsmax.com/archives/articles/2004/4/5/01552.shtml

Report this

By Big B, April 2, 2010 at 12:05 pm Link to this comment

Judging from neoconscience and omygodnotagain It is better to be molested in a catholic church than a public school.

So Kiddies, next time you are being penetrated and shat upon by your local parish priest, just thank your lucky stars it’s not some government bureaucrat with hairy palms.

And god forbid (pun intended) that we critique the church for they are the only thing standing between us and corporate domination. For the catholic church has always stood up for the little guy in times of tribulation, unless of course you were jewish, muslim, or of any non-catholic denomination. And if you are a big time donor, well hell, the sky is the limit. The only transgressions that are unforgivable are the ones you didn’t pay for (monetarliy, they could give a shit less about your conscience)

Wake up folks, the corporate world has always supported the church, for they teach they ultimate of all corporate and religious axioms…OBEY.

Report this

By samosamo, April 2, 2010 at 11:07 am Link to this comment

By neoconscience, April 2 at 2:00 pm
““Step away from the Dan Brown novel!”“

Don’t know the man, and I don’t rely on fiction to tell me
‘nothing’. The information is out there you just have to be
willing to work to find it and I dare say you would not be the
only one to be amazed as to what the vatican keeps locked up
from the world’s eyes and knowledge, no matter where it is
hidden.

Report this

By neoconscience, April 2, 2010 at 11:00 am Link to this comment

SamoSamo,

      Step away from the Dan Brown novel!

Report this

By samosamo, April 2, 2010 at 10:44 am Link to this comment

I say that while the vatican or catholick church is having to open
up to its pedophilia tendencies, they also should open up the
catacombs beneath the vatican and bring to the light of day all
those things that are deemed the secrets and mysteries(and
explain why those things are kept in hidding) of religion so the
people or laity can determine if they have been hoodwinked
more than it is worth to hold on to supporting such a system of
charlatanism.

Report this

By gerard, April 2, 2010 at 10:15 am Link to this comment

Without minimizing the priestly abuse of children one bit, I still catch a sanctimonious tone in this Robinson editorial, common to us all.  The dishonesty lies throughout the media, however, not just Mr. Robinson.  While accusing the church, all media habitually fail to call the many other abuses of children to anyone’s attention.

Sexual and other exploitations of children are common throughout the world, from industrial abuses to treatment of children imprisoned for usually minor crimes.  What about the all-too-common sale of little girls for sexual molestation—for $50 or less by poverty-stricken parents?  UNICEF and other organizations have been screaming about this for decades, to little avail.

Also neglected by media is the extreme poverty among masses of people who are so poor they have to send their children to scavenge in city dumps, or cut off one arm to make them look more legitimate as beggars?

And what about all the commercial, patriotic and provincial pandering in our own discriminatory public school systems? And oh yeah, by the way—what about wars, one after another?

We had all better unite and save all the children everywhere, mentally and physically, at the same time we devote weeks of news items to castigating the Church.  And again, please remember, this is not to minimize the evils of the church.  It’s just a case of conveniently by-passing all the other ways we abuse (or permit abuse) of children everywhere, every day of the year, year in and year out.

Report this

By Joseph Dispenza, April 2, 2010 at 9:17 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

Holy-Watergate?

Report this

By Aussie, April 2, 2010 at 8:05 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

Saying that Benedict should ‘reflect then act’ is a touch sanctimonious.  You would be referring to the one person in the curia under John Paul II who came to a sufficient clarity about the sex abuse scandals to really act.  His stiffening of reporting requirements for various offenses in 2001 remains an important step in the development of the Church’s response to the running sore.  Benedict remains the only Pope to have acknowledged the seriousness of the matter, having met with victims of abuse, and cranking up the institutional response.

On the Murphy case, there are a number of questions still left unresolved by the current reportage.  The ecclesiastical judge in charge of the Murphy case has written an account of events to which he was party here:

http://catholicanchor.org/wordpress/?p=601

Perhaps the key point of this piece is that the canon trial was NOT put on ice at anyone’s behest: as Thomas Brundage writes, “on the day that Father Murphy died, he was still the defendant in a church criminal trial.”  Murphy was facing charges of soliciting in the confessional—one of the biggest offenses on the canon law code.

It would appear that the only person seeking a stay on proceedings in the ecclesiastical trial in 1998 was the then-Archbishop of Milwaukee, Rembert Weakland.  Weakland was Archbishop at the time of the original complaints against Murphy; it was he who undertook the initial disciplinary actions, and he who protected Murphy from the civil authorities (so far as this was the case).  Fr Brundage raises some serious questions about Weakland’s conduct in this affair that are worth following the link above to see.  It strikes me that Weakland leaves the Borgia Popes in the shade in some respects.

There’s more here:

http://www.catholicherald.co.uk/features/f0000551.shtml

Report this

By neoconscience, April 2, 2010 at 6:56 am Link to this comment

The church shall not be subject to the laws of a non theocratic society. That is all.

Report this

By omygodnotagain, April 2, 2010 at 4:50 am Link to this comment

With all the columns written about the need to rein in the capitalist war machine, I am surprised Truthdig hasn’t figured out that this is an attempt by those Masters of The Universe to silence any opposition to the capitalist elite takeover. The Catholic Church is paying a penalty for speaking out against social injustice, for opposing the elites wars in Iraq. Muslims are already under attack. Then there are the Eugene Robinson types, thinking they are being cutting edge. Did you know Eugene that a few years ago the Board of Education in Westchester County New York had a NAMBLA member, you know the group that wants to make screwing young boys legal.
All this Catholic hate…wonder why there is no outrage about child abuse in PUBLIC schools which is much worse, go read Carol Shakeshaft of Hofstra University. So its not about kids. Its about a bunch of secular capitalists that want to use slander and violence to destroy these superstitious religious types, so they are good for capitalism. Thats why we are a war in Iraq, Afghanistan. In the 20th century the battle was against totaliarian socialism left and right, now that it has been tamed, time to bury those pesky Catholics and Muslims. Guess they didn’t like the fact the Vatican spoke out against the War in Iraq while all our progressive ‘democratic” leaders were pretending not to know the truth about Saddams non existent weapons of mass destruction.
Well you Catholic haters hope your children like to be corporate serfs, and your sons and daughters cannon fodder to the capitalist elite, because when the Vatican is diminished and the Muslims nuked who will be left to speak out. Studies done at Hostrau by Carol Shakeshaft and others showing child abuse is 100% worse in public schools, despite most children attending these schools, have gone ignored by the media. Why because the BIG agenda by those who really run this country and the worlds economy is to silence all opposition to their grab for power.
You Eugene are just one of their hacks

Report this

By Earthling, April 2, 2010 at 2:57 am Link to this comment

By what “-gate” shall this “Catholic” problem become known?

Report this
Newsletter

sign up to get updates


 
 
 
 
Join the Liberal Blog Advertising Network
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A Progressive Journal of News and Opinion. Editor, Robert Scheer. Publisher, Zuade Kaufman.
© 2013 Truthdig, LLC. All rights reserved.