|
|
May 24, 2013
|
|
‘Oh Yeah, Prove It’Posted on Apr 29, 2011WASHINGTON—Well, that was weird. Let’s see: The Arab world is in tumult, with worrying signs that a Libya-style descent into civil war may be happening in Syria, where the stakes are unimaginably higher. Nearby, the warring Palestinian factions, Hamas and Fatah, may be forming a united front. Closer to home, new leaders are being tapped for the Pentagon and the CIA. The government is fast approaching its legal debt ceiling. Painfully high gasoline prices have put the nation in a sour mood. Tornadoes are wreaking death and destruction across the South. So the leader of the free world summons the media for an important announcement—but not about war, peace or the economy. It’s about his birth certificate. This just in: President Obama has proved, yet again, that he is a natural-born citizen of the United States. Which we already knew—“we” meaning those of us who believe there is such a thing as objective reality. I include in this reality-based group at least some of the “carnival barkers,” as Obama called them, who have led the gullible and the paranoid down the rabbit hole of “birther” conspiracy theory. Did Donald Trump ever really believe there was a question about Obama’s birthplace? Of course not; look how quickly he moved on to the next bogus “mystery,” which apparently involves Obama’s stellar academic record—a little too stellar, perhaps? A bit too perfect? Advertisement It seems obvious to me that this campaign to paint the president as some sort of usurper—this insistence that despite winning the popular vote by a healthy margin and the electoral vote by a landslide, he wasn’t really elected—has everything to do with race. Does anyone disagree? Well, just imagine what the birthers would be saying if Obama—like his Republican opponent in 2008, John McCain—had been born in the Panama Canal Zone. Or think of the uproar if Obama—like George W. Bush in 2000—had lost the popular vote but won the Electoral College. Look, I’m not surprised that the first black president faces unprecedented scrutiny about his origins, and I hope Obama’s not surprised, either. This sort of thing comes with being a historical “first,” and there’s no way around it. To those deniers who can’t come to terms with the fact of the Obama presidency, I have nothing to offer but this: Yes, he’s smarter, richer, luckier and better looking than you, and he’s your president. Yours, mine and ours. And he’s black. Get over it. But race alone couldn’t have generated the whole birther phenomenon. Also required was an increasing tendency for facts to be treated as personal accoutrements, as easily adopted or discarded as the newest-model smart phone. If a fact is inconvenient, just ignore it. Put it aside. Surely there’s someone out there who’s selling a counterfeit version that might be more to your liking. The late Daniel Patrick Moynihan’s adage that “everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but not his own facts” seems so last century. I’m not talking about competing worldviews, I’m talking about a lack of agreement on what is provably, objectively true and what is not. Political polarization is old hat. Empirical polarization—a rejection of this nation’s founding Enlightenment principles—is something new. The birther lunacy is an extreme case. The short-form birth certificate that Obama released in June 2008 was the official document, according to Hawaii officials. They should know, right? Wrong, said the deniers, we need the long-form certificate, even though it’s not considered official. Obama produced it Wednesday, and that settles the question, right? No sooner had the president finished speaking than a birther email landed in my inbox, headlined “Case closed? Not so fast.” But there are other examples, some much more consequential. The vast majority of scientists look dispassionately at the data and conclude that atmospheric warming and climate change are real. Deniers don’t produce data of their own, they just say no, no, no—and attack the scientists’ political views, rather than their research. Rodney King famously asked, “People, I just want to say, you know, can we all get along?” If we decide there’s no difference between fact and opinion, then surely the sad answer is no. New and Improved CommentsIf you have trouble leaving a comment, review this help page. Still having problems? Let us know. If you find yourself moderated, take a moment to review our comment policy. |
By anaman51, May 2, 2011 at 7:08 pm Link to this comment
As usual, for those who believe, no proof is necessary. For those who do not believe, no proof is adequate. Nothing has changed.
Report thisBy BR549, May 2, 2011 at 5:31 pm Link to this comment
PG,
You seem awfully focused on that “race card”. You aren’t coming to the table with a few too many opinions up your sleeve, are you?
I talk with a lot of people over the course of a day and almost to a person, save perhaps for two people in particular, their dislike for the guy had nothing to do with the color of his skin. So, you can focus on it all you want, but you’re just spinning your wheels, wasting everyone’s time, and making yourself look like a real ass. As I had said before, had he done what he had promised he would do, no one would really give a shit, but then you come surfing in here with some apologist agenda, targeting “right wing trolls”, as you call
Report thisthem, and basically leave the average person believing that our country is still plagued with “left wing trolls”, so thank you for bringing up that topic and making our point so abundantly clear.
By katsteevns, May 2, 2011 at 5:13 am Link to this comment
Excellent BR549!!
Report thisBy PG, May 1, 2011 at 11:01 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
I don’t have to wonder what right wing trolls do with their time….they come to sites like TruthDig and rehash their same old nonsense. Like driving bear and John Poole, who are obviously clueless (purposely or not) about the birth certificate story. Note to the kids- Obama released his birth certificate already during the ‘08 campaign, the same reconfigured one everybody born in Hawaii in 1961 gets, and no need to call the CSI lab to check it.
Also, reality check to the fantastically deluded BR549- race has EVERYTHING to do with it. Your response “how did he get elected” is laughably beside the point. Just because a large of number of non-racist Americans voted FOR Obama doesn’t negate a number of racist ones who voted AGAINST him. This whole birther nonsense allows them to “deny” treating him as a legitimate president without the politically incorrect reason that’s really behind it. And you really needed me to tell that to you? You’re the one in denial.
Report thisBy BR549, May 1, 2011 at 9:27 pm Link to this comment
Mack,
I think you’ve been watching too many of your movies. If race was so much a part of Obama’s current declining popularity, how the Christ did he ever manage to get elected? It was because of the promises he made and the promises he broke, and had he spilled the beans as to who and what forces were actually managing the wealth of this country, those same forces would have found some quick way to reduce his body temperature to that of the soil. Kennedy made that same mistake and look what they did to him.
No, the vast majority of Americans no longer give a crap about what color his skin was, but since he has repeatedly lied to all those he asked to support him, those same people are the ones who will hang him with his own words. It doesn’t take a lot of rocket science.
I may rail against him every day, but that has nothing whatsoever to do with the color of his skin or the integrity of his parentage. It does have everything to do with his integrity, honesty, and transparency, which so far he has demonstrated none of ..... and I voted for him.
When people like Whoopi Goldberg and Eugene Robinson slither out from under their rocks and try to pass off the current disharmony as race related, they are in a total state of denial. Nearly every one of the investment houses I deal with is still admitting that Standard and Poors is padding the US credit rating and they are suggesting that their customers be very cautious about investments in this country. What the heck do you think that means? What does it also mean when the true unemployment figures are over double the lies that the government continues to pump out?
Report thisBy mackTN, May 1, 2011 at 7:08 pm Link to this comment
Yes this is about racism—Trump and others chose just the right weapon to bat
down just the right person. It always has worked before, and it has worked
now to actually produce so much doubt about his citizenship among Republican
voters. This is done all the time to black people…but you’d have to be black or
be a close friend, a confidant, of a black person to know this.
This is what makes me mad about all this. When will black people have a right
to be flawed and human and still competitive? In the movie, Look Who’s
Coming to Dinner, Hepburn/Tracy, parents of the bride, must explore their own
racial attitudes to accept Sidney Poitier as a son-in-law. Now Sidney wasn’t a
postal worker or a middle school teacher. He was a doctor, lawyer,
ambassador, author—he had every credential under the book. But he still had
to pass the scrutiny of Tracy/Hepburn because he was a Negro.
Black parents put a lot of pressure on their children to be perfect so that they
can pass this scrutiny, but they know it doesn’t matter. Their child will still be
arrested and imprisoned or stopped because of color.
To most of you, this is a lot of hooey. These things no longer happen. We are a
color blind nation.
Right.
Report thisBy Aurelius, May 1, 2011 at 12:43 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
@BR549: You’re a paid astroturfer, aren’t you? Or an astroturfing bot program.
I’ve noticed that those individuals posting the most vitriolic, asinine, propagandist remarks with little or no regard to the article (or objective reality, many times) tend to have unsettling patterns of behavior. Usually, their user names are a string of random letters and numbers, which I assume to be automatically generated for convenience by whatever number-crunching algorithm that generates it. A similar disconcerting pattern is their posting behaviour, which oftentimes purposefully includes the name of the article author (lending credibility to the notion that these individuals are real and striking a conversation), an easily programmable artifice. Blatant disregard for the article content is another red flag. It seems the content is being parsed for keywords, and automatic responses are generated, wholly independent of whatever meaning may be derived from the article itself.
Everyone, please exercise caution before replying to posters ostensibly advocating contrarian, controversial, or fantastical opinions. We live in a political age where supporters, grassroots movements, even entire online personas, can and are being arbitrarily manufactured. These people, more likely than not, are not even real, serving solely to persist the notion that such radical opinions not only exist, but are popular.
Report thisBy katsteevns, May 1, 2011 at 6:16 am Link to this comment
Imagine if Trump had held off on his BC campaign to right before the election putting everyone into a frenzy. He might have become president. I’m sure Oprah will vote for him, though. And Schwarzenegger is going back to movies. It’s ALL good news today! VOTE 3RD PARTY, if you have the cajoles. Otherwise, go crawl back under your status quo-lined shells.
Report thisBy secretmojo, May 1, 2011 at 12:06 am Link to this comment
<applause>
I disagree with the racism accusation, however. If it were Hillary, it’d be about her vagina. If it were Kucinich, it’d be about his height. It doesn’t matter with these people; the accusation follows the anger, and any smear will do.
The takeaway from the birther stuff, which I think Robinson has gotten the closest to so far, is that we’re living in a post-factual society, where bodacious fantasies can drive policy decisions (witness the birther bills, tax cuts, and wars). It’s a dangerous trend, and only by holding reason, facts, humility, and knowledge in high regard can we stop it.
I still have hope that most will eventually agree that facts and good logic should always have more weight in decision-making than the doubt-ridden contents of our own minds.
If not, we’re screwed. We might as well be animals.
Report thisBy BR549, April 30, 2011 at 6:37 pm Link to this comment
joentokyo, April 30 at 6:14 pm
“Gene, you seem content to be an echo.”
Joe, the guy is playing to an empty room. Me, I just keep wondering how long he can hold on while and his buddy Soetoro continues to show us more of his true spots and Gene’s fantasy world is collapsing around him. Sad, really, that someone can be that out of touch. While Gene is still passing out Hope and Change T-shirts, the majority of investment advisors are telling everyone that the US has now become a lost cause and they have no problem pointing the finger at all three branches of government. The government has sold this country out from underneath us; meanwhile, they continue to argue and pontificate over who is to blame.
Obama is playing his fiddle and Gene is standing in the audience while the fire alarms are sounding. While the people are tripping over each other trying to get to the exits, Gene’s still swaying back and forth, totally entranced by the music of “Yes we can.”
Report thisBy joentokyo, April 30, 2011 at 6:14 pm Link to this comment
Gene, you seem content to be an echo.
Report thisBy madisolation, April 30, 2011 at 5:44 am Link to this comment
“It’s a pity that Barak Obama has acceded to the demands of individuals who are working solely to their own petty agenda..”
Report thistedmurphy41, it’s funny how Obama timed it, isn’t it? After our Savvy Constitutional Law Professor declared that Bradley Manning was guilty before he was tried, he whips out his birth certificate as a distraction. “Look over here! My long-lost birth certificate!”
Brilliant!!!!
Frankly, I’m not looking for Obama’s birth certificate. I’d just like the notes taken when he negotiated for-profit health care behind closed doors. Or the behind-doors conversations on his Libyan War. Or all the other secret shenanigans he’s been up to since he took office.
Birth certificate, my ass: I want real accountability and transparency. I’m hoping he’ll have to whip out that birth certificate over and over in the next year in order to distract from some gaff or another he commits. The man is not exactly a genius when it comes to speaking one-on-one, is he?
By BR549, April 30, 2011 at 5:06 am Link to this comment
tedmurphy41, April 30 at 1:43 am
“Now you know who the real enemy is, you can organise yourselves in order to defeat it for good, that is if you really want to!”
The only way out now is to hope enough voters haver become so disgusted with their legislators that they vote, en masse, for anything but the two party parasite platform. Congressional approval in the single digits? That’s about as popular as dog snot on the kitchen counter. And do you think these clowns give a crap? Are they sitting in little groups wondering about what they can do to reclaim the voters’ trust and confidence and to put integrity and morality back into our once proud system of government?
Fuck no, Boehner is probably out adjusting the timer on his tanning booth again, Pelosi continues to envision herself as Queen Elizabeth, and Rep. Peter King, it seems, was recently mailed a bloody pigs foot, no doubt because someone was so pleased with his performance as a racist, bigoted, fear monger that can’t sleep at night knowing that some citizen might own a gun. Where do these idiots come from? Do they hatch them somewhere?
There are a very small handful of these people (I hate to call the good ones “politicians” because that word has become so ugly, even more than before), who do understand the oath they took and we can only hope that enough American voters get the sleepers out of their eyes in time to break out of this bad habit of voting for only Republicans and Democrats. It’ll be up to them really, because without their help, there will be skyrocketing inflation and a possible revolution. Meanwhile these people will be still blaming the “other” parties for all of America’s woes, little believing that they could have had anything to do with the current state of affairs.
The Democrats and Republicans have been in control since forever and the agenda has stayed virtually the same; the expansion of empire under the guise of bullshit words like freedom and democracy. They allowed the big banks to control the country, they continued to be bribed and coerced into giving the banks even more control, and to this day, with their control over the media, far too many voters have never heard of the Bilderberg Group or why it it has so negatively influenced our economy, our morality, and our way of life.
Politicians see voters as mushrooms; just feed them shit and keep them in the dark, and as long those voters never question what is going on, their diet will remain the same. Republicans and Democrats endorse that diet for you, so here’s your fork. Dig in.
Report thisBy tedmurphy41, April 30, 2011 at 1:43 am Link to this comment
It’s a pity that Barak Obama has acceded to the demands of individuals who are working solely to their own petty agenda; like The Terminator, they will not stop, the proof now offered will only add to their obsession.
Report thisThe best and only way to deal with these people is to ignore them and let them expend money and time on proving the impossible.
Ever since the second World War, America’s influence throughout the various Countries of the World has had a malign influence on it, until now, when it is currently starting to turn in on itself.
You don’t have to be Einsiein to work out the reasons why, as they have been exposed and out in the public arena for all to see, namely the previously faceless Corporations and their political football, the Republican party, along with certain spineless Democrats who must be included as part of this infamous crew.
Now you know who the real enemy is, you can organise yourselves in order to defeat it for good, that is if you really want to!
By BR549, April 29, 2011 at 9:39 pm Link to this comment
Gene,
Get over the race issue, ALREADY. It has NOTHING to do with race. NOTHING.
This is 2011 and nobody cares what color the guy is. Really. That isn’t why people are questioning his eligibility. They question it because he has broken every promise he made during his campaign and only served to further the Bush-Clinton-Bush war agenda. And the only thing they can do now, since the Congress seems to have lost its testicles and won’t impeach the SOB, is to challenge his eligibility, which is still a freakin’ mystery. Even Democrats are bailing on this stooge.
Perhaps when those election night 2008 goose bumps wear off, you might get your butt back in your chair and look into how many wars (actually, occupations) we are currently and needlessly involved in.
=================
Bob, are you paying any attention to Gene’s declining popularity? At some point the guy is going to have to either fish or cut bait. Right now, his cubicle is getting a bit “ripe”, if you get my meaning. The problem is that every article he writes has, out of some personal necessity, something to do with Obama and he’s still so hopelessly caught up with that Hope and Change crap, he’s lost any journalistic objectivity. This is supposed to be a news platform, isn’t it?
Report thisBy fearnotruth, April 29, 2011 at 9:10 pm Link to this comment
OH YEAH, PROVE IT! - epitomizes American ‘journalism’ today - a Carnival, indeed,
Report thisand Eugene Robinson tumbling with the clowns… spineless as always, at least
until he challenges the puppet POTUS on the 4 wars he now has going and the
millions of dead in their wake - go embed yourself Robinson - breath a month’s
worth of DU oxide, then sire a mutant - that’ll give you something ‘serious’ to
write about
By John Poole, April 29, 2011 at 5:37 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
I think most of us facing a question about our birth certificate would just present
Report thisit immediately no matter our “station” in life. Why was the matter not dealt with
within a few days of becoming an issue by Obama? If someone wants to know
my USC academic records I would immediately pay for the records to be sent
from USC to their organization for scrutiny. None of this makes sense. No one is
above the “law” which means no one is given a rider regarding personal scrutiny.
Now I am beginning to wonder how he transferred from Occidental (one mile
from my studio in Glendale in the 70s) to Columbia. Where ARE his grades? Mine I
will supply when I transferred from Glendale Community College after one year to
USC school of music.
By driving bear, April 29, 2011 at 4:31 pm Link to this comment
I will say now what I have been saying for over a year now. Go to Hawaii and get the birth Certificate and take it to a lab ( like on the tv show CSI ) a show the lab techs doing their work live on national TV . If the birth certificate proves to be real , that will be the end of the matter if it’s a fake then Joe Bidden can take over.
Report thisBy BR549, April 29, 2011 at 1:49 pm Link to this comment
Eugene Robinson; ever the Obama apologist,
Report thisSo you have put your objectivity blinders on once again and dismissed entirely the
myriad of objections from the graphic arts community, which is having a field day
with the numerous irregularities of this so-called “document”.
By TDoff, April 29, 2011 at 12:39 pm Link to this comment
People who believe in ‘Objective Reality’ are fabulists, according to the Republican Manifesto.
Report thisBy SarcastiCanuck, April 29, 2011 at 11:40 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
Maybe naysayers like the Donald should be forced to prove that they have a brain before being allowed to make public statements.Maybe enshrine it in the constitution.You have the right to free speech,if you can prove you have a functional brain…Though that could destroy the republican party these days.
Report this