|
|
May 18, 2013
|
|
Haley Barbour’s Ridiculous StoryPosted on Sep 6, 2010Mississippi Gov. Haley Barbour, who may seek the Republican nomination for president, is trying to sell the biggest load of revisionist nonsense about race, politics and the South that I’ve ever heard. Ever. He has the gall to try to portray Southern Republicans as having been enlightened supporters of the civil rights movement all along. I can’t decide whether this exercise in rewriting history should be described as cynical or sinister. Whichever it is, the record has to be set straight. In a recent interview with Human Events, a conservative magazine and website, Barbour gave his version of how the South, once a Democratic stronghold, became a Republican bastion. The 62-year-old Barbour claimed that it was “my generation” that led the switch: “my generation, who went to integrated schools. I went to integrated college—never thought twice about it.” The “old Democrats” fought integration tooth and nail, Barbour said, but “by my time, people realized that was the past, it was indefensible, it wasn’t gonna be that way anymore. And so the people who really changed the South from Democrat to Republican was a different generation from those who fought integration.” Not a word of this is true. Advertisement That was long after Barbour had graduated from high school in Yazoo City and gone on to attend the University of Mississippi—the “integrated college” he mentioned in the interview. The federal government had forced Ole Miss to admit its first black student, James Meredith, in 1962; he had to be escorted onto the campus by U.S. marshals as white students rioted in protest. The following year, a second black student was admitted. In the mid-1960s, when Barbour was attending Ole Miss, it’s no wonder that he “never thought twice” about integration. There were only a handful of black students, and by all accounts—except Barbour’s—they were isolated and ostracized by their white peers. The governor’s assertion that segregation was a relic of the past “by my time” is ludicrous. He was 16, certainly old enough to pay attention, during the Freedom Summer of 1964, when civil rights activists James Chaney, Andrew Goodman and Michael Schwerner were murdered by the Ku Klux Klan near Philadelphia, Miss. He was a young adult, on his way to becoming a lawyer, when the public schools were forced to integrate. I’ll bet Barbour could remember those days if he tried a little harder. Equally wrong—and perhaps deliberately disingenuous—is his made-up narrative of how the South turned Republican. Let me correct the record. As he signed the 1964 Civil Rights Act into law, Lyndon Johnson is supposed to have said that the Democratic Party had “lost the South for a generation.” Among those who voted against the landmark legislation was Sen. Barry Goldwater, who became Johnson’s opponent in the presidential race that fall. Johnson scored a landslide victory. Goldwater took his home state of Arizona and just five others: Louisiana, Mississippi, Alabama, Georgia and South Carolina. It was the first time those Deep South states had voted for a Republican presidential candidate since Reconstruction—and marked the moment when, for many Southern voters, the GOP became the party of white racial grievance. It wasn’t “a different generation from those who fought integration” that made the switch. Integration was the whole reason for the switch. Now, Haley Barbour is not stupid. Why is he telling this ridiculous story? Maybe this is the way he wishes things had been. You’ll recall that earlier this year, when asked about a Confederate history month proclamation in Virginia that didn’t mention the detail known as slavery, Barbour said the whole thing “doesn’t amount to diddly.” Most charitably, all this might be called denial. It’s much more likely, however, that Barbour has a political purpose. The Republican Party is trying to shake its image as hostile to African-Americans and other minorities. It would be consistent with this attempted makeover to pretend that the party never sought, and won, the votes of die-hard segregationists. One problem, though: It did. New and Improved CommentsIf you have trouble leaving a comment, review this help page. Still having problems? Let us know. If you find yourself moderated, take a moment to review our comment policy. |
By Night-Gaunt, September 29, 2010 at 5:36 pm Link to this comment
Except from you Tavis F. Smith, why not?
Report thisBy Travis F. Smith, September 29, 2010 at 5:21 pm Link to this comment
More comments.
Report thisBy COinMS, September 9, 2010 at 12:50 pm Link to this comment
Thanks. Actually, I have a lot more respect for an honest athiest than I do a dishonest right wing christian. My ‘brand’ is pacifist, non-violent, non-political, non-trinitarian, no hellfire, etc… which goes against the dominant hegemonic southern baptist culture here in Mississippi. Thankfully I am in a college town and there are a few people here not totally whacked out on rightwing republican religion. Haley Barbour, however, is gutting school programs, carrying water (or oil) for BP, decimating programs for the poor. Of course, he proudly says he is a 5-Point Calvanist, which I guess means that everything is predetermined and if you are poor, well that’s the way it has to be and quit complaining. He hides behind (a big) Confederate flag, or American Flag, but in reality is totally corporate and corrupt, through and through. I mean that in a nice way :^)
Report thisBy Night-Gaunt, September 9, 2010 at 12:28 pm Link to this comment
I agree with what Gandhi said that he liked Christ but not the Christianity attached to it. [A paraphrase of course.]
I am an Atheist but my mind isn’t closed to Humanity. What we all have in common in what is best for all of us is usually declaimed as “utopian” like an end to war and protection for all. Not really, but those whose utopia is war and pillaging and wealth for a few families and potentates is alive and damns the billions of us to their utopia even now. Lets switch for several thousands years can’t we?
Report thisBy REDHORSE, September 9, 2010 at 11:50 am Link to this comment
COinMS: I was just tipping my hat to NIGHT-GAUNT and liked your post. I was talkin’ about me,not you.
Your point that so much mindless “right-wing” propagandist hooey is attached to Christs message is important. NIGHT-GAUNT is correct. Say it like you see it—tell it like it is. All of us here struggle for the truth. Sometimes, together, we get a little wood on the ball.
Report thisBy Textynn, September 8, 2010 at 1:15 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
The way Barbour said “I went to an integrated college.” says it all. The statement sounds so racist with a thin veneer of denial that you can’t even imagine someone saying that without a thick southern accent. Too funny.
I personally think Barbour IS that stupid. First of all, he’s a Republican, the official party of morons, ignoramuses, and sociopaths. Secondly, as you know, southern schools have always ranked low in education quality and guess which state’s schools have always been 50th, aka as dead last, in the country in academic achievement…... wait for it…. Mississippi.
Report thisBy Night-Gaunt, September 8, 2010 at 1:10 pm Link to this comment
berniem so many of our presidents have been from Dixie that sometimes I wonder if they have won back some of what they lost. Many NeoCons are Neo Confederates who saw good things in the CSA & even the IIIrd Reich, but in the N.American style of course.
Report thisBy ssg13565, September 8, 2010 at 12:32 pm Link to this comment
berniem,
I know what you mean. However, there is one thing we have to remember. For the same reason we didn’t let the South secede, we have many good citizens down there that deserve to be protected from the hordes.
Report thisBy berniem, September 8, 2010 at 12:20 pm Link to this comment
There is one border that we must secure if our nation is not to be overrun by maliciously stupid and intolerant hordes. The border in question is that encompassing the confederacy!
Report thisBy Night-Gaunt, September 8, 2010 at 11:37 am Link to this comment
COinMS identifying something, or someone, truthfully shouldn’t be against your religion. Properly showing what they are doesn’t make you one of them or anything close to them since actions many times speak louder than words. Don’t they?
You aren’t promoting them are you? But condemning them for what they do isn’t that right? Then shouldn’t you want to point out evil, shine a bright light upon it of truth and right?
Mindlessness rarely exists except among the comatose* or drugged. (See the Zombie of Voodoo.)
*Recent use of f(N)MRI’s on such patients have shown them to have active minds.
Report thisBy COinMS, September 8, 2010 at 10:41 am Link to this comment
Redhorse, no problem. Actually, since I try to live the Golden Rule, I should have phrased my criticism of Barbour differently. I almost hate to say I am a Christian, since Christians lately have twisted the simple words of Christ into something monstrous.
I am certainly on the left wing of Christianity, but because I am a committed Christian, I should not have referred to him as vicious and cunning and racist, even if it is true. I don’t want to descend to their level.
All I can say is that if Barbour and Palin or Barbour and Beck get into power, kiss what is left of our anemic democracy goodbye. Perhaps liberals should get their passports in order.
Report thisBy REDHORSE, September 8, 2010 at 10:06 am Link to this comment
NIGHT-GAUNT/COinMS: Sorry. It IS a mistake to think thugs like Barbour are just “mindless apes”. Rage got the better of me. The sad fact is, Republithugs and their MSM lie machine, after wrecking our every attempt at progress, may have convinced America to cut off its’ political nose to spite its’ political face. I just hope, after the coming election, Dems are still in control of the House and Senate. (I know!!Spare us both.)
Posters here lament an MSM that allows self-serving demagogues like Barbour to lie with impunity. Since our founding, the American Press has been for sale. Perhaps, we need to replace our self-righteous indignation (my “rant” below) with a sober look and revaluation of what NEWS is. (And, lets not forget, Eugene R. laid the facts on the table for us. That’s what Journalists do. We are not without resource.)
As an adult it is an insult to be treated like a child. It causes rage. That’s what the MSM is about. They promise adult discussion and access to information vital to our lives, deliver nothing, and then sell us toothpaste. And we go back for more. Isn’t this classic passive/aggressive manipulation intended to leave one twisting in emotional space? Rage becomes permanent, distorts the ability to think clearly, and feeds a sense of hopeless depression. It’s crazy making. The line between reality, politics, entertainment and personality are so blurred and facts so distorted, it’s impossible to know what the truth is. That’s the point. And, if you try to confront the beast, like all psychopathic emotional predators, they paint you as having a “loose screw”.
Many here openly express their feeling that American MSM is an organized controlled propagandist machine. The simple reality is, corporate ad money has always corrupted content. Now it has become openly sinister. The gloves are off. That’s good news for us!! And don’t forget, the prime motivation of these geniuses. To gain absolute control of your every motivation, so they can sell you toothpaste.
Emotional kneejerk (guilty) disempowers us. The MSM strums our emotions like a banjo. In the same way an addict destroys a family by theft, high drama, emotional destruction and lies, likewise demagogues like Haley Barbour and the MSM. Until the family accepts the lying manipulative user is exactly that it cannot regain its’ mental/spiritual health.
That’s what I mean when I say, that though still a dangerous power and money addicted entity, Washington has made itself irrelevant to American reality. The entire war lie, suspension of civil liberties, economic robbery, etc., all, are the acts of a mainline junky. They are unwilling to save themselves and our only choice is to either perish with them or draw the line. They are not, and do not represent,US.
Let us unite. Reclaim our power as citizens and stop thinking we can save the morally bankrupt from themselves. We all see it, and we’re not alone.
Report thisBy miroslav, September 8, 2010 at 9:49 am Link to this comment
Hailey Barbour is even more hideous than Newt Gingrich. The persistence, the ineradicality of certain vermin that live off the body politic is astounding.
Report thisBy COinMS, September 8, 2010 at 7:09 am Link to this comment
Well, I live in Mississippi and can tell you that Haley Barbour is not stupid. He is vicious and cunning and racist but he is most definitely not stupid. He knows what he is saying is a crock, but he also knows he can get away with it because of the piss-poor excuse we have for a press in the U.S. The Mississippi press is almost exclusively right wing, and the people down here… oy. There are some gems, and some truly progressive folks, but for the most part the whites are slavish theocrats, worshiping the military and panting to destroy any social services that don’t benefit them directly. Because they are good christians, don’t you know?
Report thisThe old joke from the sixties still stands: ‘what has four ‘eyes’ and can’t see’? MIssIssIppI.
By ssg13565, September 8, 2010 at 6:39 am Link to this comment
I have to thank Eugene Robinson for his great service in writing this column.
I am old enough to remember what happened in that time period. Robinson does us the favor of laying out the time line of these events against the time line of Barbour’s life. Otherwise, even I might have fallen for one or two words in Barbour’s story.
Yes the Democrats and Republicans have both changed in the last 50 years. The Democratic party became a place where this load of bull would no longer be accepted. The southern people who still wanted to hang on to the old ways found that they had to become Republicans to find a place that would still accept this.
Report thisBy PRGP, September 8, 2010 at 6:26 am Link to this comment
Revisionism is a bastion of fascism, communism, religious delusion and the overall perfidy of those who would rule without regard to reality or honor. Unfortunately, the party of Lincoln (as they like to say) has been taken over by ignorance, anti-democracy racists and fools. Also unfortunately, too few on the Democratic side have the balls to kick ass and take names, particularly the pres. A year of mewling to pass a crappy health bill??? Where are the real leaders. Bernie Sanders and Alan Grayson can’t do it alone!!!
Report thisBy Inherit The Wind, September 7, 2010 at 5:02 pm Link to this comment
DickBarbourRoveAiles: looks and sounds like one unpleasant Humpty-Dumpty.
Report thisBy PatrickHenry, September 7, 2010 at 3:49 pm Link to this comment
Maybe those with a better memory will vote him out next election.
Report thisBy Night-Gaunt, September 7, 2010 at 3:21 pm Link to this comment
Yes it is sad when we see examples of convenient memory syndrome. Where you only remember things they way it “should” have been. The way you want them to be. Now imagine an entire leadership who has that codified into text books and school curricula? If they should ever take over it would be so and within a generation they would have obliterated the past for their own myth.
The sad fact is Red Horse is that types like Barbour do have minds and they use them for vile and venal things. No, the mind numbed ones go to sports and spend most of their time, when their not working (or searching for work) eating, drinking beer and having sex with the missus. They don’t want the status quo to change and if their politician will give it to them then fine. They have little else to be interested in. Like the foreign places like Chicago and California.
Report thisBy gerard, September 7, 2010 at 12:54 pm Link to this comment
I hope not really hopeless.
Report thisThink of the kids growing up into tomorrow.
Think of how you, we can work toward what is best for them—at the very least, not allow the worst to happen. Yhey are full of life and possibilities. Act for the sake of the children.
By ocjim, September 7, 2010 at 12:46 pm Link to this comment
Look at Barbour’s history!
He is a miscreant through and through.
He is a caricature of the ugly, white, male Southerner, devoid of thought, full of himself, full of bluster and rampant with bigotry
Report thisBy mack894, September 7, 2010 at 12:42 pm Link to this comment
I wonder why Barbour would think he’d get a pass on such a load of crock.
Those of us who lived through those times and participated in the CR
movement know the story and won’t tolerate revisions. Heck, my grandma, a
schoolteacher in TN, didn’t see integration in public schools until the 70s!
Mississippi was a hardcase, which explains why Barbour is trying to soften up
its image. It was the state in which 3 civil rights workers—Goodman,
Shwerner, Chaney—turned up dead in the river. Where Viola Liuzzo was beat
for protesting; where poll taxes and literacy tests suppressed the black vote.
My family would drive south from Chicago to Alabama every summer to visit
grandparents. The rule was not to stop in Mississippi—gas up right before you
come to the state and drive on through. Once, however, we had to stop. My
father asked to use the restroom. He was told to get a pop bottle and go out
back. He declined. Most black people knew that using bathrooms or eating in
restaurants during the drive south was out of the question. We’d cook tons of
fried chicken for the trip and carry a roll of toilet paper for peeing and pooping
on the side of the road.
Barbour only brings attention to the truth by such an obvious lie.
Report thisBy REDHORSE, September 7, 2010 at 12:22 pm Link to this comment
Barbour makes my skin crawl. Another mindless inhabitant of Lie Lie Land. Visonless, dangerous and blind to reality. Another willing “for sale”-“lets make a deal Wall Street”-“I want to be richer” Republithug baboon.
The MSM has already declared the dream that brought President O. to power dead. And, so many who know better, are willing to roll over and let it happen.
Report thisFrom HOPE to HOPELESS in two short years.
By Aaron Ortiz, September 7, 2010 at 10:04 am Link to this comment
Mr. Robinson is also guilty of revisionism in his attack of the Republican party. He
should realize that both major parties have substantially changed in the last 50 to
100 years.
Vitriol and hatred are enemies of truth.
Report thisBy Queenie, September 7, 2010 at 9:48 am Link to this comment
“Leghorn Foghorn” Barbour. Cock-a-doo-da-dooing and strutting about the barnyard as if he had a brain. No, he is not smart. He’s lucky. So far.
Report thisBy Lafayette, September 7, 2010 at 6:32 am Link to this comment
THE DUMBING DOWN OF A NATION
Each nation has its lot of dumb people.
Why is it that they want to become politicians? Is it that they are not fit for any other work that requires astuteness, competence and intelligence? Methinks yes.
And if they’ve got a bit of smarts and thus become rich; then more than ever they feel as if they were destined for the Senate. (Where 40% are actually millionaires.)
So, they spend oodles of money in their campaigns, show how “regular” they are surrounded by the handsome spouse and 3.2 children—and we figure they’re the “right stuff”?
It’s like selling soap powder on TV.
Report thisBy Scott b, September 7, 2010 at 6:22 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
Exactly. Btw, I think a correct spelling would be Faux Noise.
Report thisBy richard, September 7, 2010 at 5:31 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
He knows that Fox and the rest of the republican propaganda machine will repeat this crap until it’s true, at least to the braindead types who are their audience. And they are the only ones who count.
Report thisRepublicans have long since given up trying to be slick. They don’t have to. They can be completely transparent to anyone watching them objectively, and still have exactly the desired effect on the target audience.
There is no longer any such thing as investigative journalism, so he knows that no one will call him on it. Eugene Robinson is, hell, the Washington Post is, a whisper in the Wilderness.
By Inherit The Wind, September 7, 2010 at 4:23 am Link to this comment
A politician lying. No surprise.
A Republican lying by re-writing history. No surprise.
A White, Southern Republican lying by re-writing the history of segregation and racism. No surprise.
A public that buys this bullshit that can easily and clearly be shown to be a lie. Sadly, no surprise.
Before there was Karl Rove, there was Haley Barbour, engineering the GOP’s return to power long before anyone ever heard of Karl Rove. The whole pattern of GOP lying and re-writing history stems from Barbour’s tenure as RNC Chairman.
In the aftermath of Katrina that destroyed the reputations of the governor of Louisiana and the mayor of New Orleans, somehow, the right-wing propaganda machine spear-headed by Fox Noise, gave Mississippi and its governor a “pass” despite conditions identical to those in Louisiana. Everything they claimed about Louisiana was just as true (or false) about Mississippi, but nary a bad word was voiced about Gov. Barbour.
Southern White Republicans re-writing history, especially about race relations. No surprise.
Report thisBy Hammond Eggs, September 6, 2010 at 10:46 pm Link to this comment
Now, Haley Barbour is not stupid. Why is he telling this ridiculous story?
Who says he’s not stupid? He’s cunning, a vicious little dynamo of putrid political ambition with a cheerleader’s haircut a la Trent Lott. Rhett Butler wearing the white sheet under his expensive suit. “Oh, he’s such a gentleman. Ah just love Haley, really ah do.”
Report this