Don’t Man Up, Grow Up

Posted on Oct 19, 2010

By Ruth Marcus

In this, the year of the Mama Grizzly, let’s stop stirring the moose chili for a moment to ponder three words—man up and whore—and what they have to tell us about the muddled state of gender politics.

Man up as in “man up, Harry Reid,” from Nevada Republican Senate candidate Sharron Angle on Reid’s downplaying of Social Security financial woes. And, though it got less attention, from Missouri Democrat Robin Carnahan to Republican Roy Blunt at a Senate debate the very same night, on health care: If Blunt wants to do away with health care for others, Carnahan told him, “then you ought to repeal your own first. And man up.”

Whore as in the accidentally recorded suggestion by an unidentified aide to California Democrat Jerry Brown about a potential line of attack against Meg Whitman, his GOP rival for governor.

The man up phrase is part of a series of supposedly tougher-than-thou statements from female politicians. During the primary campaign, Delaware Republican Senate candidate Christine O’Donnell told Mike Castle he was being “unmanly,” adding, “Mike, this is not a bake-off—get your man-pants on.” In the Colorado GOP Senate primary, Jane Norton assailed Ken Buck for not being “man enough” to run attack ads himself.

The queen of such discourse is Sarah Palin. Praising Arizona’s immigration law and the state’s female governor, Palin said that Jan Brewer had “the cojones” to take on illegal immigration that President Barack Obama “does not have.” Then, Palin blasted “impotent, limp and gutless reporters.” And Palin got in on the “man up” action the other day—turning the phrase on her own side. “Hey, politicians who are in office today,” she said, “you, some of you, need to man up and spend some political capital to support the tea party candidates.”

Ladies! If we’re so tough, so confident in our toughness and so comfortable with it, what do testicles have to do with it? The breakthrough appeal of the Mama Grizzly is that she combines the ultimate feminine act—motherhood—with fierceness. Have we really come a long way if cojones equals good, and lack thereof equals wimpy?

I’m sure to some extent Angle and Carnahan were just being cheeky. There is space to acknowledge gender differences in politics, and not every reference with gender overtones—remember John Edwards’ comment on Hillary Clinton’s pink jacket?—is sexist or demeaning.

But some references are, and whore, used about a female candidate, is one of them. More outrageous than the comment itself was Brown’s get-a-life reaction to it. In a debate with Whitman last week, he grunted out an infuriatingly insincere sounding apology wrapped in excuses.

Saying whore is not equivalent to using the N-word. (OK, but not the point.) It was a “five-week-old private conversation picked up on a cell phone.” (Ditto.) “I’m not even sure it’s legal” to have released the tape. (As I said.)

More Brown: “Have you chastised your chairman, Pete Wilson, who called Congress whores to the public sector unions?” Whoa. Context matters. To take it back to the N-word, when one African-American says it to another, that’s different from a white person saying it to or about a black one. When I use the word ladies, it’s less fraught, and more obviously ironic, than it would be coming from a male columnist.

And Brown’s concluding justification: “I’m sorry it happened.” (I bet.) “That does not represent anything other than things that happen in a campaign.”

Jerry, did I hear you say, “Man up, Meg Whitman”? Because it sure sounded like “If you can’t stand the heat, get back in the kitchen.” Brown did about everything except tell Whitman to stop crying about it, little girl.

Folks, navigating the modern lines of gender and politics may seem like picking through a minefield, but the rules for safe passage don’t seem all that complicated:

Don’t equate typically female characteristics or activities (baking, wearing high heels) with weakness.

Don’t—even, or maybe especially, if you’re a woman—equate toughness with manliness. At least not unless you think it’s acceptable for your opponent to tell you to behave like a lady.

Don’t use terms with sexist or racist overtones. If you, or someone in your campaign does, groveling works better than quibbling.

Politicians of both genders don’t need to man up—they need to grow up. Judging by the campaign so far, that might be harder to pull off.

Ruth Marcus’ e-mail address is marcusr(at symbol)washpost.com.

© 2010, Washington Post Writers Group

New and Improved Comments

We are launching a major overhaul of our comments section.

In addition to more robust spam filtering and moderation, new features include the ability to rate other comments, sort how they are displayed and respond directly via e-mail or in a thread.

Unfortunately, commenters will lose their existing Truthdig identities. It's a pain, we know, but on the plus side you will now be able to log in with a plethora of options, including Google, Twitter, Facebook and Disqus accounts.

Before launching this system we spent months in discussion with our top commenters. We listened to the feedback and we hope you like what we've come up with.

Please direct any problems or concerns to us via our contact page.