LOGO: Truthdig: Drilling Beneath the Headlines. A Progressive Journal of News and Opinion. Editor, Robert Scheer. Publisher, Zuade Kaufman. Winner 2013 Webby Awards for Best Political Website
May 21, 2013

 Choose a size
Text Size

Trending:     chris hedges     economy     elizabeth warren     politics     robert scheer
Most Read

Rise Up or Die

Revenge of the Bear: Russia Strikes Back in Syria

Lock Up Washington

GOP Senator's Hypocrisy on Tornado Aid, Jon Stewart Hates Washington, and More

The Promise of a Courageous Al-Jazeera America May Be Fading

Most Comments
Most Emailed

Reports
 * NEW! * Lock Up Washington
 * NEW! * Too Soon to Tell: The Case for Hope, Continued
 * NEW! * Warming Climate Endangers U.K. Farming

Ear to the Ground

A/V Booth

Arts & Culture
Act of Congress
Daily Rituals
The Girls of Atomic City

Digs

Truthdig Bazaar
The Future of Liberalism

The Future of Liberalism

By Alan Wolfe
$17.13

more items

 
Reports

Taking On ‘Big Food’

Email this item Email    Print this item Print    Share this item... Share

Posted on Jul 23, 2009

By Ellen Goodman

What caught my eye was not just the ashtray sitting forlornly on the yard-sale table. It was the sign that marked it “vintage,” as if we needed to label this relic of midcentury America.

    Ashtrays that once graced every airline armrest, coffee table and office have gone the way of spittoons. Today the car’s cigarette lighter is used to juice up the cell phone. Ask any restaurant for the smoking section, and you’ll be shown the doorway.

    If I had to pick the year attitudes changed, it would 1994, when seven CEOs of Big Tobacco came before Congress and swore that nicotine wasn’t addictive. A lobby too big to fail and too powerful to oppose began to lose clout. Smokers are no longer seen as sexy and glamorous but as the addicted dupes.

    I don’t know that we will ever have such a dramatic moment in the annals of Big Food. But I have begun to wonder whether this is the summer when the (groaning) tables have turned on the obesity industry.

    Now that two-thirds of Americans are overweight, the lethal effects of fat are catching up to those of smoke. We regularly hear the cha-ching of obesity costs in the health care debate. And we are beginning to see that Overweight America is not some collective collapse of national willpower, but a business plan.

Advertisement

    A measure of the moment is “Food Inc.,” a documentary chronicling the costs to the land, worker and customer of a food industry that’s more grim factory than sylvan farm. A system that makes it cheaper to buy fast food than fresh food.

    A more personal measure is David Kessler’s best-seller, “The End of Overeating,” which is both a thinking person’s diet book and an investigation into an industry that wants us to eat more. The former head of the FDA had crusaded against smoking, but found himself helpless before a chocolate chip cookie. So this yo-yo dieter set out to discover what exactly we’re up against.

    Kessler is a scientist, not a conspiracy theorist. But he writes about how the food industry has learned to produce “hyperpalatable combinations of sugar, fat and salt” that not only appeal to us but “have the capacity to rewire our brains, driving us to seek out more and more of those products.”

    And if words that Kessler uses like “craveability” and “conditioned hypereating” sound exaggerated, he takes you to an industry meeting where a food scientist on a panel called “Simply Irresistible” offers tips on “spiking” the food to make people keep eating.

    We eat more when more is on the plate. We eat more when snacks are ubiquitous, when flavors are layered on and marketed as “eatertainment.” As one food executive admitted to Kessler, “Everything that has made us successful as a company is the problem.”

    Sometimes it seems that our consumer society sets up the same conflict again and again. Sophisticated marketing campaigns hard-sell everything from sex and cigarettes to the 1,010-calorie Oreo Chocolate Sundae Shake at Burger King. And we’re told to stay abstinent or tobacco-free or skinny by resisting them. We are even promised “Guiltless Grill” entrees at Chili’s that can weigh in at almost 750 calories and are only guilt-free when compared to an order of Texas cheese fries that tip the scales at 1,920 calories.

    The analogy between Big Tobacco and Big Food is imperfect. You can’t quit eating or wear a food patch. We are also quite torn between “size acceptance”—a fight against the fat bias that has even been aimed at the new surgeon general nominee’s waistline—and criticizing fat as a health risk.

    But if the campaign against smoking provides a model, it’s in the effort to label restaurant foods and expose the tactics of Big Food. It’s also recasting the folks who bring us bigger food, drinks and snacks as obesity dealers. As Kessler writes, “The greatest power rests in our ability to change the definition of reasonable behavior. That’s what happened with tobacco—the attitudes that created the social acceptability of smoking shifted.” Are we the addicted dupes of the Frappuccino?

    The honchos at McDonald’s may never confess how the Big Mac made us bigger, and the food scientists at Frito-Lay may not explain why we “can’t eat just one” potato chip. But maybe this will be the year when an entree of chicken quesadillas with bacon, mixed cheese, ranch dressing and sour cream—1,750 calories—begins to look just a little bit more like an ashtray.

    Ellen Goodman’s e-mail address is ellengoodman1(at)me.com.

  © 2009, Washington Post Writers Group


New and Improved Comments

If you have trouble leaving a comment, review this help page. Still having problems? Let us know. If you find yourself moderated, take a moment to review our comment policy.

By DHFabian, September 26, 2009 at 12:20 pm Link to this comment

We all believe in “personal responsibility” and that people who use certain products should be punished by extreme taxation—as long as it effects someone else. Few (under 20% of US adults) smoke, so we have the extraordinary tobacco tax(none of which is targeted for health care, but goes straight into general revenues). Legislators impose these tax hikes because they can do so with little risk to their careers.

Public costs resulting from alcohol use far exceed those from tobacco use, but no legislator will apply tobacco-level taxes to alcohol because far more people drink than smoke. It would be politically impossible to do this.

These are the sort of factors that drive health and health policies in the US. Politicians make calculations based how any policy will impact their careers, regardless of the social value of those policies.

Report this

By liecatcher, August 5, 2009 at 4:12 am Link to this comment

To:
PSmith, July 26 at 4:33 pm
THE FUTURE - YOUR PLANT-BASED DIET

OUTSTANDING PSMITH !!!!!!!!

Diet for a Small Planet is a book by Frances Moore Lappé

“I GAVE MY first speech as the author of Diet for a Small Planet at the University of Michigan in early 1972..”,

That should have been the “shot” heard round the world, but the brainwashing food industry prevailed, & MIPIC :

MEDICAL INSURANCE PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRIAL COMPLEX has thrived knowing that we are what we

eat. Garbage in, garbage out.

Report this

By liecatcher, August 5, 2009 at 3:52 am Link to this comment

To: Robert, August 5 at 12:27 am

AMEN Brother !!!!!!!!!!!!

“EXCITOTOXINGS: THE TASTE THAT KILLS” BY RUSSELL L. BLAYLOCK,M.D.

covers this very well along with how these neurotoxins relate to ALZHEIMER’S & ALS.

Too many people who prepare their own food still use lard, sugar & salt, so let’s not

give these early grave foods a free pass just yet.

Report this

By Robert, August 4, 2009 at 9:27 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

The Big Food lie, it isn’t fat, sugar and salt. It is addictive junk additives, the most infamous being the so called flavour enhancers. Flavour enhancers do nothing to alter the taste of the food you eat, they alter your perception of that flavour, the trick your taste buds into perceiving flavours that aren’t there. Naturally enough just like all other nuero stimulants they are highly addictive and, of course their affect does not stop at your taste buds but goes our through your whole body. Why the hell do you the that the food industry attempted to introduce legislation during the Cheney era to give them immunity from prosecution for using any ingredients that latter proved to be toxic, they already know exactly how toxic and addictive they are. Big Tobbaco, became Big Food and brought their tactics with them.

Report this

By Lilith, July 25, 2009 at 11:34 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

nestoffour:

Your second post, with the link, is very welcomed. I do love Bill Moyers grin

nestoffour and liecatcher:

nestoffour’s video link and liecatcher’s post about seniors in Florida, reminded me of something that I did not mention about being on SSI/SSA disability and social security in my earlier posts. According to the social security code, people on Social Security disability can’t, I repeat, can not receive more than $20.00 worth of food from any NGO service every 3 months. That’s right only $20 every three months. More than that, you have to report it and have it taken out of your benefits for the next month.

If family, friends, or what ever give you food and/or clothing. That also must be reported and taken off your benefits. If they help towards your rent, that too is taken off your benefits.

What this boils down to is that the disabled, and their family and friends, are forced to break federal law and become willing criminals. This is just to keep the disabled person from starving to death, going unclothed and living in horrible conditions, not to rob the system so that the disabled can live a life of luxury at the expense of the tax payer!

Here in California, the disabled have had their COLA (Cost of living adjustment), taken back by the state. We have had this done 15 times in the past 20 years. From the early 1980’s to the present, we have gone from being approx. 140+% above the poverty level in CA, to 104% currently. Arnie wants to roll back our state benfit back another $20 per month, which will then put us at approx. 98.9% of the poverty level. In other words, below the poverty level.

What can we afford to eat then? We do not get food stamps because the state pays us a small amount each month instead, which saves the state money they would be spending on issuing those food stamps to us instead. It was ment to help both the state and the disabled person. Arnie and others now look at it as a burden upon the state.

I am simply tired of having the state budget balanced on my disabled back in order to balance the budget and pay for tax breaks for the top 1% earners in CA. It is not just wrong, but in my mind, criminal.

“It was once said that the moral test of government is how that government treats those who are in the dawn of life, the children; those who are in the twilight of life, the elderly; and those who are in the shadows of life, the sick, the needy and the handicapped.” Hubert H. Humphrey

Report this

By Lilith, July 25, 2009 at 11:07 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

nestoffour:

Thank you so much for your kind words. They made all that typing (and retyping) worth it. I try to bring these facts to light when ever possible as a way to educate the public and hopefully make a difference.

Again, thank you!

Report this

By liecatcher, July 25, 2009 at 9:42 pm Link to this comment

I’ve been seriously interested in health & nutrition since 1968.

It wasn’t until the past several years, after studying about FASCISM &

brainwashing, that all of sudden everything made sense. E,G.,

why so many people smoke while waiting in food hand out lines.

I wonder how many folks remember when seniors in Florida were

eating dog food & shoplifting food just to survive. Education is an

ongoing process & so is the numbing & dumbing down of the U.S.

by the FASCIST OLIGARCHS who control everything from the

POTUS on down, including the food supply & what passes as food.

The populace is told what to eat, drink, breathe, watch, wear,drive,

without realizing that it is being brainwashed & manipulated into

consuming toxic products guaranteed to make you sick &

enter an early grave. Alcohol, tobacco, caffeine, soft drinks,

artificial sweeteners, & MSG, are a few examples. The entire

education system has been “left behind” while perpetual

trillion dollar wars continue unabated.

Report this

By nestoffour, July 25, 2009 at 7:45 pm Link to this comment

Lilith,

My previous comment related to your first two posts.  Your latest one simply broke my heart. 

****

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZhuNAQ16J24

Report this

By nestoffour, July 25, 2009 at 7:20 pm Link to this comment

Lilith,

That was quite an eye-opening post.  Sorry I cannot help you, but I thank you for educating me about something I had absolutely no knowledge of.

Report this

By Lilith, July 25, 2009 at 2:08 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

Kesey Seven:

Thank you! I am hanging in there. I have very good family and friends and I am doing this for them as well.

Corie:

To quote you: “Will my tax dollars that will support the proposed government health plan go to provide lap-band surgeries for couch potatoes who stuff their faces all day?  Probably.”

People eat better when they have the money to do so. That is a simple fact. There use to be “Poor Food”, such as fish, beans, rice, vegies, and so on, but that is no longer true, EXCEPT for highly refined foods. When you are poor or low income, often that is all you can afford.

Have you ever noticed that lots of people on Food Stamps are over weight? That is the reason. I know, I live there now and in the past. For instance, a mother on Food Stamps does not have enough money to feed everyone. What to do. Well, a candy bar cost less than a $1.00, will give you energy and hopefully tide you over till when you can really eat. So mom has candy bar for lunch and the rest get the food she can afford. I know this to be fact and something that I often did while raising my daughter. She recently said she was amazed by me because she never went hungry and never missed a meal while growing up. She could not figure out how I did it. I missed breakfast, had a candy bar for lunch and a descent meal of chicken, rice/potato,etc and a vegie at dinner, that was how I did it. During school my daughter also got a free lunch. Have you ever raised a boy? I have seen a boy eat a family’s whole month’s worth of Food Stamps in a few days during rapid growth during puberty. Then what does the family do?

Fat bigotry is the last bastion of social prejudice. It is not only socially acceptable, but enforced and encouraged by every institution in this country. Since poor families are forced to survive on cheap highly refined foods, taxing some of these foods as “Junk” foods, would add an additional burden upon those who do not have enough food to start with. THAT was the crux of the hue and cry you speak of. Yes it is a matter “still related to class”, but not in the way you think. It has less to do with education, ethnicity, and gluttony, and more with economics, cooperate welfare, and the encouraging of shipping food from long distances, rather than governments supporting local and family farms. It is a very complex and non-racial matter, but we are lead to believe that that is all it is.

Report this

By Kesey Seven, July 24, 2009 at 9:26 pm Link to this comment

Sarah Sebring,

You got that right. 

Kris Knight,

One thing that’s been helping me is setting rules, like: I don’t eat out of vending machines. I don’t eat after 8:00 PM. And then giving myself treats, like dark chocolate made on site at Whole Foods or raspberries mixed in with some raw almonds. When I break a rule, I exercise more the next day.  Rules. Treats. Consequences.  We learned to eat like monkeys in a cage. We’re gonna have to unlearn to eat like monkeys in a cage. 

G. Anderson,

Amen brother, or sister, whichever way you button your shirt.  Myself I like a combination of B12 and Folic Acid, 30 milligrams of co-enzyme Q10 per day, a healthy dose of Vitamin D for my natural deficiency, Hawthorne flower and berries twice a day (for the heart disease), cayenne capsules (again for the heart disease), plenty of Turmeric whenever possible (blood thinner), and I like to sweeten my water with Stevia, which has been banned as a food additive by the FDA, not because it’s bad but because it would likely replace the poison known as aspartame had Stevia not been banned.

Thanks for letting me share. 

Kesey Seven

Report this

By Kesey Seven, July 24, 2009 at 9:22 pm Link to this comment

Lilith,

I’m not a scientist, but I feel your pain. What a nightmare. Hang in there. Keep fighting.

—-

Fat Freddy,

The free market functioning the way it’s supposed to would have you and your kids working 18 hours a day seven days a week for slave wages.  Government doesn’t regulate business. People do. Know your country’s history. The free market behaves as a sociopath, and corporations are the free market’s psychopaths.

—-

Frederick Dennis Williams, huh?  Goodman is clever. People move less and eat more. You are correct. And? Read the book Goodman recommends “The End of Over Eating.” It might help you make a persuasive argument. We are the research. We are the experiment. We are the data. Of course the fertilizer and depleted soils are a problem.  But the bigger problem is that it’s been known for forty years and nothing is being done about it. Our democracy isn’t quick and it does not follow popular mandates.  It’s lumbering and hard. A vast majority of Americans want to us to stop our constant state of war. The war continues. A vast majority of Americans want a better education system. Our education system sucks. People have to die before things change and the food industry is killing us by the tens of millions, which is why, finally, something might—might—get done about it. My apologies for being a jerk. I know you what you were trying to say.       

—-

Jim Yell. Thank God you wrote something.  My faith in humanity was going off a cliff. The food is exactly the same as the exploding Pinto. It’s big business behaving as a psychopath.   

Spiritgirl:

Your words bear repeating repeatedly:  WE ARE THE STUDY! 

The twentieth century was a huge experiment and we were the monkeys in the cage eating whatever shit they fed us.  White rice, white bread, margarine saturated with trans fats, “instant oatmeal” stripped of all fiber and natural taste and infused with synthetic sugars, cereal not fit for pigs, soft drinks, everywhere. We even ruin foods that should be good for us, like adding salt and caramel to nuts. It’s insane,  And the deal is at first it wasn’t greed or stupidity. People and businesses didn’t know any better.  It was simple ignorance. But now the results are in.  And we have no more excuses. To continue as we are is mere greed and stupidity.

—-

Liecather,

I do not agree with you. Read A People’s History of the United States by Howard Zinn. Read it again if you already have because you weren’t paying attention. Every freedom we have was brought about by people fighting against seemingly insurmountable odds. 

Corie,

I find your perspective a little distasteful.  But hell who am I to call out someone for falling into the trap of pitting Americans of different income brackets and educations against each other? I just made an ass of myself going after Mr. Williams. I have no room to talk.  And overall I agree with you.  We should be taxing the hell out of junk food. The only thing I would add is that our kids should eat well when they go to school, not the high-carb slop and sugar they are fed now.  Teaching kids to eat right and giving them the right food to eat should be the highest priority of schools. The money we would save years later in health care would be astronomical. And the kids would learn a helluvalot more if they had the right food in their bellies to start the day. 

Kesey Seven

Report this
G.Anderson's avatar

By G.Anderson, July 24, 2009 at 1:11 pm Link to this comment

As in so many industries in the United States, what we eat is related to politics, and those politics are related to profit.

We eat what we eat, because we are conditioned into eating it by almost non stop corporate propaganda, and also because it’s the most profitable for the giant food corporations.

And if you eat it, then you will get sick, and you will suffer from a serious degenerative disease, that will more than likely kill you slowly over time.

Our food is filled with pesticides, food additives, genetically modified organisms, preservatives, fillers like wood pulp, and sythetic chemicals modified to replace something that once was food.

The fact that most American’s continue to unconsciously poison themselves, because the happy adds on T.V., tell them to, is an indicator as to where we are going as a species.

But rest assured, before we all pass into the great beyond, the FDA, will do it’s best to outlaw vitamin B6. Now that a Former Monstanto executive has been appointed by Mr. Obama to the FDA.

Report this

By Kris Knight, July 24, 2009 at 7:44 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

I agree with the above commenters—-it’s far more complex than just eating the “right food”.  And who you believe about the “right food” varies tremendously, and it’s not the same for everyone.  I too started out as a thin person, then a normal size, then ballooned with my two pregnancies, then became very slim again, then very heavy.  I am working very hard now, including a great deal of studying, to determine what will work to help me get back to a normal weight and most importantly, feel good on a consistent basis.  The various factors involved, with many negative environmental triggers and influences, are infections, inflammatory processes, insulin resistance, liver overwork/toxicity, low physical activity, and then, and only then, weak will.  For each category I just mentioned, there are many factors to consider, and many of us have several of those categories operating within our bodies, then manifesting as a “heavy” person.  So, I have found some powerfully helpful answers and hopefully am healing many layers of imbalance as i go.  But it’s very complex and that is what I think we need to remember—-that it is what is all around us that we’re programmed to want to eat, but it is far more complex than that now, and any way you slice it, it will take alot of careful homework and willpower to study and work with your body to give it the best chance possible to be a life-friendly vehicle through your time here on Earth.

Report this

By Sarah Sebring, July 24, 2009 at 7:09 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

From an economics standpoint, we cannot discount the effect that free market capitalist competition has had on our communal waistline. Formal restaurants lost to “all you can eat” buffets from coast to coast.

Report this

By Corie, July 23, 2009 at 8:51 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

About 15 years ago, California tried to impose sales tax on “junk” food—that is, food that was sold in grocery stores already prepared, like chips and frozen meals.  Fresh food would still be exempt.

I voted for this increase because I thought that the people who ate “junk” food would then be encouraged to eat, oh, apples or cottage cheese instead of tortilla chips or Stouffers.

Silly me.  The stink and hue and cry were amazing.  The opponents turned it into a class and race issue, because apparently poor minorities disproportionately purchased more “junk” food than other people.

I think it’s still related to class.  If you go to a fine restaurant, the portions are realistic and balanced.  You go to Chili’s, and it’s fat, calories and salt in portions equivalent to a full day’s USRDA.  Educated people tend to eat better. 

What can you do about it?  Force people to change?  Will my tax dollars that will support the proposed government health plan go to provide lap-band surgeries for couch potatoes who stuff their faces all day?  Probably.

Report this

By Lilith, July 23, 2009 at 8:14 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

If upon reading my two part post below, what I wrote rings true for you or someone you know, please post here and let me know. I am doing a survey.

Thanks!

Report this

By liecatcher, July 23, 2009 at 5:29 pm Link to this comment

This is a very important article.

However, after viewing the Youtube video: “THE NEW WORLD ORDER IS HERE”, it’s obvious that it’s too late
to make any meaningful changes.
Since the FASCISTS are blatantly running America & we
the people have no representation, we are effectively
enslaved.

Report this

By Spiritgirl, July 23, 2009 at 1:45 pm Link to this comment

Slow food - you know that good ole food that Grandma used to make (mainly because she didn’t work outside of her home), has lost favor because more women are working outside of the house and are working further away from where they live!  “Fast food” on the other hand has received massive “subsidies” - to allow for the lower prices!  If you think about it in the 1920’s and 1930’s there wasn’t nearly as much Frankenfood as there is now - this is a recent invention! 

“But he writes about how the food industry has learned to produce “hyperpalatable combinations of sugar, fat and salt” that not only appeal to us but “have the capacity to rewire our brains, driving us to seek out more and more of those products.””

These “tastes” that the industry has learned to produce have actually dulled the senses for real flavor!  Fewer and fewer people actually season (beyond salt & pepper) their food, and it is the taste bud that is never satisfied that they continually are trying to feed!  In the meantime Americans have turned away from the family farmers, and opted for good ole factory farming curtesy of the corporate BIG BOX GROCERY!  Want to know why our kids are bigger, along with not enough exercise - how about those hormones that have been injected into the meats?  And how about those genetically modified seeds that most of the rest of the world don’t want to touch - could it be that there are not enough long term studies of the possible risks, oh that’s right - WE ARE THE STUDY!

Report this

By Jim Yell, July 23, 2009 at 11:34 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

There are always more reasons for something that happens than we are willing to admit. The decrease in physical activity is not to be discounted, but when you get a plate groaning with surplus food every day of your life that can’t be discounted as a cause of increasing fat.

If you add to that documentation where an industry is discussing way to increase peoples eating without need, just to increase their profits, that too can’t be discounted. Anymore that the Pinto blowing up all the time in accidents when we have the auto industry on record discussing how it would cut into their profits to fix the defect causing the car to explode.

I can remember that the soda pop serving when I was young was what today would be considered a taste, when in fact it was all that was needed to still ones need. I have been trying to find products that have not been contaminated with “high fructose” corn syrup. It is hard to do, but I find the flavor much better with corn syrup. We know that our food has been contaminated, why not do something about it?

Report this

By Fredric Dennis Williams, July 23, 2009 at 6:31 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

I like Ellen Goodman’s writing. She is very clever.

But I wonder if the food suppliers are really the cause of the continuing rise in American obesity. Are they actually becoming more effective at duping consumers, or are consumers eating more and moving their bodies as little as possible. Is it possible that our vaunted agricultural abundance is based on defective science—using fertilizers that lack many essential elements found in undepleted soils.

The problem with legislation inspired by skillful writers who jump easily to conclusions that are accepted just as easily by readers and politicians, is that it is often wrong-headed. Unfortunately democracy is well-equipped to make quick and popular decisions, but poorly designed to solve problems by doing serious research and thinking carefully, which might require too much time that is now spent campaigning. And, even if Congress took the time, the average voter wouldn’t, so where is the percentage?

Report this
Fat Freddy's avatar

By Fat Freddy, July 23, 2009 at 5:25 am Link to this comment

It is government regulation and interference that allows “big food” (replace food with energy, health care, banks etc.) to maintain their competitive advantage over small and medium sized businesses which are essential in a free market system. So, the answer is more government regulation? Let the free market function the way it is supposed to, and hold consumers responsible for their decisions. More Corporatism is not the solution to Corporatism.

Report this

By Lilith, July 23, 2009 at 5:25 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

Part 2:

At first I thought it was a fat oxidation disorder, where instead of burning the calories, they where sent to the liver to be converted into fat and stored in fat cells (that is how it works when there is to much sugar in the blood, hence, weight gain). But after trying a newly discovered plant (in the west that is) called Bitter Melon, which stimulates the metabolism AND the production of insulin, I came down with severe hypoglycemia symptoms that even eating could not stop for long. My blood sugar was kept artificially high as my body went into a tail spin of removing the sugar to fast, thus causing adrenaline to be dumped into my blood stream (to cause the liver to turn fat into sugar and keep me from going into insulin-low-blood-sugar shock), which then causes more insulin to be produced, to again lower the blood sugar, and then back again, over and over for nearly two days. Crazy making and hell to live through.

At this point I realized that what was happening was that I was truly insulin resistant, which causes sugar cravings worse than nicotine, and adverse side effects that make you think you are having a seizure and can only be stopped by eating, especially sugar (sugar + protein is the best). Sigh!

Then, to my dismay, and then anger, I recently found an article in one of the medical research sites I go to and there I find that ALL children become insulin resistant during puberty, but nearly all go back to normal after a few years. Just some of us tend to develop “Reactive Hypoglycemia or True Hypoglycemia” during puberty and many of them go on to develop adult onset diabetes type 2. THIS HAS BEEN KNOWN FOR DECADES! Yet, no one told any of us about this, we where just mocked, ridiculed, told to take dangerous drugs (like Fen-Fen) and so forth because we must be: 1 Over eating and lying about it, 2 not exercising enough, 3 eating nothing but or almost exclusively fast food, sweets and so forth and 4 Not trying hard enough

It was and is not just negligent, but down right criminal. How many of us have died because these facts where not part of the general discussion on weight and diet. How many of us committed suicide, became alcoholics, cutters and so forth because of a lifetime of being told we are worthless, a nothing, a pariah because we are fat. A survey of doctors and nurse a few years ago revealed that most (or a large portion, can’t remember) hated, where groused out by or afraid to touch an overweight patient! MY GOD are we not human anymore!

Sorry, need to take a deep breath. ... So, here I am, along with millions of others, yet again facing an “it is because you are weak willed or a dupe, or what not” theory about why you are fat. Not genetics, not real science, just bigotry, bias, and the human need to hate someone, any one, to make up for all that we lack in ourselves.

Do not get me wrong, I think this discovery is great, and will go a long way to reverse the effects of what many now call “The Western Diet Disease Theory”. I support it, BUT I want to make it clear, that those of us who do everything right, and still can not lose weight, still need to be researched, helped, and understood.

Now it’s off to research what hormones are involved, exactly, in puberty, what they do, how they effect the body and how they cause the teenage body to become insulin resistant. Then match that with the two pathways sugar is passed into the cell to be used for energy. How are these related and what, if anything can I do, take, find or what every, to counter act this genetic nightmare! Any scientist out there willing to take this up?

Report this

By Lilith, July 23, 2009 at 5:23 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

Part 1:

This article both encourages me and saddens me at the same time. I am heartened to hear that fast food and refined food have always been marketed and designed to trip people up. Being a member of a family of multi-generational weight issues, this does not relate to me or my family, and it can only hurt us. It has always been so.

The women in my family start out as very skinny kids. Puberty hits and suddenly we have dizzy spells, nausea, vomiting, palpitations, sweating and so forth on a daily basis. We are often so sick we can not get out of bed for several days, every month or so. Forget PMS, its major PMSD for us as well. We also start craving sugar like crazed people, something we never did before. The doctors poo-poo us and send us home. Then in our mid to late twenties or early thirties, tada! We have full blown diabetes type 2 and all the doctors point fingers and say, see, we knew you where causing this! Dieting, starving and learning to not feel hunger, but just a stomachache, meant nothing to them, nor did being an athlete in constant training help or convince them either.

Because I knew I was not over eating, my mother was an Adel Davis fan, so we ate health food, and I was training daily, I knew I was not the cause of this. Through chance, research and other methods, I slowly learned that what we had as kids was severe Hypoglycemia, though the doctors today still say there is no such thing. Then we discovered we all had a genetic form of Thyroid disease, where anti-bodies attack and slowly kill the Thyroid. Then it is Celiac we find we have, where gluten causes our immune system to attack the gluten in our intestines, secrete a poison that then set about damaging our intestines and the ability to absorb all but the simplest sugars, fats and some proteins.

Yet when fixing these things or treating them, the weight stays on and even increases, the doctors jump on us and say, see you can’t blame it on your medical conditions. This is a hard blow, yet being an athlete, I was very in tuned with my body. I notice that after two or so months of dieting all my muscles would start to scream in pain. After 4 to 6 weeks of screamoing pain, it was only food, eating that would stop it. The best day of my life was when I stopped with the dieting over and over again lifestyle. I was happier and healthier, but still gaining weight if I was not severe with watching what and when I ate.

Next came a decade of research to find out why my muscles acted like they where starving when ever my caloric intake dropped, even a moderate amount (I tried all kinds of caloric levels, always the same results). I studied the two types of metabolism cycles, how fat oxidation worked, what ATP was and how to take B-1 and Biotin to help all that (which they do, but not enough), how the Mitochondria of each muscle converted the sugar into energy and so forth. How insulin resistance is supposed to work, and so on.

As I delved deeper and deeper into medical research papers on these various subjects, it became clear that some how the process of going into puberty triggered not only the Hypoglycemia, but all the other immune problems my family and I have as well. What was it about that particular cycle in life that would cause such non stop havoc to our bodies and sabotage every diet and exercise we did?

Report this
Newsletter

sign up to get updates


 
 
 
 
Join the Liberal Blog Advertising Network
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A Progressive Journal of News and Opinion. Editor, Robert Scheer. Publisher, Zuade Kaufman.
© 2013 Truthdig, LLC. All rights reserved.