![]() |
|
| |
|
Bush’s Short View of HistoryPosted on Jan 12, 2009Not to kick the president on his way out the door, but he was wrong when he told White House reporters at a wistful, nostalgic news conference on Monday that “there is no such thing as short-term history.” It’s true that some presidencies look different after a few decades. But it’s also true that presidential acts can have immediate consequences—and that George W. Bush will leave office next week as a president whose eight years in office are widely seen as a nadir from which it will take years to recover. “I strongly disagree with the assessment that our moral standing has been damaged,” Bush said in perhaps his most spirited response of the session. “I disagree with this assessment that, you know, people view America in a dim light.” Has he been paying attention? Did he not notice that both President-elect Barack Obama and his Republican opponent, Sen. John McCain, felt the need to promise to restore America’s honor and standing in the world? Or does Bush believe they were just joshin’? Asked to name the biggest mistake of his presidency, Bush gave a curious answer that had more to do with public relations than presidential decision-making. He mentioned the “Mission Accomplished” banner that prematurely announced the end of major conflict in Iraq—but not his decision to invade Iraq in the first place. He mentioned his failure to visit New Orleans at the height of the devastating, deadly flood caused by Hurricane Katrina—but not the decision to entrust the Federal Emergency Management Agency to the hapless and ineffective Michael Brown. In Bush’s mind, the revelation of shocking prisoner abuse by U.S. military guards at the Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq was “a huge disappointment”—but he doesn’t take any responsibility, as commander in chief, for the atmosphere of lax training and supervision that allowed Abu Ghraib to happen. The failure by U.S. forces to find weapons of mass destruction in Iraq qualifies only as “a significant disappointment”—even though the administration’s apocalyptic rhetoric about WMD was what sealed the deal for an invasion and occupation that never should have taken place. In what may turn out to have been his last news conference as president, Bush spent surprisingly little time on his actual achievements. Yes, I said achievements. Bush was the first U.S. president to put real money and serious effort into a campaign against AIDS in Africa. Even if the administration wastes far too much on questionably effective “abstinence only” programs, the fact is that millions of people in Africa are being kept alive and relatively healthy with antiretroviral drugs that wouldn’t have been available without Bush’s funding and commitment. In sub-Saharan Africa, he made a difference. Bush also tried his best to move his party away from small-minded xenophobia on the immigration issue. This doesn’t really count as an achievement, since Bush never got a reasonable immigration bill passed. But short-term history has proved him right. Latino voters defected to the Democrats in such numbers that the Republican Party looks even more like a country club than when Bush took office, and that’s saying something. As his greatest achievement, Bush would cite the fact that there has been no terrorist attack on U.S. soil—I won’t use Bush’s unfortunate term, “the homeland,” which sounds vaguely Teutonic and evokes lederhosen—since the Sept. 11, 2001, al-Qaida atrocities. Here, though, he relies entirely on short-term history. His argument, in effect, is that since we’ve made it through seven years and four months without an attack, his administration’s anti-terrorism methods must be both necessary and effective. That must be a comforting thought for the president, but it’s unjustified. The fact that there has been no new attack does not justify waterboarding, Guantanamo, secret CIA prisons or domestic surveillance. Bush believes these departures from American values and traditions were necessary, but from what we know so far, they look more like overkill—an excess of cruelty and a disdain for the rule of law that have seriously damaged this nation’s sense of itself. What we know so far isn’t enough. I understand Obama’s reluctance to conduct criminal investigations of the Bush years—and I realize that Bush might well pardon everybody in advance anyway. But it’s important to convene an investigation and learn the truth, all of it, so that no president is tempted to take such liberties again. History, both short-term and long-term, will be grateful. Eugene Robinson’s e-mail address is eugenerobinson(at)washpost.com. © 2009, Washington Post Writers Group TAGS:
|
By samosamo, January 15 at 6:17 pm #
By Bushfatigue, January 15 at 9:10 am #
We saw Bush at his delusional worst—and this man lead our country for 8 years?—no wonder we’ve been devastated. What moronic self-absorption.
On our standing, haven’t his aides shared any of the polls that show how despised our country has become, almost everywhere? Is he really that dishonest or uninformed?
Why don’t reporters or interviewers have the wit or courage to challenge him? Why has he been allowed to repeatedly claim, without challenge, that he “had” to go into Iraq because Hussein “wouldn’t let the inspectors in”? If his advisors had actually kept him in the dark on this, they should be tried for treason—
***************************************************
w is the product of the neocon think tanks, those organizations that popped up in the nixon error to come up with ways to get conservative/neocon control of all branches of our government and bring as much of america over to their way of thinking. Since the nixon era and that is a good long time to read, study and research how to gain this control of power, these treasonous traitors to the republic of the USA have worked hard and their handiwork is everywhere to see and hear. And I am talking about reading and using ideas from Orwell’s ‘1984’, milton friedman’s disastrous economic theories of the ‘unfettered’ markets, HOW TO CONTROL THE MEDIA(which came down to ignoring the anti-trust laws that were created to prevent the owership of a particular ‘persuasion’ of ideology of something as important as our source of information) by consolidating ownership by 4 or 5 neoconservative owners that control how information is ‘managed’ now and also Aldous Huxley’s ‘Brave New World’ to a lesser degree(Read ‘Brave New World Revisited’ for what I mean here).
Report thisI consider this the utmost of priorities to set back to right by breaking these monopolies where there are real journalists reporting and keeping tabs on such an easily subverted thing as what our government has become. There should not have to be a real source of information that is relegated to internet web sites and books that not all people have or pay attention to. I am talking about real journalists that appear on the mainstream media just as regularly as, say, fox does with its nonjournalist punditry. But, still with the strangle hold that people like rupert murdoch has on his idea of what information the people in this country gets, real news will still be hard to come by on those easily accessed tv and radio channels according to ‘their’ terms. And you can thank that sorry piece of fecal matter reagan for excellerating the subversion of our media by killing the fairness doctrine which stopped the right of hearing opposing viewpoints and creating that totally illegal claptrap called ‘commerical free speech’ that gave corporations the rights of what were originally for the citizens, which the ‘elite’ had already been gradually gaining control of decades ago.
By Bushfatigue, January 15 at 2:32 pm #
Bush could have cared less about Africa when he came to office, and was reliably of the “they get what they deserve” branch of the Republican party when it came to aids.
It was a heavy push from his evangelical base, in particular, ironically, Rick Warren and his group, that set him on the path to the one decent thing he accomplished in office.
Report thisBy Bushfatigue, January 15 at 2:10 pm #
We saw Bush at his delusional worst—and this man lead our country for 8 years?—no wonder we’ve been devastated. What moronic self-absorption.
On our standing, haven’t his aides shared any of the polls that show how despised our country has become, almost everywhere? Is he really that dishonest or uninformed?
Why don’t reporters or interviewers have the wit or courage to challenge him? Why has he been allowed to repeatedly claim, without challenge, that he “had” to go into Iraq because Hussein “wouldn’t let the inspectors in”? If his advisors had actually kept him in the dark on this, they should be tried for treason—
Report thisBy SteveL, January 14 at 8:05 pm #
Just more mindless untruthful talking points trying to pave the way for Jeb. This is why the Bush administration needs to be investigated and everyone needs a good strong whiff of all the crap that will be exposed.
Report thisBy Casy, January 14 at 7:28 pm #
I can only hope that during the Obama inaugural, when the departing idiot-in-chief walks down the stage to take his seat, the millions who are present to witness history collectively raise their shoes as a symbol of the utter rejection of that moron.
Report thisBy gnl, January 14 at 6:01 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)
What’s really disturbing is that we, the “represented” don’t know the all of it. E-mails in the 100’s of thousands irretrievable becuz’ the worm Rove communicated to his operatives via the RNC server. “Scooter” Libby, that paragon of “public service” refused to testify about Cheney and Bush knew, thereby rewarded with a commutation to be enhanced by a full pardon and an estate on some island somewhere. David Addiington, Cheney’s Chief of Staff, and enabler of much of the torture, eavesdropping etc., just “couldn’t remember” except that which would immunize him. We don’t know who was truly responsible for the fraud and thievery the deceit that had to be obvious to the Fed, the FCC, and all “straight” commercial bankers was allowed to sh—can the economy. Longer term history will be far more critical of this criminal, lying, cheating,bullying, stealing mafia, whose greatest thievery, bullying, cheating, criminalizing was done, we will see, to the American people. Oh yes, they murdered and tortured many more foreigners for which they should be tried, convicted and sentenced, but they stole more from the US Treasury, and busted more of the Bill of Rights and the Constitution than all of the other Presidents. To top it all, even with the wilfully ignorants’ blind obedience, the Evangelicals, they stole both “elections.” Need I say MORE!
Report thisBy Hulk2008, January 14 at 12:06 pm #
Hey, ThnkUBush,
Report thisYou missed a ThankYou - namely, you forgot to thank W for ignoring the repeated warnings before 9/11 that Al Qaeda intended to “crash airliners into public buildings”. In particular W was so intent on Sadam Hussein he blew off the specific warnings that came from various agencies in the US and abroad during August 2001. Ironically that same intelligence came from all the same sources he now says he relied upon for so-called concrete evidence of WMD. And ironically you could have skipped a bunch of your current ThankYou’s if he had taken the August warnings seriously.
But you didn’t miss your dose of the administration’s kool-aid did you? How ARE things over there at “the home” ?
By richardbelldc, January 14 at 12:04 pm #
I am disappointed to find a normally reliable columnist like Robinson joining the Washington mainstream consensus by calling for an “investigation” of the crimes of Bush and his minions.
When a robber robs a bank, we don’t call for an “investigation” to get at the truth of how the robber robbed the bank. If the investigation-grand jur-indictment-trial-punishment process is good enough for petty thiefs, why are the powers-that-be so terrified at applying the rule of law to our leaders?
If Obama does not authorize criminal investigations of Bush’s deeds, Obama will have squandered his historic opportunity to strengthen the moral backbone of the nation and renew the country’s commitment to the rule of law.
We just had an election: I don’t know about you, but I voted for courage, not cowardice.
Report thisBy hippy pam, January 14 at 10:04 am #
BOYCOTT “ole BSs” farewell speech!!!!!Shut off your T.V when his “farewell speechifying” comes on…
STRIKE a blow to his immense ego by letting him [and HIS media]know how unimportant whatever it has he thinks? and has to say!...
Each of us is a COMMITTEE OF ONE…
JUST SAY “NO”!!! to any/everything concerning “ole bullshit”....
SHOW HIM we do not care!!!
Report thisSHOW HIM he is IRRELEVANT!!!
By Margaret Currey, January 14 at 7:12 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
Still this almost ex-president has little to say and his ability to say anything coherant.
The 9/11 incident could have been avoided, if the Republician Adminiration had listened to Clinton.
And then C. Rice said “who could have imigined that planes would have been aimed at buildings”, something that came to light when Fla. Flying schools mentioned that people wanted to learn how to fly planes but not how to land them.
Chaney and Company were planning (even before the final count) on how to go to war and I sometimes wonder if 9/11 was allowed to happen, and if it did not happen what kind of know nothing President would Bush have been.
After all a war president can suspend all kinds of laws.
He was also fortunate to have all the government powers. May he trip on his way up the ramp to the plane that takes him back to Texas, not only trip but also break a leg and arm.
Report thisBy wildflower, January 14 at 3:21 am #
You’re right, Eugene. It’s very important to convene an investigation of the Bush administration. We can start by investigating some of the administration’s “incredible and deadly” lies that John Dean discusses on the Findlaw site:
“. . . in the run-up to the war in Iraq, the White House was worried about the stance of Republican Majority Leader Richard Armey of Texas, who had deep concerns about going to war with Saddam Hussein. According to the Post, Armey met with Cheney for a highly classified, one-on-on briefing . . .
During this meeting, the Post reports, Cheney turned Armey around on the war issue. Cheney did so by telling the House Majority Leader that he was giving him information that the Administration could not tell the public—namely (according to Armey), that Iraq had the “‘ability to miniaturize weapons of mass destruction, particularly nuclear,’ which had been ‘substantially refined since the first Gulf War,’ and would soon result in ‘packages that could be moved even by ground personnel.’ In addition, Cheney linked that threat to Saddam’s alleged personal ties to al Qaeda, explaining that ‘we now know they have the ability to develop these weapons in a very portable fashion, and they have a delivery system in their relationship with organizations such as al Qaeda.’”
The Post story continues, “Armey has asked: “Did Dick Cheney ... purposely tell me things he knew to be untrue?” His answer: “I seriously feel that may be the case…Had I known or believed then what I believe now, I would have publicly opposed [the war] resolution right to the bitter end, and I believe I might have stopped it from happening.”
In short, it was this lie that sealed the nation’s fate, and sent us to war in Iraq. By lying to such an influential figure in Congress, Cheney not only may have changed the course of history, but also corrupted the separation of powers with their inherent checks and balances.
Cheney’s monumental dishonesty, the news of which has been buried under the current meltdown of the nation’s economy. . . can be viewed not only as a great immorality and violation of the criminal code, but also and more fundamentally as the significant breach of his oath of office to protect and defend the Constitution that it is.”
http://writ.news.findlaw.com/dean/20080919.html
Report thisBy ThnkUBush, January 14 at 12:56 am #
Thank you President Bush for your part in capturing or killing over 2/3 of the men and woman responsible for planning and carry out the Sept. 11 attacks. Thank you for forcing Usama bin Laden, Dr. Zawahiri and Mullah Omar into a state of effectual disconnect from operational control. Thank you for your part in severing numerous global terrorist network banking and financing venues. Thank you most of all for any part you played in preventing another such attack. I know the credit goes to thousands in the armed forces, the intelligence community and local, state and federal law enforcment. But water boarding Khalid Mohammad, is and will be, recognised for killing and capturing numerous high level opperatives and disrupting attacks already in the operational pipeline. For that too I thank you immensely.
Thank you for focusing as you did on global narco-terrorism which had proven to be one of the most effective vehicles in acquiring moniess to train Ansar Al-Islam, Asbat al -Ansar and the Ansar al-Sunnah Army.
Thank you for you unabashed and unapologetic belief that ridding the world of Saddam Hussein was of the highest priority after 9/11. Taking the lesson of what’s possible for a relatively small number of people to accomplish when murder is the goal was solid reasoning on your part. You displayed in short order that you understood some of our most ardent and dangerous enemies.
Thank you for signing the Patriot Act after it’s passing overwhelmingly in the House and Senate. Thank you for continually following the Patriot Act after the democratically controled Congress re-autherized the Act in 2006 and again in 2007. Thank you for informing party leaders on government progress every step of the way. You helped to display that it was a group effort amongst almost 100 Senators and several hundred House Members.
Thank you for being one of a handful of world leaders who say what they mean and mean what they say. I didn’t always agree with you but, it seems a rare quality at times.
Thank you for being the most forceful voice amongst a small number who kept the pressure on the United Nations when it came to Sudan. You were the very first to respond with humanitarian aid and never hesitated to engage other African nations to get invloved. Your White House has been a true leader in the area.
Thank you for the Millennium Challenge Mr. President. You, and the many good men and woman around you, have quit literally saved millions of lives.
Report thisBy nrobi, January 13 at 10:31 pm #
Part 2
Report this3) The plans and implementation of the Iraq “War.”
Nothing that was concerned with this illegal and immoral use of “war power,” was a success. Everything
about this conflict was and is a complete disaster, the planning for this conflict was done by people who
never saw battle and discounted the advice of the very people who could have gotten us in and out, like
a fart in a mitten. Gen. Shinseki, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff at the time, and others in the command structure of the military, stated without reservation that the number of troops needed for the successful completion of this task, was way more than
the civilian authorities predicted. Leading us into the quagmire that we are now embroiled in.
Last but not least, for the list can run into book length, 4) The total and complete meltdown of the economy of the world, especially the Untied State.
Starting with Ronald Reagan, and continuing through the successive presidents, including William Jefferson Blythe Clinton, under the laissez-faire regime of the shrub and his neo-conservative pundits and friends, especially those in his “kitchen cabinet,” America has now become a third world country. We are now facing economic ruin, as never before seen in the history of the US, because of the lack of oversight and regulation that was instituted by the “Great Communicator,” and then followed by the successive presidents. Duhhhhhbya, only hastened this process by allowing the banking sector of our economy, total leeway in making decisions. And this without any oversight, by either the Legislative Branch or Judicial Branch of our governmental structure. We are now one of the largest debtor nations in the world, we, the people,
are in the fix for trillions of dollars that can never be repaid, and will cause the economic collapse of the “free market capitalist system.”
Nowhere can we the people borrow enough money to repay all the loans and bonds that have been taken out to prosecute an illegal and immoral war, secure
our nations borders, leave an environment that is better than what we inherited, and for toppers, we are now faced with the possibility of economic war,
with countries that we cannot possibly win against.
All this against the backdrop of history, yes, history will decide whether this administration was the worst or near worst in the history of the US.
The shrub says, “I am taking the long view, I will leave it to the future historians to decide whether
I was a good president or not.” This is the most laughable and maniacal thing that has ever come from
the mouth of the shrub. His war crimes, the crimes against humanity, and the shredding of the Bill of Rights, and the Constitution in prosecuting the “war on terror,” in a perfect world would be prosecuted
by a tribunal of International Justices. Yet in the space of less than 10 days, G.W. Bush will pardon all the actors in this farce of an administration.
There will be no one to prosecute! Pardons all around
everyone! Get your pardons here!
By nrobi, January 13 at 10:30 pm #
There are many things that I can take umbrage with that
Report thishave happened during the administration of the shrub and Darth Vader!
Certain things stand out in my mind, as time goes on they only increase in intensity and number:
1) 9/11. During the aftermath of this disaster, the world was squarely behind the United States. Pursuing the terrorists that supposedly caused this, was something that the people of the world looked upon as a
necessary and needful thing. Yet Duhhhhhhhhbya, squandered the goodwill of the world’s population by engaging in an illegal and immoral conflict, that has
only now begun to be the quagmire that people predicted and the people of the world disagreed with,
Iraq.
2) Abu-Ghraib. Here was a prime example of policy and
the implementation of that policy, gone wrong. Every
person, from G.W. Bush on down, knew that the conditions of the prison were abominable and atrocious. That there was a complete lack of oversight that caused deaths and mental illnesses to become the norm for people that were incarcerated at this hellish and abominable place.
By wildflower, January 13 at 4:59 pm #
Considering the Bush Administration’s obsession with secrecy, I imagine the George W Bush Presidential Library will probably be a departure from American traditions as well. Since anything and everything always got the old ”executive privilege” stamp, we know it won’t be open to the public - only Bush will be allowed to enter the library.
Of course, Bush may be planning to open a special wing for the public and fill it with his signing statements. There is certainly enough of these to fill a room. And it could be the library staff will provide daily “water boarding” demonstrations for the public and weekly lectures on how to break long standing laws like the Presidential Records and Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Acts.
Report thisBy hippy pam, January 13 at 3:51 pm #
“ole bullshit” has NEVER considered any other views BUT HIS OWN and he is so STUPID AND UNEDUCATED as to think his views are RELEVANT….Hopefully he will fall off his horse and break his neck as he rides off into the texas sun…....
Report thisBy Bboy57, January 13 at 3:41 pm #
It’s going to take years to recver from because that is the Republicans m/o now. They have blown up the deficit so that no new public funding can take place for the american taxpayer. Only our money being funneled into existing programs and the military industrial/oil lobbyists to get them re-elected is the name on their game. Oh and Wall street executives as well.
Jimminy just to get the economy rolling again and people working we need to borrow another trillion or so, that if the deficit hadn’t been run up on PURPOSE would not have been any issue. So much for laizei-fare Republicanism and a false debt economy. The eight years were a total wash, especially the free money given at Americans’ expense and a false war. What a false administration.
Report thisBy Hulk2008, January 13 at 2:27 pm #
To ThnkUBush:
Yes Kabul fell .... but is currently surrounded by more powerful tribesmen, Taliban, and Al Qaeda sympathizers than before - and the poppy crop exceeds any in history. (only 82 US military ? Did you forget the thousands of air sorties, pilots, naval vessels, sailors, airmen, cruise missiles, and materiel?)
Yes Bush had a clear head re: Katrina - that’s why he chose to attend a fund-raiser instead of a fly-over of New Orleans. He had other fish to fry.
(“Brownie” did a heck of a job.)
Yes W ignored the Kyoto agreement and has since implanted hundreds of anti-environment moles in our government bureaucracy to continue to block or obfuscate improvements for the distant future. (Fortunately for W he will not be around when global warming chokes the poulation. Current estimates suggest W revised over 100 times the enviro-regulations and procedures Clinton did in his last days.)
Yes you voted for W twice - which makes you even more at fault than W himself.
And he DID leave behind a Vietnam-like war, a clone of the Great Depression, a military under terrific stress, deficits that may take generations to catch up with.
He did NOT ignore dogma, hate or bigotry - he institutionalized it.
And one would hope that the Europeans and others remain whining about problems they see - W surely turned a blind eye to everything that contradicted his foolhardy plans.
W and Faux Snooze and Joe Scarborough and Pat Buchanan are on a mission to say that Abu Graib was the work of un-trained minions and waterboarding is not torture and that ANYbody can be trained to resist “enhanced interrogation”. Of course they never endured such themselves - one can be objective from outside.
Maybe after all it’s just, “Fair and Balanced” to thank Bush. Even Archie Bunker yearned for the return of Hoover.
Report thisBy Paul_GA, January 13 at 1:24 pm #
One thing’s for sure—this sorry excuse for a president is surely leaving something resembling the Augean stables to Mr. Obama; and where are the two rivers to divert through the stables to cleanse them? And the Herculean strength needed to do it?
I am SO glad I’m not the president-elect! I wouldn’t wish his predicament on anyone.
Report thisBy Inherit The Wind, January 13 at 1:11 pm #
ThnkUBush, January 13 at 5:21 am #
Inherit The Wind,
You say you take the long view?
If memory serves you are the one who opined that Bush would attack Iran before leaving office. You were certain of it. Well, you were certainly wrong.
*********************************************
By how much? VP Cheney was pushing for an attack on Iran. So, it seems, were the Right Wing of the Israeli Cabinet. All the signs and rhetoric that led to the illegal and unnecessary attack on Iraq were there. The transfer of Supreme Commander in the region went from land (Army) to sea (Navy) because that would be how an air attack would be mounted. How much did Iran back down? How much did Iran’s congratulations to Obama bring us back from the brink.
The fact that we didn’t attack Iran doesn’t mean we didn’t come close, too close. Happily, late in his administration, Bush has listened less to Darth Cheney than before. Perhaps even Dumbya figured out that Cheney is ALWAYS wrong.
*************************************
If memory serves you are the one who opined that Bush would not leave office and would impose martial law and take over Washington. Wrong again!
**************************************
Wait! We still have a week to go. Still, I am more and more hopeful every day that I AM wrong. Again, let us not forget that in 2004 Cheney (him again!) actually proposed postponing the election. Even during the Civil War, WWI and WWII elections weren’t postponed. So…why postpone it in 2004?
A President who advocated regal, dictatorial powers cannot be trusted to turn over power when the time comes. Again, perhaps, Cheney’s waning influence and his dad’s resurging influence may have helped. Then, too, this last year has been particularly tough on Bush (not that I care—it’s of his own making) and I think he’s ready to be done with it. He may even, in his heart of hearts, recognize that he is totally incompetent and unsuited to the job. This last, the financial crisis, is mostly the result of all of his 8 years of irresponsible policies.
**************************************
Your views appears very narrow indeed. Hate Bush at every turn and call him every name, and accuse him every crime, known to man.
No matter how many times you have proven yourself wrong you keep repeating the the mantra like a programed robot. Seems very narrow indeed.
*************************************
Could be you are right—but take a gander at his truly demented final press conference! He lies about the recession (“I came into office with a recession”) Nope, it began in March—two months later. (“We rescued 30,000 from the rooftops in New Orleans. Don’t tell me we were unprepared.”) Oops…Standard Coast Guard plans, not FEMA, not the WH—and there were no plans or actions for what to do with them after they were rescued. 30,000 people are STILL living in temp. housing years later.
I give Bush credit for 3 things: 1)He WARNED the GOP that their hard-assed immigrant views that he opposed would cost them Hispanic voters and was right. 2)He did more to help AIDS in Africa than any of his predecessors. 3)He just declared the Mariana Trench a protected area.
That’s not enough to rescue the man who trashed our civil liberties, our economy, our ability to respond to natural disasters, our reputation abroad, and got us into this quagmire of Iraq for no damn good reason.
Report thisBy Fadel Abdallah, January 13 at 11:58 am #
Bush in my book is the epitome of evil. The fact that he’s leaving office without being tried for crimes against humanity will always be one of the darkest pages in American history. Here are some facts:
1. He stole two elections.
2. It’s under his watch and most likely because of him or by his order that the 9/11 attack took place nine months into his presidency.
3. He is responsible for two evil and destructive wars half way around the world; wars of aggression and imperial designs based on lies and weapons of mass deception.
4. For eight long years he continued to be a serial liar, warmongering and fear-mongering to violate basic human rights.
5. As a result of his evil more than a million people died in the Iraq and Afghan wars, so he has a lot of blood on his hands.
6. He leaves the country totally broke and financially ruined, as a result of promoting a culture of greed and robbery by the rich 1% against the majority of common Americans.
7. He leaves America morally corrupt, becoming the laughing stock of the world and turning the majority of the world into enemies.
One can write books about the atrocities and bloodshed committed at the altar of this evil one. Since Hitler no one has committed crimes against humanity as he did. And if he is not tried for his crimes, I wish that he dies a violent and tragic death like the deaths he brought to so many humans in America and the world!
Report thisBy Big B, January 13 at 10:47 am #
It’s almost funny to see in print someone referring to the use of illegal imprisonment, torture, and political assassination as a departure from “american” values and traditions.
I put forth the proposition that they these despicable actions have been, and continue to be “business as usual” for the good ‘ol USA.
When you think about the attrocities committed by men wrapped in the american flag, it is impossible to come to any other conclusion other than we are some of the most cruel people in human history. Let me submit some examples:
The organized slaughter of the indigenous people of america. (by some esimates, over 18 million people)
Slavery, and our willingness to defend it by making war.
The murder of countless millions of innocents from the Phillipines, to southeast Asia, to Central and south America from the 1890’s to now in politically motivated conflicts as a means to america’s business ends.
Manzanar
Medical experimentation on blacks, and retarded people in places like Alabama, and Oak Ridge Tenn.
The second atom bomb
The organized government oppression of the civil rights movement.
The unconditional support of military juntas throughout world, just because they are friendly to US business interests.
Our proliferation of the weapons of war throughout the second and third world.
Countless political assassinations perpetrated by the american intelligence services.
The suspension of civil liberties(done to roaring applause)
And these few examples are just among the ones that we KNOW ABOUT. Yessiree, we americans are a cruel bunch! But humans have been slaughtering each other for centuries, so why should americans be held to a different standard? Oh, that’s right, we were supposed to be the “shining beacon” for the world to follow. An example for all future nations to follow.
So what kind of example does it set when we tie people down and pour water down their throats? Do the ends always justify the means? Torquamada thought so. But that was only for God.
Report thisBy ThnkUBush, January 13 at 10:35 am #
Thank you President Bush for all you’ve done to prevent another attack on the United States. Thank you for the brilliant way Kabul fell with only 82 U.S. Troops on the ground in Afghanistan. Thank you, immensely, for the absolutely brilliant decision to remove Saddam Hussein. Those moves alone will assure your high ranking in history.
Thank you for keeping a clear head after Hurricane Katrina. Thank you for keeping with the House and Senate in denying the deeply flawed Kyoto agreement. Thank you for all you did to make Social Security an issue in Washington.
Thank you, Sir. Thank you from the bottom of my heart for doing almost everything contrary to the opinions on TruthDig. I feel GREAT for having voted for you twice!
Thank you, thank you, thank you for all you’ve done.
Report thisBy michele hemenway, January 13 at 10:32 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
I dont know what the strategy is but my hope is that when Obama is in office, Bush and his buddies will get what they have coming to them. If Obama ignores that and moves “forward” without doing so, he wont’ have the backing of a huge part of his following now, myself included. What I hope that he will consider is that moving forward INCLUDES prosecuting these guys ( and gals, as the case could be). If he doesn’t do so, we won’t ever move beyond the shame of this administration. This is no Watergate situation. There ARE degrees of crimes.
I am surprised to see anyone defending BUsh here but nonetheless I commend you for coming to this site and to this writer, Eugene Robinson. How do you keep your blood pressure down? I don’t agree with you but I admire your willingness to contribute to this site considering that the Truthdig audience would not be a friendly one.
Report thisAgreed about Helen Thomas and the media, so funny to watch them now come after Obama. They are a pathetic excuse for journalism.
By ThnkUBush, January 13 at 10:21 am #
Inherit The Wind,
You say you take the long view?
If memory serves you are the one who opined that Bush would attack Iran before leaving office. You were certain of it. Well, you were certainly wrong.
If memory serves you are the one who opined that Bush would not leave office and would impose martial law and take over Washington. Wrong again!
Your views appears very narrow indeed. Hate Bush at every turn and call him every name, and accuse him every crime, known to man.
No matter how many times you have proven yourself wrong you keep repeating the the mantra like a programed robot. Seems very narrow indeed.
—-
Thank you President Bush for all you’ve done. Thank you for ignoring the short sighted view rooted in dogma, hate and bigotry. History will indeed judge you well.
Report thisBy dihey, January 13 at 10:15 am #
The most stunning remark of the President was this: “we were disappointed that we did not find Weapons of mass Destruction in Iraq”. A sane person could have said: “we were relieved when we found no WMD’s in Iraq because there was not threat to us after all but that could not be known beforehand”.
With regards to “prosecutions” of lawbreakers, our coward-in-chief Obama has already capitulated. He wants to look forward leaving a great stench (not made by him of course) behind his back which will not go away but he already argues that it’s not important given the state of our economy. I have a suggestion for Mr. CinC: he should look forward and order the release all prisoners who are in jail for possession of marijuana or hard drugs and order that no new arrests be made. That will save a gigantic amount of expenditure for all States.
Report thisBy Inherit The Wind, January 13 at 9:21 am #
I take the long view of history: George W. Bush will be remembered and regarded as the most destructive President by far in our history. Even such luminaries of incompetence and destruction like John Tyler, James Buchanan, US Grant, Warren G. Harding, Herbert Hoover, Richard Nixon and Ronald Reagan seems “not so bad” or even “metzo-metzo” when compared to this delusional @$$#0le. Considering “Old Buck” fiddled while the nation ripped itself apart leading to the Civil War, it shows just what a monster President Disaster has been.
OK, he was good on immigration and AIDS in Africa. Even a broken clock is right twice a day.
I hope the George W. Bush story is NOT over. Notice that Obama is distancing himself from investigations…but he’s saying NOTHING about Congress calling for special investigators. Bush cannot pardon himself—and anyone he pardons cannot legally refuse to testify! (so he needs to be VERY careful whom he pardons….)
To me, the Dubya story will properly end with Bush spending the rest of his life in prison for his crimes against humanity.
Report thisBy ThnkUBush, January 13 at 8:33 am #
By July, we will come to feel that 2009 will be one of the most upbeat years in our history, as what used to be the news media begins to get behind America and report on all the mysteriously wonderful things that are suddenly taking place.
All the campaign talk of the Great Depression, a Vietnam-like war, and our shredded Constitution will now thankfully subside as the Obama administration assumes office and solves problems with conciliation, dialogue, and multilateral wisdom, rather than shrillness, unilateralism, preemption, and my-way-or-the-highway dogmatism. We will hear that, by historical levels, unemployment is still not that bad, that GDP growth is not historically all that low, and that deficits, inflation, interest rates, and housing starts are all within manageable parameters. “Depression” will transmogrify into “recession” which in turn by July will be a “downturn” and by year next an “upswing” on its way to boom times.
Indeed, almost supernaturally crises will be solved with the departure of the hated Bush: no more flooding streets from cracked water mains that were a result of a President’s neglect of infrastructure, and no more spontaneous crashes of Mississippi River bridges due to diversions of critical federal aid from cash-strapped states to Iraq. And when the temperatures rise or drop, the wind howls, the clouds burst forth or go away, the snow melts or piles up, it will be, well, nature that caused the havoc, not the current occupant of the White House who failed to sign Kyoto.
As we watch the innocent die from natural mayhem, it will be due to the breakdown of local responders who now suddenly kill people, not federal inaction — except perhaps for an occasional few Bush federal holdovers that have not yet been rooted out. Human nature, of course, now will be seen more culpable, more selfish, as in needlessly resisting wise and caring federal interventions, rather than being inherently noble but shunned by an uncaring Washington. Yes, when dikes collapse and planes collide on crowded runways, it will be due to a cruel and unpredictable nature, or intrinsic design flaws, or improper local use and maintenance, or the past President’s nefarious legacy, not current government policies. (But if you still must bash the government, it will be wise to do it in 1950s style of inattentive state and local officials, prone to regional and tribal prejudices, blocking the infinite wisdom of a caring federal government.)
Some military action abroad could be necessary — and necessarily reported on as measured and reluctant, rather than cowboyish and gratuitous. European whining will be a result of miscommunications or the Euros’ unfair caricatures of Americans, not Bush’s alienation of allies. If radical Islam strikes, it will be, well, radical again and sometimes even dangerous, not a figment of neocon pipe dreams. If an administration official quits, goes on 60 Minutes, and writes a nasty tell-all book about Obama’s insensitivity and his government’s directionless ennui, he will be a heretic, a whiner, a turncoat, not a truth teller or brave maverick who blew the whistle in need of a bestseller hyped from NPR to the New York Times. We will come again to hate the filibuster, obstructionist Congressional policies, and the occasional loud-mouthed Senator who voices slurs against our nation in unpatriotic fashion.
Report thisBy jrosenb1, January 13 at 4:16 am #
Eugene Robinson is, as usual, on the mark. But I take issue with one phrase in his assessment. The horrors of Abu Ghraib were not the result of “lax training and supervision.” They were policy crafted at the highest levels of authority—deliberate and premeditated war crimes, for which the Bush administration is (by the President’s and Vice President’s own admission) directly responsible. I, too, “understand Obama’s reluctance to conduct criminal investigations of the Bush years.” But unless this is done, our very survival as a nation is threatened. Only uncompromising pursuit of the truth can enable us to guard against such grave violation of the rule of law ever happening again. Anything swept under the rug—especially that impressive and expensive new shag rug with a presidential seal that now graces the Oval Office—will fester. As a nation, we have only begun to face up to the trauma our Constitution and national psyche have suffered.
Report thisBy Mary Ann McNeeley, January 13 at 2:34 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
There’s another article in this same Truthdig called The Language of Death. Bush can barely speak English but he is fluent in Death.
Report thisBy samosamo, January 13 at 2:22 am #
This was a pitiful diatribe from a piss poor excuse for a human. It is 49 minutes of the most god awful crap from the most god awful president this country has ever had to endure. Where was Helen Thomas? And calling him president is making a far stretch of the whole thing. One thing, his comment about not being able to just put on a straw hat and sit around should be interesting because other than his terrorist buddies from his administration or those in saudi arabia, or other ruthless dictators, who would want him to see him much less be seen or photographed with him?
Report thisHe still deserves full prosecution and penalties of law no matter how much obama says to hold our breath.
Hmmm, maybe the reopening of the investigation into 911 will bring forth good results.