![]() |
![]() |
||
|
One Man’s Bid to Aid the EnvironmentPosted on Dec 23, 2008By Amy Goodman Tim DeChristopher is an economics student at the University of Utah in Salt Lake City. He had just finished his last final exam before winter break. One of the exam questions was: If the oil and gas companies are the only ones who bid on public lands, are the true costs of oil and gas exploitation reflected in the prices paid? DeChristopher was inspired. He finished the exam, threw on his red parka and went off to the controversial Bureau of Land Management land auction that the Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance called “the Bush administration’s last great gift to the oil and gas industry.” Instead of joining the protest outside, he registered as a bidder, then bought 22,000 acres of public land. That is, he successfully bid on the public properties, located near the Arches and Canyonlands National Parks and Dinosaur National Monument, and other pristine areas. The price tag: more than $1.7 million. He told me: “Once I started buying up every parcel, they understood pretty clearly what was going on ... they stopped the auction, and some federal agents came in and took me out. I guess there was a lot of chaos, and they didn’t really know how to proceed at that point.” Patrick Shea, a former BLM director, is representing DeChristopher. Shea told the Deseret News: “What Tim did was in the best tradition of civil disobedience, he did this without causing any physical or material harm. His purpose was to draw attention to the illegitimacy and immorality of the process.” There is a long tradition of disrupting land development in Utah. In his memoir, “Desert Solitaire,” Edward Abbey, the writer and activist, wrote: “Wilderness. The word itself is music. ... We scarcely know what we mean by the term, though the sound of it draws all whose nerves and emotions have not yet been irreparably stunned, deadened, numbed by the caterwauling of commerce, the sweating scramble for profit and domination.” Advertisement Likewise, the late Utah Phillips, folk musician, activist and longtime Utah resident, often invoked the Industrial Workers of the World adage: “Direct action gets the goods.” More than just scenic beauty will be harmed by these BLM sales. Drilling impacts air and water quality. According to High Country News, “The BLM had not analyzed impacts on ozone levels from some 2,300 wells drilled in the area since 2004 ... nor had it predicted air impacts from the estimated 6,300 new wells approved in the plan.” ProPublica reports that the Colorado River “powers homes for 3 million people, nourishes 15 percent of the nation’s crops and provides drinking water to one in 12 Americans. Now a rush to develop domestic oil, gas and uranium deposits along the river and its tributaries threatens its future.” After being questioned by federal authorities, DeChristopher was released. The U.S. attorney is currently weighing charges against the student. DeChristopher reflects: “This has really been emotional and hopeful for me to see the kind of support over the last couple of days ... for all the problems that people can talk about in this country and for all the apathy and the eight years of oppression and the decades of eroding civil liberties, America is still very much the kind of place that when you stand up for what is right, you never stand alone.” His disruption of the auction has temporarily blocked the Bush-enabled land grab by the oil and gas industries. If DeChristopher can come up with $45,000 by Dec. 29, he can make the first payment on the land, possibly avoiding any claim of fraud. If the BLM opts to re-auction the land, that can’t happen until after the Obama administration takes over. The outcome of the sales, if they happen at all, will probably be different, thanks to the direct action of an activist, raising his voice, and his bidding paddle, in opposition. © 2008 Amy Goodman Distributed by King Features Syndicate Elsewhere: . CommentsAre you a Truthdig member yet? Login now, or register with Truthdig. Add Your Comment |
By DAveKnTux, June 19, 2009 at 6:27 am #
Aha its a great non violent way to protest. More forms of non violent civil disobedience need to be enacted on environmental issues such as pollution, global warming and overgrazing. This guy should get a presidential pardon he essentially filerbusted an auction.
Report thisBy KDelphi, December 29, 2008 at 5:34 pm #
Keegan—Here it is , further down. I’ll repeat it, so people dont have to scroll down…
http://oneutah.org/
where there are several links to
http://www.wateradvocacy.org/id86.html
or, they say,
“If you don’t want to use a credit card, please send checks made out to “Center for Water Advocacy”. Please include “Tim DeChristopher Lease Purchase Fund” in the memo field. Mail checks to Center for Water Advocacy, P.O. Box 331, Moab, UT 84532.”
Report thisBy Keegan, December 28, 2008 at 5:54 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)
I’d totally pitch in my $10 to help TIm out.. i’d LOVE to see one person make a huge difference… anybody know where to send it?
Report thisBy Dogtail, December 28, 2008 at 3:48 pm #
Oh ye wise Damian, probaly about 22 years old yet so full of wisdom and sanctimonious drivel.
Me, I have been in the “movement” for over 50 years and have been spit on by ranchers, thrown out of public hearings, chained to a few trees, arrested and we have lost way way way more than we have won and all this time, the “movement” has dwindled down to “outings” and environmental groups like The Wilderness Society which is now cutting a deal with a developer in Idaho and will endorse this development. Get a hold of Carole King for more info if you even know who this is. You see, my little sanctimonious and naive friend, I have the feeling the one that has little experience in this, is you. Not that this matters.
And if you listen carefully to what Tim said, he was waiting for some environmental group or someone to take this on and guess what? NO ONE DID. What I typed may be over your head but this is an indictment on how lame the “environmental movement” has become.
I applaud his courage but this is also a wake up call that “environmental groups” need to get off their butts and show the same level of courage. This means foregoing the “drum circle for peace” and your meditation cushion and your narccisistic new age crap to get something real done.
To read more on the true state of the “movement” read The Death of Environmentalism by Nordhaus and Shellenberger and Confessions of an EcoT by Dave Foreman. Again, most likely, before your time or perhaps you have been living in your teepee meditating for peace that you did not notice things have gotten a LOT worse and maybe it is time to DO SOMETHING.
Happy New Year.
Report thisBy Damian, December 28, 2008 at 1:23 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
Dear Tim –
Thank you for your creative civil action during a crisis situation. It will help save the land we love here in Moab. You and your friends are welcome at our dinner table anytime!
As you enter into a time of public scrutiny and legal complications, it might help you to remember that the word “patriot” comes from the Latin word “patria,” which means home-land, with an emphasis on LAND. In other words, the original meaning of the word “patriot” is a defender of the land against those who seek to conquer it. In this sense, conservationists are the true and original patriots, because they defend the land for its own sake and for the benefit of future generations. Unfortunately, in recent decades the word “patriot” has been co-opted by the far right to mean “those who defend the economic growth of the country at all costs, exploiting the land whenever possible for a quick buck,” and they have wrapped themselves in the American flag to confuse the masses.
Because you now represent the focal point for the competing American values of land preservation and land exploitation — essentially the age-old battle between widsom and greed — you will get to see first-hand how those with financial power use it and abuse it to further their own agendas. Of course you are aware how the Bush administration is leaving a legacy of great violence toward the land of America and the climate of the world. They also leave a legacy of great violence toward innocent people who stood between vast Iraqi oil reserves and the Texas oil-men like Cheney who coveted it blindly. You are now a highly visible person who stands in between these same violent exploiters and the few drops of oil they hope to squeeze from the sands below Moab.
It might be useful to you to remember that both Gandhi and Martin Luther King repeatedly said that, while they would not condone any form of violence, their methods of protest served to expose the violence that already existed, lurking below the surface in the oppressive societies they confronted. While the protesters committed no acts of violence, they were exposed to violence from the police, who represented the arm of enforcement for oppressive regimes. Similarly, there is great psychological and social violence hiding behind the chant “Drill, baby, drill!” heard at the Republican convention earlier this year. You will be the target of that mob mentality, of the confused masses of people who believe that the only answer for their personal and collective financial woes is the further rape and pillage of the American home-land.
Please use caution where you step, and don’t underestimate the power of angry mobs. Greed, anger, and other human frailties turn into social memes that can cloud the judgment of those in power, even those who are truly well-intentioned. Please treat the individual humans who oppose you with kindness, as if they are confused but well-meaning people, because that is a correct psychological perspective, and a perspective that allows for real and permanent social change.
Gandhi and MLK both humbly adhered to Jesus’s commandment to “love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you.” They firmly believed that wisdom and justice would ultimately prevail, not by destroying the people who opposed their peaceful agendas, but by appealing to their shared humanity and eventually winning their enemies over as allies. History has proven them right. Your creative act of civil disobedience has made you the lightening rod for the anger of those who are blinded by the lust for money and oil. Now win them over with wisdom and compassion.
Meanwhile, know that you are a true hero to me and my wife, Dorina, and we open our guest room to you whenever you visit Moab!
Best regards,
Damian Nash
Report thisMoab, Utah
By check_your_tail_dog_your_constepated, December 28, 2008 at 1:02 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
dog tale
and what great things have you accomplished
I bet it is nothing but complain.
Have you don anthing close to what Tim has accomplished all by himself
Report thisBy Dogtail, December 27, 2008 at 7:37 pm #
Tim illustrates the pathetic state of our
“environmental movement” which is now made up of
MBS’s, timid people scared to take a stand on anything, nimby’s (which is the root of the movement anyway) and more pot lucks than you can stab a stick at.
Ball-less. This is the movement now.
And how about all those “climate change” conferences
that just pump more and more CO2 into the atmosphere
in the name of stopping climate change.
A remarkable warrior. Thoughtful and quiet. Who takes up the slack for all the really really lame
“environmental” groups who instead of fighting to protect what is left, are too busy endorsing housing developments with a little open space then turning around calling it a “success.”
If nothing is a commentary on how lame the “movement” is this man’s single stand to save Utah is!!!!
Report thisBy KDelphi, December 27, 2008 at 2:02 am #
mikerobe—I believe that you are totally misinterpreting the intent of the article. He didnt say that others had not sacrificed more. I think he was speaking of this particular auction.
Ron Ranft—How right you are!
I just wrote a check for $10. You can hardly be more broke then me—-cmon.
BTW—I would like to find a site where I can see how much he has collected and how he is doing, etc. The trial and all.
I do wonder wtf these wealthy people spend their money on! Well, I do know that the champagne region of France “ran out” this year. trump has a solid gold toilet seat….you’ll probably get that $300-$100 tax “stimulus” from PE Obama.
But, I noticed that Toys for Tots was empty, the food bank downtown is not much better, Earth First is always broke, so is Sea Shepherd. So, instead of wasting it on a broken stock market (lol), help the bro out!
Report thisBy cann4ing, December 26, 2008 at 11:43 pm #
By Ron Ranft, December 26 at 5:11 pm #
But here is the rub about purchasing the land. It already belongs to us.
______________________________
Excellent point, Ron. The real criminal behavior lies with the members of the Bush regime who, sans Congressional authorization, sought to sell off “public” lands to their crony capitalist friends in the oil cartel—a “sale” that really would have amounted to a “theft” of public property had it not been for Mr. DeChristopher’s bold action, for they had intended to sell the land well below its market value.
Report thisBy Ron Davisonron.s.davi, December 26, 2008 at 11:08 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)
Tim DeChristopher
You are the coolest person I have read about in a long time.
God Bless you and anyone whoever thinks like you again.
OK,
So here is my idea:
Tim needs to claim his right to buy the land he bid on and as is everyones right to do bid on our collective land that is being auctioned off. Every 300 million of us.
Ok now for the math:
1.7 million devided by 300 million
That’s 1/2 penny for each one of us.
So let’s say that only one in 200 are willing to help, that brings the total per person to 1 dollar each.
So if some of us (1 in 200) coughed up a dollar each we could pull off Tim’s ambitious plan and go beyond mere civil disruption.
1 in 2000 contribute and 10$ each is needed.
if this is was done right say by the web geniuses that helped get Presentational Elect Obama elected.
I bet we could get this done closer to the 1$ per person than the 10$, either way I am in for 10$
And I am one of the unemployed thanks to the genuineness’s steering the ship right now. But I am still good for the 10$
Report thisBy Ron Ranft, December 26, 2008 at 10:11 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)
Tim is indeed a true hero. He said that he was waiting for someone to step forward and do the right thing and when no one did he realized that you have to be the person to step forward. I am damn glad he did.
But here is the rub about purchasing the land. It already belongs to us. The land, the oil, the minerals, all of it, belong to us already. people point at Hugo Chavez and say he is on his way to becoming a dictator. But look at what he and Evo Morales have done that none of our Presidents have done. They realized that the source of their wealth was being stolen from them by the oil companies. The People were getting 20% and the oil companies were getting 80%. These leaders have now said that the oil companies will get 20 and they will get 80. And what have they done with these new found riches? How about free health care for every citizen along with a free education. And the oil companies are still posting record profits.
Our leaders continue to give away our land and resources for pennies on the dollar. Why? Because the Oil Companies have bought our elected officials. That is why they refuse to seriously investigate them for fraud, why our courts let oil compaines off the hook even when juries find them guilty and fine them billions of dollars, and why the CEO’s laugh at any attempt to curtail their abuses. See today’s LA Times article on Colorado attempting to place rulkes on oil drillers.
In a true Democracy Tim would not have to defend himself.I will contribute to his defense fund but until someone spells out exactly what is to be done with the land Tim purchased I will not contribute to that fund. That land already belongs to the People and we should not have to buy what is already ours. Tim should be able to give it back to the People without any penalty.
Report thisBy mikerobe, December 26, 2008 at 9:56 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)
i congratulate anyone who takes any action to defend the earth against the corporate state. and i congratulate you mr. dechristopher. right on.
but the line that “i didn’t see anyone else stepping up… so i had to.” come on. either you are really uninformed or you are playing others’ ignorance for your own ego. let’s see… who else has stood up? let’s start with big names like chico mendez or ken saro-wiwa. they got cut down for standing up. oh—that’s not in the u.s.? ok—david “gypsy” chain—mudered by a pacific lumber logger during the fight for california’s north coast old growth redwoods and doug firs. karen silkwood—murdered; too heavy? here are a list of folks who have stood up over and over and some are on their second stint in the cage for fighting back: rod coronado, judi berri, marie mason, eric mcdavid, jonathan paul, daniel mcgowan, brianna waters, the shac 7, i could go on.
i respect you for your action. but keep things in perspective, and give some credence to so many have gone down a lot harder than you will should they bring charges.
mikerobe
Report thisBy Jason Joyce, December 26, 2008 at 6:35 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)
...This is Rosa Parks on the bus…It is the whistle blowers, on Abu Ghraib, and warentless wiretaps, and water-boarding…it is the Zapatista in southern mexico…. people standing up for what is right, especially with the courage to go at it alone.
Report this“...a revolutionary is inspired by great feelings of love.” -Che
By teach4corners, December 26, 2008 at 5:21 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)
Fantastic move Tim DeChristopher. I was truly touched by your interview with Amy Goodman and thank you so much for saving some of the BLM land up for auction. I haven’t been able to figure out, though, what land has actually been sold (and, indirectly, lost in a way)? If there were 150,000 acres bought, where are the other acres located? I am also curious about whether any of these companies will sell back the land because they think they paid too much for it after DeChristopher’s bids boosted up the price. And my last question for now: have these companies made any statements on how they will manage the land they acquired? If anyone knows how to dig up the answers to these questions, I’d appreciate the help! The fruits of my online research have been quite meager.
Report thisBy Stephen, December 26, 2008 at 12:20 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)
The economics are ridiculous and Tim DeChristopher was a genius to figure this out. Tim DeChristopher’s bids amount to one nickel from every person in America. Put another way, it is about $1 from each in the upper income quintile. If corporations hadn’t bid, the cost would have been even less. More of this behavior would send the message that the American public really does love their country. The price is small compared to the benefits.
Report thisBy Invisigoth, December 26, 2008 at 12:10 pm #
If only there were more people like Tim DeChristopher. Evil prevails when good men do nothing. Tim has shown what can happen when people intervene creatively in the midst of corrupt government deregulation practices. I truly admire him for what he did.
Report thisBy big k 007, December 26, 2008 at 11:02 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
just in time for christmas timmy. lets hope this christmas carol don’t get you killed by some agent. watch your back jack and start rallying up that cash you’ll need for your first payment. its a good idea. maybe next time they try to auction off america’s natural capital more of its patriots will stand up and defend democracy instead of this con-facist approach that big business is readily aquiring. good luck boy. your in the big leagues now. time for some corporate sponsorship and maybe some celebs for a photoshoot out in the desert. let the stormtroopers quiver in the thought of thousands of patriots lining up to do what you’ve just done. smart cookie now make sure you get that first payment paid capitalist style. time for some of those eco-friendly millionares to start putting their money where their mouth is. maybe a foundation should be set up to counter this oil and gas grab. let the private sector save america from its own neo-con evil twin. where’s those brainwashed believers to step in and save america from the evil multinationals? i’m sure the tithe can be collected every other sunday and timmy would have enough for more bids. timmy took a leap of faith and this canadian salutes you.
Report thisBy oldog, December 26, 2008 at 9:18 am #
Thanks Tim, for your courage and bold effort to stop the rape of the Arches and Canyonlands National Parks and Dinosaur National Monument areas. I have enjoyed climbing, hiking, and just driving through that peaceful, unspoiled area.
Let’s see…there is at least 100 million people in the US that truly care about protecting our natural resources…we can probably reach 100,000 in time to make a difference…plus a decent pool to support Tim’s time and trouble, maintenance, and future auctions…that’s about $50 bucks a piece…a small price to ensure our children’s inheritance.
Tim, are you willing to hold a national treasure in trust for the future? I’m willing to put my money where my heart is.
Where do I send the check?
Report thisBy betty, December 26, 2008 at 2:05 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
what happens if everyone who wants to save the environment pitches in for the money to pay for this land to be purchased. He took a step to throw in the monkey wrench what if we make it so they can’t take it out..
Report thisBy Paul, December 26, 2008 at 1:32 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
Now come the donations and help from organizations like the Land Stewardship Project. Keep the public lands public!
Report thisBy WildMountain, December 25, 2008 at 2:39 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)
My hat goes off to DeChristopher and I extend him a warm, heart felt bow and rebellious smile. The beauty of this action only shows that the American West has not yet been numbed to the capitalist ways of much of the rest of this country. The time has come for humans of all walks to come together in the name of something larger than ourselves…in the name of the environment, our home, and the only one we have. If they will not listen to our voices, our pleas, and our lawsuits then surely direct action is the next step. The environmental crisis calls out for a multifaceted approach to defense. We CANNOT let these lands fall to the hands of a few greedy men and women and the destructive hands of the corporate hacks that threaten a livable world.
NO COMPROMISE, EARTH FIRST!
Report thisBy Margaret Currey, December 24, 2008 at 7:49 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)
Right on Mr. DeChristopher.
I remember when Kerry said Bush owned a forest and he said “me own a forest”, come to find out he had mineral rights under the forest these crooks will lie and steal as long as no one is looking.
To say that we need a smaller government is code word for so we can steal more, case in point Wall Street.
Smaller government is called a dictatorship.
Report thisBy martin weiss, December 24, 2008 at 6:09 pm #
and I do, too.
Report thisSee? No violence. The bad guys love when we get violent or destructive. Then they can justify their Nazi measures.
This was brilliant and courageous, or, as Obama would say, audacious.
Inspiring. Imagine how many wild animals will live because of Tim’s brave action.
This is the beginning of the end of the Bush/Oil rape of America.
By yellowbird2525, December 24, 2008 at 3:31 pm #
When Obama was speaking of change one of the senators snarled WE will decide what change to make (watching C span); Still under the “mistaken” mindset that this is a “democracry”???? during the DNC I watched the “rebuild & restruction” America being carried out at county level: what was SAID was it flows from Fed, to St, to county, to city: they wrote water laws so no one can even drink from their own well; they are agressively attacking all fresh water supply in the same manner; Coal mountain is but one; mining in watersheds, putting businesses up over them; (Americans will need to get a “new mindset”; while what they have to say is ok THIS is the way it will BE. Plans were made that all trees, lands, etc will be cut down & condos etc set up on all. They have ignored (not just Bush) almost all environmental laws, 3000 species of frogs are gone & far more. They have no intention of preserving anything & never have.
Report thisBy kloe, December 24, 2008 at 11:59 am #
At the suggestion of Clash I just wrote http://change.gov/ urging them to make this a priority as soon as they are in office. I will also make a donation to Tim’s defense fund. On the web site, http://www.wateradvocacy.org it doesn’t report how much has been collected so far. Am I missing it somewhere on the web page? Can we get this site to post the numbers?
Report thisBy holly, December 24, 2008 at 11:37 am #
you can donate to tim’s legal defense and/or his lease purchase fund here:
http://www.wateradvocacy.org
Report thisBy Clash, December 24, 2008 at 5:27 am #
I agree cann4ing with your entire post, and we should at the very least contact
Report thishttp://change.gov/, immediately on his behalf.
By Denis Moynihan, December 24, 2008 at 4:12 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
DeChristopher pointed us to
http://oneutah.org/
where there are several links to
http://www.wateradvocacy.org/id86.html
or, they say,
“If you don’t want to use a credit card, please send checks made out to “Center for Water Advocacy”. Please include “Tim DeChristopher Lease Purchase Fund” in the memo field. Mail checks to Center for Water Advocacy, P.O. Box 331, Moab, UT 84532.”
Report thisBy KDelphi, December 24, 2008 at 1:04 am #
DeChristopher is a hero! Does anyone have a site where we can contact him? Is he raising money for teh $45,000?
We should , at least, be allowed to thank him. I can see that encouraging everyone to sign the petition at ProPublica did no good…despite how many places I saw it posted.
Report thisBy cann4ing, December 24, 2008 at 12:56 am #
Perhaps one of President Obama’s first actions, in addition to reversing every Bush regime assault on the environment in sight, should be to pardon Mr. DeChristopher, who deserves praise, not prosecution for this brilliant episode of peaceful, non-violent civil disobedience.
Report this