LOGO: Truthdig: Drilling Beneath the Headlines. A Progressive Journal of News and Opinion. Editor, Robert Scheer. Publisher, Zuade Kaufman.Best Political Blog Winner, 2007 Webby Awards, People's Voice and Jury.   Gore Vidal and Mr. Fish - Exclusive Truthdig Gifts for the Holidays
 
November 21, 2008
Log in / Register

 Choose a size
Text Size

Most Read

Bracing for a Major Disappointment

A View From the South

Change We Can Bank On

Paulson and Bernanke Grilled on the Bailout

Lieberman: ‘Reconciliation, Not Retribution’

Most Comments
Most Emailed

Reports
 * NEW! * To Each His Own Nuke

Ear to the Ground

A/V Booth

Arts & Culture

Digs
Financial Meltdown 101
Vetting Sarah Palin

Truthdig Bazaar more items

 
Reports

The Party Police

Email this item Email    Print this item Print   
Posted on Sep 10, 2008

By Amy Goodman

The Democratic and Republican national conventions have passed, but controversy surrounds how they were funded and how they were run. Mass arrests of peaceful protesters, excessive police violence, wholesale disregard for the Bill of Rights and the targeting and arrest of journalists marred what should have been celebrations of democracy. The “host committees,” the legal entities that organize and pay for the conventions, act as large party slush funds, outside of campaign-finance restrictions. Scores of major corporations (and a couple of unions), barred from giving unlimited funds to political parties, could give whatever they wanted to the host committees of Denver and St. Paul, Minn.

According to a recent article in National Underwriter magazine, “Both the Republican National Committee and Democratic National Committee refused to comment on their insurance purchasing decisions, or even reveal who was providing coverage for their respective conventions.” Bruce Nestor, president of the Minnesota chapter of the National Lawyers Guild, who organized scores of legal observers around the Twin Cities to protect citizens’ legal rights, told me: “St. Paul actually negotiated a special insurance provision with the Republican host committee so that the first $10 million in liability for lawsuits arising from the convention will be covered by the host committee. The city is very proud of this negotiation. It’s the first time it’s been negotiated between a city and the host committee. But it basically means we [the city] can commit wrongdoing, and we won’t have to pay for it.” According to the Minnesota Independent, more than 40 journalists were arrested or detained during the Republican National Convention.

Like what happened to “Democracy Now!” producer Nicole Salazar, videotaping protests in downtown St. Paul. She was violently forced to the ground, her nose bloodied, was held down with a man’s knee or boot on her back, with another person pulling on her leg. Fellow producer Sharif Abdel Kouddous was thrown against a wall and kicked in the chest and back. The police might normally intervene and arrest the perpetrators. Except here, it was the police who were the assailants. And they arrested their victims. Arriving on the scene, I tried to have my colleagues freed, as we were all accredited journalists, and the police arrested me. And we were not the only ones.

As the mayors and police of St. Paul and Minneapolis patted each other on the back for a job well done, the nonprofit group FreePress, the head of the local chapter of the Newspaper Guild and other media advocates and reporters delivered more than 50,000 signatures to the mayor’s office demanding that the charges against the journalists be dropped. We were met by St. Paul Deputy Mayor Ann Mulholland. Free Speech TV CEO Denis Moynihan asked about the Republican host committee indemnification of the city, “Isn’t that just giving a $10 million ticket to the police to violate civil rights?” Mulholland countered, “We are very proud of that ... the $10 million was critical for our city. We would not have been able to host the convention otherwise.”

The two major-party conventions have become protracted, expensive advertising spectacles for the presidential candidates. It makes sense that Democrats and Republicans would want to control the message. But democracy is not an advertisement, nor is it under the sole dominion of the two parties. People were engaged in Denver and St. Paul in a vast array of civic dialogue, public gatherings, marches, protests, concerts, art openings—in fact, there was more democracy happening outside the convention halls than inside them. The convention center names tell the story: It was the Pepsi Center in Denver, the Xcel Energy Center in St. Paul. Xcel, which pushes nuclear power, gave $1 million to each convention. Both top candidates support nuclear power as a viable option.

In Denver, but particularly in St. Paul, dissent was crushed with a massive array of paramilitarized police, operating under the U.S. Secret Service, granted jurisdiction over the “National Special Security Events” that the conventions have been dubbed. Corporations pay millions to the host committees, earning exclusive access to lawmakers and candidates. The host committees, in turn, unleash police on the public, all but guaranteeing injuries, unlawful arrests and expensive civil litigation for years to come. More than just a campaign-finance loophole that must be closed, this is a national disgrace.

Throughout the convention week, one of the 25 remaining typeset copies of the Declaration of Independence was on display at St. Paul City Hall—not far from where crowds were pepper-sprayed, clubbed, tear-gassed and attacked by police with concussion grenades. As the clouds clear, it is instructive to remember the words of one of the Declaration’s signers, Benjamin Franklin:

“They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.”

Amy Goodman is the host of “Democracy Now!,” a daily international TV/radio news hour airing on more than 700 stations in North America.

© 2008 Amy Goodman

Distributed by King Features Syndicate

Email Newsletter

Get truth delivered to your inbox every week.

Previous item: She's Clueless, He's Worse

Next item: Stop Exploiting 9/11

Jump to Comments

Advertisement


Elsewhere: .

Comments

Are you a Truthdig member yet? Login now, or register with Truthdig.

By Pravda7, September 15 at 5:11 pm #

Amy,

First of all, I’d like to sincerely thank you for your hard work.  Sadly, I have to admit that even though I am at the age when people are usually very idealistic about life, I am very skeptical towards the notion of democracy and free press in this country. Even at our universities, students are silenced and prevented from speaking out. I had experienced this when starting a GSA (Gay-Straight Alliance) at a private university in the Chicago land area that prides itself in embracing diversity. Also, most of the editors of the official on-campus newspaper were recently forced to resign for reporting on matters that the university prefers not to talk about.

I am writing this because it provides for such a good big picture analogy. We can have our school newspaper for as long as the journalists don’t snoop around and report only positive news about the university. The students who cross this line are forced to resign and serve as a warning to the newcomers. We can have a GSA on campus for as long as we do not host events outside, attract attention or demand rights in which case the status of the organization would be terminated. All of this is done to paint a beautiful, bright picture of a modern university embracing justice, diversity and association that will open the hearts and wallets of potential students and donors.

Another aspect of this situation is that journalism students who follow the rules and don’t risk their internships by reporting the truth are rewarded, while the Amy Goodmans of our university are taught to keep quiet. If this is how reporters are trained since the very beginning of their career, are you really surprised so many of them stayed inside of the RNC building?

Report this

By Pravda, September 15 at 4:49 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)

Amy,
First of all, I’d like to sincerely thank you for your hard work.  Sadly, I have to admit that even though I am at the age when people are usually very idealistic about life, I am very skeptical towards the notion of democracy and free press in this country. Even at our universities, students are silenced and prevented from speaking out. I had experienced this when starting a GSA (Gay-Straight Alliance) at a private university in the Chicago land area that prides itself in embracing diversity. Also, most of the editors of the official on-campus newspaper were recently forced to resign for reporting on matters that the university prefers not to talk about.
I am writing this because it provides for such a good analogy to the recent events. We can have our school newspaper for as long as the journalists don’t snoop around and report only positive news about the university. The students who cross this line are forced to resign and serve as a warning to the newcomers. We can have a GSA on campus for as long as we do not host events outside, attract attention or demand rights in which case the status of the organization would be terminated. All of this is done to paint a beautiful, bright picture of a modern university embracing justice, diversity and association that will open the hearts and wallets of potential students and donors.
Another aspect of this situation is that journalism students who follow the rules and don’t risk their internships by reporting the truth are rewarded, while the Amy Goodmans of our university are taught to keep quiet. If this is how reporters are trained since the very beginning of their career, are you really surprised so many of them stayed inside of the RNC building?

Report this

By Folktruther, September 14 at 11:12 am #

Well, James and KDelphi, the tendency is to blame the people for their own oppression.  It is true that the American population tends to be corrupt, brutal and selfish, but this occurrs because oppression oppresses, and inculcates brutality, selfishiness and corruption to rule.

The major historical problem is power not the people ruled by power. There HAS been a political change in the last eight years, with a coup d’etat followed by the 9/11-anthrax false flag homicide.  It is true that this transformation to a Democratic police state is rooted in the American past, in our racism, selfish inidividualism, and obsolete political institutions.  But the neocons-neolibs are a new phenomena and it is apparent now that Obama-Biden are to continue to take us down that road.

Report this

By KDelphi, September 14 at 8:11 am #

James--excellent points and well thought out post! Thanks

Report this

By James, September 13 at 3:21 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)

The roots of corperate facisiam,police brutality and coruption lie not within any recent cultural development,nor social change but rather within the very moral fabric of America and sadly many Americans.Untill Americans place the blame for the emerging police state where it belongs’’on ourselves and our core values’’we will continue upon our path to corperate tyranny.

Our love of money,power and raw ability has led us to the alter of corperate rule.Remember the plight of the American Indian ? Remember the doctrine of Manifest destiny?

The first Americans believed in the organic truth that the earth was to be shared by all its inhabitants,not treated as a commodity to be bought ,sold,plundered for monetary profit.In our heart of hearts we know this to be true but yet we treat the land as if we were the creators,the earth the private domain of only those with legal title to land,as if those titles somehow were products of nature,grown perhaps from the trees.When the earth can be owned by a few’’as it is now’’it stands to reason that the many who inhabit the earth will be at the mercy of the few.
True freedom and equality can only be realized when we as Americans understand that we do not own,’’nor should we own’’the earth,nature or the products of nature.

Report this

By Independent Utahn, September 13 at 10:48 am #
(Unregistered commenter)

Bob Evans, the anchorman of the local Fox Network television affiliate, KSTU, clearly sided with the police in St. Paul as he narrated the video that rolled of protesters being abused.

I and others have had our ability to add perspective to news accounts by commenting on news stories have had our accounts disabled at the web site of the Salt Lake Tribune, owned by MediaNews (CEO William Dean Singleton has contributed significantly to candidates from both incumbent political parties), when we question the prevailing orthodoxy.

The local PBS and NPR affiliates will not interview candidates unless they are Republican or Democratic.

The truth is out there, but you must seek it ... and wade through the smoke generated by those actively trying to hide the truth from you.

Report this

By Levon, September 12 at 6:23 am #
(Unregistered commenter)

then don’t buy anything you don’t absolutely need and when you do try to buy from non-corporate sources. for instance, banking, belong to a credit union. food, buy from local non-corporate producers, clothing - go to a thrift shop, naturally some things can’t be avoided but minimizing the use of corporate brands will hit them where they feel it.

Report this

By J Snow, September 11 at 1:39 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)

Amy,

I’m thoroughly disgusted with the Republican and Democratic Parties.  The cheap prostitution of Party bosses to the Business Rountable bear no resemblance to the democratic process.

Personally I call for the criminal prosecution and public hanging by the neck of George W Bush and Dick Cheney for their complicit involvement in the 9/11 attacks and subsequent illegal wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.

9/11 need not have happened and many a victim of 9/11 would like justice served by holding the usurpers of the 2000 election process be held accountable. 

Sincerely,

J Snow

Report this

By KDelphi, September 11 at 10:49 am #

Yes, Dr. Blackmoore--lets hit them in the ONLY place it seems to hurt theses guys--$$$$$! Bush has said (and his ex-attornies concur) that his “biggest fear” was not being impeached or found guilty of war crimes, but, BEING SUED! (projectile vomit here)So,lets go!!

vot--not disagreeing here--far be it from me to stick up for the Chinese govt (govt does not= the people, folks). But, lets not forget “four dead in Ohio”.

Report this

By Dr Rich Blackmoor, September 11 at 10:16 am #
(Unregistered commenter)

If enough people sue and can ring up a few hundred million in damages it will help.
The fact that the Corporate media ignored this attack on our Freedom and how the Constitution is just as Bush and the republican’s define it.."just a goddamn piece of paper’.
Amy Goodman is an American Hero,patriot and all around excellent person.  So are all those who make Democracy Now possible and anyone who was in St Paul to protest.

Report this

By voice of truth, September 11 at 9:06 am #

“BTW, after a week of protests in Beijing without police crackdown, if the brave guy who stood in front of the tanks when they did finally move were to have done this in St. Paul, he would have been gassed and beat immediately.”

FYI, this guy was later executed by the Chinese Government.  I’m not sure they did that in Denver or St. Paul.

Both cities had the same types of demonstrations and both police forces reacted in the same ways.  I am not sure why there was not as much reporting about it in media regarding Denver.  Maybe because Denver set up ridiculous “protest zones” that were miles away from anything.

And one very important fact left out of this discussion so far:  While corps did/do contribute to both parties, the vast majority of the funding for these two conventions (and only these) came from taxpayer funds.

Report this

By motherearthnews, September 11 at 7:10 am #

Once again Amy Goodman tells it like it is. She could of gone further, but space is limited. Her and the rest of the staff at Democracy Now do a grest service to the public. If the rest of the media did their job like this, Americans would not be so horribly ignorant, but in a facist state, the corporate media and the government are part of the same club, so that will stay as is.
The independent media is growing in this country however, so we still have hope that democracy can be restored, but it’s going to take some time and effort to engage the general public to the point that they take their duty to be informed seriously. How much time? I wish I knew.

Report this

By KISS, September 11 at 6:15 am #

I really don’t know what when in Denver do to a lack of reporting. I do know what went on in St. Paul and it is disgusting as well as scary. I am old enough to remember the dimmo convention in Chicago in 1968.
Now laws have been changed to allow lawlessness to perfectly law-abiding. 1/2 mile away from the protesting the president....unbelievable. Fencing a mile away to keep protesters from being heard at the convention...again unbelievable, only in Amerika.
The good news is the big media newspapers are going down, let us hope TV news goes away soon.
Thanks Amy and my best wishes for you and the other heros of news reporting..

Report this

By troublesum, September 11 at 3:59 am #

There was no comparison between what happened in Denver and St Paul.  The national media outlets like democracynow are playing by rules established by the corporate media, but if you look at reporting done by smaller, localized media there really was no comparison between what happened at the two conventions.

Report this

By Folktruther, September 10 at 8:14 pm #

But troublesum, the corporations paid for both conventions, they contributed money to both parties, the insurance was to both cities, the cops attacked demonstrations at both conventions (more so at the Gop convention) and, although the rhetoric differs, both parties support similar policies in practice.

Goodman here is just telling the simple truth.

Report this

By Jerry, September 10 at 7:53 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)

This was a well written article and I completely agree with Mayponce’s comment.  I must say that I wrote the Mayor’s office in Denver about the police abuse of the Code Pink lady and received a personal response immediately from their communications director promising that there was an internal investigation underway and if malfeasance were to be found that it would be dealt with appropriately.

When I contacted the St. Paul Mayor’s office concerning gross misconduct, I received nothing.  I observed press conferences from St. Paul’s Mayor, Police and Ramsey County Sheriff and found them to claim ignorance of journalist arrests and completely self-righteous and deflective in their actions.  It reminded me of Soviet Union style propaganda.  Even the Chinese were better during the Tienanmen Square protests.  BTW, after a week of protests in Beijing without police crackdown, if the brave guy who stood in front of the tanks when they did finally move were to have done this in St. Paul, he would have been gassed and beat immediately.  I’m not saying that China is anyway, shape or form better, but think about the hypocrisy here.

I observed protests in Washington, D.C. and with over 100,000 people demonstrating between the White House and the Capitol with a small group of Capitol Police and they react nothing like the police in St. Paul.  They are friendly and only take action when there is a violent person or direct conflict.

I guess that is what happens when you give them 50 million dollars for security and they are not trained nor do they understand basic rights in America.  It is like giving whiskey and car keys to junior high students.

I grew up, went to high school and college in Minnesota and I am more than embarrassed, I am ashamed.  The Cities (Mpls/St. Paul) let themselves become a Police State and it was a disgusting display.

Here is what the Denver Mayors Office wrote in response.  I don’t know what will ultimately happen, but at least they were decent and did not become excuse-makers for out of control peace officers.

--------------------------------------
On behalf of Mayor Hickenlooper, thank you for taking the time to write. Please be aware that we take allegations of excessive force very seriously and will investigate fully and that the Internal Affairs Division of the Denver Police Department, and the City’s Independent Monitor are both looking into the incident.  As soon as we know the facts, we’ll provide more information.

Thanks again for sharing your concerns.

Regards,

Sue Cobb
Communications Director
Office of Mayor John Hickenlooper
City and County of Denver”

Report this

By knute, September 10 at 5:53 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)

I’m amazed at the lack of total outrage at what went on in Saint Paul. It could’ve been choreographed out of an G. Orwell story written generations ago. To think that journalists and cameramen could be attacked and dragged off by our own police for the crime of reporting the events at hand should scare the living crap outa any american who still has even a dim grasp of what this country was supposed to be about. There are so precious few journalists out there today with the courage of Amy Goodman, there is so little oppurtunity to get the truth out when our media is controlled by a relatively few republicans in the end. When we have a head of the FCC that favors monopolies instead of diversity. I remember a shock and outrage when the news came out after the national guard opened fire on students at Kent State. Where was the coverage of this republican convention on the streets in 2008 ? The Bush family dynasty will go down in history with one lasting legacy. They brought facism to power in america.

Report this

By kath cantarella, September 10 at 5:39 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)

There’s footage on youtube of confrontations between police and a couple of protesters at the DNC. It’s milder than the RNC, but still… the basic principle is rotten.

Report this

By kath cantarella, September 10 at 5:14 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)

Were people arrested in Denver too? Surely not. Jesus, i hope not.

Report this

By troublesum, September 10 at 4:29 pm #

She mentioned both sides because the rules laid down by the corporate media say that you can’t criticise republicans without criticising democrats as well even if their is no comparison in culpability.  Good journalism is about telling the truth not playing tit for tat.

Report this

By Mayponce, September 10 at 4:18 pm #

She mentioned both conventions because she’s a good journalist.

Just because she and her colleagues weren’t personally arrested in Denver doesn’t mean that others weren’t. In fact the abuses in Denver are well documented.

The Democrats are just as guilty as the Republicans in this regard. I haven’t even heard of any Democratic officials condemning any of these abuses.

The Democrats are not only complicate as usual but active participants in these crimes.

Report this

By troublesum, September 10 at 4:13 pm #

Even the annual World Social Forum is run by corporations now.  They rule the world.  In time even democracynow! will be taking financial support from corporations if you are not already doing so.  They rule the world.  They buy and sell anything and anybody.

Report this

By troublesum, September 10 at 4:05 pm #

Don’t equate the two conventions, Amy Goodman.  You were arrested in St Paul, not in Denver.  Were any of your reporters bloodied up in Denver?

Report this

By KDelphi, September 10 at 3:43 pm #

Thanks you for everything you do, Amy. You have plenty of support out here!

Report this

By KDelphi, September 10 at 3:42 pm #

Thanks you for everything you do, Amy. You have plenty of support out here.

Report this

Add Your Comment

Posts by unregistered readers are moderated. Posts by members
are published immediately. Why wait? Register today!






Notify you when others comment on this article?


Are you a human?
Retype the word you see here.


Please read and abide by our comment policy.
By submitting this comment, you agree to this site's terms and conditions.

Newsletter

Get Truthdig in your inbox

Privacy Policy

 
Click here to advertise with Truthdig
 

 
Join the Liberal Blog Advertising Network
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A Progressive Journal of News and Opinion. Editor, Robert Scheer. Publisher, Zuade Kaufman.
Copyright © 2008 Truthdig, L.L.C. All rights reserved.