![]() ![]() |
|
| |
|
Baghdad’s Other Power StrugglePosted on May 11, 2008
By Anna Badkhen BAGHDAD—By the time American soldiers walked into Hadi al-Farji’s darkened home, a half-dozen people had complained to U.S. Army Lt. Rusty Mason about the lack of infrastructure in their neighborhood. Now Farji was going at it as well. “The power supply is really bad,” said Farji, a judge who loves old Arabic poetry. “We barely get any power from the city, and the power we have from the generator is not enough to make even one refrigerator work. “When the British colonized Iraq they built something—power lines, a railroad. What did the Americans build?” the judge persisted. “When Americans came here we hoped it would get better. But it’s been five years and we are still struggling.” Mason, who arrived in Baghdad’s upscale Saidiyah neighborhood last fall, when streets here were ravaged by sectarian violence and abandoned by most of its residents, could barely contain his frustration. “In Saidiyah, it’s easy to focus on the power because for the average person Saidiyah is safe. But there are parts of other neighborhoods that don’t have paved roads, let alone power,” said Mason, a platoon leader in Alpha Company of the 4-64 armor battalion of the Fourth Brigade, Third Infantry Division. The company has surrounded the neighborhood with a 12-foot concrete wall and set up checkpoints, effectively putting an end to the sectarian violence that raged here. “It seems that they don’t see all the things we do for them,” he said. That Saidiyah residents can complain about power, Mason said, is a measure of success and “a sign of things being good in the community,” whereas less than a year ago Sunni and Shiite militias showered each other with submachine-gun fire and dead bodies sometimes lay unclaimed in the rubble-strewn streets for days. But on the other hand, Mason acknowledged, the lack of basic services in this neighborhood exemplified how little has changed for the better since American troops invaded Iraq in 2003. “It’s frustrating for me because I don’t really see much improvement as far as power goes since we’ve been here,” he said. In fact, basic services all over Baghdad have improved little, if at all, in the last two years. In 2006, Baghdad’s neighborhoods got power four hours a day—one hour on, six hours off. Many blocks have purchased generators to augment their electricity supply. Today, some parts of Saidiyah get power four hours a day, according to Lt. Col. Johnnie Johnson, the 4-64 battalion commander, but Farji’s street had not received any electricity through the city’s power supply in the last two weeks. Residents there rely entirely on privately owned generators, which transmit power on no particular schedule two or three hours a day and charge about $12 per ampere. A typical family, with an average monthly income of about $400 a month, spends about $65 each month on electricity. “Yesterday was a good day: The power came on for two hours in the afternoon, then for an hour in the evening, and for 15 minutes at 4 a.m.,” said Basem as-Zuwaidi, a chemical engineer who works for the Ministry of Industry. “Sometimes we only get one hour of power.” The water supply is equally inconsistent. Baghdad residents use electric pumps to draw water from the city supply. In some areas on Baghdad’s outskirts people have no running water at all, Johnson said. Trash pickup, which stopped shortly after the war began, is irregular or nonexistent, and varies from one neighborhood to the next. In Saidiyah, garbage collection is more or less steady, but still not robust enough to remove discarded soda cans, rotting food, empty paint containers, plastic bags and scraps of paper and cardboard that line some streets. A block away from Judge Farji’s house, a car mangled by a roadside bomb sits on the curb, an unintentional monument to the neighborhood’s violent past. In other parts of the city, where no one regularly collects the trash, people are using the yards and rooftops of their neighbors’ abandoned houses as impromptu landfills. Plastic bags get stuck in sewage pipes, clogging them and causing waste to spill into city streets in putrid pools of green. In some parts of the city, the pools have been stagnant for years. Johnson accuses Sunni and Shiite militias, which target garbage collectors because they work for the Iraqi government, of sabotaging trash pickup. “If you have contractors hired to clean the road, and if they are threatened to not come back here, it’s hard for us to get someone to come back to work,” said Johnson. Saidiyah residents acknowledge that, compared to the devastation that sectarian warfare wrought here a year ago, the neighborhood has improved significantly, even though occasional gunshots still puncture the air at night. But they are impatient to see improvements in their lifestyle and miss the relative luxury of prewar times, when the area got power and water almost round the clock. They see the current Iraqi government as largely powerless to improve their lives, and complain about contractors who are corrupt or incompetent. Last week, for example, a contractor hired to upgrade decrepit power lines in one section of Saidiyah started digging for cables and punctured the pipe supplying water to the area, said Ali al-Ameri, the chairman of the Saidiyah neighborhood council, which has been trying to improve life and infrastructure in the area for months. “I think fixing these problems is very simple,” said Faras al-Qabi, the secretary of the council. “All you need to do is to give money to contractors who won’t steal. To tell you the truth, many of them do [steal],” he said. “Not all of them, but many of them.” Johnson, who attends most of the neighborhood council’s meetings, said he is used to hearing Iraqis complain about poor infrastructure, and considers it a sign of their trust in what they see as the Americans’ ability to make things work. “Because the government has been not as effective as it should be, we represent progress,” Johnson said. “If they want something done quickly, they ask us. Unfortunately, the power supply is not up to me. The entire country is like this, and the Iraqi government has to fix it.” Anna Badkhen has returned to Iraq for the 10th time since 2003. She has covered wars in Iraq, Afghanistan, Somalia, Israel and the Palestinian territories, Chechnya and Kashmir. Her previous trip to Iraq was in 2006. Read more in her Baghdad journal on The Muckraker. Previous item: The Defining Moment for Climate Change Next item: Render Unto Darwin That Which Is Darwin's Elsewhere: . CommentsAre you a Truthdig member yet? Login now, or register with Truthdig. Add Your Comment |
By conservative Yankee, May 16 at 12:31 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)
By Marshall, May 16 at 11:59 am #
By Conservative Yankee, May 13 at 10:57 am #
“So I’m going to assume that you’re a Libertarian, since it’s going to be difficult to argue that there’s anyone running now who stands for the kind of reform you seem to think we need.”
Libertarians are for “free” (read unrestricted) trade, I am for tariffs on drugs, food, and any item made by or for a US company which used to make that item here.
I also am in favor of single-payer universal health care. I believe it is in the country’s best interest to remove the cost of health care from business. How is an auto parts manufacturer in the United States going to compete world wide if other governments subsidize their auto-parts manufacturer by providing health care without additional cost to the employer?
I also reject the idea of a “national identity card” by the back-door method of blackmailing folks who need a driver’s license. If the government believes we need an identity card (so they can say, with a German accent, Your papers please") then let them declare for that. I want my license to be proof that some state believes I can operate a motor vehicle. I don’t need it to do anything else.
Where I really split with libertarian philosophy is in the area of employment. I believe the government should replace any and all welfare programs with an “employer of last resort” If a person can’t find a job anywhere else, they could go to local government who would “employ” them at minimum plus transportation. This would give the employee a reason to find something better, and the government a reason to make the local enviornment better for companies which hire unskilled workers.
labels are far too confining. this country’s government needs new ideas to get it back on track.... beating up Bush who will soon become irrelevant, arguing about impeachment, or returning to the (less than perfect) Clinton era is counterproductive.
Just my opinion… alternatives accepted for consideration.
Report thisBy Marshall, May 16 at 11:59 am #
By Conservative Yankee, May 13 at 10:57 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
So I’m going to assume that you’re a Libertarian, since it’s going to be difficult to argue that there’s anyone running now who stands for the kind of reform you seem to think we need.
Report thisBy Conservative Yankee, May 13 at 10:57 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
My “hatred of the United States?”
Hell Marshall I’ve lived all over this great land. From Maine To Florida, and from Phoenix to Seattle. I’ve lived in The Bronx, Brooklyn, and Westchester County. I’ve lived in The Big VA hospital in Millington New Jersey taking care of folks you probably wouldn’t sit next to on a subway. I’ve lived in the burnt-out old mill towns of Massachusetts after the government changed policies allowing companies to renege on their responsibilities and leave their former employees high&dry;without the pensions they paid for.
I worked in the Manchester (New Hampshire) State industrial school with children who did nothing more than skip school. Their biggest crime was being born to parents who really didn’t want children.
I’ve lived everywhere in this land, and done just about everything. (never mined coal...and surprisingly, I’ve never found one place where I couldn’t settle down and be quite happy.
No Marshall I love this country… It is its government I can’t stand. I know the “government” claims it is the country, but it is not!
Report thisBy Marshall, May 13 at 7:27 am #
Well you’ve confirmed my “self-loathing” appraisal with your Rev. Wright “we caused 9/11” comment. In your mind, the U.S. is pretty much responsible for everything bad that happens in the world, including to itself. In your own way, you’re as arrogant as the hyper-religious who believe God’s universe revolves around them and the “plan” it has for their lives. Yet you contradict your premise by claiming that most of the world’s people are simply concerned with their own, local situations.
Your scattered hatred of the U.S. is all over the place, as these types of arguments are given their complexity and contradictions.
Report thisBy heavyrunner, May 12 at 3:59 pm #
“In 2006, Baghdad’s neighborhoods got power four hours a day—one hour on, six hours off.”
Bad arithmetic. If they have four cycles a day, each one has to total 6 hours, i.e., 1 hour on 5 hours off.
1 + 5 = 6, 6 x 4 = 24
I was in Rawalpindi, Pakistan last summer and the power there went off every afternoon when it got hot and came back on in the evening when the Sun went down.
It is disgraceful that the U.S. has such criminal leadership. Let’s hope President Obama will do better.
Report thisBy DennisD, May 12 at 5:58 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
“In fact, basic services all over Baghdad have improved little, if at all, in the last two years.”
The complaint department at Bu$h Inc. isn’t taking any calls either. The phones are all disconnected.
Report thisBy Conservative Yankee, May 12 at 4:37 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
Marshall
“you should acknowledge that every group everywhere “owes” somebody an apology or reparations for something. Your portrayal of the U.S. as the world’s only guilty party is childish. In fact, there’s so much guilt residing in every part of the world and on the head of every nation and every national that resides therein, as to make the idea of guilt an unfunny joke. “
I acknowledge no such thing. I do not know “every group”.
I did not say anything which suggested, even remotely that the US was “the only guilty party” BUT it is the guilty party for which I (under our constitution) have responsibility.
And since you don’t know me I’ll forgive you your “self Loathing” comment. I do not “loath” the United States, its people, or most assuredly myself. My friends often use the word “narcissistic” when discussion my “good points”
...and if you truly believe that tripe about the evils elsewhere and how superior “we” are, you have obviously received a proper public school education. Governments may be better or worse than ours, but in my travels I’ve found most folk to be EXACTLY like US citizens in their concerns.. Most of them are just trying to support their families and get by.
AND our CURRENT economic system which we are intent in installing in every part of the world is genocidal, regressive, and unsustainable. At some point a better system must be explored where folks are not steamrollered just because they have resources but little money. That system creates anger, resentment, and 9/11’s.... I can say that because I live here..AND I’m not running for any office!
Report thisBy Marshall, May 11 at 11:40 pm #
You derive the wrong point from your own post. Instead, you should acknowledge that every group everywhere “owes” somebody an apology or reparations for something. Your portrayal of the U.S. as the world’s only guilty party is childish. In fact, there’s so much guilt residing in every part of the world and on the head of every nation and every national that resides therein, as to make the idea of guilt an unfunny joke. This is human nature we’re talking about, not American nature. Can you imagine the cacophony of meaningless apologies, let alone ridiculous transfers of capital that would result if each ethnic group, nation, tribe, populace, and religion began “making good” on all the sins of its ancestors throughout history? And “Uncle Sam” is a whole lot better than history’s finest genocidal maniac dictators, mongol hordes, suicide bombing religious militant wackos, assorted imperialist emperors, pillaging barbarians, and caliphate loving terrorists that roamed the world and still do. Just wait till one of today’s worst gets hold of a nuclear weapon. Then, I suppose, the U.S. will get what’s coming to it, in your mind. Which simply says more about your self-loathing than about anything else.
Report thisBy cyrena, May 11 at 9:54 pm #
Good points all CY. Thing is, there’s no point getting in line, with or without a number. Ain’t none of these paybacks gonna happen.
Seems like the best we can hope for is to just get ‘em to quit stealing from us and killing us all outright.
That alone is the task of the century, especially since all of their plans lead to an increase of what they’ve been doing for a couple of Centuries.
Report thisBy SamSnedegar, May 11 at 2:42 pm #
We didn’t occupy Iraq to fix the things we broke; we are there for oil and oil alone, not for democracy and good government and good water and electricity. When you speak of Iraq and do not mention oil, you are just nattering and muttering, and not telling the truth at all about it.
You don’t have to wear a hair shirt and ask forgiveness for out sins of coveting, lying, stealing, and murdering, just own up to our true and venal motivation for being there.
Report thisBy Conservative Yankee, May 11 at 12:18 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)
Mr. Stivers says the US owes the Iraqi people.
Well, maybe, but I wouldn’t hold my hand on my ass awaiting payment.
The US Owes the Native People in both the Americas restitution for genocide and theft.
The US owes the African people stolen from their land more than the 100+ years of lip-service.
We owe the people of Palau for the atomic tests of the 50’s
likewise the people who formerly lived on Bikini Atol.
We owe the Chinese an apology for meddling in their affairs from the late 1800’s to the start of WW II.
We owe the Vietnamese, The Chileans, The Palestinians, The Lebanese, the Iranians, The Philippineos. We owe everyone in Central America, not to mention certain segments of our own population, for economic policies which have marginalized them and their families.
My point?
If you are waiting for anything “owed” by Uncle deadbeat, grab a number and get in line.
Report thisBy Don Stivers, May 11 at 8:45 am #
The United States of America owes it to the Iraqi people to rebuild the infrastructure throughout Iraq. Period!!!!!
Report this