LOGO: Truthdig: Drilling Beneath the Headlines. A Progressive Journal of News and Opinion. Editor, Robert Scheer. Publisher, Zuade Kaufman.Best Political Blog Winner, 2007 Webby Awards, People's Voice and Jury.   Boots on the Ground by Dusk: My Tribute to Pat Tillman, By Mary Tillman with Narda Zacchino
 
July 24, 2008
Log in / Register

 Choose a size
Text Size

Reports
Obama on the Brink
No Easy Out for Obama

Ear to the Ground

A/V Booth

Arts & Culture

Digs
Inside the Data Mine

Truthdig Bazaar
The China Reader: The Reform Era (Vintage)

The China Reader: The Reform Era (Vintage)

By Orville Schell and David Shambaugh
$17.00

more items

 
Reports

Stay Classy, Mike Huckabee

Email this item Email    Print this item Print   
Posted on Jan 10, 2008

By David Sirota

“The uncool subject is class,” author Bell Hooks once wrote. “It’s the subject that makes us all tense.” What an understatement, considering the two leading “change” candidates in the latest presidential polls.

Barack Obama is contending for the Democratic nomination as a candidate who avoids focusing on economic class. He asks us to believe—nay, to “hope”—that the interests of Wall Streeters underwriting his campaign can somehow be “brought together” with the interests of workers harmed by corporate America’s wage, job and pension cutbacks.

By contrast, former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee is competing for the Republican nomination on a call for proletarian solidarity. Next to Democrat John Edwards, he is the “classiest” presidential candidate, explicitly deriding “plutocracy” and “the Club for Greed” that he correctly says runs Washington.

“There’s a great need in this country to elect someone who reminds [voters] of the guy they work with, not the guy who laid them off,” Huckabee thunders.

This is taboo territory. Though the Wall Street Journal reports that America has among the lowest class mobility in the industrialized world, the Establishment stifles discussion about class. Why? Because those controlling the debate—from television anchors to political donors to campaign consultants—are among the wealthiest members of what Huckabee calls “the ruling class.” They have an obvious self-interest in pretending class does not exist.

Not surprisingly, officialdom has reacted quite differently to the Obama and Huckabee phenomena.

The ruling class roundly praises Obama’s class-averse campaign. Even George Will, the columnist-spokesman for country club Republicanism, effused that Obama is “refreshingly cerebral.”

Will lambastes Huckabee as “an adolescent” for daring to “lament a shrinking middle class.” Such vitriol is commonplace, from the National Review calling the Republican candidate “deeply naive” to Time’s Joe Klein praying for a “monumental implosion” of Huckabee’s campaign.

To those with money and power, Huckabee is committing the worst sin. His class rhetoric puts his Christian religion’s altruistic, meek-shall-inherit-the-Earth tenets above Washington’s free market fundamentalism. And the cultural roots accompanying Huckabee’s cause are even more appalling to the limousine crowd. This Republican apostate is not an Ivy Leaguer putting on a wink-and-nod show. He’s a former Baptist minister from a low-income family who was never scrubbed by an elite brush—meaning he might actually believe in his class crusade.

This explains not just the difference in treatment of the Harvard-educated Obama and the Ouachita Baptist University-educated Huckabee, but an even more revealing hypocrisy involving President Bush.

Recall that the media portray Bush’s alliance with the religious right as proof of his convictions. Huckabee’s alliance with the same religious right is subtly cast as a sign of supposed ignorance. Bush’s rhetorical gaffes are often painted as endearing—evidence that despite his silver-spoon pedigree, he is the authentic “average American man” thinking “in a common-sense way,” as Republican commentator Peggy Noonan wrote. Huckabee? The Weekly Standard calls him “a village idiot” and a “rube,” while Noonan derides him for “populist manipulation.”

Bush, you see, was always an aristocrat underneath the “windshield cowboy” veneer. He is the son of a president, a Skull-and-Bones man—ruling class all the way.

Huckabee, on the other hand, is a real-life regular guy. He views religion as more than just a convenient political cudgel and truly did pull himself “up from the bootstraps”—and his class grievances are personal. The well-heeled narcissists in the media and political establishment are appalled. They see Huckabee as a country bumpkin getting uppity.

As UCLA professor Mark Kleiman wrote, “If you went to Harvard, it’s plain embarrassing to say you’re going to vote for someone as, well, unwashed, as Huckabee.”

Certainly, Obama’s underlying policy platform is good for working-class America—and better than Huckabee’s, which is led by a punishingly regressive tax proposal.

However, the campaigns’ rhetorical themes are critical to consider because they impact what will—and will not—be acceptable topics of political debate in the post-Bush era.

Personally, I want to believe Obama’s vision of America as a class-free utopia where change comes without rancor or division. But history shows that most positive change in America has been about class and conflict—whether it was the battle for basic labor laws or the fight for Social Security.

That’s why, whoever wins the primaries, the more class forces its way onto the presidential stage, the better.

In short, stay classy, Mike Huckabee.

David Sirota is the best-selling author of “Hostile Takeover” (Crown, 2006). He is a senior fellow at the Campaign for America’s Future and a board member of the Progressive States Network, both nonpartisan research organizations. His daily blog can be found at www.credoaction.com/sirota.

© 2008 Creators Syndicate Inc.

Email Newsletter

Get truth delivered to your inbox every week.

Previous item: Chauvinists Fly Under the Radar

Next item: A Vagueness in Obama's Message

Jump to Comments

Advertisement


Elsewhere: .

Comments

Are you a Truthdig member yet? Login now, or register with Truthdig.

By Kathryn, January 23 at 6:35 am #
(Unregistered commenter)

To understand the condition of the State of Massachusetts, please visit http://www.massresistance.org. Also google Boston’s Children’s Hospital Sex Change Clinic. We are in need of many, many prayers and support. God Bless!!!

God’s Children

God’s Children have lost their way
Jesus has very much too say
Will they listen
Those restless souls
Or will they go their own way
Loneliness, trouble and despair
They will meet at their will
But Jesus’ Will shall never fail
To come and Heal them
And bring them home

Report this

By John Borowski, January 16 at 4:13 am #
(Unregistered commenter)

If Huckabee loses out on the presidency I pray that the Roman Catholics will make him the pope as a consolation prize. (When my computer parses my writing, it says, no John you mean Chickadee)

Report this

By ender, January 14 at 11:26 am #

Great info.  BTW for anyone stupid enough to ever vote for a BUSH again in this lifetime, make sure to look at JEB: America’s next Bush.  He’s just as dirty as Shrub, but not as stupid.  A dangerous combination.

After reading this"Stay Classy” article, I went to Huckabee’s website and read his position statements.  He said all I need to know.

He is adamantly pro Israel. Probably more so than GWB.  He says he believes we are fightint the WOT in Iraq.  While he’s not your normal Repugnican on education, those first two positions show his ignorance of international affairs or his unqualified support of the Carlisle Group and mark him as just more of the same as George on the international front.

That said, he might actually do more for the average American than Hillary, and they are about the same on Iraq, Iran and AIPAC’s contributions list.

This is discusting already.  With Kucinich out, no candidate will even raise the real issues of the Constitionality or legality of this administrations actions, commit to ending US aggression, put and end to NAFTA and CAFTA or attempt to curb corporate control our gov’t.

When a rightwing nut Xtian preacher and con man looks like one of the best choices to an Atheist and Socialist like myself, American politics has reached a level of corruption and insanity that are beyond comprehension.

Report this

By dick, January 13 at 10:09 am #
(Unregistered commenter)

Huckabee is an ignorant,superstitious, dangerous religious fanatic.

Report this

By Robert Hutwohl, January 13 at 8:31 am #

Right on! This long-held belief of putting trust in God or a god (which has never been proven to exist from an anthropomorphic existence standpoint), has prolonged the inevitable: humans need to take responsibility for their thoughts, words and actions. George Bush and Dick Cheney and their other Neocon-cohorts don’t think they will have to suffer one bit for their actions of war on other nations. Just rob the tax-payers of their money and divert it to the War Machine and let the dominoes fall where they may!

Huckabee is just another believable moron in the realm of American politics, nurtured and materialized by superficial fundamentalist Christians, much in the way Paracelsus was able to create miniature beings in a flask or Erlenmeyer jar, all by certain processes of MANIFESTATION. Their imaginings of fulfillment have manifest a Huckabee, which will turn out to be a barren birth, in time.

Report this

By WmsStamps, January 12 at 9:01 pm #

Do yourself a favor and research John Edwards. Having done that, you may come to the same conclusion I did . Support John Edwards.

Report this

By RAE, January 12 at 3:43 pm #

“Huckabee’s alliance with the same religious right is subtly cast as a sign of supposed ignorance.”

SUPPOSED ignorance! As far I’m concerned ANYONE who allies him/herself with the “religious right” IS ignorant without any doubt in the world.

Elect Huckabee and you’ll elect another G.W.Bush - sleazy and smarmy and a hypocritical liar down to his bootstraps.

I wonder how many “fundamentalists” the American people will have to suffer under before they get it through their thick skulls that RELIGION & BELIEF IN AN AIRY-FAIRY, IMAGINARY “GOD” is a sign of MENTAL DEFICIENCY?

It’s profoundly scarey to understand that half the American population at this moment think that belief in “God” makes a candidate QUALIFIED to be President. Someday, this “belief” will DISQUALIFY anyone from positions of responsibility but that’s apparently a long way off.

Report this

By kath cantarella, January 11 at 8:58 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)

my blue-collar genes are not convinced: they say he don’t walk the walk.
The majority of the poorer classes are female. I’m sure the non-white races are over-represented there as well. It is pretty stupid to try and divorce classism from either racism or sexism, since they are significant determinants of who winds up where.

Report this

By fredhead08, January 11 at 6:51 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)

That’s why Fred Thompson’s flat tax is the way to go! check it out at fred08.com, under the issues page. It’s a common sense approach that can actually pass. Not knocking the fair tax, but it will never pass, and I would rather have tax reform in the next 4 - 8 years instead of none.

Report this

By KISS, January 11 at 6:29 pm #

David, how can you get it so wrong? I hope the air in DC hasn’t affected that fine brain of yours.

Report this

By Libgress, January 11 at 5:00 pm #

bell hooks doesn’t capitalize the letters of her nom de plume.

Report this

By Linda, January 11 at 1:08 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)

Huckabee appears “out to get Romney”. Is Huckabee afraid of losing to Romney?  Does he resent Romney as being the one true conservative of the candidates? From the start, I mistrusted Huckabee.  He appears to be a slick talker, maybe sleazy.  Some of his comments are downright dishonest.  When I read articles from Arkansas describing his past activities, it only reinforces some of my anxiety about him being my commander in chief. 

The leader of the Southern Baptist Convention and other evangelica leaders have endorsed Romney.  Why is it that Huckabee is able to “pull the wool over the eyes” of those that appear to be a cult following of his candidacy?

Report this

By robert bowen, January 11 at 10:08 am #
(Unregistered commenter)

I agree with the thrust of dustinchicago’s comments. I too like Huckabee’s populist bent though I do distrust the possibility of it being simple demagoguery. Class is the elephant in the middle of the room banned forever as suitable political discussion in America after emerging from WWII and the McCarthy era. Sales taxes- or comsumption taxes- penalize the poorest. Income taxes can target the more economically able to shoulder the burdens our civilization must ask of us all to bear to some degree.

Report this

By Gabir, January 11 at 9:32 am #

The dark side of Mike Huckabee

The national media seems to have a crush on our ex-governor, but here in Arkansas, we know better.

By Max Brantley (Salon.com) {Part One}

Nov. 13, 2007 | LITTLE ROCK, Ark.—The Pony Express has reached us here in the Arkansas backwoods with the latest journals from the big cities. So the country correspondents have taken a break from hand-setting lines of type to read the Beltway boys and girls rave about our former governor, Mike Huckabee.

“Easy to like,” wrote Newsweek’s Jonathan Alter. “Who Doesn’t Heart Huckabee?” said the headline over Gail Collins’ column in the New York Times. And those are restrained commentators. If you Google the names Ronald Reagan and Mike Huckabee in tandem, I understand you get better than 600,000 hits.

OK. I exaggerate. I have a phone and a computer (and it’s 208,000 hits). But you’d think from national press comments that our friendly state is unreachable by phone or Internet. Do national commentators do homework? Or is a smiling, shoe-shining parson all it takes to generate such fluff?

Come to Arkansas. You’ll have to look hard to find a long-term political analyst who’d subscribe fully to the national media narrative about the latest man from Hope—fresh face, funny, nice.

Mike Huckabee is fresh to you, maybe. Funny? If barnyard humor is your shtick of choice. Nice? Well, he did do some good things in his 10 years as governor, but ... read on.

Before we begin, though, a word of warning to any reporters who might want to repeat, on air or in print, any of the facts recounted below. Huckabee does not take kindly to journalists who practice journalism.

Report this

By Gabir, January 11 at 9:29 am #

The dark side of Mike Huckabee (Part Two)

The national media seems to have a crush on our ex-governor, but here in Arkansas, we know better.

By Max Brantley
Even editorialists and columnists at the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette, the state’s dominant (and Republican-friendly) daily paper, use words like “petty” and “thin-skinned” to describe Huckabee. Then again, he’s compared hard-hitting (and accurate) news reporters for the Democrat-Gazette to the press fabulists Jayson Blair and Janet Cooke. He called liberal columnist John Brummett of Stephens Media “constipated” when that early admirer commenced some gentle criticism. His administration paid $15,000 to settle a suit filed by Roby Brock, the host of a public TV news show whom Huckabee’s people tried to force off the air for his critical commentary.

Then there’s me. I’m the editor of an alternative weekly, but I began covering Huckabee when I was a columnist for the now-defunct daily Arkansas Gazette in 1991, and Mike and I have been on the outs pretty much ever since. He once called me and the Memphis Commercial Appeal bureau chief “junkyard journalists” for our reporting. He also compared me, in print, to serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer and, I’ve been told on good authority, has wished aloud for my early and violent demise.

It all began 16 years ago for Mike and me. Huckabee, in his political debut, was preparing to become the Bible-thumping, abortion-decrying Republican challenger to U.S. Sen. Dale Bumpers, the Democratic incumbent. With a playbook straight out of James Dobson, he tried to portray Bumpers as a pornographer for his support of federal grants to the arts.

More important, Huckabee revealed an enduring weakness as glaring as that other Arkansas governor’s fondness for women. Huckabee seems to love loot and has a dismissive attitude toward ethics, campaign finance rules and propriety in general. Since that first, failed campaign, the ethical questions have multiplied.

In the 1992 contest with Bumpers, Huckabee used campaign funds to pay himself as his own media consultant. Other payments went to the family babysitter.

In his successful 1994 run for lieutenant governor, he set up a nonprofit curtain known as Action America so he could give speeches for money without having to disclose the names of his benefactors. He failed to report that campaign travel payments were for the use of his own personal plane.

After he became governor in 1996, he raked in tens of thousands of dollars in gifts, including gifts from people he later appointed to prestigious state commissions.

In the governor’s office, his grasp never exceeded his reach. Furniture he’d received to doll up his office was carted out with him when he left, after he’d crushed computer hard drives so nobody could ever get a peek behind the curtain of the Huckabee administration.

Until my paper, the Arkansas Times, blew the whistle, he converted a governor’s mansion operating account into a personal expense account, claiming public money for a doghouse, dry-cleaning bills, panty hose and meals at Taco Bell. He tried to claim $70,000 in furnishings provided by a wealthy cotton grower for the private part of the residence as his own, until he learned ethics rules prevented it. When a disgruntled former employee disclosed memos revealing all this, the Huckabee camp shut her up by repeatedly suggesting she might be vulnerable to prosecution for theft because she’d shared documents generated by the state’s highest official.

Report this

By Gabir, January 11 at 9:20 am #

By Max Brantley(Salon.com) {Continued}

He ran the State Police airplane into the ground, many of the miles in pursuit of political ends. Inauguration funds were used to buy clothing for his wife. He once took control of the state Republican Party’s campaign account—then swore the account had been somebody else’s responsibility when it ran afoul of federal election laws. He repeated the pattern when he claimed in a newspaper story that his staff controlled the account to stage his second inauguration. When I filed a formal ethics complaint over what appeared to be an improper appropriation of donated money, he told a different story, disavowing responsibility for the money. He thus avoided another punishment from an Ethics Commission, which had sanctioned him on five other occasions. He dodged nine other complaints (though none, despite his counter-complaints, was held to be frivolous). In one case, he was saved by the swing vote of a woman who left the chairmanship of the Ethics Commission days later to take a state job. She listed the governor as a reference on the job application. Finally, unbelievably, Huckabee once sued to overturn the ban on gifts to him.

My newspaper chronicled all this and so much more. Since my paper wrote critically about him, I didn’t often experience the “nice” Mike Huckabee that so many national commentators have enjoyed. In fact, ultimately Huckabee ended press services, which are publicly financed, to my newspaper. The Arkansas Times received no news releases from the governor’s office, no notices of news conferences, no responses to routine questions. He was condemned for this by journalism organizations.

Truth is, we were happy to be thrown into the governor’s briar patch. The world is full of disaffected Huckabee campaign workers, former employees and garden-variety Republicans who love to pass on tips about a governor they’d found self-centered and untrustworthy. If you think he left a well of warm feelings in Arkansas, note that Hillary Clinton had raised more money in Arkansas at last report and that a recent University of Arkansas Poll showed her a 35 to 8 percent leader over Huckabee in the presidential preferences of Arkansas residents. Only one-third of 33 Republican legislators have said they will support him for president. 

Thanks to such unhappy people, we’ve broken numerous stories about Huckabee, from the first early word of his destruction of state computer hard drives (more fully reported by the Democrat-Gazette); to the time and place of his announcement for president; to his sale and purchase of homes; to his infamous “wedding registry.” About the last: Three decades after the Huckabees’ wedding, his wife registered at department stores so their new home, post-governor’s mansion, could be stocked with gifts of linens, toasters and other suitable furnishings. In early 2007, our reporting also prompted the former first lady to decline dozens of place settings of governor’s mansion china and Irish crystal that had been purchased with tax-deductible contributions to the Governor’s Mansion Association, nominally set up to improve the mansion, not to buy going-away presents for former occupants.

Report this

By RdV, January 11 at 8:33 am #

and he is a talented politician AND a genuinely likable personality (with a sense of humor).

He represents the change that Obama shouts about (only to obscure that he really doesn’t represent any real change other than passing the baton from the Clintons)

Too bad he is limited to an evangelical world view. Sort of cancels everything out.

Report this

By dustinchicago, January 11 at 7:54 am #

I still have not made up my opinion on the national sales tax to replace income tax.  The numbers are confusing, the current tax policy is confusing, and a simple sales tax is very appealing. i am still working out some of the fundemental flaws, and comparing that with current system (without loopholes etc it would be progressive).  But I do not discount the national sales tax as quickly as David Sirota does.

I have a great interest in Huckabee and Edwards exactly because of their class rhetoric.  I very much like some of the positions of Ron Paul, Gravel and Kucinich.  I feel the rest of the known field are Establishment.  And I still have not competely swallowed Kucinich’s explanation of throwing his support to Obama. 

I for one will never shy away from talking about real class issues.

Report this

By ocjim, January 11 at 7:53 am #

I don’t call a candidate classy who villifies his Republican opponent, Romney, by called him the devil and then belatedly says I’m sorry (lawyer technique: smear and withdraw). I don’t consider sanctimony a good ingredient for a classy candidate. He has a few praiseworthy stands but that provides no case for CLASSY.

Are you sure your name isn’t David Huckabee?

Report this

Add Your Comment

Posts by unregistered readers are moderated. Posts by members
are published immediately. Why wait? Register today!






Notify you when others comment on this article?


Are you a human?
Retype the word you see here.


Please read and abide by our comment policy.
By submitting this comment, you agree to this site's terms and conditions.

Newsletter

Get Truthdig in your inbox

Privacy Policy

 
Click here to advertise with Truthdig
 

 
Join the Liberal Blog Advertising Network
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A Progressive Journal of News and Opinion. Editor, Robert Scheer. Publisher, Zuade Kaufman.
Copyright © 2008 Truthdig, L.L.C. All rights reserved.