![]() |
|
| |
|
Huckabee the RebelPosted on Dec 20, 2007By E.J. Dionne WASHINGTON—The rise of Mike Huckabee has put the fear of God into the Republican establishment. Its alarm has nothing to do with the Almighty. The Huckabee surge represents a break with what has been standard operating procedure within the GOP for more than a generation. Huckabee’s evangelical Christian army in Iowa ignored the importuning of entrenched leaders of the religious right and decided to go with one of their own. Huckabee himself preaches a gospel of populism that rejects conservative orthodoxy on trade, the value of government and the beneficence of Wall Street. Huckabee is no William Jennings Bryan, the great fundamentalist scourge of big business a century ago. But Bryan would have appreciated Huckabee’s attack on politics as a mere extension of economics. “If it was all about the money,” Huckabee said recently, “then we might as well put the presidency up on eBay.” The former Arkansas governor has exposed a fault line within the Republican coalition. The old religious right is dying because it subordinated the actual views of its followers to short-term political calculations. The white evangelical electorate is tired of taking orders from politicians who care more about protecting the wealthy than ending abortion, more about deregulation than family values. That’s why Washington-focused religious operatives tied to old GOP strategies are being outdone by new leaders with authentic grass-roots followings—people such as Michael Farris, who chairs the Home School Legal Defense Association and supports Huckabee. The paradox is that if Huckabee’s candidacy poses a mortal threat to Mitt Romney in Iowa, the Baptist minister’s rise may boost Romney’s effort to consolidate establishment conservative support. This could help Romney in his Jan. 8 showdown with John McCain in New Hampshire. The rallying to Romney began earlier in the campaign, says David Keene, chairman of the American Conservative Union, because many on the right saw Rudy Giuliani’s candidacy as the main threat to their cause. But Huckabee poses an even greater danger since Giuliani, despite his apostasy on abortion and gay rights, has pledged fealty to economic and foreign policy conservatism. Huckabee, said Keene, a Romney supporter, “is not a conservative who is an evangelical, he’s an evangelical populist. It’s not the evangelical part that conservatives worry about. It’s the populism. It’s his economic views.” National Review—the canonical publication of the conservative movement—rallied behind Romney last week in an editorial that was candid about the dangers facing the conservative coalition. Giuliani and Huckabee, the magazine’s editors argued, “would pull apart the coalition from opposite ends: Giuliani alienating the social conservatives, and Huckabee the economic (and foreign-policy) conservatives. A Republican Party that abandoned either limited government or moral standards would be much diminished in the service it could give the country.” But the crackup that National Review fears may already be happening. In a report issued in May 2005, the Pew Research Center pointed to the rise of a new group within the Republican alliance it labeled “pro-government conservatives.” Pew sees this group accounting for just under a third of the GOP’s core support. The report described them as “broadly religious and socially conservative, but they deviate from the party line in their backing for government involvement in a wide range of policy areas, such as government regulation and more generous assistance to the poor.” They sound like Huckabee conservatives—or what conservative writers Ross Douthat and Reihan Salam called “The Party of Sam’s Club” in a 2005 Weekly Standard article that they have expanded into a book to be published next year. “On domestic policy,” say Douthat and Salam, the Republican Party “isn’t just out of touch with the country as a whole, it’s out of touch with its own base” [their emphasis]. Reaching such voters requires “talking about economic insecurity as well as about self-reliance.” That’s what Huckabee does. The polls suggest that religious conservatism, not economic populism, is behind Huckabee’s rise in Iowa. But he is not backing down from his role as a tribune of the dispossessed. On NBC’s “Today” show Wednesday, he declared that “the Wall Street-to-Washington axis, this corridor of power, is absolutely, frantically against me.” He insisted: “The president ought to be a servant of the people and ought not to be elected to the ruling class.” Power to the People, Mike, Right On! If you had to bet, you’d wager that the Republican establishment will eventually crush Huckabee. But the rebellion he is leading is a warning to Republicans. The faithful are restive, tired of being used, and no longer willing to do the bidding of a crowd that subordinates Main Street’s values to Wall Street’s interests. E.J. Dionne’s e-mail address is postchat(at)aol.com. Previous item: Fear, Loathing and the Crisis of Confidence Next item: Which Clinton for President? Elsewhere: . CommentsAre you a Truthdig member yet? Login now, or register with Truthdig. Add Your Comment
|
A Progressive Journal of News and Opinion. Editor, Robert Scheer. Publisher, Zuade Kaufman.
Copyright © 2009 Truthdig, L.L.C. All rights reserved. |
By BruSays, December 26, 2007 at 3:16 pm #
Re: #121888 by Jaki on 12/22 at 9:56 am
Jaki, thanks for the ‘sentimental’ support. I hear your concern about election tampering but I feel safe on this one. So safe, in fact, that Huckabee’s nomination by the ‘Repugnicans’ will remain in my fantasies; it won’t happen.
Report thisBy Thomas Billis, December 24, 2007 at 1:16 pm #
The guy that would really give the religious conservatives fits if he ran would be Jesus Christ.Take care of the poor heal the sick the National Review would implode.They would have to repudiate the new testament and become in Ann Coulters words imperfect.Wait till he gets to the part if you have two coats…..
Report thisBy Jaki, December 22, 2007 at 3:15 pm #
Sorry, my mistake, Chauncy. Edwards was there. But Kucinich wasn’t. It seems he is the ONLY Democrat candidate not on this Ron Paul Supporters-generated list.
Report thisBy Jaki, December 22, 2007 at 3:07 pm #
#121789 by Chauncy on 12/21 at 6:59 pm
(Unregistered commenter)
Chauncy, I went to the site you referred us to about the CFR and the New World Order/Globalization plans.
Your list of Presidential candidates who support this move away from maintaining our country’s sovereignty does not seem to be entirely correct. John Edwards name was not there.
Report thisBy Jaki, December 22, 2007 at 9:56 am #
#121764 by BruSays on 12/21 at 3:53 pm
(49 comments total) “Republicans: Please, Please, Please nominate Huckabee!
Only with a Huckabee nomination will moderate Americans in general, and mainstream Republicans in particular, finally - FINALLY - be awakened to the fact that the GOP has been hijacked by right-wing zealots.”
Bru—Although I certainly agree with your sentiments, we have to remember that the Repugnicans STOLE THE LAST TWO PRESIDENTIAL ELECTIONS by BALLOT FRAUD AND ELECTION TAMPERING.
That basically calls into question the concept of wanting the most extreme candidate anywhere on the ballot.
Report thisBy Jaki, December 22, 2007 at 9:45 am #
#121708 by ForeverDem on 12/21 at 9:31 am
“The electorate is losing confidence in the Democrats, due to the ineffectiveness of Congressional Democrats to confront the lawless Bush Regime… This has got to change and change FAST or Democrats are likely to lose seats in both Houses in November 08. REID AND PELOSI SHOULD STEP ASIDE NOW!!”
ForeverDem: We have a criminally insane FASCIST self-appointed, KING in the White House who threatens vetoes of everything he opposes, and carries out those threats. This is contrary to the intentions of the Founders of Our Country, but it is FACT. Reid, Pelosi, ALL of the House and Senate Democrats are powerless AT THIS POINT to override this demagogery and unmitigated power. They do not have the votes, nor much hope of getting them.
THEREFORE, OUR ONLY HOPE, in terms of the future of our country AND THE PLANET, is to get rid of as many Repugnicans as possible in the next elections, nationally, state-wide, and locally. PEOPLE NEED TO REMEMBER that one of the ways the Repugnicans WIN is to focus on local elections and extreme issues (often by the “initiative process”) to bring out their truly “base” voters. Another way they win is to lie, so we have to throw them ALL out, no matter how good they sound.
In the next election, the immigration card will be played over and over and over, and it is a false (AND RACIST) issue. Not that all of us are not concerned on some level by the influx of people into our country and the drain on our already dwindling resources (Thanks to King George’s UNHoly War). But we need to better understand WHY this is happening, and that it isn’t the fault of those who desperately seek to come here because multi-national corporations have decimated their lives in their own countries.
Those same multi-national corporations WANT that cheap labor to come here, too (and King George supports it). Otherwise, they wouldn’t be hiring them to take the jobs our workers would otherwise have. They used to justify this by saying Americans don’t want and won’t do those jobs, and we bought into it. Like who wants to be bent over in the sun all day picking strawberries full of pesticides? But construction? Service jobs? You name it. The working class is being squeezed out into homelessness and poverty.
Do not blame the victims. Do not blame the powerless in our government. Put the blame where it belongs: greedy corporations and their henchmen who control government (lobbyists and the elite).
Frankly, I’m not convinced the Democrats will fulfill our dreams of a truly egalitarian, socially conscious, society, but the ONLY SANE OPTION we will have in 2008 and beyond (for many elections) is to give them a chance. As others have duly noted, it is EXTREMELY IMPORTANT to control who goes onto the Supreme Court.
So, let’s commit to voting for Democrats (even if it hurts) for a while to see if there IS a real difference between these two parties, while We The People do everything we can to hold their feet to the fire. If after a decade or so of Democrat Majority we are in the same boat, let’s think and debate about sinking it.
I urge everyone to go to http://www.pbs.org and watch or read the transcript of Bill Moyers’ Journal, shown last night (12/21/07).
Report thisBy Jaki, December 22, 2007 at 8:57 am #
#121697 by Bill in LA on 12/21 at 8:54 am
(Unregistered commenter) “Great article As an evangelical pastor in California, I couldnt agree more with this statement. The GOP is in trouble because it is losing the emerging generations of evangelicals as we see more compassion in the social justice agendas of the left…
I think Huckabee has managed to tap into those changing currents among evangelicals, who want to remain socially conservative (ie. look more like a republican in issues like abortion), but also are looking to embrace a socially compassionate agenda (ie. look more like a democrat in issues like immigration, the environment, and programs for the poor).”
It is just so revealing when right wing religious zealots exclude a Woman’s Right to Choose from the category of compassionate social conscience. Remember, the anti-choice people want to ban ALL abortions, including pregnancies caused by rape and incest, or when a woman’s life is at stake should she carry the pregnancy to term.
To be truly compassionate and “populist,” the RIGHT of a woman to guide her own destiny and decide when and whether she wishes to allow her body to be an incubator, is her RIGHT OF CHOICE and RIGHT TO PRIVACY (as guaranteed by The Constitution with validation by The Supreme Court). It is not to be decided by men or other women or parents, priests, doctors, or politicians.
ALL OF THE REPUBLICANS ARE ANTI-CHOICE. So it really doesn’t matter which one gets nominated. Socially conscious, enlightened, TRULY COMPASSIONATE, women and men will come out of the woodwork to defeat them. We will not go backwards. We The People do not want religion to control our government or our bodies. Their days are numbered. We will not be fooled again.
Report thisBy Conservative Yankee, December 22, 2007 at 6:35 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
121638 by P. T. on 12/20 at 11:32 pm
“Mike Huckabee has already sold out his base amongst ordinary people by advocating the replacement of the progressive income tax with a regressive consumption tax.”
Your income tax is progressive??? What nation do you pay? Here in the US those of us with less than 10% of the wealth pay 60% of the income tax…. Go figure.
Report thisBy Chris Bieber, December 21, 2007 at 8:35 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)
it is quite amazing that there is ANOTHER Strongman in the race for the White House..for a long time Generalissimo Benito had a monopoly on MORE law and MORE orter…now the innocent softspoken! Governor from Bugtussle AK is cajoling oblivious and FuehrerPrinzip-afflicted CRighters into lemming-like support his Childrens Crusade…er campaign..so HE can wield the MIGHT Club of Government and USE it without the meddling niceties of the Constitutional LIMITATIONS on Executive Branch actions…the HE** with Declaring War and US Soveriengty and the impending COLLAPSE(like Zimbabwe!)of our currency….he will USE the Club inerringly on the side of what God tells him to do…
Just like the beloved and wellmeaning fiscal conservative and NONNationbuilding W…
The plague we will inherit if we keep going down this UnScriptural and philosophically BANKRUPT smilingface FASCISM and FeelGood EMPIRE will and ought to be laid on the feet of these servile toadies of the Huckabee as well as the softspoken HueyLongish Huckabee…and the GOPugnicans…
(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)
Report thisBy Chauncy, December 21, 2007 at 7:26 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)
If Huck is doing so well in the polls how come he can’t raise any money? It really doesn’t add up.
Report thisBy Enemy of State, December 21, 2007 at 7:14 pm #
I think EJ has it right. At this point there is no indication that Huckebee is for sale to the monied interests. And that is a big concern for those interests. That he may open up the cracks of the inconsistiencies that the party has become, is also frightening. The demographic of religiously conservative, but compassionate people will go for Mike. The rest of us will fear that if he is elected great naivete about the ways of the world will rule. I suspect that it was naivete in the form, that any prisoner who professes to believe the right things religiously will automatically be a good safe release, rather than calculated evit that led to those pardons.
It will be an interesting spectacle to watch. I can’t say how it will come out. But it does seem unlikely the Republican party will be the same afterwards.
Report thisBy Chauncy, December 21, 2007 at 6:59 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)
Just for the record, Huck is currently earning his wings as a member of the Council on Foreign Relations. His foreign policy adviser, Richard Haas, is president of the CFR.
I hate to be the one to break it to you folks, but Huck is nothing more than a puppet.
And so is..
Fred Thompson
Rudy Giuliani
John McCain
Mitt Romney
Hillary Clinton
Barack Obama
John Edwards
Joe Biden
Chris Dodd
Bill Richardson
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vo5CZvD3-QM ..in this video you will discover the agenda of these CFR candidates, and you’ll find some pretty scary quotes from Huck’s foreign policy advisor, and other prominent CFR goons.
Report thisBy BruSays, December 21, 2007 at 3:53 pm #
Republicans: Please, Please, Please nominate Huckabee!
Only with a Huckabee nomination will moderate Americans in general, and mainstream Republicans in particular, finally - FINALLY - be awakened to the fact that the GOP has been hijacked by right-wing zealots.
As the author Sam Harris (“Letters to a Christian Nation,” etc.) has pointed out, the apologetic and ‘compassionate’ religious moderates have long cushioned or even prevented what normally would be the inevitable collision of mainstream moderate and progressive ideology from the extremes of radical evangelicals.
The same has been true of the Republican moderates who for years have tap danced around and carefully softened the messages of their Bible pounding GOP brethren. But put a real Bible pounder - a real anti-evolution, anti-abortion, anti-gay, anti-tolerance, anti-science, anti-education, anti-separation of church and state radical on the ticket and the Democrats will have a field day a at the polls.
I’m convinced that Americans will FINALLY see that the Republican Party has gone too far; that the GOP had long ago been hijacked by backward thinking people who’ve become the joke of world opinion.
Report thisBy HEYHO, December 21, 2007 at 3:49 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)
2 WORDS… Jesus Freak!
Report thisBy MaryT, December 21, 2007 at 12:59 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)
I agree with EJ. The repub’s elite will not let Huckabee win. They are too close to burying all the New Deal programs. The big one, Social Security is still out there, waiting for their greedy hands. They need a Willard, Fred or Rudy to put that last nail in the SocSer coffin. Huckabee will not do it for them. It’s all about m-o-n-e-y.
Report thisBy P. T., December 21, 2007 at 10:41 am #
“All I have to say is Wait and See youll all be just as shocked and dumb-founded as you were last election when Bush was re-elected.”
Report thisI wasn’t shocked. I knew Bush could steal elections.
By john, December 21, 2007 at 10:29 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
All you Huckabee hating fools who think he can’t win the nomination and beat Clinton or any other dem(oboma might be a challange) are in for a rude awakening when you wake up and realize he is the next president. All I have to say is Wait and See you’ll all be just as shocked and dumb-founded as you were last election when Bush was re-elected. However, I think Huck will do a much better job than Bush has in the past few years(it shouldn’t be that difficult)
I’d hate to rain on your anti-Huckabee parade but he has the ability to pull votes from both sides of the isle he has several UNION endorcements and I have seen posts from many DEMS that say they would vote for him in the general election which will make it extreamly difficult for a dem to get elected.
Anyone BUT Hillary!! Go HUCKABEE, Go OBOMA(to insure it’s not Hillary)
Report thisBy P. T., December 21, 2007 at 10:28 am #
I get a kick out of how Mike Huckabee suggests his success is a miracle. In other words, he is saying that God is backing him for president. Fundamentalist preachers operate that way.
Report thisBy P. T., December 21, 2007 at 10:18 am #
For all their talk of moral absolutes, fundamentalists believe the means justify the ends. That includes the use of lying. Something is okay if it advances the cause.
Report thisBy P. T., December 21, 2007 at 10:14 am #
Mike Huckabee says the commercial was shot in front of a bookcase. However, it looks like a window to me. The cross pattern surrounds the windowpanes. Notice the reflection of the Christmas tree ornaments in the window.
Report thisBy P. T., December 21, 2007 at 10:00 am #
Iowa, with its caucuses, rewards zealots, who turn out. When the primaries get going, The Republican establishment will get rid of Mike Huckabee.
Report thisBy ForeverDem, December 21, 2007 at 9:31 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
Huckabee and his legion of religious fundamentalists are indeed on the march!! It’s SICK as hell but also very REAL! However, even though this is discusting & outrageous to Democrats, here is something we should really be concerned with:
“Sen. John Sununu (R-NH) now leads challenger Jeanne Shaheen (D), 52% to 41%, in a re-match for U.S. Senate, according to the latest American Research Group survey.”
Sununu (another Bush Fascist) is rapidly putting distance between himself and Shaheen - something that was NOT happening a few months back!
WHY is this happening?...The electorate is loosing confidence in the Democrats, due to the ineffectiveness of Congressional Democrats to confront the lawless Bush Regime. The weak and incompetent leadership of Reid in the Senate and Pelosi in the House is beginning to take its toll. This has got to change and change FAST or Democrats are likely to loose seats in both Houses in November 08. REID AND PELOSI SHOULD STEP ASIDE NOW!!
Report thisBy Harris, December 21, 2007 at 9:30 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
Good article. A sore has been festering within the Republican party for years. This battle was inevitable, but it took Huckabee’s rise to kick it off. It looks like it will be fiscal cons vs. social cons. Whichever team doesn’t win the primary will be pretty angry. The question is whether the loser will be angry enough to not vote for the anointed Republican candidate, or not vote at all. This IS the battle for the direction of the party.
Report thisBy Bill in LA, December 21, 2007 at 8:54 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
“The old religious right is dying because it subordinated the actual views of its followers to short-term political calculations. “
Great article… As an evangelical pastor in California, I couldn’t agree more with this statement. The GOP is in trouble because it is losing the emerging generations of evangelicals as we see more compassion in the social justice agendas of the left.
I think Huckabee has managed to tap into those changing currents among evangelicals, who want to remain socially conservative (ie. look more like a republican in issues like abortion), but also are looking to embrace a socially compassionate agenda (ie. look more like a democrat in issues like immigration, the environment, and programs for the poor).
Report thisBy Leefeller, December 21, 2007 at 6:45 am #
I wouldn’t vote for Huckabee with your vote. It would be nice to see the Crusades be called the Crusades, instead of the war on terror, nice Christian nation that we are.
Report thisBy John Borowski, December 21, 2007 at 6:24 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
To illustrate the stupidity of the average American is the Supreme Court make up. You cant get an objective or unbiased judgments if you load up the Supreme Court with biased right wingers or Liberal oriented people. The Supreme Court should have people (If that is possible) to be totally objective in their judgments. If this type of Supreme Court existed the British would ban it.
Report thisBy www.TaxHikeMike.org, December 21, 2007 at 5:37 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
http://www.TaxHikeMike.org
Report thisBy John Borowski, December 21, 2007 at 5:03 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
Folks, there is no way a big guy in the sky would allow charlatans, sex abusers, and thieves to violate his house. The latest insult to a god is in Philadelphia where a priest was accused of stealing $900,000 from gods pockets. If that priest truly believed in a god he wouldnt steal a penny of his money because the priest would know he wouldnt get away with it. If this Huckabee had more respect for the American voters he would never come out with something like this.
Report thisBy Marjorie L. Swanson, December 21, 2007 at 4:39 am #
Give the Republican base what they want. Please. Because it seems that the people that use religion as their litmus test for president want Huckabee. And it would appear that not only does their idol have feet of clay he may be clay from head to foot. Many people are sick and tired of religion being force-fed into every conversation and issue. I hope Huckabee is the nominee because that will absolutely guarantee that a Democrat sits in the oval office. And while I support John Edwards, I want to know for sure that it is a Democrat that nominates the one or two new nominees for the Supreme Court that will surely come up during the next administration. Conservatives have always known how important this is. Most liberals don’t seem to care.
Report thisBy Derek, December 20, 2007 at 11:39 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)
Governor Huckabee is the only republican candidate that I would vote for, if he doesnt get the nomination I will be going third party or not voting in 08. If the rich elitist such as slick Mitt want to divide this party so be it, this will be the end to the grand old GOP.
GO HUCKABEE
Report thisBy P. T., December 20, 2007 at 11:32 pm #
Mike Huckabee has already sold out his base amongst ordinary people by advocating the replacement of the progressive income tax with a regressive consumption tax.
Report thisBy Jaki, December 20, 2007 at 10:36 pm #
Main Street’s Values? Is it Main Street’s values to let a homicidal rapist free only to have him rape and kill two more women? Huckabee did this, even after many women wrote to him and one even met with him, pleading not to let Wayne Demond free. He put pressure on the parole board, whose high-paying jobs were in his power.
One woman was raped, with a butcher knife held to her throat, in front of her 3 year old. She is the one who went to meet with Huckabee, who ignored her and many other women with similar experiences with Demond.
Do you think Main Streeters want a person with such poor judgment running the country?
Main Street Values? Huckabee has said he is not interested in having women have parity in the workplace, and actually thinks it is wrong. Do you think those Main Street folks are living on one income?
Investigators reported today on Democracy Now! that neither church that Huckabee pastored will release copies of his sermons from the past 12 years. Why?
Huckabee is a Huckster. He’s one of those innocent-looking, boyish-appearing, down-home evangelical menaces the Republicans know they can get their “base” to fall for. He’s an actor, saying what he thinks they want to hear. He is not genuine. Just an actor playing genuine.
You say “Power to the People, Mike, Right on.” What a load of crap. Get real. Huckabee has no interest in The People. Women are people. Huckabee is anti-woman, anti-choice, homophobic, and a divider, not, as he claims, a uniter. Heard that before? He is interested in power. Get it right.
Report this