![]() |
|
||
|
Telling the Truth About IranPosted on Dec 6, 2007By Joe Conason Even when George W. Bush tells the truth, he cannot quite bring himself to tell the whole truth. Although the White House released a new National Intelligence Estimate on Iran’s pursuit of nuclear weapons, indicating that the Iranians shut down their program more than four years ago, the president treated those conclusions as a vindication more than an embarrassment. With the usual propagandists filtering the NIE to conceal their mistakes, it is worth reproducing a few of the new report’s most salient quotes. “We judge with high confidence that in fall 2003, Tehran halted its nuclear weapons program,” said the NIE text, reflecting a strong consensus among the nation’s 16 intelligence agencies. “Tehran’s decision to halt its nuclear weapons program suggests it is less determined to develop nuclear weapons than we have been judging since 2005.” Now it is encouraging to learn before, and not after, a military invasion that the vaunted weapons of mass destruction don’t exist, thereby possibly avoiding loss of life, treasure and national reputation. Considering that the Bush regime remains in charge, such a reversal of events can only be regarded as progress. But the abrupt unveiling of the new intelligence estimate, which so bluntly refutes the president’s recent remarks about “World War III,” raises fresh questions about him and his administration. Actually, they are the same old questions that have plagued us since the invasion of Iraq. What did they know and when did they know it? And in neither case have those questions been addressed with sufficient candor. Advertisement Yet his own national security adviser, Stephen Hadley, told reporters that the president had first learned of the NIE findings “a few months ago”—which means that the White House knew its alarmist rhetoric was wrong as early as late summer. Curiously, The Washington Post reports that U.S. intelligence agencies intercepted information about the discontinued Iranian nuclear program sometime in July, and passed that data on to White House officials, presumably in the National Security Council. The top officials who knew the truth early on must have included Vice President Dick Cheney, a man notorious for demanding raw intelligence on Mideast issues (and for distorting that information to fit his own policy preferences). Late in October, the vice president delivered a demagogic speech in Washington on the Iranian nuclear threat. “Our country, and the entire international community, cannot stand by as a terror-supporting state fulfills its grandest ambitions,” he said, adding that Tehran “continues to practice delay and deceit in an obvious effort to buy time.” When he uttered those words, did Cheney believe that he could rewrite or suppress the new NIE? Trying to understand why both he and the president continued to promote false perceptions of Iran is mystifying. Sometimes their behavior raises real concern about their own capacity to perceive reality—as when the president insisted repeatedly that Saddam Hussein had refused to let U.N. weapons inspectors into Iraq. Now the president is claiming that his administration reached out to the Iranians in 2003, but that those gestures were rebuffed following the election of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad. His account is wrong, of course. The regime that preceded Ahmadinejad sought better relations with the United States on several occasions between 2001 and 2003—but neoconservatives in the White House rejected those efforts because they have long cherished the notion of a military strike against Tehran. So much for those bloody daydreams. There is no way to justify bombing Iran. Although the president declares that the new NIE justifies everything he has said and done and proves that Iran is a danger to humanity, his old policies are discredited and defunct. So is the war rhetoric of Republican presidential candidates like John McCain and Rudolph Giuliani and their advisers. That doesn’t necessarily mean there is no potential problem in Iran, or that the Iranian leadership will not someday decide to use its nuclear facilities for nefarious purposes. It means that the next president will have to engage Iran in negotiations that will someday lead to normalized relations—and renew the American commitment to nonproliferation. Joe Conason writes for the New York Observer (www.observer.com). © 2007 Creators Syndicate Inc. Elsewhere: . CommentsAre you a Truthdig member yet? Login now, or register with Truthdig. Add Your Comment
|
A Progressive Journal of News and Opinion. Editor, Robert Scheer. Publisher, Zuade Kaufman.
Copyright © 2009 Truthdig, L.L.C. All rights reserved. |
By Louise, December 9, 2007 at 2:48 pm #
There is a potential problem in Iran. The same potential problem that existed in Iraq before the repubs stole the White House. Actually in Iran, it’s moved beyond potential into the realm of very likely, if not fact.
Which is where it was heading when the Stumped was stumping. Yes, Saddam had the same plan Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad has. And it aint about nukes!
Whether or not Bush saw the threat, or the threat was simply whispered in his ear, we may never know. But we do know for sure whoever the whisperer was sure picked the wrong ear.
There is no sane logic behind anything that’s come out of the repub controlled congress and their friend in the White House. Nothing the bush has done has in any way been good for the country. In fact if one didn’t know better, one might think that was the intention from the beginning. To destroy the country.
Were we to search in vain for any successes coming out of the White House in the past seven years, [has it been only seven?] that would have to be it. One man and his delusional adorers, oops I mean supporters have managed to pretty well destroy everything and anything they have put their minds and hearts too, including the dollar.
Now you and I may not see that as success, but obviously somebody does ... because the complete indifference to the damage caused by this truly psychopathic administration runs so deep and has hurt so many and will take so long to fix ... it cant possibly have been an accident.
I’m talking about the petro-dollar of course.
That’s it you know ... that’s the “potential problem in Iran.”
http://uk.news.yahoo.com/rtrs/20071208/tpl-uk-iran-oil-dollar-02bfc7e_1.html
“Iran stops selling oil in U.S. dollars”
Can it be that simple?
Of course it can.
Name one thing you did today that wasn’t dependent in some way on the oil industry. One thing!
This little tin empire we live in is based on oil, and the petro-dollar. Every thing else coming out of Bushes GWOT, the war profit, the profit that was made from 9/11 was just icing on the cake.
Even so, I doubt if George ever thinks about money. He’s never had to lift a finger to earn, or spend, or even account for money. The big charge, I suspect, is the reflection. George the super star. George the war prezident. George the decider guy. Big George. Bad George. Bold George.
So the whisperer whispered, and watched what he feared might happen, happen. Serves him right for sending an empty vessel to put out the fire.
Because George was appointed and not elected. And improved on the cheating just enough to get that second term without the Supremes meddling. I find I am a victim, as are you, as are the majority of honest hard working citizens in this country who were never dumb enough to vote for that George in the first place! And way ahead of him when the lying started. Actually before he ever put a muddy boot on the White House floor!
And if there is no better reason to damn the dems who promised so much and have delivered so little, let that be it!
How can they see so much and understand so little?
I’m tired of hearing Bush is a liar. It’s not that simple! He’s sick. The kind of sick that needs to be monitored so he cant hurt himself, or anyone else. The compulsive lying is just one of many easily recognized symptoms of this very serious condition.
I’m tired of hearing the Americans are stupid. They’re not. They’ve had this Bush pegged almost from day one! I’m tired of hearing pious and self-righteous indignation from the dems in congress ... every friggen day ... when they flat out refuse to even TALK about impeachment. And most of all, I am damn sick and tired of hearing media know-it-alls explain the madness as though it made sense!
Kripes! If the congressaurs and the media types haven’t got the balls to call a spade a spade they need to go find a job they can handle!
Shoveling shit in a horse barn might be good.
Report thisBy PatrickHenry, December 9, 2007 at 11:54 am #
Lets cut of funding to Israel and cancel all their contracts with Amdocs and Infosys until they permit IAEA to check out Dimona and come clean on the rest of their nuclear program.
Report thisBy KYJurisDoctor, December 7, 2007 at 5:02 pm #
The folks who gave us the intelligence report are our persons for the week:
http://osi-speaks.blogspot.com/2007/12/persons-for-week.html#links
Report thisBy mlevass, December 7, 2007 at 3:58 pm #
SHHHH…..DON’T MENTION THIS….SHHH
While U.S. intelligence agencies have “high confidence” that covert work on a bomb was suspended “for at least several years” after 2003, there is only “moderate confidence” that Tehran has not restarted the military program. Iran’s massive overt investment in uranium enrichment meanwhile proceeds in defiance of binding U.N. resolutions, even though Tehran has no legitimate use for enriched uranium. The U.S. estimate of when Iran might produce enough enriched uranium for a bomb—sometime between late 2009 and the middle of the next decade—hasn’t changed.
“Tehran at a minimum is keeping open the option to develop nuclear weapons,” says the summary’s second sentence.
Report thisBy Brons, December 7, 2007 at 10:45 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
Bush the Bozo and the administration got it wrong on Iraq.
Report thisNow it’s apparent he’s been wrong on Iran. When is the collective intelligence of the american people going to stand up and call this menace of a president the liar he is?
I’m beginning to feel like a sheep waiting to be sheared or worse! The majority of this country can’t be
that blind! Or do they just choose to ignore…..
His legacy will be an example of mismanagement and deceit.
By Artist General, December 6, 2007 at 10:19 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)
SNAFU PIKER$? OOP$EE
—-THE WEALTHIEST WAR CABINET
ON THE MOST CHICKENHAWKED WARPATH IN AMERICAN HISTORY—-
How many lies must a leader tell
before they call him a liar?
The answer my friend is blowin in a war:
the answer is blowin in the War
Sow the Spin / Reap the Whirlwind
Neocons, Whigs, PNAC Gallery, O my indeed. Hundreds O Billions in—Fortune$ O War as far as the mind$eye can behold.
Theyre huffer$, unrecu$ed for life , blasted on the sheer euphoric magnitude of what seems even now still PO$$IBLE, given the scandal-fatigued American Public.
Money is Power and Power is Money, that is all they know, and all they need to know.
Heres their nightmare—an albeit unlikely (given M$M status quo) but possible [sudden, unforseen!] Moment of Truth in Journalism—i.e., that [rightly celebrated] Walter-Cronkite-Type-Event:
http://www.foggybog.com/movies/cronkite.html
WHAT WERE UP AGAINST:
SF Bay Guardian Visual (Political Art of the Week)
http://www.sfbg.com/blogs/politics/2007/08/political_art_of_the_week.html
A BATTLE STATION FOR THE ASKING:
SUNDAY EDITORIAL
Nov. 25 2007
Radical Ethics: No bucks from war
P-I EDITORIAL BOARD
...this left-wing, left-coast idea actually reaches into the heartland and history of the country…
http://www.commondreams.org/archive/2007/11/25/5422/
Report thisBy PatrickHenry, December 6, 2007 at 7:22 pm #
I wish Bush was as adamant about Israel revealing their nuclear program as he is about Iran and theirs.
I’d like to see the IAEA check out Dimona.
Report thisBy Thomas Billis, December 6, 2007 at 6:15 pm #
Joe I hope you read the comments on Truthdig because you seem so confused as to why this administration lies us into wars in the middle east.Let me write it slowly o i l.Copernicus solved all the riddles about planetary movement when he put the sun into the center of the universe.Joe if you put oil into the center of the Bush universe it will solve the riddles you seem to have as to why Bush and Cheney do certain things in middle east policy.
Report thisBy A Khokar, December 6, 2007 at 4:38 pm #
Mr Joe Conason very rightly said that in pursuit of grandest US ambitions and long cherished notions of military strike against Tehran; the NIE reports bluntly refute the president George W Bush deceitful resolve and rhetoric about World War III. Here Israel being in Middle East and having a first hand information and extra ordinary intelligence facilities to know, must also be singled out; that Israel also knew the factual position.
What ever our intelligence reports and assessments say; this is but certain that we need a visionary; a Messiah to come up with some justifiable; a Just system in the Middle East and win the hearts and minds of people. Invading the countries or installation of some agents with a bad intent like; Israel etc to bully around and thrusting the policy of extermination of innocent inhabitants, plus terrifying them or make them starved by imposing sanctions and blockages; coercing and tying them into trades bondages; may not be the solution. It may make the heads bow but that does not mean that it will also bend the minds.
It is Gods design that on this planet earth; today we find the rich, flourishing and technologically advanced economies lying in the west where as their life line…feed (oil) stems from the East. This unique layout of interdependence, dictated by the nature demands that some fair and befitting system such as Barter Systems etc be put in place and be run with all the fairness of business and grace.
Iran may be having its natural ambitions dictated by the lay of its land and century old traditions which maketh it stand as lofty as it could be as a big brother in the Persian Gulf; over looking and guarding the Arab peninsula. This centuries old status of Iran is very well established and well seated in the local populace and culture; and is duly recognised in the Arab world. Any conquest or adventurism against this may not obliterate it.
America may find Iran on their right hand in negotiating all these aspects with a befitting ‘logic and wisdom’; because logic and wisdom is deep seeded in their souls and soil.
Report this————————————————-
Love for all, Hatred for none
By SamSnedegar, December 6, 2007 at 3:11 pm #
Iran comprises a clear and present danger to the USA when it invades the Emirates, Kuwait, and Saudi Arabia in order to steal those country’s oil in the same way we stole Iraq’s oil. Iran also is a threat to Israel’s ability to bully the entire arab world on the strength of its nuclear bombs.
Iran also threatens any US Congressman or Senator who depends on the American Israel Public Affairs Committee for money and votes for his reelection.
There is one more minor item: Liebermann always starts with a “LIE.”
Our preoccupation with Iran is a result of only one thing: it’s about oil. Everything is.
The second verity of the Sam Snedegar algorithm for understanding Bushitter foreign policy applies here also: Bush is a moron. If you know these two verities, all is explained.
(1) It is about oil.
(2) Bush is a moron.
20 bytes each, a total of 40 bytes, (41, if you include the carriage return) and you have a complete explanation of the Bushitter modus operandi with respect to the mideast and also most domestic policy matters as well.
Report thisBy QuyTran, December 6, 2007 at 12:39 pm #
GWB didn’t have any truth to tell by birth. He was born with inpertinence from head to toes and this was his hereditary. Don’t be surprise !
Report this