|
|||
|
Welcome to ‘Palestine’Posted on Jun 22, 2007By Robert Fisk How troublesome the Muslims of the Middle East are. First, we demand that the Palestinians embrace democracy and then they elect the wrong party—Hamas—and then Hamas wins a mini-civil war and presides over the Gaza Strip. And we Westerners still want to negotiate with the discredited President, Mahmoud Abbas. Today “Palestine”—and let’s keep those quotation marks in place—has two prime ministers. Welcome to the Middle East. Who can we negotiate with? To whom do we talk? Well of course, we should have talked to Hamas months ago. But we didn’t like the democratically elected government of the Palestinian people. They were supposed to have voted for Fatah and its corrupt leadership. But they voted for Hamas, which declines to recognise Israel or abide by the totally discredited Oslo agreement. No one asked—on our side—which particular Israel Hamas was supposed to recognise. The Israel of 1948? The Israel of the post-1967 borders? The Israel which builds—and goes on building—vast settlements for Jews and Jews only on Arab land, gobbling up even more of the 22 per cent of “Palestine” still left to negotiate over ? And so today, we are supposed to talk to our faithful policeman, Mr Abbas, the “moderate” (as the BBC, CNN and Fox News refer to him) Palestinian leader, a man who wrote a 600-page book about Oslo without once mentioning the word “occupation”, who always referred to Israeli “redeployment” rather than “withdrawal”, a “leader” we can trust because he wears a tie and goes to the White House and says all the right things. The Palestinians didn’t vote for Hamas because they wanted an Islamic republic - which is how Hamas’s bloody victory will be represented - but because they were tired of the corruption of Mr Abbas’s Fatah and the rotten nature of the “Palestinian Authority”. I recall years ago being summoned to the home of a PA official whose walls had just been punctured by an Israeli tank shell. All true. But what struck me were the gold-plated taps in his bathroom. Those taps—or variations of them—were what cost Fatah its election. Palestinians wanted an end to corruption—the cancer of the Arab world - and so they voted for Hamas and thus we, the all-wise, all-good West, decided to sanction them and starve them and bully them for exercising their free vote. Maybe we should offer “Palestine” EU membership if it would be gracious enough to vote for the right people? Advertisement We love Hosni Mubarak of Egypt, whose torturers have not yet finished with the Muslim Brotherhood politicians recently arrested outside Cairo, whose presidency received the warm support of Mrs.—yes Mrs.—George W Bush—and whose succession will almost certainly pass to his son, Gamal. We adore Muammar Gaddafi, the crazed dictator of Libya whose werewolves have murdered his opponents abroad, whose plot to murder King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia preceded Tony Blair’s recent visit to Tripoli—Colonel Gaddafi, it should be remembered, was called a “statesman” by Jack Straw for abandoning his non-existent nuclear ambitions—and whose “democracy” is perfectly acceptable to us because he is on our side in the “war on terror”. Yes, and we love King Abdullah’s unconstitutional monarchy in Jordan, and all the princes and emirs of the Gulf, especially those who are paid such vast bribes by our arms companies that even Scotland Yard has to close down its investigations on the orders of our prime minister—and yes, I can indeed see why he doesn’t like The Independent’s coverage of what he quaintly calls “the Middle East”. If only the Arabs—and the Iranians—would support our kings and shahs and princes whose sons and daughters are educated at Oxford and Harvard, how much easier the “Middle East” would be to control. For that is what it is about—control—and that is why we hold out, and withdraw, favours from their leaders. Now Gaza belongs to Hamas, what will our own elected leaders do? Will our pontificators in the EU, the UN, Washington and Moscow now have to talk to these wretched, ungrateful people (fear not, for they will not be able to shake hands) or will they have to acknowledge the West Bank version of Palestine (Abbas, the safe pair of hands) while ignoring the elected, militarily successful Hamas in Gaza? It’s easy, of course, to call down a curse on both their houses. But that’s what we say about the whole Middle East. If only Bashar al-Assad wasn’t President of Syria (heaven knows what the alternative would be) or if the cracked President Mahmoud Ahmedinejad wasn’t in control of Iran (even if he doesn’t actually know one end of a nuclear missile from the other). If only Lebanon was a home-grown democracy like our own little back-lawn countries—Belgium, for example, or Luxembourg. But no, those pesky Middle Easterners vote for the wrong people, support the wrong people, love the wrong people, don’t behave like us civilised Westerners. So what will we do? Support the reoccupation of Gaza perhaps? Certainly we will not criticise Israel. And we shall go on giving our affection to the kings and princes and unlovely presidents of the Middle East until the whole place blows up in our faces and then we shall say—as we are already saying of the Iraqis—that they don’t deserve our sacrifice and our love. How do we deal with a coup d’état by an elected government? Originally published in Britain’s The Independent on Sunday. Robert Fisk is the Middle East correspondent for The Independent and the author of “The Great War for Civilisation: The Conquest of the Middle East.”
Previous item: The Trial of Saddam Hussein We Never Saw Next item: Truthdigger of the Week: Gen. Antonio M. Taguba New and Improved CommentsWe are launching a major overhaul of our comments section. In addition to more robust spam filtering and moderation, new features include the ability to rate other comments, sort how they are displayed and respond directly via e-mail or in a thread. Unfortunately, commenters will lose their existing Truthdig identities. It's a pain, we know, but on the plus side you will now be able to log in with a plethora of options, including Google, Twitter, Facebook and Disqus accounts. Before launching this system we spent months in discussion with our top commenters. We listened to the feedback and we hope you like what we've come up with. Please direct any problems or concerns to us via our contact page. |
By lilmamzer, June 23, 2007 at 8:41 am Link to this comment
#80669 by Non Credo:
Now Hamas is in power - not because the Palestinians are a bunch of crazy fundamentalists, but because the Palestinians, many of whom are Christian, desperately wanted change, and Hamas was the only electorally available alternative.
There are hardly any Christian Palestinian Arabs in Gaza (a church was burned last week, in fact, by arsonists), and the number in Judea and Samaria is dwindling fast as Muslim-on-Christian repression is growing.
Hamas was not the only available choice, but the fact remains that the Arabs voted for Hamas, and never created the situation for viable, non-violent, non-Jihadi alternatives to flourish. Hamas rules by the sword and the gun. Intimidation is the name of their game.
Don’t you think Hamas was making a point by throwing Fatah members off of roofs last week? And stripping Fatah men naked and them shooting them in front of their families in the street?
That’s called Palestinian Arab politics.
Report thisBy lilmamzer, June 23, 2007 at 8:16 am Link to this comment
#80670 by http://www.fatimatalk.com:
Palestinians have had the courage to elect whom they believe is capable of snatching their rights from the jaws of the occupier.
How many Jews were living in Gaza when Hamas was elected?
—————————
Beginning with the immoral embargo imposed to not only punish the choice of the people, but also the people for their choice. With a dramatically increasing rate of families living in demeaning poverty, almost 65% in Gaza, such an embargo is stripped off any moral justifications.
It would be immoral NOT to embargo Hamas. There is so much aid money flowing into Gaza that Hamas spends on explosives and RPG’s and Kassam missiles. Screw the people of Gaza who voted for Hamas. That was their choice and imposes absolutely no obligation for freedom-loving people to support them for that decision.
————————
America will continue to ignore the fact that resistance has become a way of life for Palestinians, that resistance is not merely a phase of its struggle against an illegitimate occupation.
Arabs will continue to ignore the fact that Jewish resistance to genocide and aggression has become a means of survival for the nation, and IS but one phase of the eternal renewal of Jewish sovereignty in Israel. Peace will come, but not by capitulation to Arab genocide and violence.
——————————-
Resistance is an idea, and ideas do not die.
Jews will resist the extermination philosophy of Hamas and Israel will live and prosper long after Hamas is only footnote in history books.
Report thisBy www.fatimatalk.com, June 23, 2007 at 7:28 am Link to this comment
Palestinians have had the courage to elect whom they believe is capable of snatching their rights from the jaws of the occupier. Yet is seems the Palestinian National Authority is next on the list of elected governments targeted and perhaps overthrown by American foreign policy, more specifically by its tools in the region. Beginning with the immoral embargo imposed to not only punish the choice of the people, but also the people for their choice. With a dramatically increasing rate of families living in demeaning poverty, almost 65% in Gaza, such an embargo is stripped off any moral justifications.
From day one, Hamas continued to call for a unity government, although it received no real power from Abu Mazen. Hamas offered a 10-year seize fire, it adhered to a unilateral cease-fire for 18 months, and yet these actions found no echo from the international community and world media.
Another cynical step attempted by America was to supply the architects of destabilization with money, weapons, and advice, to purue the American agenda in Palestine. The recent events in Gaza that have restored security for the first time in months, have been repeatedly been described as a coup. Ironically, it is Abbas who has unlawfully replaced the winning government lead by Ismail Haniyeh with a new Fatah- lead government (the losing party in parliamentary elections). All of this under harsh circumstances Hamas withstands, beginning with the threat of assassinations, to the economic embargo, to the imprisonment of many of its parliament members!
America will continue to live under the delusion that it can cast away the will of the people, that figures such as Mahmoud Abbas can be propped up indefinitely in the face of an eager urge for change. America will continue to ignore the fact that resistance has become a way of life for Palestinians, that resistance is not merely a phase of its struggle against an illegitimate occupation. Resistance is an idea, and ideas do not die.
Report thisBy www.fatimatalk.com, June 23, 2007 at 7:24 am Link to this comment
If anyone thinks that Arabs and Zionists will ever live side by side in peace, they are fooling themselves.
Report thisThe occuppier and the occuppied can never treat eachother as equal humanbeings, let alone friends and citizens of the same land.
What needs to happen is for Palestinians to have their land back, the whole Palestine.Israeli’s should leave to their origianl countries e.g. Russia , Hungary, Britian etc.
The 4 million Palestinian refugees should return to their land.
It needs only a little education to know that Zionists aided with American and Europe occuppied Palestine unlawfully.
Reverse that mistake, and the Middle East will nourish and prosper.
By Fatima AbdulRahman, June 23, 2007 at 7:12 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
Thank you Robert Fisk !!
American foreign policy will continue to ignore the reality of Hamas, the suffering of Palestinians within their country, and the 4 million Palestinians in exile waiting to return to their homeland, until oneday they wake-up to a horrifying reality!!
The last sentence in Fisk’s article is quite insightfull. We cant describe what Hamas has done in Gaza as a <coup>, they are the winning elected party! America thinks it can prop up Abbas indefinetely against the Palestinian urge to change!
Why cant the international community acknowledge the fact that a peace agreement will never end the conflict.
Palestinians have been thrown out of their land in 1948. Zionists from all around the world occuppied Palestine, America and Europe love it ofcourse..!..They have just guaranteed a threat to the entire Arab world, so they can continue stealing oil, and kill any hope of Arab revolution and development.
Best Regards
Report thisBy lilmamzer, June 23, 2007 at 7:09 am Link to this comment
#80661 by TDoff:
Enough, Mr. Olmert, its time to tear down your walls and give Palestine back to the Palestinians.
The Jews of Israel ARE the “Palestinians”.
“Palestine” was a name invented by the Romans 2000 years ago when they occupied Israel and tried, unsuccessfully, to remove the Jewish identity from the homeland. Before the re-establishment of Jewish sovereignty in Israel in 1948, Jews from say, Jerusalem and Tel Aviv were called “Palestinian”. It did not mean “Arab”.
The local “Palestinian” Arabs are ethnically Egyptian, and Jordanian.
Keep the fence, Olmert, until the local Arabs stop trying to slaughter the children of Israel. The good news is that the fence is working.
Report thisBy TDoff, June 23, 2007 at 7:01 am Link to this comment
The way to solve the Palestinian problem is for the US to elect a human, liberal ‘Ronald Reagan’ as president, someone who will stand eyeball-to-eyeball with Olmert, and say, ‘Enough, Mr. Olmert, it’s time to tear down your walls and give Palestine back to the Palestinians’.
Report thisBy Fatima AbdulRahman, June 23, 2007 at 6:48 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
Thank you Robert Fisk !!
American foreign policy will continue to ignore the reality of Hamas, the suffering of Palestinians within their country, and the 4 million Palestinians in exile waiting to return to their homeland, until oneday they wake-up to a horrifying reality!!
The last sentence in Fisk’s article is quite insightfull. We cant describe what Hamas has done in Gaza as a <coup>, they are the winning elected party! America thinks it can prop up Abbas (leader of the losing party in parlimentary elections) indefinetely against the Palestinian urge to change!
Why cant the international community acknowledge the fact that a peace agreement will never end the conflict??!!
Palestinians have been thrown out of their land in 1948. Zionists from all around the world occuppied Palestine, America and Europe love it ofcourse..!..They have just guaranteed a threat to the entire Arab world, so they can continue stealing oil, and kill any hope of Arab revolution and development.
Best Regards
Report thisBy P. T., June 23, 2007 at 2:09 am Link to this comment
Here is a link to an article about U.S. and Israeli plans for a coup against the Palestinian government. http://www.guardian.co.uk/israel/Story/0,,2108926,00.html
Report thisBy jeremy, June 22, 2007 at 11:56 pm Link to this comment
I think that Jews gobblin’ up the “Palestinians” thing is definitely true. Those Jews man, always causin’ trouble. It’s what I was always taught, them Jews ain’t nothin’ but trouble.
I can really picture those large-mouthed Jews just gobblin’ up all those poor “Palestinians,” eatin up all their babies and everything. It’s just sad, really, that more people don’t know about the poor “Palestinians” and their fight with them Jews. That they eat the babies, too, the poor “Palestinian” babies.
And that 22% thing is probably true, too. I once got Jewed out of like 75% of my rent, and I was supposed to get 10% off in the first place. I bet those Jews won’t stop until they get 100% of the “Palestinian” babies for their ritual sacrifices.
I just wish those fat cats down in Washington would stop helping them Jews so much. We should be helpin’ the Arabs, because they is got alls the oil. Who cares how they treat their women, each other, or us Americans? Who cares if they worship a culture of death? We should talk to ‘em and help ‘em because they’re just tryin’ to kill some Jews.
Problem is, the Jews control Washington too. Those darn pesky Jews is everywhere you turn. Sometimes they’ll jump out of dark alleys when you’re walking alone at night. “Jew! Jew!” they yell.
Report thisBy WriterOnTheStorm, June 22, 2007 at 7:36 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
Cheers again to TD, one of the few places where one can find an alternative to the relentless spin coming out of mainstream media on this issue. But I can’t help thinking it’s a pity that I feel the need to congratulate Mr Fisk for doing something that should be obvious and natural to everyone - recognizing the facts.
I’m sure someone will correct me if I’m wrong but I don’t recall the CNWhatevers even once pointing out the simple fact that Israel and the US have thrown up every obstacle they could muster, including military invasion, in their shifty maneuvers to oust the elected representatives of the Palestinian people.
Why is no one upset about this? Perhaps we only have the emotional capacity to absorb one middle-eastern megablunder at a time. Well I say Iraq is a lost cause - except for political price the neocons are going to have to pay. But this new development in Palestine could ruin the chance of mid-east peace for generations.
When I see what a mess these people are making out there, I can easily understand why some countries want to go nuclear. Apparently, it’s the only “Keep Out” sign these meddlers can read.
Report thisPage 2 of 2 pages < 1 2