14 States Take Health Care Bill to Court
Posted on Mar 23, 2010
The attorneys general of Alabama, Colorado, Florida, Idaho, Louisiana, Michigan, Nebraska, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, South Dakota, Texas, Utah, Washington and Virginia are suing over the health care reform bill, citing state sovereignty and alleging federal overreach under the Commerce Clause of the Constitution.
That’s the part of the Constitution that says Washington has the right to regulate interstate commerce, a bit of language recognized by Supreme Court after Supreme Court as the justification for many a federal intrusion into state affairs. This time, say the attorneys general, the feds have gone too far.
Christian Science Monitor:
At a press conference in Florida, McCollum said his lawsuit is intended to move through the courts to the US Supreme Court. “I am confident the court is going to declare the new healthcare law unconstitutional,” he said.
Democratic leaders have downplayed any potential legal problems with the healthcare reform package. Many legal analysts agree with them. Others suggest the issue is open and could produce a landmark decision if the high court decides to take it up.