|
|
May 26, 2013
|
|
High Court Scrutinizing Affirmative Action at CollegesPosted on Feb 21, 2012
A hot-button issue from the ’80s and ’90s has come up once again at the U.S. Supreme Court: affirmative action on the college level. On Tuesday, the robed powers that be at SCOTUS agreed to take on a case concerning the University of Texas at Austin’s admissions policy, specifically regarding race and ethnicity. —KA
Advertisement New and Improved CommentsIf you have trouble leaving a comment, review this help page. Still having problems? Let us know. If you find yourself moderated, take a moment to review our comment policy. |
By gerard, February 22, 2012 at 4:14 pm Link to this comment
Mixed-blood applicants must give them fits!
Report thisBy felicity, February 22, 2012 at 12:41 pm Link to this comment
Marian - Actually Rove tried to ‘buy’ a degree. He was
Report thisasked to speak at a college and asked it in return to
award him an honorary degree (because he didn’t have a
legitimate one, it seems.) The college turned him
down. Of course, that was then and this is now when
everything is for sale - for a price.
By bpawk, February 22, 2012 at 10:06 am Link to this comment
There should be interviews with no names involved (the interviewer asks questions and fills out forms but no names are used but each person given a number for ID) as well as blind applications where race (or even age) is not a factor - keep it anonymous. That way it is based on merit. Not unlike scientists testing products and applicants where it is done blind, even to the scientist.
Report thisBy Marian Griffith, February 21, 2012 at 3:26 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
@felicity
Why limit yourself to buying your way into college.
Report thisA degree is free speech too, so you should by able to buy as many of them as you want.
By John M, February 21, 2012 at 2:17 pm Link to this comment
http://public.econ.duke.edu/~psarcidi/grades_4.0.pdf
If affermative action results in minority students at elite schools having much potential but
Report thisweak preparation, then we may expect minority students to start off behind their majority
counterparts and then catch up over time. Indeed, at the private university we analyze, the
gap between white and black grade point averages falls by half between the studentsífreshmen
and senior year. However, this convergence masks two e§ects. First, the variance of grades
given falls across time. Hence, shrinkage in the level of the gap may not imply shrinkage in
the class rank gap. Second, grading standards di§er across courses in di§erent majors. We
show that controlling for these two features virtually eliminates any convergence of black/white
grades. In fact, black/white gpa convergence is symptomatic of dramatic shifts by blacks from
initial interest in the natural sciences, engineering, and economics to majors in the humanities
and social sciences. We show that natural science, engineering, and economics courses are
more di¢ cult, associated with higher study times, and have harsher grading standards; all of
which translate into students with weaker academic backgrounds being less likely to choose
these majors. Indeed, we show that accounting for academic background can fully account for
di§erences in switching behaviors across blacks and whites
By John M, February 21, 2012 at 2:16 pm Link to this comment
http://public.econ.duke.edu/~psarcidi/grades_4.0.pdf
If affermative action results in minority students at elite schools having much potential but
Report thisweak preparation, then we may expect minority students to start o§ behind their majority
counterparts and then catch up over time. Indeed, at the private university we analyze, the
gap between white and black grade point averages falls by half between the studentsífreshmen
and senior year. However, this convergence masks two e§ects. First, the variance of grades
given falls across time. Hence, shrinkage in the level of the gap may not imply shrinkage in
the class rank gap. Second, grading standards di§er across courses in di§erent majors. We
show that controlling for these two features virtually eliminates any convergence of black/white
grades. In fact, black/white gpa convergence is symptomatic of dramatic shifts by blacks from
initial interest in the natural sciences, engineering, and economics to majors in the humanities
and social sciences. We show that natural science, engineering, and economics courses are
more di¢ cult, associated with higher study times, and have harsher grading standards; all of
which translate into students with weaker academic backgrounds being less likely to choose
these majors. Indeed, we show that accounting for academic background can fully account for
di§erences in switching behaviors across blacks and whites
By felicity, February 21, 2012 at 1:25 pm Link to this comment
Given the Citizens United decision, it’s pretty
obvious that the Court will eliminate affirmative
action at colleges. (By the way, 72% of political ad
spending during the 2010 elections would have been
prohibited before Citizens United.)
Maybe the Court will decide that grades, the SAT,
Report thisaffirmative action should be eliminated as criteria
for college admittance and replace them with everyone
has a right to BUY his/her admittance into a college.
Certainly be consistent with the Citizens United
decision. (If you can buy an election you should
surely be able to buy your way into college.)