Mar 10, 2014
Ellsberg: Snowden Made Right Decision by Leaving America
Posted on Jul 8, 2013
In an op-ed in The Washington Post on Sunday, whistle-blower Daniel Ellsberg explains why he believes NSA leaker Edward Snowden made the correct decision when he exited the U.S. and sought asylum elsewhere. Ellsberg, who acknowledged comparisons to Snowden, argues that he was able to remain in the U.S. after leaking the Pentagon Papers because, “The country I stayed in was a different America, a long time ago.” The former Truthdigger of the Week notes that Snowden would be greeted with a much different fate and, as a result, Ellsberg disagrees with those who compare Snowden to him unfavorably for leaving.
“When I surrendered to arrest in Boston, having given out my last copies of the papers the night before, I was released on personal recognizance bond the same day,” Ellsberg writes. “Later, when my charges were increased from the original three counts to 12, carrying a possible 115-year sentence, my bond was increased to $50,000. But for the whole two years I was under indictment, I was free to speak to the media and at rallies and public lectures.”
Ellsberg continues: “There is no chance that experience could be reproduced today, let alone that a trial could be terminated by the revelation of White House actions against a defendant that were clearly criminal in Richard Nixon’s era—and figured in his resignation in the face of impeachment—but are today all regarded as legal (including an attempt to ‘incapacitate me totally’).”
Instead, the fate that Snowden would likely meet if he stayed in—or returns to—the U.S. would be completely different from the one that Ellsberg encountered. He points out that there’s little to zero chance that Snowden would even be offered bail. And most likely, if Snowden ever does come back, he will be tossed into jail like another whistle-blower: Pfc. Bradley Manning.
Ellsberg speculates that Snowden would probably be confined to total isolation like Manning, except for a much longer period than the eight months the WikiLeaks source was forced to endure in conditions that the United Nations Special Rapporteur for Torture described as “cruel, inhuman and degrading.” For Ellsberg, that’s reason enough for other countries to grant Snowden’s asylum request.
Ultimately, however, Ellsberg believes Snowden didn’t do anything wrong by releasing top-secret documents about the National Security Agency’s surveillance programs.
“More than 40 years after my unauthorized disclosure of the Pentagon Papers, such leaks remain the lifeblood of a free press and our republic,” Ellsberg writes. “One lesson of the Pentagon Papers and Snowden’s leaks is simple: secrecy corrupts, just as power corrupts.”
—Posted by Tracy Bloom.
Next item: Dozens Dead After Clashes in Egypt (Video)
New and Improved Comments