|
|||
|
Death by Firing SquadPosted on Apr 24, 2010
In a throwback to Utah’s Wild West past, convicted murderer Ronnie Lee Gardner has requested, as per state law, to be executed by firing squad. The request sets the stage for what almost certainly will be a contested debate on capital punishment. Gardner would be only the third person to be killed by the method in the U.S. since 1976. —JCL
Advertisement New and Improved CommentsWe are launching a major overhaul of our comments section. In addition to more robust spam filtering and moderation, new features include the ability to rate other comments, sort how they are displayed and respond directly via e-mail or in a thread. Unfortunately, commenters will lose their existing Truthdig identities. It's a pain, we know, but on the plus side you will now be able to log in with a plethora of options, including Google, Twitter, Facebook and Disqus accounts. Before launching this system we spent months in discussion with our top commenters. We listened to the feedback and we hope you like what we've come up with. Please direct any problems or concerns to us via our contact page. |
By PatrickHenry, April 25, 2010 at 6:06 pm Link to this comment
If we are to have a death penalty, might as well have an economic one.
Report thisBy William W. Wexler, April 25, 2010 at 5:15 pm Link to this comment
By mike112769, April 25 at 9:31 pm #
Hey William W. Wexler: If you think Glenn Beck is a shithead, why are you using his link to reinforce your argument?
————————————————
Don’t worry. We all have those posts we’d like to take back.
DOH!
Report thisBy mike112769, April 25, 2010 at 4:31 pm Link to this comment
Hey William W. Wexler: If you think Glenn Beck is a shithead, why are you using his link to reinforce your argument?
Report thisBy Robert, April 25, 2010 at 4:17 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
I think Seth is way off base here.
Anyone who has studied the Mountain Meadows Massacre knows that the Mormons of that day all took an Oath of Vengeance in their temple vows – that they would avenge the blood of Joseph and Hyrum Smith should they ever encounter any individual who took part in their killings.
Unfortunately for the outsiders traveling through Southern Utah, one of their own boasted while in Cedar City that he had had a hand in the killing of Joseph Smith. And in doing so he sealed the fate of the entire party. The Mormon leadership determined that in order to honor their oaths, they had to kill this guy, but by allowing the others to continue to California where they would relate the deed, it could bring to Utah Territory an army against the Mormons. So they determined to kill all but the youngest of children. Those who could not yet speak. And one of the really terrible things that happened in this crime was that those children were then adopted into Mormon homes and raised as Mormons.
Anyway, the Oath of Vengeance is only a manifestation of the doctrine of Blood Atonement, which states that there are some sins so heinous that the blood of Christ cannot atone for them. And that only the blood of the individual can bring him hope of forgiveness and salvation.
The list of unforgiveable sins at various times has included apostacy (leaving the church), murder, adultery, homosexuality, and in this special circumstance, anyone who had a hand in the killings of Joseph and Hyrum Smith. The church did away with the Oath of Vengeance in the early 20th century when it was determined nobody who could have been a part of those killings could still be alive.
Although the state is no longer overwhelmingly Mormon, Mormons continue to dominate the state government and social life. And they have ensured the firing squad remain an option so that Mormons like Gary Gilmore who committed an ‘unforgiveable’ offense could choose to atone for his own sin by having his own blood shed, as Christ’s blood was shed for all the rest of us who have less serious sins.
Acknowledging that true history, and the impact it continues to hold today does not make anyone who dares relate it ignoramus. Nor does it excuse the crimes committed against the Mormons at other times, such as the Hauns Mill Massacre. However, that is another incident entirely that has nothing to do with the doctrine of Blood Atonement. In fact, Hauns Mill was a reaction to the Mormons burning an entire town down, and by Sidney Rigdon (the 2nd most powerful man in early day Mormonism) from declaring that Jackson County belonged to the Mormons and all the non Mormons would either convert or be forced out by the bayonnete.
Trying to compare anyone who simply relates LDS history as it factually happened to someone who would have taken part in Wounded Knee is desperate. It is entirely illogical.
Report thisBy diman, April 25, 2010 at 2:46 pm Link to this comment
“Critics say the method is a relic from the state’s Wild West past and should be abolished”
Well, I guess, then the lethal injection is a sign of a highly evolved and humane society, what a bunch of hypocrites.
Report thisBy nemesis2010, April 25, 2010 at 12:23 pm Link to this comment
@ William W. Wexler:
What part of “has requested” do you not understand? Isn’t he just as dead at the end of the day?
Report thisBy William W. Wexler, April 25, 2010 at 12:18 pm Link to this comment
Seth…
I take it you’re a Mormon.
If so, you’re a cultist nutjob and I don’t have to bring your PAST up to criticize you, I can bring up your PRESENT, which is the topic of today’s conversation on EXECUTION by FIRING SQUAD because of MORMON BLOOD ATONEMENT.
You don’t have any idea about what my history is. You know nothing about me, so what makes you think you can take this argument to me personally? Your misplaced sense of Mormon superiority over everyone else?
For all you know I might even be black descended from slaves. If that were the case, then you could tell me I’m cursed, it says so in the Bible and that’s what Mormons believe. Or maybe I’m a woman, in which case I should just shut my mouth and spit babies out of my vagina like it’s a tommy gun or a clown car. Or even worse, maybe I’m an excommunicated Mormon, an apostate, some cursed person that you’re not even allowed to speak to.
Please spare me your cracked interpretation of history. What happened at Mountain Meadows is an atrocity committed by the founders of your cult. It’s WORSE than what Charles Manson’s cult did, they only killed 7 people. Your founder Brigham Young ordered over 100 killed in cold blood.
You know, American history is filled with lots of disgusting incidents, and you’re right to mention that the way white people stole this country from natives and built it with slave labor is revolting. So are the lot of imperial wars we’ve picked, so is being the only country to use nukes, and so are a lot of things. We have a lot of baggage as a nation.
But the connection between Mormons in 1857 and Mormons today is a direct one. It is alive, it lives on in the cult practices of people who follow the psychotic ramblings of a petty thief turned murderer named Joe Smith. It’s alive in the wily political maneuverings of polygamist then polygamy denouncer and murderer Brigham Young. It’s alive in the Mormon President who claims that God speaks through him. It’s alive in the Doctrines and Covenants and the Book of Mormon and the 12 Apostles and the “elders” and secret rituals. It lives in Mormons today from the holes in their t-shirts to the crap stains in their temple garments.
Yeah, there’s a direct connection from Mountain Meadows to the President’s desk in SLC and no amount of wishful thinking is going to change that. It’s the biggest mass murder in America by a religious cult. Nice.
Now what were you saying to me about history?
-Wexler
Report thisBy skulz fontaine, April 25, 2010 at 8:16 am Link to this comment
Gardner is a psychopath. Gardner is a murderous psychopath. Gardner earned
Report thishis right to face the firing squad the old fashioned way, he psychopathically
murdered. Gardner is akin to a rabid dog and rabid dogs are routinely ‘put
down’. Utah’s firing squad practice is arcane if not medieval but, at least Utah
gave up the gallows. Wow, ain’t “progress” simply amazing?
Capital punishment is certainly an enigma wrapped tightly inside a conundrum
and yet given the wars that America is about the business of in “our modern
world”, the death sentence seems profoundly status quo. A ‘death sentence’
ranks right up there with state sanctioned torture, wars of naked aggression,
John Yoo, Glenn Beck, and Obama’s “McChrystal surge strategy in Afghanistan.”
Utah and “Mormons” will not now nor ever be dragged into the twenty first
century. (see comments by W W Wexler) It is a given that Utah is Mormon
occupied territory. To live in Utah is to at least pay lip service to the Mormon
occupation. Yeah, I live Utah. Any “distraction” caused by Mormon occupation
or whatever simply detracts from the evil that is Ronnie Lee Gardner.
Utah has the right to terminate Gardner’s existence. Some cancers must be
surgically excised from a body. An ugly axiom and I can admit that.
Back to the ‘wars’ mystique and given American fascination with brutal violence
and extrajudicial killing, Gardner is to be executed and what’s the big deal?
By Seth R., April 25, 2010 at 6:44 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
OK William,
If you’re going to call modern Mormons barbaric for an isolated massacre that occurred nearly 200 years ago, do I get to do the same to you?
Perhaps I should say that William here is “the same kind of people who committed the Wounded Knee massacre.” Ever heard of Hauns Mill? Maybe William is willing to own that piece of history.
Or maybe not. Maybe he is simply an ignoramus who feels free to criticize the history of others simply because he’s clueless about his own.
Report thisBy Michael, April 25, 2010 at 6:29 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
It seems slightly less (very slightly less) barbaric to allow him to choose.
Report thisBy By Deb, April 25, 2010 at 5:31 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
Actually, he should be killed the same way his victim was killed!
Report thisBy Screwjak21, April 24, 2010 at 8:19 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
Frankly I dont care what happens to this inmate. He killed an innocent person in cold blood, he deserves the death penalty. Why should the taxpayers pay to keep him locked up in a cell for the rest of his trivial life. Is it really that “barbaric” to sentence a murderer to death?
Report thisBy William W. Wexler, April 24, 2010 at 7:35 pm Link to this comment
“One may call it barbarism, but enforcing your point of view on someone else is even more barbaric.”
Really? Exactly what do you mean by “enforcing”? There is a legitimate debate going on among civilized people in which one side (correctly) points out that the death sentence itself is not only barbaric but is un-Constitutional. Most of the civilized world has discontinued executions, which puts the US in with some pretty interesting company.
I’m not trying to enforce my view on anyone, I’m stating my opinion. What does it have to do with Mormons? You decide. They’re the ones who kept the firing squad law on the books until 2004. The MAJORITY state population of Mormons, I mean.
Seems to me that stating your opinion has a lot less barbaric content to it than standing 20 feet from a prisoner and pumping 4 bullets into them. If I could enforce my opinion the guy would serve life without parole. Just sayin’.
“Rest assured, though, that I would not base my argument in favor of this man’s choice of death on ANYTHING said by Glenn Beck.”
Well, I don’t know if Beck has said anything about it or not. If he has, he’s probably stated that attempts to do away with the death penalty are a sure sign that Marxists have taken control of the government.
He’s a shithead.
Report thisBy John Kace, April 24, 2010 at 7:11 pm Link to this comment
Distraction. I didnt read this story the first time I saw it and I didnt read it here. Its nothing but a distraction to stir emotion.
Report thisBy Kaelieh, April 24, 2010 at 5:42 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
If you’re going to be executed you might as well be able to choose how they’re going to do it. Seems like it should be your right, or at least the fair thing to do.
Report thisBy mike112769, April 24, 2010 at 3:59 pm Link to this comment
Who gives a damn about Mormons? Who mentioned Mormons? Not everyone in Utah is a Mormon. They are just as weird as any other religion.
Report thisThis man is going to die. If he wants to be shot in the heart, that’s his choice. At least he’ll get to be outside in the fresh air when he dies, instead of strapped to a bed in front of a roomful of witnesses like a rat in a cage.
One may call it barbarism, but enforcing your point of view on someone else is even more barbaric. Rest assured, though, that I would not base my argument in favor of this man’s choice of death on ANYTHING said by Glenn Beck.
By edWatters, April 24, 2010 at 3:10 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)
ONLY three people executed by firing squad since 1976. Sounds like a lot to me.
Report thisEsp in a country that thinks of itself as civilized.
By samosamo, April 24, 2010 at 2:37 pm Link to this comment
Mormons will probably only object to it not being a public event
because that religion is all too akin, to say the jewish mafia, and
compassion was never something to get in the way of either of
those organized crime family’s idea of justice. Besides, if the guy
is guilty and condemned to death and wants to go out that way,
let him.
Amazing, with the amount of blood all over america’s collective
Report thisbody, how people jump out to invoke the sanctity of human life,
even of a cold blooded killer, its like he could turn out to be the
second coming of bejeezus.
By William W. Wexler, April 24, 2010 at 12:28 pm Link to this comment
This is exactly the kind of barbarism I would expect from the Mormons. These are the same people who, under leadership of Brigham Young and the guise of being “Indians”, slaughtered a wagon train passing through their territory in 1857. The Fancher-Baker party was stopped at Mountain Meadows and under seige by the Mormons. They were talked into surrendering, and on September 11, 1857, after surrendering to the Mormons, they were slaughtered in cold blood, every man, woman and child over age 2.
http://glennbeckreport.com/2009/11/glenn’s-cult-membership/
The Mormons control the government of Utah and blood atonement is one of their many cult beliefs. For some sins, if you’re going to become a god, (another one of their heresies) you have to shed your blood on the ground. Literally. Blood. On the ground.
Crackpots.
-Wexler
Report this