![]() |
![]() |
||
|
Remembering Sacco and VanzettiPosted on Aug 23, 2009
Eighty-two years ago Sunday two Italian immigrants were executed after a dubious trial for murders someone else later confessed to. Whatever really happened, Ferdinando Sacco and Bartolomeo Vanzetti have come to stand for the greater inequities of American justice. The pair may have been guilty, as Upton Sinclair is reported to have suspected. But it is difficult to imagine that their status as immigrants, workers and political radicals did not influence their trial, which was later ruled unfair. And it was because “the unfairness was flagrant,” as historian Howard Zinn put it, that Sacco and Vanzetti’s fate should deeply trouble us all: “The case of Sacco and Vanzetti revealed, in its starkest terms, that the noble words inscribed above our courthouses, ‘Equal Justice Before the Law,’ have always been a lie. Those two men, the fish peddler and the shoemaker, could not get justice in the American system, because justice is not meted out equally to the poor and the rich, the native born and the foreign born, the orthodox and the radical, the white and the person of color.” Read more of Zinn’s 2007 essay. Visit the Sacco and Vanzetti Commemoration Society. Fifty years after they were executed in Massachusetts, Gov. Michael Dukakis proclaimed Sacco and Vanzetti were killed without a fair trial. Read a news story from the period here. —PS Elsewhere: . CommentsAre you a Truthdig member yet? Login now, or register with Truthdig. Add Your Comment
|
A Progressive Journal of News and Opinion. Editor, Robert Scheer. Publisher, Zuade Kaufman.
Copyright © 2009 Truthdig, L.L.C. All rights reserved. |
By Augustus, August 24 at 2:20 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)
I was a student of Howard Zinn at Boston University decades ago. He was and
Report thiscontinues to be a mentor. A truly remarkable human being, his voice will never be
silenced. Thank you Howard, and thank you TruthDig.
By NYCartist, August 24 at 10:12 am #
P.S. I think today is Howard Zinn’s birthday.
Report thisSo please allow me to recommend my favorite book,
Howard Zinn’s autobio/memoir,
“You Can’t Be Neutral on A Moving Train”, Boston:
Beacon Press, 2003 edition (the introduction is
wonderful as “stand alone” piece) - it’s a handbook
for social change, as well as the man’s story
told by him. Viva Howard Zinn!
By NYCartist, August 24 at 10:08 am #
Amazing! Under the heading of “like minds”:
I saw the title and went to get the link to Howard Zinn’s column url on the Progressive Mag. before I
read the article text. It’s still good to have the link: http://www.progressive.org/zinn
Thanks for all things Howard Zinn. Also see the
Report thiswebpage http://www.howardzinn.org
By photoshock, August 24 at 6:43 am #
Of course, there is no such thing as, ‘Equal justice before the law, for all!’
Report thisMoney and power and privilege have always trumped the system of fairness and the equal justice that is supposed to be the hallmark of the American Jurisprudence system. One need only look at the cases is which the death penalty is meted out and you will see the inequity of the system that has become what the founding fathers envisioned.
Even then, in the time of the founding fathers, women and African Slaves were not treated as having any rights whatsoever.
The case of Sacco and Vanzetti though, is one of the hallmarks of the American Injustice System. Playing upon the fears of immigrants and ‘socialists,’ the court and the trial lawyers, put on a sham of a trial. There was no true defense of these two men for the crime they were accused of, they were nowhere near the scene of the crime, yet through amazingly circumstantial evidence and a populace inflamed by the media, these two men were quite wrongly convicted of murder and kidnapping.
It seems to me, that the meting out of justice cannot and will not ever be ‘equal before the law,’ until the system of how we treat defendants is changed and must be changed. In some cases, even today, the defendant is charged on flimsy evidence and is considered guilty until proven innocent. We need only look no further than the ‘witch hunting’ trials of Salem Oregon, where practically the whole town was considered guilty of ‘molesting and killing’ children. A fever of prosecution swept through the whole area and did not stop until these supposedly traumatized children recanted their stories of molestation, baby killing, animal sacrifices and Satanism.
Are we to conclude that because this system is the only one we have that it is truly the best? Never!
Justice reform, prison reform and the reform of the ‘long arm of the law,’ must become a priority in this country or we will see the coming of more and more sham trials for crimes against the state and other seemingly innocuous offenses. A police state is what we live in now, it will become worse and worse should the ‘Far Right Wing Nuts’ have their way and this includes the ‘Blue Dog Democrats’ that were elected in the last election cycle.
These so-called Democrats are nothing more than GOP members in the guise of Progressives, using the cloak of the Democratic Party to get elected to the United States Senate and Congress.