LOGO: Truthdig: Drilling Beneath the Headlines. A Progressive Journal of News and Opinion. Editor, Robert Scheer. Publisher, Zuade Kaufman.Best Political Blog Winner, 2007 Webby Awards, People's Voice and Jury.   On the Campaign Trail : Bill Boyarsky Reports on the Election
 
August 28, 2008
Log in / Register

 Choose a size
Text Size

Reports

Ear to the Ground

A/V Booth

Arts & Culture

Digs
Inside the Data Mine

Truthdig Bazaar more items

 
Ear to the Ground

‘The Good Germans Among Us’

Email this item Email    Print this item Print   
Posted on Oct 15, 2007

Frank Rich of The New York Times argues that although there’s plenty to blame on the Bush administration, a timid Congress and a compliant press, it’s time for the American people to accept at least some responsibility for the Iraq war and its many disastrous episodes. From Abu Ghraib to contractor killing sprees, we the people have known far too much for far too long to feign surprise when things suddenly go sour.

New York Times:

By any legal standards except those rubber-stamped by Alberto Gonzales, we are practicing torture, and we have known we are doing so ever since photographic proof emerged from Abu Ghraib more than three years ago. As Andrew Sullivan, once a Bush cheerleader, observed last weekend in The Sunday Times of London, America’s “enhanced interrogation” techniques have a grotesque provenance: “Verschärfte Vernehmung, enhanced or intensified interrogation, was the exact term innovated by the Gestapo to describe what became known as the ‘third degree.’ It left no marks. It included hypothermia, stress positions and long-time sleep deprivation.”

Still, the drill remains the same. The administration gives its alibi (Abu Ghraib was just a few bad apples). A few members of Congress squawk. The debate is labeled “politics.” We turn the page.

Read more

Email Newsletter

Get truth delivered to your inbox every week.

Previous item: China: Democracy Isn't for Us

Next item: Craig Bitter Over His Treatment by Romney

Jump to Comments

Advertisement


Elsewhere: .

Comments

Are you a Truthdig member yet? Login now, or register with Truthdig.

By Akira_Maritias, October 18, 2007 at 6:46 am #

Which again leads to the fact that SOMEONE would have noticed a friggin’ MISSILE flying over DC to hit the Pentagon-as well as every other place that it had to fly over. Who did they enlist to fly the planes, if it wasn’t a missile? Did they convince Osama to send some of his men to do a strike, so we could come back and attack Osama?

Why do you so desperately want to believe that our government’s only desire is to kill us? You seem to have NO trouble believing that our government would willingly kill thousands of its’ own civilians, so...why remain here? Why not go somewhere like Australia, England, Switzerland, Ukraine, Poland...anywhere but here? Why remain in a country that you KNOW has no qualms with slaughtering you for absolutely NO gain. That would be like living in a mass murderer’s house, knowing that he is a mass murderer, and telling everyone that he is a mass murderer, AND knowing that he would have NO problem killing you. It doesn’t make much sense...so why are you staying in the house when you KNOW that the killer could get you, too?

That goes for all nutjobs who think that the government is secretly plotting to kill us/ruin our lives/destroy the US from the inside. If you’re so positive that this is the truth, why the hell are you staying? Most of the freedoms that America has are reflected in some other big countries, so it sure ain’t for the freedom. Nor is it for the beauty of America, since many countries look just like it. It can’t be for the people, since we have racists, sexists, and religious zealots on every corner (you can find a similar society elsewhere). You’ve got family here, of course, but most people have family overseas as well. Furthermore, if you were oh so positive that the government was evil, wouldn’t you want your family to leave as well? Save them from the evil government?

You have no reason to live in America if you think that it’s evil; and it sure don’t help your case any if you are here while saying that the government is evil (I don’t trust my luck enough to play with fire like that, so why do you?)

Report this

By Conservative Yankee, October 18, 2007 at 4:19 am #
(Unregistered commenter)

107637 by Akira_Maritias on 10/16 at 6:39 pm

“It’s simply not feasible. Argue away that our government is corrupt and greedy, and yes, they are dumb, but if you’re willing to throw away that last part to say that the government carefully calculated a strike, you would have to look at it as if they were smart.”

Or they knew enough to outsource this job.

I lived through the deceit of the Kennedy assassination, Watergate, and Iran Contra… There is no low deed of which this government is not capable.

Report this

By Akira_Maritias, October 16, 2007 at 6:39 pm #

It’s simply not feasible. Argue away that our government is corrupt and greedy, and yes, they are dumb, but if you’re willing to throw away that last part to say that the government carefully calculated a strike, you would have to look at it as if they were smart. A monkey can smack buttons all day; but that don’t mean that he’ll hit the right buttons at the right time to make a carefully calculated move. Similarly, you can’t expect Bush to be a pure moron that managed to pull off an ingenious attack...on himself. No, he’s either a genius or an idiot. Can’t be both.

Of course, if the government found a way to ID everyone in the general area of the Pentagon (pretty much all of DC, ‘cause I think they saw-and heard-a plane coming) and pay them to lie to you, then can you honestly find a good reason why we haven’t found Osama? Why we’re struggling overseas? If it takes no leap of the imagination to assume that our government can kill off thousands of civilians, then make thousands more lie JUST TO START A WAR, one can safely assume that they would be able to FINISH that war.

Unless, of course, Bush’s big plan all along was to throw the entire country into massive debt, make the better part of the world hate us, increase tension between every big nation (and a few little ones), kill off thousands more Americans in a war we can never win, cause more anti-American extremists to crawl out of the gutters of the world, AND singlehandedly make all of America look like a bunch of half-retarded chimps that think that evolution is fake and that the Earth is 6,000 years old...well, need I explain? This ‘plan’ can be nothing more than a very well thought out strike to take down America as a whole; a plan that was in the making ever since George Bush Sr. decided to name his son GW. A plan to destroy the oil companies that GW thrives off of...yeah, I can see it.

Totally ingenious plan with absolutely no pay off, reward, dignity, or intelligence. Why, it almost sounds like a bunch of conspiracy theorists thought this up to hide their sorrow and rage over the fact that a bunch of terrorists managed to attack us on our soil-oh wait.

Never mind rationality; Bush had a plan, and dammit if it don’t sound reasonable that our government did it until you gut this rotten fish and let the juicy insides spill out. Bet that not a one of you morons-and I use that term lightly; I respect some morons more than ones who buy into this conspiracy crap-even once thought of that.

Report this

By Conservative Yankee, October 16, 2007 at 11:53 am #
(Unregistered commenter)

107286 by Akira_Maritias on 10/15 at 2:05 pm

“...they would be MORE than willing to believe that the government paid the repair crews, the bystanders, the Pentagon workers, and the families of the ‘supposedly’ dead passengers on the plane to LIE to you.”

and our government would never do anything like that!

Report this

By Akira_Maritias, October 15, 2007 at 2:05 pm #

Weather, my father worked on the repairs of the Pentagon. My dad isn’t a moron. He saw, quite clearly, that it was NOT a missile. It was a plane.

Whether or not you want to believe it, it was a terrorist hijacking of planes. It was not a cunningly masterful way to send in a missile at such an angle that you would think that EVERYONE would identify it; it was a plane. A plane that struck, and that eyewitnesses saw. A plane that Pentagon workers saw flying towards them.

Of course, if one wants to truly believe that a missile hit the side, they would be MORE than willing to believe that the government paid the repair crews, the bystanders, the Pentagon workers, and the families of the ‘supposedly’ dead passengers on the plane to LIE to you.

Just think, weather: why, oh why would the Bush administration feel the need to lie about THAT of all things? Just think. If a MISSILE hit the Pentagon instead of a plane, wouldn’t Bush FINALLY have a reason to do what he wants? He would be able to proudly hit that button that we were all scared he would hit, and he would nuke Afghanistan. Why? Because they had the ability to send a MISSILE onto our soil.

If it was truly a missile, this would have been MUCH more catastrophic. You put too much faith into the terrorists who did this; you assume that they had the capability to launch missiles at us without it being intercepted or avoided. Nevermind that a missile launch would be picked up by radar, especially PENTAGON radar, and everyone would have been evacuated.

Unless, of course, you think this was a carefully plotted out scheme to hit the Pentagon. In which case the following might shock you:

If we are agreeing that WTC was hit by terrorists, why the hell would the President WANT to hit the Pentagon as well? Let’s say that he intended to attack Afghanistan, and use 9/11 as a reason to do it. Why would he hit the PENTAGON, OF ALL PLACES? He would be literally trying to destroy the military base of operations that he needed in order to attack Afghanistan. Secondly, do you think Bush to be a mastermind...at anything? Bush can’t do shit; you should know that. Did he somehow manage to pull off the most ingenious attack ever and hide it as a terrorist plane strike, then manage to fail at EVERYTHING else that he tried to do?

It’s just not feasible on any level to say that WE sabotaged OURSELVES. Furthermore, it’s not feasible that the terrorists would use a missile, either. Let’s face it: a plane hijack costs NOTHING to do. A missile? That costs quite a bit, although we can see that the missile did a shitty job; it cut a nice plane shaped gash into the Pentagon, instead of blowing it up like any missile would.

Questions? Comments? Angry bitching? Feel free to PM it to me; this does not need to become a public war. I can iron this out with you all day, but I don’t see a point to keeping up the public bickering. If you see a point, I’ll play along-for as long as my patience holds.

Report this

By fretless2012, October 15, 2007 at 12:10 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)

I’m down with WR Curley. Let’s take a page from the immigrant’s (and other’s) playbook and put a day’s wages where our mouth’s are. Let’s do more than that. Why not show some real guts and stage a nationwide TV fast. Indefinitely! You’re damn right we’re complicit (and complacent) Mr. Rich. It’s time we acknowledge responsibility for what they are doing with our money and in our name. Can’t we shake ourselves awake from our perpetual, mindless entertainment long enough to be shocked at the inherent immorality of many of our government’s actions? And if we are complicit, can someone tell me why we, as civilian accomplices to this administration’s crimes, should be off limits to a terrorist’s violent aggressions? We go after their source of money, why not they ours?

Report this

By 7man, October 15, 2007 at 12:07 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)

Before Mr. Rich slides the responsibility for this sad state of affairs onto the shoulders of the average slob (that does deserve some blame for being so trusting), he should look at the role of the media propaganda machine that pays him so well each month. Homeland Security? Why do we have such Nazi jargon presently in our government? The press has an obligation to investigate the ‘real story’, not to be part of the spin and cover-up of government/corporate crimes. While I am glad Mr. Rich is now writing such essays in these dark days, I agree with others that he should have been shouting the same story years ago. We have become a nation of liars. Whom do we trust now? Certainly not The NY Times (thanks Judy).

Report this

By Martin, October 15, 2007 at 10:25 am #
(Unregistered commenter)

I agree mostly with this article. In fact I am seeing the parallels since the election in 2000. I also agree with the ‘guilt’ of the American Public at large. Fascists cannot reign against the majority, but they know how to ride the lowest instincts of a society, the hate and fear, the doubt, and use it for their nefarious purposes. It is the American society at large with its 83% believing in God rate, in whose name those atrocities are committed. And just like the Japanese and German people, the Americans will only give it up after utter defeat.
We will need Tokyo or Nurnberg style tribunals to cleanse the society from this evil pack when they finally fall. Americans have such patience to watch how everything good in their life is being dismantled. They will maybe rise up when the bread lines are getting long.
And just like with the Germans and Japanese will historians find that a violent culture led to the coarsening of people. Murder and killing your enemies in film and video games is brainwashing, just like an emperor cult in Japan or the Fuhrer Kult in Germany. They learned to hate an enemy that the government created out of whole cloth. Jews in Germany, Koreans and Chinese in Japan, Muslims in America. The low instincts are within the people. But the fascists know how to ticke them out.

Report this

By Don Stivers, October 15, 2007 at 9:22 am #

I never voted for this administration and I was always against going to war with Iraq.

I bitched loud and clear.

Who listened?

IS anybody listening?

Does anybody care in our government?

Report this

By weather, October 15, 2007 at 8:30 am #

hate doesn’t motivate me in the least, nor am I interested in pursuing my own little insignificant X file.

I lost 2 friends and lived/worked through the clean-up. The specious link you directed me to fails suture up the one part of the entrails in this choreographed masterpiece, how did the 19 Saudis manage to put a missile into the side of the Pentagon and leave the public to believe it was a commerical airliner? eom

Report this

By WR Curley, October 15, 2007 at 8:21 am #
(Unregistered commenter)

The parallels with Germany in 1938 are apt. Here and now, as there and then, government, industry, and the press collude to marshall a nation into catastrophic adventures. Mr. Rich works for the Times, one of the most powerful of the partners complicit in building the new American fascist state. It might do well, while we’re rolling “hypocrisy” around on the tongue, for the man to acknowledge this fact.

What to do? Shut it all down.

There is a revisionist notion that public protest played no role in the final inglorious demise of our foray into southeast Asia. Not so. I was there. In San Francisco thousands of capitalism’s loyal cadres took a day off to march up Montgomery Street in protest of the crimes being committed in their names. Waves of well-heeled well-dressed well-groomed citizens poured out of the office towers and rolled up the glass canyons chanting their intention to starve the beast fed on the fruits of their talents. The financial district all but shut down.

Let’s all agree on a day - any day - for a nice quiet moratorium. Mr Rich can use his pulpit to help gather the faithful, if he likes. We decline to participate for a day. We decline to earn. We decline to spend. March, if you are so disposed, but it’s not necessary. Stay home, put your feet up, crack a cold one, catch some Oprah (though one hopes she’d stay home too). It will work, people. It has worked before. It will remind our putative masters that they have no power without our cooperation.

We’ve done too much baying at the moon, already. This is not that tough. Let’s just pick a day and shut it all down.

WR Curley
Elizabeth, Colorado

Report this

By Akira_Maritias, October 15, 2007 at 7:51 am #

Weather, just for you:

http://www.thebestpageintheuniverse.net/c.cgi?u=911_morons

All of the proof needed to show why there was no 9/11 conspiracy. 9/11 happened, you don’t need to sniff around for extra reasons to hate your government. It wasn’t a conspiracy by our government, it was a half-baked plan by some terrorists to throw some planes into buildings-and I say that with the tiniest grain of remorse for making it sound so blunt, as I have always felt an immense sorrow at even the slightest mention of 9/11.

Report this

By weather, October 15, 2007 at 7:36 am #

Frank Rich, don’t you dare deflect this near deacde of dark deceit onto the public-at-large.

If the Media were authentic in doing their job w/even a modicum of integrity you would have confronted the Mother of all frauds 9/11 and found that none of these Abu Ghraib, “war” for Oil and Israel schemes wouldn’t have stood a chance to indeliably infect America.

No Frank the self-inflicted crime of the Century took place in your zip code and you were too busy picking out the wall colors for your Renzo Piano bespoke office space.
When the NYTimes has the balls to confront the truth, pls. write us.

Report this

By don knutsen, October 15, 2007 at 7:12 am #

It is easy to look to our vapid media to blame for not bothering to ask the hard questions of our leaders. Its too easy to continue to heap blame on our elected representitives for not pushing back at the criminals in the White House. But, as Mr. Rich points out, its all of us, all of us who have watched this mess unfold day by day, shrug our shoulders as if there is nothing we can do about it that are to blame. How can we expect a change unless more of us take the time to communicate our outrage to our representitives, continuing to do so over and over untill they wake up and begin to do what we ask of them. That is their job, to represent us, not the corporations, us the american people. How many of us take the time to do anything but piss & moan occasionally on the blog-o-spere ? Our system is based on the citizens being involved in it. Over the years most of our country has become complacent, about half of us bother to vote at all, and most never communicate with their representitives, and somehow magically expect them to put our concerns on the table ? This current administration has shown us what you get when most are asleep at the wheel. They are criminals, who snear in contempt at our democracy, and our people. They are following the lead of a very few individuals with a caustic philosophy who are so full of themselves no one else’s opinion matters to them, not former diplomats, world leaders, scientists, or the people of this country. This is not a democracy anymore folks, it is a corporate dictatorship, ran by cheney and its become a criminal enterprise more akin to the mafia then a democracy. Each day they remain in power we are diminished alittle more by the decisions they make and who they make them for. Since the democratic leadership refuses to work towards impeachment, how about we cut to the chase. INDICTMENT..for the exact crimes the nuremberg trials indicted the nazi leadership that was brought to trial 60 yr.s ago..

Count One: Conspiracy to Wage Aggressive War The “common plan or conspiracy”
Count Two: Waging Aggressive War, or “Crimes Against Peace”
Count Three: War Crimes
Count Four: Crimes Against Humanity

These are the leaders of our country today, and they have caused more damage to our country then a dozen Bin Laden’s could ever dream of accomplishing.

Report this

By farmertx, October 15, 2007 at 6:43 am #

Re: Verne Arnold

Uh...it looks to me that the hypocrisy is within our leadership of the Democratic side. They are the ones who could conceivably stop the madness that is going on in Iraq.
The average citizen can do little but stay informed and vote. But, despite our votes, the Democrat’s would rather go after the bribe money, instead of doing their sworn duty.
The Preamble to the Constitution tells us that it is our duty to throw out a Government that is not responsive to the People.
That implies an armed rebellion, something I would dearly like to avoid.
Does anybody know the procedure for calling a Constitutional Convention? It seems to me that we must take that approach and try and work within the system.
It has been proven by the actions of those elected in ‘04 that they are uninterested (at least most are) in changing the status quo.
We have signed petitions and emailed our Congress critter’s, all to no avail, other than getting a canned response thanking us for sharing our opinions.

Report this

By bbkemp, October 15, 2007 at 5:38 am #

None of us want to wind up like those poor bastards in Nazi Germany.  So what if our appointed, anointed and mindless leader claims he cries on God’s shoulder? At this point, we all should. Face it, our top dog has over tugged his leash and shredded his food bowl. The only person who might stop this country’s extinction is the Nancy we put in charge of ?we the people’s’ House. If that well-heeled ?yes’ woman has any sense, she’ll raid Condi’s closet, strap on the jackboots and stomp that rat Cheney before he chomps down on the - you know, freaking button. 

Catch Volt & Electra’s full take on why a full 35% of all Americans already belong to the Neocon’s Nazi Party....CHEERS!
http://www.populistamerica.com/cheers

Report this

By Verne Arnold, October 15, 2007 at 5:38 am #

The New York Times‘ Frank Rich argues that although there’s plenty to blame on the Bush administration, a timid Congress and a compliant press, it’s time for the American people to accept at least some responsibility for the Iraq war and its many disastrous episodes. From Abu Ghraib to contractor killing sprees, we the people have known far to much for far too long to feign surprise when things suddenly go sour.

The American people are collectively responsible for this war at this time.  We have been “at war” in Iraq for almost 5 years: 5 years of proven incompetence (on all levels), 5 years to make a decision, 5 years of gross human rights violations, 5 years of war crimes (by any international standard), 5 years of acquiescence by the electorate, 5 years of destroying our own constitution and bill of rights.  We have had many opportunities to stop this but we don’t…”WE” don’t!!!!  This is supposed to be a democracy, you know, the thing we are spreading across the world; so where is the democratic process in the worlds leading democracy?  If in fact 70% of the American people are truly against this “war” and it doesn’t stop, then I submit, we are a failed “democracy”!  We need to shut up, our hypocrisy is showing.

Report this

By bbkemp, October 15, 2007 at 5:36 am #

None of us want to wind up like those poor bastards in Nazi Germany.  So what if our appointed, anointed and mindless leader claims he cries on God’s shoulder? At this point, we all should. Face it, our top dog has over tugged his leash and shredded his food bowl. The only person who might stop this country’s extinction is the Nancy we put in charge of ?we the people’s’ House. If that well-heeled ?yes’ woman has any sense, she’ll raid Condi’s closet, strap on the jackboots and stomp that rat Cheney before he chomps down on the - you know, freaking button. 

Catch Volt & Electra’s full take on why a full 35% of all Americans already belong to the Neocon’s Nazi Party....and Cheers!

Report this

By Conservative Yankee, October 15, 2007 at 5:13 am #
(Unregistered commenter)

WOW....why did we out here in the hinterlands never think of this?

Does Frank Rich get any of his vast knowledge from the internet? 

Has he ever listened to anti-war folks who DO NOT want Hill-the-business-shill to be the next president, or read any of their ubiquitous criticisms?

I feel like I’m reading last year’s newspaper!

Report this

By farmertx, October 15, 2007 at 5:13 am #

Yes, there has been too much turning of the page.
But when the people ‘spoke’ as they did in ‘04 and elected those who promised some relief from the Shrubs’ version of reality, those who were elected chose to play politics as usual.
Non binding resolutions, meaningless hearings and now a resolution condemning Turkey over an incident a century before?
Yup, America has the best politician’s that money can buy.
And until we force them to quit selling their votes and support to the highest or most powerful bidder, we will get more of the same, just from different folks.

Report this

By Akira_Maritias, October 15, 2007 at 5:08 am #

Great...America’s become just like Nazis, apparently. The only difference is that the ENTIRE country is completely against these actions, and the government is STILL doing it. We aren’t ‘quietly looking away’. What will it take? ALL of America marching on the White House? I hope that we don’t need to do something so drastic, but I honestly believe that nothing else will change the opinions of those doddering apes in Congress and in the White House.

Report this

Add Your Comment

Posts by unregistered readers are moderated. Posts by members
are published immediately. Why wait? Register today!






Notify you when others comment on this article?


Are you a human?
Retype the word you see here.


Please read and abide by our comment policy.
By submitting this comment, you agree to this site's terms and conditions.

Newsletter

Get Truthdig in your inbox

Privacy Policy

 
Click here to advertise with Truthdig
 

 
Join the Liberal Blog Advertising Network
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A Progressive Journal of News and Opinion. Editor, Robert Scheer. Publisher, Zuade Kaufman.
Copyright © 2008 Truthdig, L.L.C. All rights reserved.