LOGO: Truthdig: Drilling Beneath the Headlines. A Progressive Journal of News and Opinion. Editor, Robert Scheer. Publisher, Zuade Kaufman. Winner 2013 Webby Awards for Best Political Website
May 24, 2013

 Choose a size
Text Size

Trending:     chris hedges     economy     elizabeth warren     politics     robert scheer
Most Read

How to Make a Million Dollars an Hour

Colbert Slams PBS for Appeasing Koch Brothers

A Call to Action

Obama Heckled During Speech, Warren Lands a Book Deal, and More

After Oklahoma Disaster, Give Thanks to Government

Most Comments
Most Emailed

Reports
 * NEW! * A Mission on Climate Change

Ear to the Ground

A/V Booth

Arts & Culture
A Call to Action
Act of Congress

Digs

Truthdig Bazaar more items

 
Arts and Culture

‘Bully’: Zooming In on Childhood Demons

Email this item Email    Print this item Print    Share this item... Share

Posted on Apr 1, 2012
IMDb

By Richard Schickel

Is bullying on the rise in schools around the country? I don’t know. You don’t know. And, most important, Lee Hirsch, director of the documentary “Bully,” doesn’t seem to know either.

The implication of his film is that it probably is. “Bully” tells, in its sometimes annoyingly fractured fashion, the story of five teenagers—two of who end up as suicides—who have been victimized in this way, and all of them present sad and instructive tales. On the other hand, the reviews I’ve seen exhibit, or so it seems to me, a certain reluctance to fully embrace the movie. It has been respected by the critics, and it has many celebrity endorsements, but it has been received with a degree of reserve and skepticism. Five case studies do not make a trend, and there is no narration to fill in the larger picture. We pretty much have to accept Hirsch’s implied contention that bullying is a growing problem in the U.S. (A nonsensical “R” rating by the MPAA, a side issue we’ll come to in a minute, has not helped to clarify the issues raised by the film.)

At the center of the film is a 14-year-old named Alex from Sioux City, Iowa. He’s a little funny looking (among the kindest epithets hurled at him is “fishface”), and he is picked on mercilessly, particularly on the school bus (these buses, totally unsupervised by eyes-on-the-road drivers, seem to be a larger part of the problem than Hirsch acknowledges). Alex seems to me essentially a good kid, if possibly a trifle immature for his age. Astonishingly, he takes the view that the bullies are really his friends and that they are just “messing” with him, and that sometime they will cease and desist their egregious behavior.

Fat chance of that, we think. In any case, clueless school officials are consulted, all of who take the view that “boys will be boys.” After a fruitless meeting with an assistant principal, Alex’s mother asserts that she and her husband have been “politicianed,” and that is true not only in Sioux City but everywhere Hirsch goes. The school people’s interest is in preserving the notion that they are presiding over what seems to be a smoothly running system. Occasionally, they take notes on the problem or offer little lectures on good behavior, to which the bullies respond politely but with barely concealed indifference.

The parents do the best they can in this situation, offering the advice that has been standard from time immemorial, which is basically “stand up for yourself.” Sometimes meetings are held and school officials earnestly promise to do something about the situation, though there is little evidence that they will do anything but hold some more meetings. At the end of the film, the father of one of the suicides is holding meetings at which fine speeches are made and balloons are loosed into the sky, symbolizing the freed spirits of the lost children.

It is a gesture not without its poignancy. It is also a gesture not without its impotency. The problem with bullying is that it is an amorphous subject. It’s a problem that has been with us as long as we have sent our kids off to school, where outside the confines of the classroom they have plenty of unsupervised time to, well, “mess around” with people who look or act differently from the norm. The cure for it is, alas, to “outgrow” it, and victims and victimizers mostly do, I suppose—except, of course, for the tragic exceptions, which in some way mark them for life. Or, more tragically, cancel out their lives entirely.

Another way of putting that is that this is not a social problem subject to amelioration by 10-step programs or renewed efforts at good will and patient understanding. It is, I think, an existential problem. There are simply some people who are born to be bad—or at least radically anti-social—and some people who are born to be their victims. I met a few of them when I was kid, and so did you. The answer was avoidance—at which, happily, I was adept. And at changing the subject.

Which is what, finally, the MPAA has done with its “R” rating, based on the fact that the f-word is occasionally used in the film—not, I’m here to tell you, in any way that you’ll notice. The movie is not about language. The people in it are sometimes, in their troubled ways, both articulate and inarticulate. But these figures are all struggling to find words to describe an issue that, as I’ve said, resists anything like an easy definition. It is ludicrous for the ratings board to confine the discussion to a word that does not even register on our consciousness as we watch the film. I don’t think the movie is entirely successful in addressing the problem it is earnestly trying to raise. But the producers are correct to send the movie into the world unrated. And, we may hope, open a discussion about a system that is prissily outdated. Listen to your children and grandchildren. You’ll find they are entirely familiar with the f-word. And a lot of other words and ideas that you would prefer they didn’t know about.

More Below the Ad

Advertisement

Get truth delivered to
your inbox every week.

Previous item: Black Power and Sports Today

Next item: Throwing Up for Peace



New and Improved Comments

If you have trouble leaving a comment, review this help page. Still having problems? Let us know. If you find yourself moderated, take a moment to review our comment policy.

By Eric, April 4, 2012 at 3:16 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

Focusing on physical violence in the schools is
necessary; but what is more important to investigate
are alienated youths. Nobody wants to acknowledge
their bottled up anger over being wronged and
shunned—and for what, acting a little goofy?
Emotional damage is typically more painful than the
physical.

I’m not talking about boosting self esteem, stirring
up egos, and say everyone’s-a-winner. This is about
teaching children how to acknowledge and respect one
another, even if they’re not friends with the person.
I know we can’t make kids like the lame ducks; but we
can certainly discipline them to acknowledge and
respect them as human beings.

Report this

By rosemerry, April 4, 2012 at 3:04 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

I think that anyone has the possibility of being a bully, and the comments and behaviour of adults eg Hillary Clinton, Obama, WBush and all his team show the example set.
The thoughtful comments and practical advice of urekismet give some hope.

Report this

By drs, April 4, 2012 at 1:25 pm Link to this comment

Surfnow obviously has never been bullied.  Consider yourself lucky, dude.

Report this

By Hmmmmmmmmm, April 4, 2012 at 1:07 pm Link to this comment

Bullying isn’t likely any higher than it has always been.  The only thing that has
changed is that it is currently the focus of a society that is desperate to focus on
anything besides the fact that our own government has become the bully on the block
and corporations are its big brother.

Excuse me if I don’t hold my breath while society does only this lip service to how
horrible bullying is… again.  The playground monitors never paid much attention to
these mean little interactions when we were kids.  A few years ago when my son put
himself in the middle of a bully and a victim, he was the one that got in trouble. 
Where was the playground monitor? Not knowing or caring about what really was going
on in the playground, that’s for sure.  That particular bully had be plaguing the
kids for quite a while, so its pretty certain that the monitor wasn’t adequate to the
task on many levels.

These bullies arise out of families that don’t care about them and are dumped in a
society that don’t care about them and when they act out and are not challenged or
counseled, its confirmed to them from all corners that there is no concern for others
to be had or required.

Report this
moonraven's avatar

By moonraven, April 4, 2012 at 11:42 am Link to this comment

surfer:

I object to your promoting bullying on this site.

or anywhere else, for that batter.

I cannot speak to the current schoolyard bully situationon the playgrounds of Gringolandia, but by looking at your foreign policy—which is make war on any country with a dominantly non-white population and grab its resources, what would you expect kids to model?

Gringolandia has always been the biggest and loudest bully on the planet.  Just gran a gander at Hillary the Hateful Hag threateneing Syria, Iran, your mother, etc.  She’s the top gun of your foreign policy and she is a BULLY.

Bullying is on the rise in Mexico’s schools, too—every since the gringos imposed their bogus War on Drugs as a condition of allowing Calderon 6 years in the presidential chair.  75,000 folks murdered.  That’s outsourcing bullying at a newer, faster rate.

Report this

By balkas, April 4, 2012 at 8:52 am Link to this comment

the mother of bullying, belittling, looking dwn on people, racism, warfare, expoitation, wife
beatings, etc., is discrimination.
discrimination started by just first ever biped looking down on or belittling another human being.
the first such an act most likely went ununderstood or even unnoticed by most members of a
settlement.
thus, the misdeed went unpunished or not spoken against.
‘religion’ [organized mafia, really] which arose from discriminating against and belittlement of
some individuals, was its natural consequence.
one could see how easy it is to control a person by just discriminating against herhim.
one could see that the person being discriminated against would burst into anger; s/he may run
away, or withdraw to heal one’s wounds and thus become less fit to adapt to reality.
==
and if ‘teachers’ et al cannot see that grading children in school is DISCRIMINATION AND ROOT OF
ALL EVIL and sees it as a virtue, then we can expect more suicide, withdrawals, feeling sorry for
oneself, murder, etc.

Report this

By diman, April 4, 2012 at 8:44 am Link to this comment

BLAME THE PARENTS !!! AND ONLY THEM!!!

Report this

By Tobysgirl, April 4, 2012 at 8:08 am Link to this comment

Bullying has not been around since the beginning of human existence, and it is not the result of evolution.

We simply did not evolve to live in so-called civilization, which will likely be our downfall. In “pre-conquest consciousness” (pre-civilization) societies, each individual is concerned that every other individual in the group is happy and contented. These people do not know what lying is, what time is, etc. You might say they are still living in the Garden. (An interesting equivalent is the way canines function in your family if they are part of it. They have no concept of time except NOW and don’t want any other family member to be unhappy. Which is why they have much more to teach us than vice versa.)

We live in a bullying society. People are paid lots of money to go on TV and bully each other in reality shows. Then we have the Nancy Graces of the world, who are professional bullies. Beyond this scale, our nation likes to bully people all over the world. Then we fuss about the bullying that children do in imitation of us.

The best thing parents can do is raise their children to be strong and assertive. Boys and girls tried to bully me when I was a kid, and they never tried a second time.

Report this

By surfnow, April 4, 2012 at 4:46 am Link to this comment

Anti-bullying is just more milquetoast, liberal PC.  On the local and state level, like all of the other school guidance department mumbo-jumbo : ADHD, Aspergers and all the other phony syndromes- anti-bullying is designed to create useless jobs and wind up just babying kids and wasting tax dollars.To Korporate Amerika on the federal level its just more good deflection. No ,don’t look over there at the endless wars and MIC, let’s focus on flag-burning, DADT and that schoolyard bullying.

Report this

By Silverado_Lady, April 4, 2012 at 4:23 am Link to this comment

Bullies are the product of their PARENTS. I am willing
to bet that the father’s/mother’s of these kids, do
their best to be JUST AS INTIMIDATING as they can
possibly be and the kids see this kind of action and
follow suite.

Report this

By frankdouglas, April 4, 2012 at 1:17 am Link to this comment

Bullying has always existed in some form throughout
human existence.  And the common response for thousands
of years was violence.  Only in the last few decades
have the first-world nations come to deplore this
response and encourage the emphasis on self-esteem that
has saturated our school systems.

I think a situation like Columbine is more in tune with
a visceral, human response than forgive and forget, as
awful as that sounds.

Report this

By Pierrey, April 3, 2012 at 6:20 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

I think bullying is a part of ‘human nature’. Our society is built on roles of
leadership and followings—teacher-student, boss-employee… and the whole
game of politics really boils down to a big bully-fest [nuclear arms race,
communism vs, capitalism… human history of conquest and colonization].

Don’t we remember our own childhoods? Most of the teen movies in the history
of teen movies deal with bullying as a major plot-point. This is a cross-
cultural, international ‘phenomenon’. Our parents dealt with bullies/where
bullies/both. We were also. We all witnessed acts of bullying in our youth-some
of us acted to stop it, some of us stood idly by, some of us joined in… This is
not new. What is new is how our kids are dealing with it.

To those that ask for criminal punishment, could you explain to me what good
ever came out of putting a child through a correctional facility? Aside from
creating a toughened criminal.

Our role as parents and educators is to prepare our children to navigate the
intricacies of society and be as successful* as possible (*whatever your
definition of success may be). I feel we are doing our children a great disservice
by over-sheltering them. I think a few of the posters here are right and we
need to allow our children to play freely and ‘unsupervised’ and then guide
them in how to resolve conflicts as they occur. Be involved, not over-involved.

also, sometimes, a good ass-whoopin’ from your peers is necessary in order to
learn the lesson.
I learned a few getting my ass kicked. The most important one being how not
to get my ass kicked.

Report this
UreKismet's avatar

By UreKismet, April 3, 2012 at 4:08 pm Link to this comment

I don’t live in amerika (wow you don’t say) but there has been a much greater emphasis placed on bullying in schools here, by both parents and the media.
Is it on the rise?  Maybe - one doesn’t hafta look far to see the probable causes. 
Greater emphasis on the duty of ‘me’ to meet my needs & less on the virtues of living in a co-operative society where everyone matters.

If bullying is more prevalent there are other factors at work here, that make parents want to be more proactive about confronting bullying now.

The first is the disadvantage of children brought up in a society where all parents have to work, usually away from home.  I am a keen advocate of equal pay and the right for everyone to be able to work. 
The problem is that in an unregulated society, one where everything is determined by ‘demand’, it didn’t take many dual income families to increase demand on essentials from increased purchasing power, Eventually dual income families stopped being a choice & became a neccessity for survival.

Parents love their kids so if their time spent together with kids is diminished they put greater emphasis on time spent together.  Nowadays parents are more likely to ‘hear’ their childrens concerns about bullying and try to ‘do something’ about it.

Driving around 21st century suburbs I don’t have to drive slowly concentrating hard not to run over the local kids anymore. 
Once neighbourhood kids would all hang together playing sport, climbing trees, & planning outrages against ‘the oldies’ etc. 

Not now. 

Many kids get left in the charge of minders.  Minders have instructions to take kids swimming, riding, sports training etc.  All play is structured leaving no time for unstructured play with yer neighbours.

This is bad because kids, like adults, generally stick to the ‘ya can pick yer friends but you can’t pick yer neighbours’ that most adults follow.
After a few hiccups local kids left to their own devices usually work out problems and stick together.  All the kids swap social skills about things like bullying and how to deal with it.

This is rarely learned in structured play, where adults supervise and quash any issues themselves denying kids the opportunity to work it out.
Public transport like school buses has always been hard for a kid because many of the passengers only interact together in the time and space they share on the bus. 
Defenses are up, kids don’t have any shared history, and odds are they will lack the skills to defuse situations.

We may think of bullying as being worse for boys, but both genders cop it bad. One of my daughters was getting a pasting every day from some snotty little twerps practising the skills of their trophy wife mums.
You can’t be there all the time to stick up for the child, & chalkies just want an easy life; if they witness something particularly egregious they may intervene, but they are often under the thumb of bully parents.

All a parent can do is to socialise their children.  I put a year or so of intensive work into encouraging other kids from the ‘burb to spend time at our house with my daughter; in increasingly unstructured play.  Provide decent food and some ‘choice’ distractions and kids will come.  As my daughter spent more time with children who weren’t ‘picking on her’ but did have the occasional falling out all children do, her self confidence increased as well as the skills she needed to hold her own among a clutch of bitches.
By the time she started High School it was long behind - apart from an awareness of how that stuff feels & a determination to step in if she saw someone else copping it.

Luck plus my daughter’s determination to deal with her tormentors worked. But parents must make the time.  A kid who’s learnt to interact with humans will have a better life than one who had every piece of consumerist crap growing up.

Report this

By nestoffour, April 3, 2012 at 4:06 pm Link to this comment

Well said, giacomofrugoli.

Report this

By Golady, April 3, 2012 at 1:24 pm Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

Rush Limbaugh is a bully.  George Bush was a bully. Republicans have behaved as bullies—the “my way or the highway crowd”. “You don’t have rights to reproductive Health”  Get raped? Tough!  You will deal with the problem the way we say.  End of discussion. Our state legislatures are full of bullies. Religions are full of bullies. Cover yourself from head to toe, or be stoned.  Get saved or go straight to hell. Even if people are not born bullies, it is no wonder some become bullies. There are plenty of role models.

Report this

By drs, April 3, 2012 at 11:33 am Link to this comment

Bullies should be arrested for assault and suffer appropriate penalties for that crime.  Maybe then the incidence of bullying will decline.

Report this

By dahoit, April 3, 2012 at 9:07 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

It’s a worldwide phenomena committed by liberal hypocrites and their neocon allies against the worlds population,so why wouldn’t kids copy their elders?

Report this

By giacomofrugoli, April 3, 2012 at 9:06 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

No one is “born” to be a bully or a victim, or anything for that matter. This is simply a ludicrous statement (genes do not program behavior, they program protein synthesis). Child abuse, however, does create perpetrators and victims in various contexts, and to some degree, so does culture.

Report this

By dblack, April 3, 2012 at 9:04 am Link to this comment
(Unregistered commenter)

Is anybody else annoyed that this was reviewed by
giving a synopsis of the documentary? I think the
potential impact of seeing Bully is lessened when I know two of the kids “end up as suicides”, and that there is
a heart-wrenching scene where balloons are released. Now I’m EXPECTING these events.

Every other review I’ve read of “Bully” managed to
discuss its merits/downers without disarming the film’s
potential impact.

What the hell truthdig??

Report this

By erinever, April 3, 2012 at 8:14 am Link to this comment

I just find it interesting that Hunger Games, a movie
about a group of teenagers killing each other, was so
widely accepted when a documentary about real life
bullying was met with criticism. LA times had an
interesting article about the two ratings:
http://www.latimes.com/entertainment/news/movies/la-et-ratings-reform-20120317,0,2963068.story

Report this
kerryrose's avatar

By kerryrose, April 3, 2012 at 2:34 am Link to this comment

Do bullies ‘outgrow’ it?  This is an interesting observation/question.  Who are the people that bully mercilessly when they grow up?

Do they normally become society’s victims themselves, or do they institutionalize the bullying and become the sociopaths we know and love?

Report this
Clash's avatar

By Clash, April 2, 2012 at 6:45 pm Link to this comment

It would be a wonderful thing if children could be raised in paradise, taught from the beginning to be human. Evolution though negates this out come, instinctively homo sapien is thrown into an environment of eat or be eaten, survival of the fittest. It is deplorable that children should suffer do to the lack of human intervention in their lives.

Homo sapien:

Killer ape

Human:

HE/SHE who stands ready with the bow to defend the lambs, from the bird of prey or the rabid dog.

Report this
Newsletter

sign up to get updates


 
 
 
 
Join the Liberal Blog Advertising Network
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A Progressive Journal of News and Opinion. Editor, Robert Scheer. Publisher, Zuade Kaufman.
© 2013 Truthdig, LLC. All rights reserved.