LOGO: Truthdig: Drilling Beneath the Headlines. A Progressive Journal of News and Opinion. Editor, Robert Scheer. Publisher, Zuade Kaufman.   Exclusive Truthdig Merchandise - Gore Vidal signed first editions - Signed Mr. Fish prints
November 7, 2009
Log in / Register

 Choose a size
Text Size

Most Read

Karzai Told to Fight Corruption; Abdullah Supporters Told to Keep It Civil

Ni Hao, Mickey Mouse: Disney Goes to Shanghai

Magic Bomb Wand Would Be Funny if It Didn't Kill People

Abbas Unlikely to Seek Re-Election

Learning to Speak Anew in a Tribal World

Most Comments
Most Emailed

Reports

Ear to the Ground

A/V Booth

Arts & Culture

Digs
Financial Meltdown 101
Vetting Sarah Palin

Truthdig Bazaar
The Five Biggest Lies Bush Told Us About Iraq

The Five Biggest Lies Bush Told Us About Iraq

By Robert Scheer, Christopher Scheer and Lakshmi Chaudhry
$9.95

more items

 
Arts and Culture

Dobbs Takes a Dive

Email this item Email    Print this item Print   
Posted on Jun 10, 2009
rackjite.com

It seems that immigrant bashing isn’t the ratings fertilizer it used to be. Just ask CNN blowhard Lou Dobbs, who hitched his wagon to a xenophobia boomlet only to discover that angry white men are a fickle bunch.

New York Observer:

But in the eyes of TV news critic Andrew Tyndall, Mr. Dobbs’ cooling off is primarily attributable to the fading of immigration as a core issue of national concern. “On the general news agenda, immigration has just completely disappeared as a story,” said Mr. Tyndall. “The extent to which, in his reincarnation, he came back as a immigration guy—that’s a very narrow beat. If immigration is not an issue, what’s he got?”

“Every night Lou Dobbs continues to tackle the most complex, challenging issues facing this country and our world,” said a CNN spokesperson when asked for comment. “No other show at 7 p.m. offers the insightful, solid reporting on subjects from the economy, to North Korea, national security, foreign policy, with strong debate and discussion from all sides.”

Read more

More Below the Ad

Advertisement

Get truth delivered to
your inbox every week.

Previous item: Actors Reach 'Devastatingly Unsatisfactory' Agreement with Studios

Next item: 'Get Rich Cheating,' Part 2



Elsewhere: .

Comments

Are you a Truthdig member yet? Login now, or register with Truthdig.

By boggs, June 19 at 1:51 pm #

Turns out that Lou is just another “angry white man.”
And his rhetoric is tiresome to say the least.

Report this

By samdfred, June 15 at 7:14 pm #

I used to enjoy watching Lou Dobbs. I did not always agree with him, but, I felt he had integrity. Since he has devolved into show after show of immigrant bashing I can no longer watch his show without getting angry. Its too bad because I think he is playing to the lowest common denominator now and no longer represents the middle class that he was so proud of.

Report this

By Pat Hardiman, June 15 at 4:00 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)

When Dobbs does take aim at something he does a creditable job of researching and reporting it which is more than you can say for - well, all the rest of them. But this illegal immigration thing is losing steam simply because these guys are all going back where they came from. There are plenty of other very important issues he could and should get involved in and he’d better do it if he wants to survive. Personally I would like to see him get his teeth into what really happened on 9/11.

Report this

By The Gay Species, June 14 at 6:28 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)

I agree that Dobbs has risen to xenophobia, but he’s still basically right. Entry into the U.S. should be according to the Rule of Law, not the lawlessness of the Bush Administration, expropriating cheap labor to make the economy seem sound when it was anything but.

Xenophobia is repugnant, but asking people to wait their turn, apply for a visa, to avoid expropriation of labor, is hardly xenophobia. We will always rely on immagrants, but after the Eastern European fiasco at the turn of the last century, ASSIMILATION requires at least one generation have lived here before a “boat lift” of foreigners invade.

Report this

By Cathy, June 14 at 2:48 pm #

Like Photoshock, I also watched Lou Dobbs for a while.  He was very good when he did his “Attack on the Middle Class” tour, because it wasn’t centered on immigration.  I remember he talked about health care a lot.  But then it became the same old, same old, and the economy took are of most of the illegal immigration situation. 

Health care is the big issue right now for the middle class.  Obama has put it on the front burner and every plan, except for single payer, is going to hurt the middle class.  As long as the insurance industry and pharma and the AMA (only 25% of doctors belong) are in the middle class and poor are screwed.  His ratings would spike tomorrow if he started talking about single payer and all the other issues having to do with health care.

Report this

By Carli Munoz, June 12 at 2:48 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)

By the way,it is not that I’m am opposed to solid immigration laws—I’m opposed to the idea of a mayor network news anchor continually advocating his own sick agenda.

PS. My previous comment translate to: “Each swine has his 24th of December coming”; meaning that his time is up—in many Spanish countries a pig gets slaughtered on Christmas eve!

Report this

By Carli Munoz, June 12 at 2:36 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)

A cada lechón le llega su 24 de Diciembre.

Report this

By BobZ, June 12 at 2:09 pm #

Dobbs like his contemporary O’Reilly have turned into middle aged white guys with an axe to grind. In O’Relly’s case, he keeps his audience titulated with culture warrior stories that stir up the base. Dobbs is just plain boring with his pit bull determination to beat the illegal immigration story to death, when the rest of America has moved on.  And contrary to the CNN spokesperson, Dobbs does a very poor job of covering any subject other than illegal immigration. His reporting bias leans very right, close to Hannity-right. So if you’re looking for unbiased news reporting, Dobbs is not your man. He also comes across as mean spirited which doesn’t help him. Add to that his permanent staff who don’t do more than just agree with everything Dobbs says. Even by the mediocrity of the cable news networks, Dobb’s show is pretty lame.

Report this

By Twin Towers, June 11 at 9:25 pm #

Lou had a good issue until this present economic collapse and the jobs dried up. Since I live in Texas, I have watched the change happen, quickly.

I knew that he was not the least bit Xenophobic. That is a false charge. He is just older and slower to focus on a primary issue he can get his head around. You can bet that will change. Once the does, he will know his subject and contribute to the public debate. He must not be into healthcare and the insurance scam, yet. He skipped over the investment banking debacle and Mozilla and the Countrywide mess.

It is true that the clock is ticking and he will not be allowed to blather away about secondary issues, like O’Reilly and that burned-out bunch of has-beens.

Report this

By Animadverto, June 11 at 6:03 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)

His slide in the ratings has nothing to due with his so called “xenophobia” but, in fact, his propagandist stance on “green shoots”, that don’t exist, and the wars in Iraq, Afghanistan and Pakistan.

Report this

By Paracelsus, June 11 at 9:47 am #

Teuton? I wasn’t aware that this was the 1st century bc.

Swedes are what make Sweden Swedish. I know that is redundant, but I can’t think of Sweden as Swedish if they accede to al-sharia law, and family honor codes. And the recent economic refugees don’t seem to be assimilating. With current low birth rates for Swedes and high birth rates for Arab/Moslem populations, you could have an essentially Arab/African population in Sweden.

Now we are very concerned with preserving the cultures and peoples of First Nations, American Indians, African pygmies and Australian aboriginals. Shouldn’t the Swedes be concerned with their self preservation?

Report this

By Purple Girl, June 11 at 9:29 am #

One Trick Pony….Does his daughter’s illegal Mexican’s Groom him before the show, too?
Dobbs is like all the other racist Hypocrits, bitching about Illegals in the same breath while screaming at Jose to shine his daughters riding boots before she enters the show ring.
It is actually mind boggling how easily these people talk out of both sides of their mouths at one time. Perhaps they are incorporating the other round orifice, like ventriloquist in reality. Oh they bitch about their ‘laziness’, their ‘stupidity’, their ‘demands’ for decent pay, housing or safety, their ‘shiftiness’...yet they continue to hire them. In fact they hire all these family members too. Then complain they are ruining our country.These are nothing more than modern day Plantation owners complaining and blaming the slaves for their woes.
Anyone who is a labor advocate, including Union members should be fighting for the rights of these workers- the represent the ‘floor’- the lowest level the Plantation owners wish to push ALL labor down to. In fact it is more aptly called the Subfloor.
They use this shadow workforce not only to increase profit margins, but as threats and scapegoats to the other workers. ‘Won’t accept these conditions, then I’ll hire a Mexican to take your job, who will’.
It’s time to stop wastng our time,effort and money on seeking out every illegal immigrant who submits an application - it’s time to go after those who accept the application and offer the job.If these people had decent well paying jobs in their own country- they wouldn’t be here in the first place.This is not just an American Worker issue this is a global labor force issue. This sweatshop mentality and Globe Trotting to find the cheapest indentured slave population must end.Human rights Always Trumps Corp Interests! Bring wages up around the world and what will happen….an increase in comsumerism throughout the world market.Win/win.

Report this

By Dar, June 11 at 12:37 am #
(Unregistered commenter)

Paracelsus, June 10 at 6:56 pm:
” In Sweden, native Teutonic women face intimidation, even rape from immigrant Moslem communities.”

Teuton? I wasn’t aware that this was the 1st century bc.

Report this

By rockinrobin, June 10 at 8:56 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)

never listened to the man; however, Leno’s neighbor got a bill of $28,000 for breaking his arm; does it cost that much to fix a broken arm? NO. But when the AGENDA of the POLITICAL system in the USA is to TARGET and HARM for PERSONAL PROFIT & GAIN; much is to be GOTTEN when they DELIBERATELY working together as a unit, inflate prices of homes? No? Corps have even gone right into Congress with lawyers & said THIS is how we want it done & gotten it so WELL do they WORK together as a UNIT and the TARGET of course is US the PEOPLE; replacing us with others is what Dobbs tried to get across; bringing IMMIGRANTS in from NATIONS where our Gov has set up the SAME EXACT criminal system; Live LARGE, be in CHARGE, do whatever you want whenever you want however you want & never be brought to justice. BTW, THIS is the REASON they DELIGHT in getting contracts to get schools built etc; they KNOW how much INFLATED the PRICES on COSTS are: and they POCKET the REST; it is LEGAL to be CRIMINAL in the USA; ask our Congress. Exploitation is the PROBLEM not capitalism; but a CRIMINALIZED GOV working WITH CORPS against the people; BTW, they are TRYING to get the PEOPLE to have to pay CORP taxes on top of their own; carrying out Hitler’s agenda in the world; Corps running EVERY nation; gosh, any WONDER every other nation KNOWS that WE have been enslaved by Corps with the most corrupt Gov on the planet?

Report this

By photoshock, June 10 at 8:35 pm #

At one point, I too, was sucked into the quagmire of Lou Dobbs’ belief system of anti-immigrant stances.
He is a very beguiling and charismatic character, who presents a well researched and emotive argument. But that’s where he stops, at CNN/HLN his ideas drew much attention.
He was the only true mainstream media person who attempted to talk about the then current immigration and border problems.
Now however, the economy and foreign policy are front and center issues and Mr. Dobbs in his ‘infinite wisdom’ has not moved from those issues to the newest things on the minds of those in his target audience. It seems to me, that the largely white, upper and middle class male, has abandoned the cause of Mr. Dobbs. They are now more concerned with the world’s view of America, the tanking economy and how they are going to survive the worsening economic crises, in the manner to which they have become accustomed. Should Mr. Dobbs turn his attention to these matters, then maybe he could regain his audience, but Obama bashing is not the way to the hallowed halls of audience attention.
Mr. Dobbs, is now on the way out of the mainstream media and will eventually do the same thing as all the rest of the wannabe Obama bashers, and will join the Faux News Network, and become the sensation of the day there. Much like the Glenn Beck debacle, he will draw attention for a time but hopefully sooner than later, Mr. Dobbs will fade into the place where he truly belongs, being a legend in his own mind.

Report this

By Paracelsus, June 10 at 6:56 pm #

@ Leefeller

Always the blame game, so immigration is the reason our country is sucking wind, and all this time I believed it was caused by gay rights and abortion, the jews, the blacks and anyone but the old white guys who love to send our kids to senseless wars and manipulate reality.

Too much immigration and laxity on illegal aliens is one problem among many. Gays, Jews, and blacks don’t really benefit from the onslaught as many of those immigrant/illegal alien cultures look down upon them. Many Muslim and Latin American immigrant/illegal alien communities have a really sour attitude toward them. In France, French Jews are more likely to be victimized by Arab immigrant communities. In Sweden, native Teutonic women face intimidation, even rape from immigrant Moslem communities. I suppose if one were anti-semitic or homophobic or misogynistic, it would be the perfect cleansing of society to let in tons of legal and illegal aliens. Even better is for an antisocial elite who needs the chaos and cheap labor of these migrants to push for massive social engineering. It is patently illiberal to have an open border policy, for it treats all of humanity as being as fungible and indistinguishable as cattle.

Report this

By rylly, June 10 at 5:59 pm #

Oh dear, clicking on this was a waste of time, there was nothing in the article.  What is happening at Truthdig?

Report this

By Leefeller, June 10 at 5:38 pm #

Always the blame game, so immigration is the reason our country is sucking wind, and all this time I believed it was caused by gay rights and abortion, the jews, the blacks and anyone but the old white guys who love to send our kids to senseless wars and manipulate reality.

Division and fear are great tools fostering public attention on non issues, divisiveness so useful for the constant diversion from the puppeteers of the Punch and Judy show.

Ignorance provides lackey supporters for the Libaughs of the world, are they really effective?
It is almost as if fanatics, people who need Limbaugh like religion were already unhappy in their lives, symbiotic relationships of misfits. The need to hate and fan the fires of hate are most important in the distractions.

Report this

By Paracelsus, June 10 at 5:29 pm #

@ bluelori

The correct term is Illegal Aliens attempting to change the terminology does not change the truth.

You are correct. The main issue now is getting E-verify funded, and the Democratic majority has been very stubborn about funding it.

Report this

By bluelori, June 10 at 4:31 pm #

The correct term is Illegal Aliens attempting to change the terminology does not change the truth.

Report this

By G.Anderson, June 10 at 4:31 pm #

Well, the issue of immigration may also have slowed because, the immigration laws are being enforced a little bit better, and there is less immigration, due to the economy.

Try not to confuse the issues, Dobbs isn’t the issue, immigration is. Saying that Mr. Dobbs is just the representative of angry white men and a blowhard is demaining and predjudiced, and simplifies the issues to the detriment of everyone involved in this debate.

There are many thousand of people in minority groups, many of them former immigrants themselves, who favor restrictions on immigration.

Report this

By rockinrobin, June 10 at 4:23 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)

the MEDIA is being SILENCED on MANY THINGS: working with our LAWLESS LEADERS and even LOCALLY as in the COUNTY REFUSING requests to “let the PEOPLE KNOW!” by county commissioners; you see, it is NOT democracy at all folks; it is FASCISM: it is not even a TWO party system: cuz the AGENDA is the SAME target & harm for personal gain & profit; CRIMINALLY run GOV;
DO NOT blame the IMMIGRANTS: blame the ROOT CAUSE of the PROBLEM: a CRIMINALLY RUN CORRUPT GOV who does in TRUTH not even RECOGNIZE the PEOPLE at all nor do they have ANY RIGHTS at all until you are a CORPORATION: THEN you have RIGHTS, and are RECOGNIZED; my my my: what they PEOPLE have to say is NOTED however THIS is the way it will BE!
NOTE: close friends with China for decades despite the “misleading & deceiving” political they claim talk: which is out & out LYING: they told them years ago to put up a Congress; pretend to “listen” to the PEOPLE: write the laws they want (put on the books for looks) people will leave you alone; do whatever you choose;
Immigrants were given large sums of $; brand new cars/trucks/job preferences/no interest loans like $3,000 for dental work ALL the while CITIZENS were being DELIBERATELY overbilled; for EVERYTHING; including CRIMINAL interest rates & FRAUDULENT addl fees put on everything including houses all with GOV oversight, knowledge & consent; (we are BROKE) is the LIE: all kinds of $ at both state & fed levels folks; but the PEOPLE are so STUPID they will believe ANYTHING! ESP when from an AUTHORITY figure!
BTW, JOURNALISTS have been targeted & killed on orders from PENTAGON: http://www.democracynow.org; army whistleblower; kept out of Mexico, & Iraq & everywhere else; DETAINED illegally; yep, THIS is the FREEDOM folks they want to PUT GLOBALLY on EVERYONE. FALSE reports, FALSE pictures, FALSE so called SCIENTIFIC reports; FALSE democracy; my my my;

Report this

By wagonjak, June 10 at 2:57 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)

I watched some of Lou’s early shows, and I had hope that he would be a champion of the working man, but for the last couple of years, he’s been able to blame anything wrong in the US on Obama and the Dems…and on the immigrants!

If he were entertaining or insightful it would be one thing, but he’s just another angry old white guy who spins the news in a Faux Noise manner!

Totally unwatchable!

Report this

By Paracelsus, June 10 at 2:30 pm #

Either the media isn’t covering the immigration issue in Congress or Obama and the Congressional leadership have decided to leave the issue alone so as to introduce legislation again after Dobbs and other restrictionists have suffocated from lack of oxygen. The best thing Bush and the Dems did for the immigration restrictionists was to keep pushing the issue. This gave the open borders lobby plenty of public scrutiny. And it gave Dobbs plenty of grist for the mill. Such unpopular legislation has to be sneaked in before the anti-amnesty opposition has a chance to flood the Capitol with angry responses.

Report this

Add Your Comment

Posts by unregistered readers are moderated. Posts by members
are published immediately. Why wait? Register today!







Number of characters remaining: 4000

Notify you when others comment on this article?


Are you a human?
Retype the word you see here.


Please read and abide by our comment policy.
By submitting this comment, you agree to this site's terms and conditions.

 
Click here to learn more about Truthdig
 

 
Join the Liberal Blog Advertising Network
 
 
 
 
Get any 3 books for $3.00 - Join Progressive Book Club today
 
 
 

A Progressive Journal of News and Opinion. Editor, Robert Scheer. Publisher, Zuade Kaufman.
Copyright © 2009 Truthdig, L.L.C. All rights reserved.