![]() |
|
||
|
Polish Politics at the PianoPosted on Apr 27, 2009
Polish pianist Krystian Zimerman’s debut at the Walt Disney Concert Hall in Los Angeles took a political turn on Sunday night when he took a moment before his final number to announce that he wouldn’t play in the U.S. again as long as America pursues an imperialist agenda on the world stage.
Elsewhere: . CommentsAre you a Truthdig member yet? Login now, or register with Truthdig. Add Your Comment
|
A Progressive Journal of News and Opinion. Editor, Robert Scheer. Publisher, Zuade Kaufman.
Copyright © 2009 Truthdig, L.L.C. All rights reserved. |
By bluejeanne, May 4 at 4:42 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)
Les Blachut, April 29
<< “I remember Krystian from my school back in Katowice, Poland. I just started when he was about to graduate and then go on to win the Chopin piano competition and conquer the world. I also remember Adam Makowicz. He is a great piano player in both jazz and classical genre.” >>
Les . . . did you know Mjetek Litwinski as well ? He was studying at the Warsaw Conservatory but was also originally from Katowice ? And what about his friend RR ? I was studying in Warsaw through the Kansas University program and working at the American Embassy library at the time of the declaration of Martial Law in Poland (1980 ). Krystian Zimerman was pointed out to me by students of the Conservatory, as an upcoming prodigy.
Report thisHow bizarre to hear that people actually walked out of a concert as a protest to a person’s right to express his opinion. (Free Speech)
Yes, musicians are on a different evolutionary plane than the rest of the mere mortals. It requires exceptional sensitivity to “create music” and the general population i.e. the masses, cannot grasp the nuances of the fragile nature of those ‘angelic beings’ who make the drudgery of daily life bearable through the gift of music.
By Folktruther, May 2 at 8:27 pm #
What hasn’t been reported in the American mass media is that when Obama was in Chezcho in mid-April, he stated publically that the US was going ahead with the first strike missile base against Russia, with the absurd pretense that this was a defense against Iran. Continuing Bush’s extremely dangerous policies against the will of the Chezch and Polish people. In the interests of Israel and against US interests.
Report thisBy blogdog, April 29 at 4:14 pm #
RE: The British paper Guardian today has an article about the US torture camp near the US military base in Poland where it is Bush-Obama policy to render political prisionrs.
This has been in the news in Europe since 2005. Made it to the NY Times in 2006. Former Communist Era prisons (closed over 15 years, since the regime change) were refurbished to serve in the Global Torture Gulag.
There are carrots and sticks. TheKaczynski brothers (measuring in at about 5 feet each) love the feeling of big pointy missiles; but one’s gone and the other’s swarmed by scandals. Tusk is more sensible and secure. Many in Poland hope he’ll stand up to the thugs in Brussels and Washington - invalidate the Rumsfeld vision of the New Europe - presumably where the proportion of imprisoned population matches that of the US - largest in the industrialized world…you know, land of the free…yada, yada
Report thisBy samosamo, April 29 at 3:53 pm #
By blogdog, April 29 at 1:59 am
My, my, you sure did grow up(I think) loving your disney and that is where you must spend a lot of your free time. Disney IS part of the msm problem which apparently you’re a classic example of the effect of that part of MSM.
Report thisHint: this is all this bantering back and forth will be about as you have hopelessly secured your position by protecting disney. Why don’t you go take a trip into fantasyland?
By Folktruther, April 29 at 1:55 pm #
The US power system IS insane, Louise, or elements of it, and infects the population with the hysteria for their own purposes. It is suffering from that ‘megalomania’ that the British historian Eric Hobsbaum says routinely affects imperialism.
The British paper Guardian today has an article about the US torture camp near the US military base in Poland where it is Bush-Obama policy to render political prisionrs. An appelent court just overrled the Bush-Obama policy of preventing prisoners from appealing their incarceration, although it is doubtful that Obama will obey the law, in the same way Bush didn’t. But US law is reluctant to apply to foreign policy.
But the point is that Zimerman, like the other Poles, probably knew of this prison, along with the threatened missile base, and was disgusted by it. As even Obama cheerleaders like yourself are. But the American audience didn’t know it, and so elements of them had their consciousness ‘disappeared’ to induce them to walk out. But they were systematically deceived and deluded by Bush, just as they are currently being deluded and deceived by Obama.
Report thisBy Louise, April 29 at 11:16 am #
About 30 or 40 people in the audience walked out, some shouting obscenities. “Yes,” he answered, “some people when they hear the word military start marching.”
~~~
Great line, but off the mark. People don’t jump up and march out because they hear the word military. They jump up and march out because they are programmed to respond to a challenge to their blind obedience!
The US isn’t insane ... people are insane. And when you (you being we the people, through our elected officials) allow a policy based on histaria to become the norm, the insane come crawling out of their cubby holes. Job security for the insecure. Stability for the unstable.
We see them every day. In grocery stores, in airports behind the security scanners, and behind the cameras carefully placed where we cant see them. We see crime commited in front of those cameras. We see the action captured and often as not, the cameras are so cheap the picture is worthless. Is it sane to place the camera to catch the crook, knowing full well the need to buy the cheapest renders the camera useless? In other words, we see insanity run amuck.
A sense of panic that drives a need that has a flawed outcome because the histerical can see a need for “protect” but cant understand protect by search and destroy is only destroy. There commitment to protect stops at their own fanny. Their collective histeria driven by a view so narrow that even they cant understand exactly what “it”, or their place in “it” is all about.
The incident of the fly-over in Manhatten the other day clearly defines the kind of insanity that fills the little gaps in the larger hole called National Security. I’m not talking about the folks in Manhatten who reacted in a very honest, sane and understandable fashion. I’m talking about the idiot, or idiots who, because of some off-base notion of “threat” decided not to give the folks in Manhatten a heads-up! That is exactly the kind of insanity I’m talking about! So many imagined threats. So few sane people to “practice” on how to deal with them. But then if the threat is percieved based on info that’s imagined, guided by fear that’s driven by histeria and insanity, how can anything be clearly defined and dealt with?
The whole point being ... we have unqualified, poorly trained, often stupid and generally frieghtened people with severe emotional problems and absolutely no practical experience in human relations, daily making decisions about fear, problems and human relations.
The wonder is that Zimerman came back to America at all! The wonder is that anyone chooses to enter our airports and fly. The wonder is that nobody seems to have realised yet, it’s not fear of terrorism that keeps people from flying, it’s fear of the insane and idiotic staffers that staff the security that keeps us from flying!
Report thisBy Les Blachut, April 29 at 3:33 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
I remember Krystian from my school back in Katowice, Poland. I just started when he was about to graduate and then go on to win the Chopin piano competition and conquer the world. I also remember Adam Makowicz. He is a great piano player in both jazz and classical genre. I just found this website after listening to the announcer at WKCP 89.7 FM South Florida Classical Radio talking about Zimmerman and Makowicz erratic behavior and the notorious history of Polish concert pianists in US going back to Ignacy Jan Paderewski. I personally don’t mind people speaking their minds even though they’re not supposed to do that during a public performance. I hope nobody regrets coming to this concert, after all the whole program was played as planned. Even Chopin himself wrote and performed Polonaise Militaire and Revolutionary Etude as a protest against those pursuing an imperialist agenda against his country. So why do we all get worked up when a Polish artist in US expresses musically or verbally what they feel at the time, even though it may seem slightly inconvenient to some in the audience?
Report thisBy blogdog, April 29 at 1:59 am #
INCREDIBLE: “You sure are going out of your way to protect a corporation that is a big part of those that have more than their fair share of say so in the running of this country”
I am not protecting anybody! I am pointing out that by slamming into this discussion, totally ignorant of how business is done in the fine and performing arts, you sound like an idiot. The Disney Corp. had nothing, absolutely nothing, to do with this performance.
Not even Krystian Zimerman has a big enough name as an “artist” for a corpse the size of Disney to give a damn about anything he says, anywhere. If one of the “celebrities” on the Disney payroll spoke out like this, yeah, then they might be moved to put on some pressure.
Get a clue! In this (the most philistine nation of all time) almost nobody, needs, cares or even thinks about what “artists” do. This nation, populated overwhelmingly with “boob-tubed” consumers, only cares about “celebrities!”
Report thisBy samosamo, April 29 at 1:17 am #
By blogdog, April 28 at 7:52 pm
Report this““The Disney Corp. did not produce this performance - Disney’s name is only on the hall because of the estate’s $50-mil contribution to its construction. A local presenter of classical musical performances produced this show.”“
*********************
You sure are going out of your way to protect a corporation that is a big part of those that have more than their fair share of say so in the running of this country.
I don’t believe I said disney produced it, just said hopefully the guy got paid and that disney with its patriotic place in diverting attention from real issues would have a say so in him being paid. I would say that he was paid before he stepped on stage but you want to bet if disney would or could have a say so about what happens to any performer? Especially when they contribute so much to build a facility. Remember that disney is part of one of the conservative owned and controlled MSM.
By irspariah, April 29 at 12:09 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
It’s high time the rest of the world decided to boycott the US. Yeah, some places could be inconvenienced—but enough is enough. Fuck it!
Report thisBy Folktruther, April 28 at 11:19 pm #
William Wexler- an interesting anticdote. Did you know that it is now legal to take cig lighters abroad US planes, courtesy of the tobacco industry, but illegal to take shampoo? To fend off the danger no doubt that someone will threaten to violently wash somebody’s hair.
In Italy they seized my wife’s jam because… because…well, I don’t remember the reason, and fortunately the guard didn’t understand English when I explained why he shouldn’t.
Report thisBy blogdog, April 28 at 7:52 pm #
RE: “I just hope disney didn’t renege on paying him for his performance. It is something I would not be surprised of the great disney corporation doing.”
General ignorance about the fine and performing arts is, in this - the most philistine nation of all time - patently embarrasing.
The Disney Corp. did not produce this performance - Disney’s name is only on the hall because of the estate’s $50-mil contribution to its construction. A local presenter of classical musical performances produced this show.
Of course the presenter paid.
The irony in this is that Zimerman was known in Poland for making similar comments from the stage about the regime during the Martial Law era, when I would have been seen as a hero by the very hostile gang that’s now slamming him relentlessly over at the LA Times Comments section.
Report thisBy samosamo, April 28 at 6:15 pm #
I just hope disney didn’t renege on paying him for his performance. It is something I would not be surprised of the great disney corporation doing.
Report thisBy Jim Yell, April 28 at 5:15 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)
It was stupid to tear up his piano because someone thought the glue smelled strange. Glue usually does smell strange. This whole bogus homeland security has made us less free and less safe. A bunch of poorly trained people, who don’t know what they are looking for, but have to intrude to prove they are doing something.
It seems I am the only one who ever remembers that the government had the information to have stopped the 9/11 attack, information obtained the old fashion way, based upon facts not wishful thinking or horror your Steinway stinks.
The need for rockets in Poland is just another ploy of the military industrial complex, exactly what Ike warned us about. You know Ike the General who actually knew what war was about, unlike Bush, Cheney and Rumsfeld, our supposed modern military leaders. Except for Rumsfeld none of them even pretended to serve, Cheney lest of all.
My family has been American for over 300 years and I give a hurrah for the pissed off pianist.
Report thisBy nestoffour, April 28 at 11:39 am #
wow!!
Report thisBy Blackspeare, April 28 at 11:35 am #
Sounds to me that the piano that smelled odd had strings attached to it!
Report thisBy jkfields, April 28 at 11:26 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
Piano aside, I’m glad he called a bully a bully. He could have just referenced the fact that the U.S. had located a hidden torture prison in his homeland. He demonstrated for us what Democracy should be. God bless him!
Report thisBy Thomas O. Anderson, April 28 at 9:35 am #
This is the kind of moral autonomy and courage the world is waiting on.
When we quit listening to the pundits and pimps manufactured by Washington, and start paying heed to the voice of Humanity, our nation may at last see “real” change.
Report thisBy William W. Wexler, April 28 at 7:59 am #
As a pianist and former professional musician, if anyone representing a government destroyed any of my equipment I’d never play there again. I never traveled with my Mason & Hamlin grand. Anyone who orders the destruction of a Mason & Hamlin or Steinway because of a smell is an ignorant, paranoid bastard who should be flipping burgers rather than working to keep the world safe from democracy.
Here’s a short anecdote as a point of reference. During the Cold War my band played in Europe for 3 months. The guitarist and I flew to Switzerland to pick up our gear and a truck, then drove to Frankfurt to meet up with the rest of the band. We ended up taking a “shortcut” into Germany due to a hitchhiker we picked up.
I was very diligent about making sure our equipment was properly checked in to the country due to having done some gigs in Canada years back. (US will try to charge you duty on your equipment when you come back in unless you have paperwork on it). Our sponsors said it was no big deal but I wanted to be sure. So I’m driving along in this small town and the next thing I know I’m reading German signs IN GERMANY and we have just driven past the guard shack. I pulled over, walked back to the shack, and encountered a non-English speaking guard and was trying to communicate with him that we had a truckload of stage gear that I wanted to check in somehow. Finally he came over and looked at it, and as we paged through the dictionary trying to figure out what the other guy was saying, finally he understood what I was trying to do and cheerfully said “OK” and waved us on.
No inventory confirmation, no pawing through our luggage, no examining every amplifier and cable, no nothing… just a glance into the back of the truck and wave the American hippies through from Switzerland to Germany, the country where terrorist cells were active and there was a line of nuclear-equipped airbases to protect the country from the Russians. He never even looked at our passports.
We have bad karma here, really bad. That’s why they hate us, it’s not because we’re free.
Bravo to Krystian Zimerman. I would have stood if I were there and cheered if I knew the back story on it. I guess I’ll just have to settle on buying all of his recordings.
-Wexler
Report thisBy dsmith, April 28 at 6:50 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
I suppose that rules out playing in Israel also.
Report thisBy david, April 28 at 6:47 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
Bravo Mr Krystian Zimerman !
Wake up America, not everyone wants to be abused by your playground-bully arrogance. Perhaps if you imagined the tables turned, perhaps then you would understand.
Report thisBy Claus-Erik Hamle, April 28 at 2:35 am #
(Unregistered commenter)
According to former Trident missile engineer Bob Aldridge-www.plrc.org-the Pentagon aims to achieve a disarming and unanswerable first-strike capability. According to Bob Aldridge the US Navy can track and destroy all enemy submarines simultaneously. Please see the article by Keir Lieber and Daryl Press, “The Rise of US Nuclear Primacy” in the 2006 March/April issue of Foreign Affairs. Minuteman-3s and Trident-2 D5s linked to NAVSTAR obtain a CEP of 30-40 metres, enough to destroy any hard target. A First-Strike Capability won´t be complete without the missiles in Poland to shoot down any surviving Russian missiles. Even if it´s only for blackmail, the Russians may have no choice but implementing Launch On Warning. Bob Aldridge resigned because a disarming and unanswerable first-strike capability is suicidal.
Report thisBy Folktruther, April 27 at 11:16 pm #
They destroyed the piano of one of the world’s greatest pianists because the glue smelled funny? And people think I exaggerate when I say that the US is politically insane.
The US is threatening to put a first strike missile base in Poland, causing Russia to target Poland with nuclear weapons. Since the US is obviously politically insane, killing hundreds of thousands of non-US people so far, Zimerman has a point that the American people have not yet realized.
The Geyry concert holl is astonishing. We were down there when the workers putting on the alumininam roof were jiggling the jigsaw-like pieces to try to get them to fit. the whole building is of metal, like the art museam in Spain. It is not large but reports at the end claimed that it finally cost nearly a billion dollars to construct. And pisses off the artists that play in them.
Report thisBy blogdog, April 27 at 10:38 pm #
In 1987, the late Lillian Disney made an initial gift of $50 million to build a world-class performance venue as a gift to the people of Los Angeles and a tribute to Walt Disney’s devotion to the arts…the only reason the Disney name is on that hall.
The people of LA would be fools to turn down this gift. As for artists, in the fine and performing arts are many, using their voices and craft to illuminate the horror of our epoch - the creators of this production would, as well, be fools to turn down a booking at Disney Hall: http://www.thefall01.info
The punch in Zimmerman’s gesture lies in the fact that the US Government, by comparison to other nations, supports very few fine and performing arts on world tours. The Polish Government probably funded Zimmerman’s travel to the US, maybe even his travel within the US - it’s called cultural ambassadorship. The US seems to think the film industry does that for this nation, and so it does, but it’s message is generally pretty vulgar.
Zimmerman’s now telling US presenters, “Tap your dwindling endowments to pay more for the travel and per diem of US artists,” I’m withdrawing as a cultural ambassador to the Imperial US.
Report thisBy Celia, April 27 at 9:40 pm #
(Unregistered commenter)
I’d be pissed off too if a bunch of minimum-wage TSA employees (probably actually sub-contractors) thought a piano smelled “funny” and destroyed a Steinway. I mean, come ON. They’d obviously been sniffing something of their own.
Good for him.
Report thisBy samosamo, April 27 at 8:30 pm #
It’s a start, but I wish this guy was more atuned to disney’s role in subverting this country and would boycott them wherever disney reared its ugly head.
Report this